
Inside Glasgow's tenement crisis and the call for new laws
Some of the owners had insurance, others did not. There was no block insurance.
And so the Victorian B-listed building was stuck in bureaucratic stasis.
If there is anything surprising about the situation at Albert Cross, it is that it is still relatively rare for any of the 77,000 pre-1919 homes in Glasgow to completely collapse before our eyes.
The deterioration is normally much more gradual.
READ MORE FROM UNSPUN:
But for how much longer? The city's tenements are in crisis. Age and a lack of maintenance are catching up with them.
Roofs, stone façades, joists and chimneys have endured more than a century of Scottish winters.
In my Pollokshields tenement, we've just been handed an eye-watering quote to fix our mullions. I didn't even know what a mullion was until a couple of months ago.
A 2018 survey found around 46,600 tenement flats in the city need structural, weather-tightening and restoration work.
And as these buildings age, the pace of their decline will only accelerate.
The big problem, when it comes to major structural repairs, is getting everyone in the block to agree.
Replacing a roof, securing bulging sandstone, dealing with dry rot – it all needs to be carried out collectively. All the owners in a close need to agree and pay their share.
In theory, a simple majority of owners can approve common works. In practice, as anyone who has ever been in this situation can attest, if even one refuses or cannot afford to pay, everything grinds to a halt.
Councils have the power to step in – by paying a "missing share" and pursuing repayment – but budgets are tight and such interventions are rare.
And compulsory purchase orders are rarer still and even more tricky to get over the line.
The problem is that the system we have to deal with these situations simply was not designed to cope with this scale of failure.
So, is it time for a new Tenements Act?
That is the proposal from Labour MSP Paul Sweeney. But what would it involve?
The Scottish Parliamentary Working Group on Tenement Maintenance has been meeting for seven years now. In 2019, it recommended ministers look at owners' associations, sinking funds and five-yearly inspections.
In response, the Scottish Government asked the Scottish Law Commission to develop options for legislation.
That's still ongoing, but with a year until the election, the onus must now be on parties to come up with some suggestions.
One possibility touted by Jon Molyneux, the Green councillor for Pollokshields, and worthy of consideration, is mandatory insurance.
Sign up to Scotland's top politics newsletter and get it directly to your inbox.
That would likely go beyond the current legal requirement for individual owners to insure their own flats, instead requiring comprehensive block-wide coverage that would ensure repairs could proceed even when some owners lack adequate insurance or funds.
The collective cost of repairing Scotland's pre-1919 housing stock could run to the billions.
But the cost of doing nothing will be far higher.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Guardian
2 hours ago
- The Guardian
Homes for sale with wild gardens in England and Wales
This large Victorian house, set back from the road, is true to its era, with a red-brick elevation under a mixture of pantile and flat roof. The facade is screened by mature shrubs and covered in mature wisteria and climbing roses. The main garden, to the south and east, has a wildlife pond and a decked walk that leads to another garden with fruit trees. The popular village has a railway station, a shop, a pub, a recreation ground and a primary school. Melton adjoins the riverside market town of Woodbridge, which has several sailing clubs. £855,000. Bedfords, 01728 454 505 Photograph: Bedfords Just over a mile outside the busy village of Culmstock, in the Culm Valley, is Silver Street Farm. The approach is a long drive bordered by wildflower meadows. The restored Georgian farmhouse has eight bedrooms and sits in 3.8 hectares (9.6 acres) that include a no-dig kitchen garden, open paddocks and a cottage. Behind the house is a courtyard of outbuildings covered in roses and surrounded by fruit trees. The kitchen opens on to a terrace, and a large utility room connects the main house to the events barn. The nearest town is Prescott. £2.5m. Knight Frank, 020 7590 2451 Photograph: Knight Frank Near the foothills of the Berwyn mountains and just over three miles from the nearest village, lies this secluded retreat. Until the 1960s it was a working farm; then it was split up with different sections sold off. The farmhouse that is up for sale is in a limewash under a roof of timber rafters, bordered by the original walls of local stone. A woodland shelters the buildings, with beech, oak, conifer and sycamore trees and fern, broom and dog rose. A second area is a wetland with two ponds surrounded by rowan, alder and willow. £495,000. Savills, 01952 239 500 Photograph: Chris Curl/Savills Down an old farm track, on the outskirts of a ridge-top village, is the historic French Court Farmhouse, built in about 1640, with later additions. The writer CS Lewis recorded he once lodged here. It has been restored with period features intact: the inglenook fireplace and the winder staircase. The whole plot covers one hectare (2.5 acres), and includes a wildflower front garden, woodland, paddocks, a wildlife pond and a Mediterranean courtyard. Pett sits between Winchelsea and Hastings, and it is only a six-minute drive to the nearest beach. £1.5m. Inigo, 020 3687 3071 Photograph: Suzie Gibbons/Inigo This low-slung mid-century house is Grade II-listed and has glazing on all sides, letting in plenty of light and framing views across 2.6 hectares (6.5 acres) of land. The plot consists of woods and paddocks with a leafy side garden separating the house from the road. There are perennial grasses and secluded spots, with winding paths leading to a beech wood past snowdrop and daffodil dells and the wildlife pond. Grimsby and Louth are about half an hour away, and it's about 20 minutes drive to the coast. £800,000. The Modern House, 020 3795 5920 Photograph: The Modern House


Daily Record
14 hours ago
- Daily Record
Former First Minister's in-laws in Gaza 'can't even find grass or leaves to eat'
Dundee councillor Nadia El-Nakla, the wife of Humza Yousaf, said it was 'traumatising' to watch her relatives go through a 'living nightmare'. The wife of former Scottish first minister Humza Yousaf has said the lives of her family in Gaza are 'hanging in the balance' as she accused Israel of starving two million people in the Strip. Nadia El-Nakla said her family could not even find grass, leaves or any animals to eat, amid an Israeli blockade on the amount of food and supplies going into the region. The Dundee councillor said it was 'traumatising' to watch her relatives go through a 'living nightmare'. She described the territory as 'hell on earth'. Asked on BBC Scotland's Drivetime programme if she thought she would ever get back to Gaza to see her family again, she said: 'I think Gaza is gone – I don't think Gaza will exist any more. 'The situation is just incredibly difficult, heartbreaking, traumatising for us to watch, and for them their life is now hanging in the balance.' She said her cousin Sally, a mother of four, has been moved to different tents 15 times after her house was destroyed. 'She has no food,' Ms El-Nakla said. 'She had a loaf of bread the other day that she was trying to save for her children. My other cousin told her, 'look, just eat grass, eat leaves, eat plants', and she said 'we can't even find them'. 'There's no cash either, so even if I sent her £1,000, she can't access that money, and there's no way for her to buy anything. So it's just a living nightmare – it's hell on earth.' She added: 'It's just, it's so devastating because her husband is going out every day, and they're so scared that he'll not come back because of the bombing, to try and find food, and he can't find any.' She said that even for those who can access money, the price of a kilo of sugar is about 200 dollars (£148), making it inaccessible for most. She urged world leaders to do more to force Israel to allow more aid into Gaza, amid warnings from aid agencies about mass starvation. Speaking about her cousin Sally, she said: 'She sent me a voicenote saying 'I hate the world – no-one is coming to help us', and I could hear her children in the background. 'That's what breaks my heart the most, is they know that no-one's coming to help them, and to have your child hungry, to be hungry yourself, how that feels to have hunger, and how you're supposed to look after your kids, and they're crying to you because they're hungry – like I say, it's a living nightmare.' She added: 'Now nothing exists. It's bare survival. 'They feel that they're all going to die and we're all watching them through the process of being terrified for their lives from bombs, from being shot at and having to run, which I've had calls with her where she's like, 'I can hear the gunfire', and she's having to run, and then now calls that there's no food there. 'It's a silent killer. They're killing them so slowly and quietly, but they're killing them at every single point. And it's just devastating to watch. It's heartbreaking. It's sickening.' Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. Ms El-Nakla said she feels 'physically sick' hearing about her family's situation in Gaza, adding that she feels 'completely inadequate as a cousin, as a human being, that I can't do anything'. She said she was angry with the UK Government, which she said 'isn't doing anything' to 'try to stop the genocide'. She said aid must urgently be allowed in to stop the 'catastrophic starvation of two million people'. "We are living in a dystopia where we are just watching two million people slowly die,' she said. 'For our own humanity, how can we live with that? Our Government has to do something.' The UK Government and Israeli embassy in London have been approached


Daily Mirror
17 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
UK hotspot could ban 'irresponsible' motorhomes and campervans after outcry
The city's green space is a popular spot for motorhome and campervan owners - but locals and a new activist group is demanding action and calling for them to be banned. Motorhomes and campervans are set to face a massive setback as a popular hotspot is on the brink of banning vehicle parking. A petition demanding an end to vehicle dwelling has garnered over 8,000 signatures. The activist group"Protect the Downs" made their case at a Bristol City Council meeting, advocating for the removal of larger vehicles from the historic green space. In a statement shared with the BBC, the newly formed Protect the Downs group stated its aim to "hold Bristol City Council accountable for enforcing laws, restrictions and bylaws", which ensure the Downs remains available for "legitimate public use". The group expressed concerns about "irresponsible driving and obstructive parking" by van dwellers posing a threat to pedestrians, health and safety risks due to "overcrowded, unsanitary and dangerous conditions" and environmental damage caused by litter and human waste, reports Birmingham Live. "We've come together because we love the Downs, but this wonderful green space relied on by residents across Bristol is being misused and that's putting people in real danger," said chair Tony Nelson "Children, the elderly, council workers and even emergency responders are at risk, and the environmental damage is heartbreaking." Amy Dickson, 35, has been residing on the downs since last year. She moved into a van after she was evicted from a series of rentals in the city: "I've always been in minimum wage jobs. My family don't have any money. I can't get a guarantor. I just can't afford to rent any more." The council has pledged to establish 250 temporary pitches on land earmarked for development by the end of the year. "We've all parked together and it is really nice," she said. "It is awful to receive so much hate." She continued: "We have jobs here.. that is talking out of total privilege. It is so ignorant. "Cracking down on one location in the absence of better alternatives, just means people will move somewhere else," Barry Parsons, the Green chair of the housing committee, said. "People living in vehicles are fellow residents of Bristol and we have just as much responsibility to support them as anybody else."