McDonald says all rights should be respected after Sinn Féin TD criticised
Mary Lou McDonald says she wants everyone to be able to live a 'full, authentic life' following criticism of a social media post by a Sinn Féin TD on trans issues.
Last week, Sinn Féin health spokesman David Cullinane apologised for a post on X, formerly Twitter, about the UK court ruling on excluding trans women from the definition of 'woman' in equality law.
Advertisement
Mr Cullinane said the 'complex' issue needs to be approached with 'compassion' and he apologised for any offence caused.
The UK Supreme Court ruled last week that the terms 'woman' and 'sex' in the 2010 Equality Act 'refer to a biological woman and biological sex'.
Sinn Féin TD David Cullinane (Brian Lawless/PA)
This means transgender women with a gender recognition certificate can be excluded from single-sex spaces, such as changing rooms and homeless hostels, if 'proportionate'.
On Wednesday evening, Mr Cullinane called for the ruling to be 'fully examined in this state'.
Advertisement
The Waterford TD said on X: 'The Scottish (sic) Supreme Court ruling on the legal meaning of woman is a common sense judgment.
'The ruling found that for the purposes of equality legislation a 'woman' means a biological woman & 'sex' refers to biological sex.
'It also confirmed that trans people are protected under their Equality legislation in a separate category of gender reassignment.'
He subsequently deleted the post and stated: 'I want to apologise for the hurt and offence that I have caused to the trans community following a tweet I sent last night.
Advertisement
'That was never my intention. This is a complex issue for many but we need to approach it with compassion, understanding and dignity for all.
'I'm sure those in the trans community will feel vulnerable and isolated today in the aftermath of yesterday's judgment, and I apologise that my words added to that.'
On Friday, Ms McDonald said Mr Cullinane had explained his position in the subsequent post.
Sinn Féin housing spokesman Eoin O Broin said his colleague 'responded appropriately' in deleting the tweet and apologising (Cillian Sherlock/PA)
The Sinn Féin leader said a problem with social media is that it is 'immediate, fast and reflexive', adding that short posts are not the best way to comment on 'sensitive and complicated matters'.
Advertisement
Speaking on the Late Late Show, Ms McDonald said the matter was not an 'abstract issue' for her personally.
'I have a trans sibling, and I love my sister. She's compassionate and clever and accomplished, and she's loved beyond measure and unconditionally.
'I want her to live a full, authentic life. I want that for every human being and I want us to live in a society where that's possible.'
She added: 'So, the first thing in discussing any of the issues around this, you need to have the right atmosphere, and we need to reassure each other that we're starting from a position of respect.
Advertisement
'If we don't have that, we can't have the conversation to clarify, to reassure and to straighten out the issues that need to be addressed.
'So for me, I look across to Britain, you look further afield and you see a really toxic, divided, divisive approach to issues that can't be solved in a hostile environment.'
Pressed on whether the UK Supreme Court decision would influence Sinn Fein policies, Ms McDonald said it would have implications in Northern Ireland.
However, she said it was unclear what influence it would have in the Republic of Ireland.
She added: 'The first decision has to be that we work for equality, for inclusion and, by the way, the rights of everybody can be protected and maintained.
'We shouldn't have to select individuals – women, men, trans women, trans men – everybody has to have their rights respected, and I believe that we can that to point in a fair, balanced way that brings reassurance to people.'
Earlier, Sinn Féin housing spokesman Eoin O Broin said trans constituents contacted him after being 'upset' by Mr Cullinane's social media post.
Mr O Broin said his colleague 'responded appropriately' in deleting the tweet and apologising, adding that he was satisfied the matter was closed.
Asked if the party needed to clarify its position on transgender people, Mr O Broin said: 'The party's policies are the party's policies.
'And David Cullinane did the right thing in removing the tweet and apologising.
'I've been contacted by quite a few constituents who are trans, or family members of trans people who were very upset by it.
'Obviously, the party is doing a piece of work around further developing a policy on trans rights and trans healthcare in due course.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Western Telegraph
20 minutes ago
- Western Telegraph
Defections are ‘good thing', claims Badenoch
Nigel Farage's Reform – which claimed to have 11,000 members north of the border – has taken a steady stream of councillors from the Tories in Scotland in recent months, most recently on Thursday when Aberdeenshire representative Lauren Knight made the move. The shift comes after the party surged in the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse Holyrood by-election, rising to third and coming close to the SNP in the seat, won by Labour's Davy Russell. Ms Badenoch spoke on Friday (Andrew Milligan/PA) But despite the perceived threat to the Tories from Reform, Ms Badenoch said she did not have an issue with people leaving for the party. 'Reform are not a centre-right party,' she told journalists at the Scottish Tory conference. 'This is a party that's talking about nationalising oil and gas. 'This is a party that wants to increase benefits at a time when the benefits bill is so high. 'So if Nigel Farage is taking out of the Conservative Party the people who are not Conservatives, then I'm quite fine with that. 'One of the things that we ned to do is make sure that people see an authentic Conservative Party, we don't want people who want nationalisation and more benefits.' The Reform UK leader is a 'threat to the union', Ms Badenoch said (Jeff Moore/PA) She later added: 'If offering a very, very clear kind of conservatism is now sending out the people from our party who don't believe in our values in the long run, that's a good thing. 'There is no point in us just accumulating lots of people who don't believe in conservatism just so we can win, then when we get into government, we can't govern. 'That's what we saw happen before, that's what we're seeing with Labour, they don't have a plan. 'They just had a plan to win elections and now they're going round and round in circles. 'We want to have people who believe in our agenda, not just people who want to be politicians.' The Tory leader also hit out at former Tory MSP Jamie Greene – who defected to the Lib Dems earlier this year, attacking his support for the Scottish Government's controversial – and ultimately blocked – gender reforms. 'How anyone could have supported what was obviously a mad piece of legislation and think themselves a Conservative is beyond me,' she said. Former party leader Jackson Carlaw and current health spokesman Dr Sandesh Gulhane both also backed the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill. Speaking as she made her first appearance at the Scottish Tory conference since taking over as leader, Ms Badenoch declared Nigel Farage a 'threat to the union'. 'If he wants the SNP to have another five years, then that is a threat to the union,' she said. She pointed to an interview Mr Farage gave to the Times earlier this year where he suggested his party could side with the SNP ahead of Labour, but he added that Scotland was 'not going to leave the United Kingdom, it's not going to happen in a month of Sundays'. In her speech, the Tory leader said: 'In April this year, Nigel Farage said he would be fine with the SNP winning another five years in power. 'He's fine with another five years of higher bills, longer waiting lists, declining school standards, gender madness, and ultimately, independence.' Addressing members of the party, she said 'Scottish people deserve better' than another five years of the SNP – the party currently leading in the polls ahead of next year's election – while also announcing her party would scrap the windfall tax on oil and gas if it wins back power at the next UK-wide vote. While the SNP may be in the lead, some polls suggest Reform could beat Labour to second place and push the Tories to fourth. A pleasure welcoming @KemiBadenoch to Scottish Tory conference. Together, we're fighting for a common-sense future for our country 🇬🇧🏴#SCC25 — Russell Findlay MSP (@RussellFindlay1) June 13, 2025 'In April this year, Nigel Farage said he would be fine with the SNP winning another five years in power,' she said in her speech. 'He's fine with another five years of higher bills, longer waiting lists, declining school standards, gender madness, and ultimately, independence.' Addressing her first Scottish conference since taking on the top job, Ms Badenoch claimed: 'Reform will vote to let the SNP in, Conservatives will only ever vote to get the nationalists out.' Part of her 'positive vision of the future' includes 'standing up' for the North Sea oil and gas industry, with Mrs Badenoch claiming that by increasing the energy profits levy – also known as the windfall tax – the Tories had introduced, Labour is 'killing the oil and gas industry'. Speaking about the levy, she said: 'Frankly if it is allowed to remain in place until 2030, as is Labour's current plan, there will be no industry left to tax. 'Thousands will have been made unemployed and all the while we import more gas from overseas – from the very same basin in which we are banned from drilling.' She called on the UK Government to remove the energy profits levy, as she added that the Tories would also 'scrap the ban on new licences' for oil and gas developments that has been imposed since Labour came to power. 'We will champion our own industry,' Mrs Badenoch told supporters. 'We will let this great British, great Scottish industry thrive, grow and create jobs – ensuring our energy security for generations to come and making Scotland richer in the process.'
Evening Standard
24 minutes ago
- Evening Standard
Defections are ‘good thing', claims Badenoch
Addressing members of the party, she said 'Scottish people deserve better' than another five years of the SNP – the party currently leading in the polls ahead of next year's election – while also announcing her party would scrap the windfall tax on oil and gas if it wins back power at the next UK-wide vote.
The National
31 minutes ago
- The National
Coatbridge couple lose court case to restore Winter Fuel Payment
Pensioners Peter and Flo Fanning, from Coatbridge, took their case to the Court of Session in Edinburgh, claiming that both sets of decision-makers failed to consult pensioners and did not release an equality impact assessment on the changes. The Court of Session ruled to refuse the petition on Friday morning. Peter and Flo lost their entitlement to the financial assistance and became worried about their ability to afford their heating costs. READ MORE: Plans approved to turn Robert Burns-linked estate into whisky distillery Peter, 73, receives a state and a work pension, while Flo, 72, receives just a state pension. They do not meet the criteria to qualify for pension credits and decided to take action in a bid to have the benefit restored for all who previously received it. Peter said he was going to court to "give a voice" to other pensioners. The couple both suffer from medical conditions that are made worse by the cold. During the winter, they say they have to use their household heating daily to combat symptoms. Peter and Flo Fanning (Image: PA) They also claimed the decision to end the £300 benefit for thousands of people across the country last year was "irrational" and breached their human rights. Lady Hood found that neither of the governments had failed to exercise their duties under the Equality Act 2010 and neither was under a duty to consult. In her judgment, she stated: 'This case is not a verdict, nor even an expression of opinion, on the merits or demerits of government policy as debated in the public arena. 'The purpose of the case was to test a much "narrower question", namely whether the policy decisions made by the governments were unlawful, and if so liable to be struck down by the courts. READ MORE: Reform UK claim to have 11,000 Scottish members in challenge to Labour 'I shall therefore repel the petitioners' first to eighth pleas-in-law and refuse the petition. The question of the appropriate remedies, had I found in the petitioners' favour therefore does not arise.' Late Alba Party leader Alex Salmond was instrumental in putting the Fannings in touch with the Govan Law Centre ahead of the action being raised. A spokesperson from Govan Law Centre, who represented the couple, said they still felt the action had been merited and worthwhile. They added: "While our clients have lost their case at first instance, we have no doubt that this litigation has been influential in securing the partial U-turn made by the Scottish Government last November and the major policy U-turn confirmed by the UK Government earlier this week. "We hope that Holyrood will now follow suit and restore the Winter Fuel Payment in full for people such as our clients." Westminster abandoned plans to withdraw the payments from all but the poorest pensioners after the scheme drew widespread criticism. The Scottish Government had already launched its own Winter Fuel Payment in response to the original cut, which included extra support for those less well-off, but also a universal payment which is unaffected by income.
