B'putra water flow not dependent on China: Himanta busts Pak scare narrative
2
Guwahati: After India decisively moved away from the outdated
Indus Waters Treaty
, Pakistan is now spinning a new scare narrative — what if China stops Brahmaputra water to India? Assam chief minister
Himanta Biswa Sarma
's response, backed by researchers, dismantles this myth saying the Brahmaputra grows in India and not shrinks.
"Let's dismantle this myth — not with fear, but with facts and national clarity," Sarma wrote on X reminding Pakistan that "Brahmaputra is not a river India depends on upstream — it is a rain-fed Indian river system, strengthened after entering Indian territory."
Sarma further wrote on X that China contributes only about 30–35% of the Brahmaputra's total flow, mostly through glacial melt and limited Tibetan rainfall, while remaining 65–70% is generated within India, thanks to torrential monsoon rainfall in Arunachal Pradesh, Assam, Nagaland, and Meghalaya.
Sarma listed the major tributaries like Subansiri, Lohit, Kameng, Manas, Dhansiri, Jia-Bharali, Kopili which feed Brahmaputra river inside India in addition to the inflows from the Khasi, Garo, and Jaintia Hills via rivers such as Krishnai, Digaru, and Kulsi.
Sarma said if China turns off the tap, which he says is unlikely, it may actually help India mitigate the annual floods in Assam, which displace lakhs and destroy livelihoods every year.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Xu hướng tủ lạnh 2025: Chọn lựa thông minh với giá cả hợp lý
LocalPlan
Đọc thêm
Undo
Sarma pointed out that at the India-China border at Tuting in Arunachal Pradesh's Upper Siang district, the flow is about 2,000 to 3,000 m³/s which swells to 15,000–20,000 m³/s in Assam plains and swells during the monsoon.
"Meanwhile, Pakistan — which has exploited 74 years of preferential water access under the Indus Waters Treaty — now panics as India rightfully reclaims its sovereign rights," Sarma added.
Researcher Nilanjan Ghosh, who is also the vice-president at Development Studies and senior director at Observer Research Foundation at Kolkata centre, backing Sarma's fierce response to Pakistan, replied that conclusive evidence were provided that Chinese interventions will have negligible or almost no effect to India but "unfortunately, over the last decade, nobody listened to us, despite that I wrote on this on so many forums.
"
Ghosh cited a scientific paper published in International Journal of Water Resources Development, which he co-authored with Sayanangshu Modak, a human-environment geographer and a scholar of water governance, that the Yarlung Tsangpo's (the main stem of the Brahmaputra system in Tibet) "contribution to the Brahmaputra flow is not even 30-35%, but in the range of 15-20% at most."
Modak is also a doctoral researcher at the University of Arizona at Tucson.
"Unfortunately, over the last decade, nobody listened to us, despite that I wrote on this on so many forums," Ghosh wrote on X, appreciating Sarma for recognising these facts.
Ghosh cited another article, "How data deficiency is hindering hydro-diplomacy between China and India" published on Mongabay last Feb, which he co-authored with Modak where they pointed out that the discharge of the Yarlung Tsangpo, measured at Nuxia in Tibet, is 31.2 billion cubic meters (BCM) annually, swelling to an estimated 135.9 BCM as it passes through the Great Bend and exits China, the rain-rich stretch of the river where China plans to harness hydropower.
"However, when compared with the annual discharge of approximately 526 BCM at Pandu in Guwahati, India, and 606 BCM at Bahadurabad in Bangladesh, the data begins to unravel. This dramatic surge isn't driven by glacial melt but by the sheer force of the monsoon on the south side of the Himalayan crestline which extends predominantly to Medog County through a moisture corridor along the Yarlung Tsangpo Grand Canyon," they wrote in the article.
The Brahamputra river system originates in the Angsi Glacier in Tibet and flows to the Bay of Bengal, covering a distance of 2,880 km. The river starts as Yarlung Tsangpo for 1,625 km before entering India where it flows for 918 km — first as the Siang, then the Dihang, before transforming into the Brahmaputra. Its final 337-km stretch before entering the sea is in Bangladesh where it is named as Jamuna, merging with the Ganga.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
United News of India
36 minutes ago
- United News of India
Foreign Secretary Misri calls on Nepal PM Oli, hands over invite for India visit
Kathmandu/New Delhi, Aug 17 (UNI) Indian Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri, who is visiting Kathmandu, called on Nepalese Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli today and formally handed over an invitation for his India visit. During the meeting with Oli at the latter's office in Singha Durbar, Misri handed him the invitation letter on behalf of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, according to the Prime Minister's Secretariat. "During the courtesy meeting with Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli, Indian Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri handed over an invitation letter from the Prime Minister of India, Narendra Modi, to Oli. Prime Minister Oli thanked him for the invitation," the PM's Secretariat told Nepalkhabar. The Indian side has proposed September 16-17 for Oli's India visit. However, the dates for the visit have not yet been finalised. Misri arrived on a two-day official visit to Nepal in the morning at the invitation of his Nepali counterpart Amrit Bahadur Rai. He paid courtesy calls on President Ram Chandra Paudel, Nepali Congress President Sher Bahadur Deuba, CPN (Maoist Centre) Chairman Pushpa Kamal Dahal 'Prachanda' and Foreign Minister Dr Arzu Rana Deuba. Misri called on President Ramchandra Paudel at the President's Office, Sheetal Niwas, today. On the occasion, Paudel said Nepal has benefitted from India's progress as a close neighbour and friend, and expressed hope for greater benefits in the future. 'As a rising international power, India's progress in socio-economic and technological fields has made us happy and encouraged. As a close friend and neighbour, Nepal has benefitted from India's achievements and seeks to gain more,' Paudel's Press Advisor Kiran Pokharel quoted him as saying. Highlighting the longstanding social, cultural, religious, spiritual, economic, and people-to-people ties between the two nations, President Paudel said Nepal-India relations are based on sovereign equality, friendly cooperation, mutual respect and trust. He added that Nepal has always placed high priority on its relations with India and appreciates India's 'Neighborhood First' policy. According to the President's Press Advisor, Misri said under PM Modi's policy of prioritising neighbouring countries, Nepal holds an important place. Misri also expressed confidence that his visit would provide an opportunity to discuss enhancing connectivity for mutual progress and development in the modern era, thereby further strengthening bilateral relations. Misri also paid a courtesy call on CPN (Maoist Centre) and former Prime Minister Pushpa Kamal Dahal at the latter's personal residence in Lalitpur, according to Dahal's secretariat. During the meeting, they exchanged views on various dimensions of Nepal-India relations. FS Misri and his Nepalese counterpart Amrit Bahadur Rai held a bilateral meeting this evening. During the meeting, the two secretaries discussed various issues of bilateral cooperation ranging from connectivity to trade, and development collaboration to bilateral partnership, reinforcing the robust bond between the two countries. "The discussions covered a wide range of issues, including connectivity, trade and development cooperation, underscoring the strong bond between the two nations," the Nepalese Foreign Ministry said. Earlier after his arrival in the morning, Misri performed a special puja at the Pashupatinath Temple in Kathmandu. Misri will return home on Monday, wrapping up his two-day visit to Nepal. The Indian Embassy in Nepal said in posts on X: 'Foreign Secretary @VikramMisri called on the Rt. Hon'ble President of Nepal Mr. Ramchandra Paudel @RcPaudelNepal and conveyed greetings of the Indian leadership, apart from briefing Hon'ble President on the progress in bilateral ties.' 'Foreign Secretary @VikramMisri called on the Rt. Hon'ble Prime Minister of Nepal, Mr. K.P. Sharma Oli @kpsharmaoli. 'FS reaffirmed the deep civilizational ties and strong India-Nepal partnership, and discussed ways to further strengthen cooperation across various sectors.' UNI RN SSP
Time of India
41 minutes ago
- Time of India
‘Not off the table': Marco Rubio leaves door open for Ukraine-Russia ceasefire; urges negotiations toward permanent peace
Secretary of State Marco Rubio (File Photo) Secretary of State Marco Rubio on Sunday said that while the United States, Russia and Ukraine view a permanent peace deal as the best way to end the war, a temporary ceasefire between Ukraine and Russia is 'not off the table. ' 'It was agreed to by all that the best way to end this conflict is through a full peace deal,' Rubio said during an interview with NBC News. 'There's no doubt about that. I mean, who would be against the fact that tomorrow we came to you and said, 'We have a full peace deal, and it's done.' I think that's the best way to end the war.' 'Now, whether there needs to be a ceasefire on the way there, well, we've advocated for that,' Rubio added. 'Unfortunately, the Russians, as of now, have not agreed to that.' Rubio's comments came hours after President Donald Trump returned from Alaska, where he met with his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin and a delegation of Russian leaders. Although Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and other officials were not present at the talks, US officials still expressed hope that progress could be made toward a ceasefire or eventual peace agreement. After the Alaska summit, Trump told reporters, 'There's no deal until there's a deal.' by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like The 5 Books Warren Buffett Recommends You To Read in 2025 Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Undo Rubio placed the responsibility for stalled progress on Moscow, pointing to continued Russian strikes in Ukraine. 'We think usually it's very hard to negotiate when you're in the middle of hostilities. But that said, the only way to have a ceasefire is for both sides to agree to stop firing at one another ... and the Russians just haven't agreed to that,' he said. Zelenskyy is expected at the White House on Monday to meet with Trump and European leaders, including German Chancellor Friedrich Merz, UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer, Finland President Alexander Stubb, European Commission President Ursula von der Leye and Nato Secretary-General Mark Rutte. At a joint press conference with von der Leye in Brussels on Sunday, Zelenskyy said a ceasefire is crucial to advance peace deal negotiations. 'Putin has many demands, but we do not know all of them, and if there are really as many as we have heard about, then it will take a lot of time to go through all of them, and it is impossible to do this under the pressure of weapons," Zelenskyy told reporters. "So, it is necessary to stop the fire and work quickly on a final agreement. We will talk about this in Washington. Putin does not want to stop the killings, but he must do it. ' Rubio also defended the Trump administration's decision not to impose new sanctions on Russia, arguing that such measures could undermine ongoing peace efforts. 'If we're not going to be able to reach an agreement here at any point, then there are going to be consequences, not only the consequences of the war continuing, but the consequences of all those sanctions continuing, and potentially new sanctions on top of it as well. But what we're trying to do right now is end the war,' Rubio said during interview. 'I don't think new sanctions on Russia are going to force them to accept ceasefire. They're already under very severe sanctions," he added. The secretary of state said imposing new sanctions on Russia could undermine efforts to reach a lasting peace deal. He also defended the Trump administration's decision not to impose new sanctions on Russia, arguing that such measures could undermine ongoing peace efforts. Senator Chris Murphy, Democrat of Connecticut, had called Trump's meeting with Putin 'a disaster'. 'That meeting was a disaster. It was an embarrassment for the United States. It was a failure. Putin got everything he wanted,' Murphy said. 'Trump said, 'If I don't get a ceasefire, Putin is going to pay a price.' And then he walked out of that meeting saying, 'I didn't get a ceasefire. I didn't get a peace deal, and I'm not even considering sanctions,'' Murphy added. 'You heard Secretary Rubio downplay sanctions. And so Putin walks away with his photo op with zero commitments made and zero consequences. What a great day for Russia.'
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
CPM Kerala unit lands in controversy after party businessman alleges Govindan's son involved in leaking of his letter to politburo
1 2 3 Kozhikode: The CPM state unit found itself in the centre of a controversy with Chennai-based businessman Muhammed Sharshad B alleging that party secretary M V Govindan's son Shyamjith could be involved in the leak of a private complaint letter he had written to the party politburo against UK-based businessman Rajesh Krishna, who is also associated with the party. In a letter to CPM general secretary M A Baby on Aug 12, Sharshad questioned how the confidential letter came into the possession of Krishna and was used as primary evidence in the defamation case filed by him in the Delhi high court. "I suspect the possible involvement of Shyam, son of M V Govindan in this matter. My concern arises from his reportedly close association with Rajesh Krishna, particularly in connection with financial dealings involving a well-known industrialist from Malabar — a matter which, I understand, was previously settled by Rajesh," Sharshad said. He also urged Baby to launch a thorough inquiry into how this breach of confidentiality occurred. "I also urge you to take appropriate steps to safeguard internal communications and uphold the values of trust and discipline within the party," Sharshad said. In an earlier letter to the politburo, Sharshad alleged that many CPM functionaries were having close contacts with Krishna. He also alleged that a private security services firm transferred large sum of money to India under the guise of undertaking its activities and redirected it to unrelated accounts. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Could This NEW Collagen Blend Finally Reduce Your Cellulite? Vitauthority Learn More Undo He added that such large-scale transactions were made to personal accounts including his former wife Ratheena and handed over to major Left leaders, not just during election times but regularly through account heads like consultancy and other services. Sharshad told reporters in Kannur on Sunday that Govindan ignored the complaint he had raised against Krishna. Sharshad said that while former party state secretary Kodiyeri Balakrishnan kept Krishna away from the party after allegations were lodged against him, Krishna was able to make a strong comeback after Govindan became the party state secretary. When asked by the media whether he had evidence that Shyamjith leaked the letter, Sharshad said that he did not have direct evidence, but the circumstances pointed to that. "Otherwise, there was no reason for leaders in the party state secretariat and state committee to support him. Shyam might have been forced to help him," Sharshad said adding that though he had tried many times to meet Govindan after he bacame party secretary, he could not do it. Sharshad reiterated that Krishna had settled some financial dealings engaged by Shyamjith in connection with a film project. "Govindan would be remaining silent to protect his son. I have told Govindan all matters personally at Apollo hospital in Chennai, but the complaint was ignored. If the stand taken by Balakrishnan had continued, then Krishna would not have become a delegate in the CPM party congress in Madurai. Sharshad alleged that he suspected that the letter written by him to the politburo was presented as evidence along with the defamation complaint lodged by Krishna to embarrass the party. Though Krishna was invited to attend the party congress in Madurai, he was asked to stay away from the event after Sharshad lodged complaint against him. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
