Public transport needs more than just LRT, says expert
GEORGE TOWN : Public transport systems that rely only on light rail transit (LRT) without a broader transport plan are bound to fail, says rail and transit systems expert TC Chew.
Speaking at a state-hosted forum on the future of transport in Penang, Chew said while LRT systems were often seen as a fix for urban congestion, they could only work if tied to good town planning that included effective land use, policy and long-term delivery.
'If you just offer an LRT system and do nothing else, you will fail,' the Royal Academy of Engineering fellow said at the forum held at Komtar.
Chew, who has worked on urban rail networks in Hong Kong, Singapore and the UK, said both Hong Kong's mass transit railway (MTR) and Singapore's mass rapid transit (MRT) succeeded because they were supported by strong government policy and land control.
He said the Hong Kong government, for example, used the profits made from the increased value of its property surrounding its rail network to fund MTR development.
'They started thinking about property as the key driver. But this only worked because the state had firm control over property. They could plan rail and development together,' he said.
Chew said in Singapore, laws were passed to allow the state to acquire land around new MRT lines, making sure the public also gained from the investment.
'The thinking was that if the state is paying for the MRT, the public should get some of the benefit, not just private developers,' he said.
Shifting political winds
Penang transportation executive councillor Zairil Khir Johari said the LRT project had been delayed for years mainly due to shifting political winds.
'We spent many years in the wilderness. The monorail was approved years ago, and the airport expansion too … both were shelved for political reasons,' he said.
The federal government, under the late former prime minister Abdullah Ahmad Badawi, had mooted a monorail project, but it was shelved in 2008 due to changes in national priorities.
Zairil said the state government was therefore moving quickly now – while federal politics allowed it.
He said Penang had already started planning the LRT before receiving federal support, and even held advanced talks with the Asian Development Bank on funding, but had seen slow progress without federal approval.
'There are many ways to skin a cat. Of course, the cat becomes smaller without federal backing. But Penang will always find a way,' he said.
The Mutiara LRT line, which will run from Komtar to Bayan Lepas, with a spur line from the Macallum area to Butterworth, is now being built by the federal government through the transport ministry and MRT Corp.
Work on the RM17 billion, 29.5km project is expected to begin this year.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Free Malaysia Today
30 minutes ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Certain quarters trying to pit me against Zahid, says Tok Mat
Umno deputy president Mohamad Hasan said being the party's number two was no easy task, as the role comes with the heavy responsibility of supporting party president Ahmad Zahid Hamidi. PETALING JAYA : Umno deputy president Mohamad Hasan claims certain quarters are trying to create friction between him and party president Ahmad Zahid Hamidi. Speaking at the Ledang Umno division meeting today, the foreign minister said he was not swayed by the attempts to pit him against Zahid, Berita Harian reported. Without naming anyone, he said these attempts were likely meant to undermine the party. 'Some people are trying to drive a wedge between me and the Umno president. 'I just smile because these people cannot be trusted, especially since they've also spoken badly about the president. 'I don't even know what they might be saying behind my back,' he was quoted as saying. According to Mohamad, being the party's number two was no easy task, as the role comes with the heavy responsibility of supporting the president. He said Umno's focus now must be to serve the people and to champion the interests of race and religion. 'The party must always come first. If we win, we win as one. If we lose, we all go down together as well. 'There will definitely be those who will abandon the party when we lose. So, my only hope is that members will remain loyal to the party,' he said.
Free Malaysia Today
32 minutes ago
- Free Malaysia Today
ILO looks to Malaysia as reference point to regulate gig economy, says Zahid
Key aspects of the Gig Workers Bill 2025 include the introduction of an official definition for gig workers, setting minimum compensation and establishing a grievance mechanism. (Bernama pic) BANGI : The International Labour Organization (ILO) is looking to Malaysia as a reference point in its effort to regulate the gig economy, says deputy prime minister Ahmad Zahid Hamidi. Zahid, who chairs the high-level committee for the establishment of the Malaysian Gig Economy Commission (SEGiM), said the ILO's interest reflected the global significance of Malaysia's pioneering approach in drafting legislation aimed at protecting gig workers' rights. 'This bill, which will be tabled and potentially passed in Parliament in August or September this year, is not just about setting the protection net (for gig workers) in stone,' he told reporters after chairing a roundtable session on the gig economy here today. 'It's the first of its kind focussed entirely on the gig economy, unlike in other countries that simply append it to existing laws.' He said a representative from Malaysia had presented the country's framework at the ILO headquarters in Geneva recently, with the organisation expressing interest in studying Malaysia's experience more closely. Zahid confirmed that SEGiM would be set up under the Prime Minister's Department to oversee the development and implementation of policies tailored for the gig economy, including upskilling initiatives and social protection mechanisms. The commission will work closely with the digital, transport and human resources ministries to ensure gig workers are given opportunities not just for temporary income but also for long-term career development, including entrepreneurship. Zahid also said SEGiM would serve as the main authority for the gig sector nationwide. It would be responsible for ensuring industry compliance with standards and transparent policy execution, while also strengthening self-regulation practices among platform providers, he said. To enhance policymaking and ensure industry feedback is heard, Zahid proposed informal town hall sessions involving gig platform operators, government officials, and other stakeholders. He said such dialogue should happen in a more relaxed setting, reflecting the flexible nature of the gig sector. 'Too many meetings are too formal. I've suggested we adopt a more casual, open format for discussions. No rigid protocols – just honest conversations between those affected and those responsible for the policies.' The establishment of SEGiM was first proposed by the Malaysia Digital Economy Corporation under the digital ministry. Key aspects of the Gig Workers Bill 2025 include the introduction of an official definition for gig workers, setting minimum compensation, establishing a grievance mechanism, and implementing social security protection such as mandatory contributions to the Social Security Organisation.
Free Malaysia Today
33 minutes ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Forget ego if you care about Umno, suspended and sacked leaders told
Umno Youth chief Dr Akmal Saleh said the party recognised the contributions made by the former leaders. (Bernama pic) PETALING JAYA : Suspended or sacked Umno leaders must set aside their egos if they truly care about the party, says Umno Youth chief Dr Akmal Saleh. Akmal said Umno president Ahmad Zahid Hamidi has already indicated his willingness to consider appeals from those who were subjected to disciplinary action, Berita Harian reported. 'The party is for everyone, and we must come together again. We need them (those who were suspended or sacked) to help strengthen the party. 'But there's one condition – everyone must put their ego aside. God willing, Umno will become stronger,' he was quoted as saying after officiating the Seremban Umno Youth annual general meeting last night. He was commenting on a motion by Sembrong Umno calling for suspended former division chief Hishammuddin Hussein to be welcomed back to the party However, the Sembrong MP and former party vice-president has hinted that he would not appeal his suspension, saying that he had not been officially told what he had done wrong, and appealing was not a measure of loyalty. Akmal said he was also open to facilitating the return of not only Hishammuddin but also other former leaders like Khairy Jamaluddin and Shahril Hamdan. 'Those who were disciplined had contributed in ways we cannot forget. That's why I say unity in Umno is crucial, and that unity cannot come from just one side,' he said.
