'Newton's third law': Schmidt defence of rested Tizzano
Tizzano has been omitted from the match-day 23 for Saturday's "dead rubber" in Sydney after being swept up in raging debate swirling around the Lions' last-gasp 29-26 second-Test win in Melbourne.
The Wallabies were furious that Jac Morgan's clearout on Tizzano in the build-up to Hugo Keenan's final-minute try at the MCG last Saturday went unpunished by the officials.
Lions flyhalf Finn Russell later accused Tizzano of making the most of the challenge, stating that he "obviously holds his head and tried to get a penalty from it", while former England flanker James Haskell declared the Wallabies replacement should have been sent off for "diving".
Schmidt, though, insists it's all a matter of physics.
"He's had a really tough week. He's copped a lot of online abuse," Schmidt told reporters.
"The only thing I'd say in defence of Carlo is that there were just over 54 Gs of force that went directly through the neck, which is enough to cause serious injury, although not to a rugby player who is as well conditioned as Carlo.
"We are all aware of Newton's third law - for every action there is an equal and opposite reaction.
"When that force hits him and the speed of his head collapsing down, he recoiled out the back of the ruck.
"I don't think he wanted to recoil like that but that's the nature of force. That there is an equal and opposite reaction.
"We weren't sure about him on Tuesday. He was still pretty sore. He was great today (Thursday). He was right back to the irrepressible character he is.
"I've advised Carlo to stay away from the media full stop, and the opinions that are out there. For Carlo, it's better that he sits this one out."
Schmidt made it clear in the bitter aftermath to last week's series-deciding loss that he felt Morgan's clear-out was illegal and the no-penalty decision went against World Rugby's campaign for player safety.
While the New Zealander escaped sanction, World Rugby chief Alan Gilpin was unimpressed.
Five days on and Schmidt wants to leave the saga in the past and focus on ensuring the Wallabies avoid becoming the first team to be whitewashed 3-0 in a Lions series in Australia since 1904.
"You can lament all sorts of things," Schmidt said.
"I actually feel like (Italian referee) Andrea Piardi had a good game.
"There's a couple of decisions we might not agree with, but I thought he refereed well. So we're not looking at refereeing decisions.
"We're looking at what we could have done better, making sure that we try to repair those things."
With agencies
Wallabies coach Joe Schmidt reckons resting Carlo Tizzano from the third Test against the British and Irish Lions is best for the flanker's welfare after becoming the target of online abuse.
Tizzano has been omitted from the match-day 23 for Saturday's "dead rubber" in Sydney after being swept up in raging debate swirling around the Lions' last-gasp 29-26 second-Test win in Melbourne.
The Wallabies were furious that Jac Morgan's clearout on Tizzano in the build-up to Hugo Keenan's final-minute try at the MCG last Saturday went unpunished by the officials.
Lions flyhalf Finn Russell later accused Tizzano of making the most of the challenge, stating that he "obviously holds his head and tried to get a penalty from it", while former England flanker James Haskell declared the Wallabies replacement should have been sent off for "diving".
Schmidt, though, insists it's all a matter of physics.
"He's had a really tough week. He's copped a lot of online abuse," Schmidt told reporters.
"The only thing I'd say in defence of Carlo is that there were just over 54 Gs of force that went directly through the neck, which is enough to cause serious injury, although not to a rugby player who is as well conditioned as Carlo.
"We are all aware of Newton's third law - for every action there is an equal and opposite reaction.
"When that force hits him and the speed of his head collapsing down, he recoiled out the back of the ruck.
"I don't think he wanted to recoil like that but that's the nature of force. That there is an equal and opposite reaction.
"We weren't sure about him on Tuesday. He was still pretty sore. He was great today (Thursday). He was right back to the irrepressible character he is.
"I've advised Carlo to stay away from the media full stop, and the opinions that are out there. For Carlo, it's better that he sits this one out."
Schmidt made it clear in the bitter aftermath to last week's series-deciding loss that he felt Morgan's clear-out was illegal and the no-penalty decision went against World Rugby's campaign for player safety.
While the New Zealander escaped sanction, World Rugby chief Alan Gilpin was unimpressed.
Five days on and Schmidt wants to leave the saga in the past and focus on ensuring the Wallabies avoid becoming the first team to be whitewashed 3-0 in a Lions series in Australia since 1904.
"You can lament all sorts of things," Schmidt said.
"I actually feel like (Italian referee) Andrea Piardi had a good game.
"There's a couple of decisions we might not agree with, but I thought he refereed well. So we're not looking at refereeing decisions.
"We're looking at what we could have done better, making sure that we try to repair those things."
With agencies
Wallabies coach Joe Schmidt reckons resting Carlo Tizzano from the third Test against the British and Irish Lions is best for the flanker's welfare after becoming the target of online abuse.
Tizzano has been omitted from the match-day 23 for Saturday's "dead rubber" in Sydney after being swept up in raging debate swirling around the Lions' last-gasp 29-26 second-Test win in Melbourne.
The Wallabies were furious that Jac Morgan's clearout on Tizzano in the build-up to Hugo Keenan's final-minute try at the MCG last Saturday went unpunished by the officials.
Lions flyhalf Finn Russell later accused Tizzano of making the most of the challenge, stating that he "obviously holds his head and tried to get a penalty from it", while former England flanker James Haskell declared the Wallabies replacement should have been sent off for "diving".
Schmidt, though, insists it's all a matter of physics.
"He's had a really tough week. He's copped a lot of online abuse," Schmidt told reporters.
"The only thing I'd say in defence of Carlo is that there were just over 54 Gs of force that went directly through the neck, which is enough to cause serious injury, although not to a rugby player who is as well conditioned as Carlo.
"We are all aware of Newton's third law - for every action there is an equal and opposite reaction.
"When that force hits him and the speed of his head collapsing down, he recoiled out the back of the ruck.
"I don't think he wanted to recoil like that but that's the nature of force. That there is an equal and opposite reaction.
"We weren't sure about him on Tuesday. He was still pretty sore. He was great today (Thursday). He was right back to the irrepressible character he is.
"I've advised Carlo to stay away from the media full stop, and the opinions that are out there. For Carlo, it's better that he sits this one out."
Schmidt made it clear in the bitter aftermath to last week's series-deciding loss that he felt Morgan's clear-out was illegal and the no-penalty decision went against World Rugby's campaign for player safety.
While the New Zealander escaped sanction, World Rugby chief Alan Gilpin was unimpressed.
Five days on and Schmidt wants to leave the saga in the past and focus on ensuring the Wallabies avoid becoming the first team to be whitewashed 3-0 in a Lions series in Australia since 1904.
"You can lament all sorts of things," Schmidt said.
"I actually feel like (Italian referee) Andrea Piardi had a good game.
"There's a couple of decisions we might not agree with, but I thought he refereed well. So we're not looking at refereeing decisions.
"We're looking at what we could have done better, making sure that we try to repair those things."
With agencies
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
2 minutes ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Wallabies win on the right side of violence
The Wallabies' victory over the British and Irish Lions was just on the right side of violence as they inhabited that elusive space between where all big Tests are won. It's been a while since they've been there - right on the edge, sometimes over it and always in the Lions faces - but Saturday night was the statement performance of the Joe Schmidt era. It also felt like a message to the Lions committee, to those of us in the media whose default position with Australian rugby can sometimes be doom and gloom, to the teams currently ranked above the Wallabies, and to those casual Wallabies supporters who might have fallen off the bandwagon. The message was: never turn your back on Australian rugby. Yes, there will be bumps on the road ahead - two Tests in South Africa are next - but the Wallabies won four halves out of the six in this series. Come on Ronan, free Willie The particulars of Will Skelton's contract with La Rochelle in France have always seemed to be - how can we put this diplomatically? - quite favourable to the club over country. It appears that Rugby Australia will now have to negotiate with the French to have Skelton play in the Rugby Championship, even though it is a bona fide World Rugby release window. Perhaps La Rochelle coach Ronan O'Gara will be sympathetic to Schmidt's cause. O'Gara has previously declared an interest in the Wallabies job, and no doubt the past two weeks have increased the appeal of that role. But it might be time for some back scratching first. The TMO lottery
7NEWS
2 hours ago
- 7NEWS
Lions coach Andy Farrell under fire after players caught with phones during lightning delay in loss to Wallabies
British and Irish Lions coach Andy Farrell has slammed any suggestions of player complacency as 'completely, utter rubbish' in the aftermath of a 'bittersweet' third Test loss to the Wallabies. While Wallabies coach Joe Schmidt had been alert to the possibility of a lightning break and said they had a 'plan', television broadcast showed Lions players — including player of the series Finn Russell — on their phones in the change rooms during a 38-minute delay of the eventual 22-12 defeat in Sydney. Players had been ordered off the field due to lightning striking near Accor Stadium early in the second half, when the Lions were trailing 8-0. Both sides were given 10 minutes to warm up, with the Wallabies shooting out to a 15-0 lead shortly after play resumed. Grilled by the critical British press to clarify the procedures surrounding the lightning delay, Farrell disputed any suggestions his players had failed to use the time seriously. 'That's completely utter rubbish. Utter rubbish,' Farrell said. 'You don't know until you know, and when you do know, then you have to agree that the warm-up time allocated is going to be acceptable to both teams. 'We agreed on 10 minutes for the warm-up, and through our advice from our experts in that field, we only made the call to come out five minutes before and stay there so that we'd be ready to go.' Farrell's Wallabies counterpart Schmidt said he had wanted his players to remain connected during the delay. 'We had been warned that there might be lightning, so we had a little bit of a plan,' Schmidt said. 'We wanted to make sure that players kept moving, so we had different guys rotating on the bikes. 'We had four balls in the change room that we were just throwing around, just so they could stay connected.' The Wallabies emerged the better side following the delay, with Farrell labelling winger Max Jorgensen's stunning 50-metre runaway try in the 55th minute as 'the try that broke the camel's back'. 'I suppose what came off the back of that is that Australia hit the ground running and thoroughly deserved their win,' Farrell said. 'Rigor mortis was setting in at one stage there for the lads. 'Anyway, I suppose that's what you come to expect with a schedule like a Lions schedule, so we've seen it all now, haven't we?' A serious head knock to Lions lock James Ryan had soured the opening minutes of the second half, just minutes before the lightning delay. Ryan had to be stretchered off after copping an accidental knee to the head from Will Skelton, but Farrell confirmed the 29-year-old was in 'good spirits'. 'He's up and talking. He was out there for a good few minutes,' Farrell said. 'But he's back up in good spirits, so hopefully he's going to be fine.' Lions lock Tadhg Beirne, named player of the series, could only describe the loss as a 'bittersweet moment'. 'We lost tonight, which is obviously a bit crap for us,' Beirne said. 'But as 'Faz' says, we'll get over that because at the end of the day, we still won the series. 'It's the last time we'll be in that change room together as a group, and I suppose that's the bitter part, that we won't get that moment again.'
News.com.au
2 hours ago
- News.com.au
‘Disgraceful': Rugby rocked by foul play by Lions captain as Wallaby concussed
British and Irish Lions star Dan Sheehan has been cited for a 'disgraceful' act of foul play during the Wallabies' big win on Saturday night in Sydney. The acting Lions captain will be forced to front an Independent Foul Play Review Committee (FPRC) hearing on Sunday after an ugly clean-out left Wallabies fly-half Tom Lynagh concussed. It was a sad end to a hard-fought engrossing series as the Wallabies showed impressive courage to win 22-12 in a chaotic third Test interrupted by lightning. However, the win has been soured somewhat by the ugly scenes of Lynagh failing his head injury assessment (HIA) following a shoulder to the head from Sheehan. Commentators, including Wallabies great Tim Horan, and fans were left flummoxed that the cleanout from Lions player Dan Sheehan that led to Lynagh's injury went unpunished. Many were stunned the incident was not looked at by the Television Match Official (TMO). Leading Irish rugby journalist Rúaidhrí O'Connor wrote on X: 'Dan Sheehan is incredibly lucky this wasn't a red card'. Aussie sport journalist Mark Gotlieb posted it was 'unforgivable by the TMO'. The Times rugby reporter Will Kelleher pondered if it was a 'dodgy clearout'. Rugby journalist Tom Decent wrote: 'Disgrace. Red card every day of the week. So dangerous. 'You can see Lynagh brace as he knows it's coming.' Veteran rugby reporter Iain Payten posted: 'Match officials do nothing. Ya kidding at this point'. Incredibly, Lynagh remained on the field for several more minutes before he was called off to undergo the HIA. Irish hooker Sheehan faces a potential suspension. World Rugby said in a statement: 'British & Irish Lions player Dan Sheehan will have a citing complaint reviewed by an Independent Foul Play Review Committee (FPRC) after being cited by the independent citing commissioner Adrien Menez for an act of foul play'. In bouts of torrential rain at Sydney's Stadium Australia, the hosts went to the break with an 8-0 lead after an eighth-minute try before showing steely nerve to finish the job. Dylan Pietsch and Max Jorgensen both dotted down to put them 15-0 clear. The Wallabies had thrown away an 18-point advantage to lose the second Test in heartbreaking fashion last week, but learned their lesson. They largely controlled the contest in front of 80,312 fans, swift at the breakdown and with plenty of attacking flair despite atrocious conditions. 'It was a disappointing week after such a tough loss,' Wallabies captain Harry Wilson said. 'To bounce back the way we did, I'm so proud of everyone. To get the win was so special.' The teams were forced from the field two minutes into the second half because of a lightning warning, with play suspended for 35 minutes. 'We spoke about that before the game, that it could happen,' Wilson said. 'We had a few plans in place. We just wanted this game so badly, whatever we had to do we were going to do.' Victory ensured the Lions' six-week visit ended in disappointment after winning all eight previous tour games. 'Our goal before the series was to try to win 3-0,' said Sheehan, who was the Lions acting captain after skipper Maro Itoje went off concussed. 'We gave it everything under harsh circumstances. The Wallabies have been in every Test and I thought they deserved the win. 'It was a bit disappointing on our end to finish with this.' The Lions won the first Test comfortably 27-19 in Brisbane before clinching a controversial 29-26 series-winning victory in the last minute last week in Melbourne. That loss was gut-wrenching for Joe Scmhidt's Australia, the head coach rallied his injury-hit troops to bank the biggest win of his tenure. In doing so, they denied the Lions a first unbeaten series since 1974 and gained some much-needed confidence heading into the Rugby Championship this month.
