Circular Debt of Pakistan: Understanding the Crisis
Circular debt is a major financial problem in Pakistan's energy sector, created by a mismatch between the cost of generating electricity and the revenue collected from consumers. It involves a complex chain of payments between different stakeholders, including power generation companies (IPPs), suppliers, distributors (Discos), gas utilities, and the government.
As of now, Pakistan's energy sector faces a massive deficit, with circular debt accumulating to around Rs2.3 trillion. This growing debt has significant economic implications, leading to inefficient power supply, higher electricity costs, and fiscal stress on the government.
What is Circular Debt?
Circular debt refers to the financial shortfall in Pakistan's energy sector, where various entities involved in electricity generation, supply, and distribution owe large amounts of money to each other. The problem is rooted in poor management, delayed payments, and inefficiencies in revenue collection.
The key players involved in this circular chain include the federal government, independent power producers (IPPs), government-owned power supply companies (Gencos and Discos), energy suppliers, and the financial institutions that finance the sector. These players often fail to pay one another on time, causing the debt to spiral out of control.
How Circular Debt Has Grown
Circular debt in Pakistan's energy sector has grown significantly over the years due to several factors:
Low Recoveries & Theft: Power companies struggle to recover payments from consumers, and widespread theft further exacerbates financial losses.
Unreimbursed Tariff Subsidies: The government has failed to fully compensate power companies for the tariff subsidies, increasing the debt burden.
Misaligned Billing Cycles: Billing inefficiencies and long delays in the collection process lead to a backlog of unpaid dues.
Capacity Payments: IPPs are required to make large capacity payments, regardless of whether electricity is generated or consumed. This contributes to the increasing debt as power plants get paid without generating enough electricity to cover costs.
As a result, the total circular debt has reached staggering amounts, leading to an unbalanced energy market where costs are passed down to consumers and institutions that are unable to meet their obligations.
Key Components of Circular Debt
The circular debt issue in Pakistan is divided into three main components:
Payables of PSC (Power Supply Chain): These are the costs incurred by the power supply chain, including losses from electricity theft, unpaid bills, and support for life-line consumers.
Payables of ESC (Energy Supply Chain): The ESC is burdened by unpaid fuel bills, especially for gas and other essential energy resources.
Payables of GOP (Government of Pakistan): The government owes significant amounts due to subsidies for power generation and distribution, as well as unpaid payments to energy companies.
Government's Response and Proposed Solutions
To address the growing circular debt, the Government of Pakistan has begun implementing several measures to resolve the issue. These steps focus on managing the debt more effectively, streamlining payments, and negotiating better terms with stakeholders.
Debt Settlement Efforts: The finance ministry has started discussions with IPPs and other stakeholders to settle the existing circular debt. Negotiations include restructuring payment terms and adjusting tariffs to lower the debt.
Debt Service Surcharge (DSS): A new DSS of Rs3.23 per kWh has been introduced, which will be added to electricity bills. This surcharge will help generate funds to pay off the outstanding debt to banks and other financial institutions.
Interest Rate Adjustments: The KIBOR (Karachi Interbank Offered Rate) has been adjusted to ease the debt burden, which will reduce the overall financial pressure on the sector.
Improving Cash Flow Management: The government has stressed the importance of transparent and real-time tracking of financial flows to better manage the circular debt and ensure timely payments.
Why Circular Debt Has Spiraled
The circular debt crisis in Pakistan's energy sector has spiraled out of control for several reasons:
Low Payment Recoveries: One of the main causes of the growing debt is the inability of power companies to recover payments from consumers. This is exacerbated by inefficiencies in billing and distribution.
Theft and Mismanagement: Power theft is rampant across the country, leading to significant financial losses. Poor management and a lack of accountability have only worsened the situation.
Structural Inefficiencies: The energy sector suffers from misaligned tariff structures, inadequate infrastructure, and weak planning, which causes delays in generating sufficient revenue to cover costs.
Governance Failures: A lack of effective governance and sector regulation has led to inflation in power tariffs and inefficiencies that have compounded the financial crisis.
Solutions and Future Roadmap
Moving forward, the Pakistani government must focus on comprehensive reforms to tackle circular debt in the energy sector:
Improving Billing and Collection Systems: The government needs to reform the billing process to ensure timely payments and minimize losses due to inefficient systems.
Better Financial Management: Effective cash flow management, including real-time tracking of payments, will help reduce inefficiencies and increase accountability.
Addressing Structural Inefficiencies: Tariffs must be reviewed and aligned with actual costs to ensure the sector remains financially viable in the long term.
Governance Reforms: Stronger governance and accountability measures will help improve sector management, reduce financial mismanagement, and ensure that funds are used effectively.
The circular debt problem in Pakistan's energy sector is a complex challenge that requires a multi-pronged solution. While the government has made strides in addressing the issue, long-term success depends on structural reforms, improved financial management, and better governance. By implementing these measures, Pakistan can begin to reduce its circular debt, improve energy supply, and create a more sustainable energy market for the future.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
a day ago
- Express Tribune
Bitcoin data centres to boost employment opportunities
Listen to article Pakistan plans to use its surplus electricity for Bitcoin mining in an effort to expand digital economic activity and increase foreign exchange earnings, officials say. The country's total power generation capacity stands at 46,000 megawatts, significantly exceeding demand. In summer, power consumption reaches 26,000 megawatts, while in winter it falls to just 10,000 megawatts. Due to seasonal variations in electricity usage, the government aims to divert excess capacity to Bitcoin mining. Under the plan, 2,000 megawatts of electricity will be allocated for this purpose. Officials say the initiative will provide a source of income without relying on imports and will help boost foreign reserves. The government, in collaboration with the private sector, will develop Bitcoin mining as part of its broader 'Digital Pakistan' strategy. Authorities say the move will generate state revenue and create job opportunities for youth through the establishment of modern data centres. Better utilisation of Independent Power Producers' (IPPs) capacity will also support the stability of the national power grid, according to the plan. Read: Pakistan's crypto bet: digital dream or power misstep? Previously, government announced to allocate 2,000 megawatts (MW) of electricity in the first phase of a national initiative to power bitcoin mining and AI data centres, finance ministry said. The allocation is part of government's plans to use its surplus electricity to bitcoin mining and AI data centres. Country's energy sector is grappling with challenges, including high electricity tariffs and surplus generation capacity. The rapid expansion of solar energy has further complicated the landscape, as more consumers turn to alternative energy sources to mitigate high costs. The initiative is spearheaded by the Pakistan Crypto Council (PCC), a government-backed body, which is part of a broader strategy to monetize surplus electricity, create high-tech jobs, and attract foreign investment, the ministry said. The allocation is the first phase of a broader, multi-stage digital infrastructure roll-out, it added.
Business Recorder
4 days ago
- Business Recorder
Iesco, Fesco and Gepco set for sell-off by Dec-end
ISLAMABAD: Three electricity distribution companies - Iesco, Fesco and Gepco - will be ready for privatisation by the end of December this year. This was stated by an official of the Power Division in the National Assembly Standing Committee on Economic Affairs' meeting held under the chairmanship of Muhammad Atif Khan. Additional Secretary Power Division Mehfooz Bhatti, in his presentation, told the committee that along with Privatisation Commission, the Power Division is working on the privatisation of all 10 Discos. He said that the privatisation process of Islamabad Electric Supply Company (Iesco), Gujranwala Electric Power Company (Gepco) and Faisalabad Electric Supply Company (Fesco) is already in advance stage. 'The due diligence process of these three Discos is in final stage and Financial Advisor has also been hired,' he said. The official said as per his information, the Privatisation Commission is working on the financial structure and by December this year, Expressions of Interest (EOIs) would be invited and terms and conditions of sale purchase agreement will also be finalised. Chairman Committee Atif Khan said that no one is stopping the government from privatising the Discos but it does not mean hiring in these Discos should be stopped. He said in his constituency for hundreds of kilometers there is only one lineman and because of this people were facing a lot of hardship in getting their complaints addressed. The Power Division official clarified that their ministry did not stop any Disco from hiring necessary staff. MNA Sher Ali Arbab said that as per his knowledge there are 80,000 vacancies in all 10 Discos but Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif has given approval to hire only 20,000-25,000 personnel to keep things afloat. Members, unanimously, expressed concern over the methodology that exclusively targets Discos with minimal transmission and distribution losses for privatisation. The committee emphasised that by limiting privatisation to only the most efficient utilities, the government would be compelled to retain chronically underperforming Discos, thereby, exacerbating existing operational challenges and making their eventual privatisation virtually unattainable. The Power Division official informed the committee that their current installed capacity is 39,952 MW that includes 46 percent from clean energy and 54 percent from fossil. The power sector informed that there is overreliance on fossil than clean energy. The Power Division presented a comprehensive overview of Pakistan's current power generation capacity to the Standing Committee, reporting a total installed capacity of 39,952 MW. The energy mix analysis revealed a concerning imbalance, with fossil fuel-based generation accounting for 54 percent compared to just 46 percent from clean energy sources. The committee was informed that Pakistan's power sector currently faces a significant surplus of approximately 7,000 to 8,000 MW in electricity generation capacity. Members expressed serious concern over the substantial financial burden imposed by capacity payments for this unused electricity, which continues to strain the national exchequer despite serving no practical purpose. The committee members raised serious concerns regarding the inequitable distribution of development projects and budget allocations for Khyber Pakhtunkhwa in the proposed federal budget for 2025-26. The committee noted with concern that while KP has a substantially larger population than Gilgit-Baltistan (GB), both regions have been allotted only two new projects each, reflecting an unjust disparity. Furthermore, the budgetary allocations for development projects across provinces revealed that Balochistan receiving Rs209.6 billion, Punjab Rs76.6 billion, Sindh Rs145.9 billion, and KP Rs30.843 billion. The Economic Affairs Division (EAD) informed the committee that it has filed appeals and interim relief applications, with hearings ongoing and the next scheduled for September 2025. Meanwhile, the EAD has sought the federal cabinet's in-principle approval for a new legislative framework, the 'Foreign Contributions (NGOs and NPOs) Regulation Act, 2025,' to address the legal gaps. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
4 days ago
- Business Recorder
Oh, the audacity of being a DISCO!
There was a reason the 'Apna Meter Apni Reading Scheme' earned public approval. It was not just about giving power back to the people; the real reason for the jubilation was that it took away from power distribution companies the opportunity to be dishonest with their customers. Now, an official audit has alleged massive irregularities in how consumers were billed in FY24 by state-owned DISCOs—the very same entities that were touted as the cornerstone of the Energy Ministry's performance in a recently held press conference. If this level of irregularity still resulted in a loss (inefficiencies and under-recovery) of Rs 591 billion by the end of FY24, then heaven help us if these DISCOs had been honest in their affairs. Meanwhile, the official audit—details of which have yet to be released publicly—has alleged that eight DISCOs, including one that is a front-runner for the government's privatisation agenda, were involved in overbilling consumers to hide their line losses, electricity theft, and other inefficiencies. These eight are out of the ten DISCOs operating in this sector. The argument for verifying DISCOs' data and information through external auditors could not have become stronger—every dataset that comes from these DISCOs needs independent scrutiny. The report states that five companies reportedly overbilled 278,649 consumers by Rs 47.81 billion in a single month. More than 900 million extra units were billed to customers during FY24, with no action taken against the officials responsible, the audit reveals. This is roughly 2.5 million units billed irregularly every single day—imagine the level of inefficiencies being masked. But is it really a surprise?The regulator, the National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (NEPRA), has already raised these concerns several times in its State of Industry Report. Understand this: these issues often only come to light when consumers raise complaints. In many cases, complaints aren't even brought to the authorities' attention. Millions of customers and yet, the lack of accountability is astonishing. Coming back to the audit. The AGP report attributes the overbilling to incorrect meter readings and violations of the official detection billing policy. These inflated bills were later revised, and refunds—proof of which, according to some media reports, was still not handed over to the AGP office—were issued. Crucially, the report concludes that this was not an accidental oversight but a deliberate attempt to conceal actual line losses and widespread electricity theft. Rather than addressing the underlying issues or holding responsible officials accountable, DISCOs have reportedly resorted to temporary credit adjustments. No disciplinary action has been taken, exposing a deep lack of transparency and institutional accountability. More troubling is the revelation that the DISCOs' management and the Ministry of Energy were made aware of these irregularities and yet failed to take meaningful corrective action. The inaction further underscores systemic governance failures within the power sector. Interestingly, the report identifies LESCO (Lahore Electric Supply Company) as having the highest number of overbilled consumers—11,996 in total. This is in the political stronghold of the leader of the coalition government. Separately, and prior to the release of this audit, Minister for Energy Sardar Awais Leghari praised the DISCOs for reducing line losses and power theft. He specifically lauded LESCO for outperforming others in loss reduction. However, this narrative now stands in stark contrast to the findings of the AGP report, which reveal that such improvements may have been achieved through manipulation of billing data rather than genuine operational efficiency. The issue isn't just that overbilling took place; what's worrying is that it seems to have become institutional practice. You cannot overbill millions and pocket billions unless multiple layers of management and stakeholders are involved. Perhaps the most interesting part of the media coverage on this was that 'despite repeated requests, relevant records were not shared with audit teams.' Such audacity!
