'Strange': Shubman Gill's defensive strategy at Edgbaston slammed by former England cricketer
Former England cricketer David Lloyd has criticised Shubman Gill's captaincy during the Edgbaston Test of the Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy, particularly questioning his defensive field placement when Harry Brook and Jamie Smith's partnership of 303 runs shifted the momentum.
Despite India's commanding first-innings total of 587, Lloyd found Gill's decision to spread the field with only two slips puzzling, especially when England were struggling at 84/5.
The partnership between Brook and Smith proved to be a significant turning point in the match. Brook scored 158 runs from 234 balls, while Smith contributed 184 runs from 207 deliveries. Their stand ranks as the second-best partnership for England's sixth wicket and the third-best against India overall.
"The runaway train. This game quickly went away from Shubman Gill. With 587 in the bank, I thought it was strange that the field was so defensive with only two slips. Regardless of the counter from Brook and Smith, that was the time to keep the pressure on. With three slips in there, it would have at least made them think twice because a few chances went there," Lloyd wrote in his Daily Mail column.
Akash Deep press conference: On replacing Jasprit Bumrah, message from Gautam Gambhir and more
England's innings witnessed a dramatic collapse after the Brook-Smith partnership.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
3.5, 4.5 BHK Homes starting at ₹4.89 Cr.*
Hero Homes
Learn More
Undo
The team lost their final five wickets for just 20 runs, ultimately conceding a 180-run lead to India.
India ended the day's play at 64/1, extending their lead to 244 runs.
"What a topsy-turvy day of cricket, with quite a remarkable scorecard in the end. Six of the England team were out for ducks. They were staring down the barrel, then came a magnificent counter attack and then from nowhere, the tail was blown away by Siraj, with Smith left high and dry on 184.
Surely somebody could have stayed with him," Lloyd noted.
IND vs ENG 2nd Test: Rain Arrives After Stumps on Day 3 | What It Means for India's Batting
Lloyd attributed England's batting collapses to mental fatigue rather than pitch conditions.
"Much of the talk on day two was that this is a lousy pitch. That went a bit quiet when England were 84 for five and in a bit of a pickle. Mental fatigue played a part because the batters' minds were scrambled after two days in the field. That's a great part of Test cricket. The Aussies called it mental disintegration. Apart from Brook and Smith, who played excellently, England were mentally spent," Lloyd explained.
For real-time updates, scores, and highlights, follow our live coverage of the
India vs England Test match
here.
Game On Season 1 continues with Mirabai Chanu's inspiring story. Watch Episode 2 here.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
15 minutes ago
- The Hindu
WI vs AUS, 2nd Test: Smith, Green score fifties to put Australia in control v West Indies on Day 3
Half-centuries by Steve Smith and Cameron Green turned Australia's situation against the West Indies from delicate to controlling on day three, Saturday of the second Test. Australia, 1-0 up in the three-Test series, was back in charge after recovering its second innings from 12 for two at the start of the day to 221 for seven at Stumps and a decent lead of 254 runs. With the pitch playing tricks, often shooting low, Australia was beginning to like its chances of setting a target that was beyond the West Indies' reach. AS IT HAPPENED: West Indies vs Australia, 2nd Test Day 3 Highlights 'We are in a nice spot,' Smith said. 'I don't think the wicket is going to get any better, will probably do a few more tricks. The new ball is going to be pretty crucial for us. Hopefully, we can get (the lead) up to somewhere around 300.' Australia generally laboured to score 209 runs in 58.3 overs, with around three delays for showers that added up to nearly two hours of play lost. When Stumps were called because of bad light, Alex Carey was on 26 off 27 balls with captain Pat Cummins on four. But they were on top. Smith joined Green after nightwatchman Nathan Lyon held out for nine overs to reach eight. The first ball Smith faced from Alzarri Joseph smashed his right glove. Inside the glove was the pinkie finger he dislocated in the World Test Championship final last month, and which sidelined him from the first Test in Barbados. 'It was not ideal (getting hit on the finger), but it feels all right,' Smith said. 'It is that kind of surface. Some can shoot up, you might have to take a few on the hands.' Green resumed the day on six and soon passed his highest score at No. 3 in the order, 15. After Lunch, his fifth boundary earned him 50 off 122 balls. ALSO READ: Shubman Gill scores 200 and 100 in same Test, 2nd Indian to achieve feat But on the next ball, he was out when he edged Shamar Joseph onto his stumps. Green finished on 52 and ended a 93-run partnership with Smith. Smith's sixth boundary brought up his 50 in 79 balls. He and Travis Head got Australia to Tea and a lead of 208. But soon after, Smith was trapped by Justin Greaves. Smith reviewed, but it showed the ball hitting his pad in front of the off-stump. His 71 off 119 balls included seven boundaries and a six flogged off Roston Chase over long-off. Greaves also got Beau Webster for 2, but Head and Carey gave the total a 31-run surge before Head's off-stump was bowled by Shamar Joseph on 39.
Time of India
20 minutes ago
- Time of India
FIFA Club World Cup: Mbappe magic seals Real Madrid's spot in semi-final vs PSG
Real Madrid's Kylian Mbappe, bottom, scores his side's 3rd goal. (AP Photo) Real Madrid held off a late Borussia Dortmund surge to clinch a 3-2 win and book their place in the semi-finals of the FIFA Club World Cup, where they will face European champions Paris Saint-Germain. The match, played under sweltering heat at the MetLife Stadium near New York City, saw Gonzalo Garcia and Kylian Mbappe steal the show for the Spanish giants. Gonzalo Garcia, 21, opened the scoring in the 10th minute, slotting home his fourth goal of the tournament after an inch-perfect cross from Arda Guler. Ten minutes later, full-back Fran Garcia doubled the lead, finishing off a flowing move that included a cutback from Trent Alexander-Arnold. Real Madrid dominated the opening stages, stifling Dortmund's rhythm and forcing them to chase shadows. Go Beyond The Boundary with our YouTube channel. SUBSCRIBE NOW! Coach Xabi Alonso praised his team's display but acknowledged the chaotic finish: 'Everything was going under control… but the last 10 minutes were kind of crazy. Overall, a good 80 minutes and the last 10 minutes to improve.' Indeed, Dortmund mounted a dramatic late comeback. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like An engineer reveals: One simple trick to get internet without a subscription Techno Mag Learn More Undo Maximilian Beier fired in from a loose clearance in the 93rd minute to make it 2-1. But Real's response was emphatic — Mbappe, who came off the bench in the second half, produced a sensational overhead kick to restore the two-goal cushion. WATCH: Mbappe, still yet to start in the tournament due to recent illness, now has his first goal of the Club World Cup and 44th of the season. "It will be a great challenge for us to face PSG, but let's take positives from today and move on for the next one," said Alonso ahead of the semi-final showdown. There was still more drama to come, as Dean Huijsen was sent off for bringing down Serhou Guirassy, who converted the resulting penalty to bring Dortmund back within a goal. Despite the scare, Real held on, much to the delight of the 76,611 fans in attendance — a repeat of the 2024 Champions League final, but with far more twists. Dortmund coach Niko Kovac reflected, 'It is a deserved win for Real Madrid. We showed our qualities and it is not a failure if you go home after a defeat against them.' Game On Season 1 continues with Mirabai Chanu's inspiring story. Watch Episode 2 here.
India Today
39 minutes ago
- India Today
ENG vs IND: Will rain spoil India's chances of maiden Test win at Edgbaston?
India, led by Shubman Gill, stand just seven wickets away from making a bold statement — their first-ever Test win at Edgbaston, and a dominant one at that. As the second Test heads into its final day, England find themselves deep in trouble, needing 536 more runs with only seven wickets in on the other hand, have done almost everything right so far. They piled on the runs with authority, declared at 427 in their second innings to set a daunting target of 608, and then ripped through England's top order before stumps on Day 4. Zak Crawley was dismissed for a duck, Ben Duckett couldn't survive either, and the biggest blow came when Joe Root was removed — all thanks to a disciplined bowling display from Mohammed Siraj and Akash vs IND 2nd Test Day 4 Updates Gill has led by example with the bat, scoring a stunning 269 in the first innings and following it up with a fluent 161 in the second. Siraj, with six wickets across the game, has spearheaded the bowling attack, while Akash Deep — standing in for Jasprit Bumrah — has delivered crucial breakthroughs when it are in the driver's seat, and the series, currently 1-0 in England's favour, could be levelled. But there's one big variable that could throw a spanner in the works — the Birmingham vs IND, Edgbaston Test: Rain threat on Day 5The rain gods might still have their say at Edgbaston. According to both the BBC and AccuWeather, showers are expected early in the morning on Day 5. The probability of rain is as high as 79% around 7 am local time. However, the forecast becomes more encouraging as the day progresses, with chances dropping to about 22% by 1 match is scheduled to begin at 10:30 am local time, which means the first session might be washed out — potentially delaying the start until after lunch. While that would eat into India's bowling time, it wouldn't entirely eliminate their are expected to stay under 20C, with steady cloud cover and strong wind gusts of up to 50 km/h. These conditions could heavily favour India's pace attack, giving the ball every chance to move around. Seam, swing, and pressure — India will have all the tools needed, as long as the skies don't completely close here we are: England hoping for a miracle or a downpour, India praying the weather holds long enough to make history. All signs point to an Indian win — except the clouds.- Ends
