Supreme Court refuses to reverse Bombay high court ban on pigeon feeding
A bench of justices JK Maheshwari and Vijay Bishnoi noted that proceedings in the matter remain pending before the high court, which is expected to take up the case again on August 13. 'Parallel indulgence by this court is not proper. Petitioner can move the high court for modification of the order,' said the bench, refusing to interfere.
The high court, hearing multiple petitions by animal lovers and rights activists challenging the BMC's demolition of decades-old kabutarkhanas, initially stayed the demolition but barred feeding. On July 30, after noting continued feeding and obstruction of civic officials, the high court ordered criminal cases under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, calling the acts a 'public nuisance likely to spread diseases and endanger human life.'
On July 24, the high court warned that pigeon breeding and large congregations at kabutarkhanas posed a 'grave social concern', stressing the decision was in the 'larger interest of societal health, from children to senior citizens.'
In court, BMC presented medical evidence that pigeon droppings and feathers can trigger asthma, hypersensitivity, pneumonitis, and lung fibrosis, conditions with no cure once advanced. The civic body argued that many victims realise the damage only after irreversible harm to the lungs.
Petitioners in the Supreme Court, including Pallavi Sachin Patil, argued that pigeon feeding is a long-standing religious practice, particularly among Hindu devotees and the Jain community, with some 51 feeding spots in Mumbai operating for decades. They claimed health concerns were overstated and that asthma was more directly linked to pollution from vehicles and open burning. They proposed alternatives, such as bird towers for human-pigeon coexistence.
The crackdown sparked street protests. On August 6, hundreds clashed with police at Dadar 'kabutarkhana', tearing down tarpaulin sheets erected to block feeding. Two days earlier, over 1,000 community members protested after the site was barricaded with bamboo poles and covered.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
an hour ago
- India Today
Delhi dog removal may reverse rabies gains, create chaos: Edinburgh professor
India's hard-earned progress in rabies prevention could be 'substantially reversed' if the Supreme Court's recent order on removing street dogs is implemented, warns Prof. Krithika Srinivasan, Principal Investigator of the ROH-Indies research project at the University of an exclusive conversation, Prof. Srinivasan, whose work combines human geography, behavioural ecology, and public health, made it clear that the proposed measures risk derailing two decades of steady has made remarkable gains, reported human rabies deaths have dropped from 274 in 2005 to just 34 in 2022. But these health gains are fragile. Mass removal of dogs breaks up vaccinated, stable populations and triggers movement, increasing bite risks and rabies exposure,' she VACUUM EFFECT: A PROBLEM THAT BITES BACK The 'vacuum effect', a term many in the public may not have heard before, is central to her warning.'When community dogs are removed, the empty space is quickly filled by new, often unvaccinated dogs from surrounding areas,' Prof. Srinivasan explained. 'This disrupts herd immunity and creates instability.'The phenomenon is not unique to India. In the UK, after street dogs were eliminated, foxes and gulls filled the gap, both now considered urban nuisances and, in some cases, safety threats. In North America, coyotes, raccoons, skunks and even hybrid coywolves have taken over the ecological DOGS ARE NOT THE WHOLE PROBLEMEven countries without free-living dogs continue to struggle with bites and fatalities.'In England and Wales, hospital admissions for dog bites rose 88% between 2007 and 2021-22, and deaths linked to dogs have surged by 850% since 1983. Most of these incidents involve owned dogs, not strays,' Prof. Srinivasan research shows India's street dog bite rates are actually lower than in parts of the UK, a surprising finding that challenges the assumption that eliminating street dogs will automatically improve public CASE FOR ABC AND MASS VACCINATIONIndia's existing policy, the Animal Birth Control-Anti Rabies Vaccination (ABC-ARV) programme, is both cost-effective and globally endorsed by the WHO.'When done properly, ABC-ARV stabilises dog populations, reduces rabies, and lowers injury risks. Goa's rabies control programme recorded zero human rabies deaths for five consecutive years after its intensive vaccination and sterilisation drive,' she she emphasises that the current scale is inadequate. 'We need far more investment in universal, free post-exposure prophylaxis, mass vaccination, and public education on safe human-dog interactions,' she OPINION ISN'T AS POLARISED AS HEADLINES SUGGESTSContrary to the perception that the public overwhelmingly wants dogs removed, Prof. Srinivasan's surveys across Chennai, Jaipur, and Malappuram reveal a majority support vaccination and sterilisation over than 70% opposed killing all street dogs, even amongst those who had been bitten. The picture is far more moderate than extreme social media narratives suggest,' she THE COURT'S CONCERN IS VALID, BUT THE FIX COULD BACKFIREWhile Prof. Srinivasan acknowledges the Court's intent to safeguard public health, she warns that high-visibility removals can create a 'false sense of having taken action' while diverting resources from measures that actually work.'If the goal is to reduce rabies and bites, the science is clear, removal is not the way,' she concluded. 'Cities thrive when public health measures are rooted in science, implemented consistently, and supported by communities.'- EndsMust Watch
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
UAE: What is Abu Dhabi's ‘Hayat' program? How it enabled 1,090 life-saving organ transplants since 2017
Abu Dhabi completed 1,090 organ transplants since 2017 under the Hayat programme, including 290 in 2024 across four hospitals/Image: WAM In a landmark achievement that underscores Abu Dhabi's rise as a centre of advanced medical care, the Emirate has successfully completed over 1,000 organ transplants through its national organ donation programme 'Hayat'. As of 2024, a total of 1,090 transplants have been carried out across leading transplant centres, demonstrating the UAE's growing capacity in life-saving medical procedures and its commitment to pioneering healthcare solutions. TL;DR: 1,090 organ transplants completed in Abu Dhabi since 2017 290 transplants in 2024, including heart, liver, kidney, lung, and pancreas Hayat' programme promotes organ donation for UAE residents aged 21+ A historic milestone in transplant medicine Abu Dhabi's journey in organ transplantation has reached a critical milestone, with 1,090 organ transplants performed between 2017, when the 'Hayat' National Programme for Donation and Transplantation of Human Organs and Tissue was launched, and 2024. The announcement was made on World Organ Donation Day (13 August 2025), highlighting the Emirate's expanding capabilities in complex medical procedures. The year 2024 alone saw a record 290 transplants, which included: 142 kidney transplants 117 liver transplants 22 lung transplants 7 heart transplants 2 pancreas transplants Leading centres and medical breakthroughs These procedures were carried out across four advanced transplant centres, all contributing significantly to the overall success of the programme: Cleveland Clinic Abu Dhabi (CCAD) Established in 2017 as the UAE's first multi-organ transplant centre, CCAD performed an impressive 241 transplants in 2024 alone. Among its standout achievements: First combined heart-lung transplant in the UAE First combined lung-liver transplant in the region (2023) First triple-paired kidney exchange in the UAE Houses the UAE's only lung transplant programme and the only ICU dedicated to multi-organ transplant patients Sheikh Khalifa Medical City (SKMC) A subsidiary of PureHealth, the largest healthcare platform in the Middle East, SKMC continues to enhance its transplant capabilities: Over 114 kidney transplants performed in 2024 Expanding liver transplant programme for both adult and paediatric patients Reinforces its position as a centre for world-class care and improved patient outcomes Burjeel Medical City (BMC) BMC has quickly risen as a key player in transplant innovation, with multiple national firsts: First paediatric living donor liver transplant in the UAE First ABO-incompatible kidney transplant Youngest paediatric liver transplant performed on a five-month-old patient Sheikh Shakhbout Medical City (SSMC) SSMC combines clinical care with research and academic excellence: Delivered 10 international conference presentations in the field Won Best Abstract Award at ISODP 2023 in Las Vegas Performed the UAE's first COVID-positive organ donation Ranked second in the UAE for the number of utilised organ donors in 2022 About the 'Hayat' programme Launched in 2017, Hayat is the UAE's National Programme for Donation and Transplantation of Human Organs and Tissues. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Pensioners Can Buy These Electric Cars in Malaysia - See Prices Here! Electric Cars | Search Ads Search Now Undo It was established following a Federal Decree Law passed in 2016 to position the UAE as a global role model in organ and tissue donation. Key Features of the Programme: Encourages both living and deceased donor registration Allows donation from deceased donors with the consent of their families Open to all UAE nationals and residents aged 21 and above Hayat's Goals Include: Regulating organ and tissue donation and transplant processes Providing care to patients with organ deficiencies Improving health and quality of life across communities Saving lives by promoting donor registration through the Hayat platform The programme serves as both a humanitarian initiative and a regulatory framework, aiming to develop a safe, ethical, and efficient transplantation ecosystem across the nation. FAQs: Q Who can register for the Hayat programme? Any UAE national or resident over the age of 21 can register to become an organ donor. Q . Can organs be donated after death? Yes. Deceased organ donation is possible with prior donor registration and family consent. Q. Which organs and tissues can be donated? Organs like the heart, lungs, liver, kidneys, pancreas, and tissues such as corneas, bones, and skin can be donated. Q. How can one register as a donor? Registration is available via the official Hayat platform, which is accessible online. Q. What impact does one organ donor have? A single donor can save up to 8 lives and enhance over 75 more through tissue donation.
Hindustan Times
3 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Bengaluru records over 13,800 dog bite cases in 6 months amid stray dog concerns
Bengaluru has recorded 13,831 dog bite cases within the first six months of 2025, all within the limits of the Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (BBMP). May registered the highest number of incidents at 2,562, while February saw the lowest, with 1,883 cases.(PTI) According to official data, May registered the highest number of incidents at 2,562, while February saw the lowest, with 1,883 cases, Deccan Herald reported. The sharp rise in cases mirrors a statewide trend, with Karnataka witnessing a 36% surge in dog bite incidents compared to the same period last year. Despite ongoing awareness programmes and vaccination drives, officials admit the numbers are "alarming." According to BBMP's Annual Anti-Rabies Vaccine (ARV) report, a total of 50,055 dogs have been vaccinated in the city so far. Bengaluru's stray dog population, as per BBMP's latest census, stands at 2.7 lakh, the DH report further added. Karnataka needs an estimated 38,000 to 40,000 rabies vaccine doses every month, and all government hospitals are required to treat dog bite victims free of cost. (Also Read: Bengaluru civic body rolls out Aadhaar-based eKhata mutation: Here's a step-by-step guide) Supreme Court on stray dogs A plea regarding the relocation of stray dogs was mentioned before a bench led by Chief Justice of India DY Chandrachud on Wednesday. CJI Chandrachud briefly responded, saying, 'I will look into it.' This comes in the wake of the Supreme Court's recent directive on Monday, ordering that all stray dogs in Delhi-NCR be picked up within eight weeks and housed in shelters to be set up by the appropriate authorities. The order has sparked a flurry of reactions, while some have welcomed the move as a much-needed relief from rising dog bite incidents, others have criticised it as impractical and warned that forced relocation could worsen human-animal conflict. The matter was again brought before the court along with a reminder of its previous ruling, which barred the relocation or culling of stray dogs and stressed strict compliance with animal welfare laws. (With agency inputs) (Also Read: Bengaluru Metro's Yellow-Green crossover caught on camera, video goes viral)
