Echo Chamber: Te Pāti Māori gets the last laugh
Echo Chamber is The Spinoff's dispatch from the press gallery, recapping sessions in the House. Columns are written by politics reporter Lyric Waiwiri-Smith and Wellington editor Joel MacManus.
The public gallery was closed for Tuesday's question time. All this talk of filibustering and Te Pāti Māori must have sent a chill down the speaker's spine, keeping him awake all hours of the night with a dreadful anxiety over the decorum in the chambers. Were those Māori plotting against him? Hath none any respect for this institution? It's easier to close the door on the possibility of a haka in the public gallery than risk being turned into the butt of the joke simply for saying 'no, don't do that'.
But the privacy did work out nicely for one senior minister, who needed only worry about the vultures circling above in the press gallery benches – but he tries his best to act like he doesn't care what they think of him, anyway. Winston Peters, as the MPs milled around and took their seats, scrolled his X account in silence, and watched the video of himself that went viral earlier that day, in which he met a fellow geezer who likes saying naff and bollocks just as much as he does, and realised there are still people out there who can match his freak.
View this post on Instagram
A post shared by RNZ (@radionewzealand)
If a closed gallery wasn't enough of a flashing red warning sign of Gerry Brownlee's lack of patience, his interruptions during oral questions as an attempt to defuse any landmines along the way should have been enough of a hint. Finance minister Nicola Willis kicked off oral questions with patsies from National MP Cameron Brewer, and as she was laying it on thick, her mind naturally wandered to the MPs on the opposition benches and their failures.
In not so many words, Brownlee basically said: 'no, don't do that.'
When Peters, minister for rail, fielded questions from his NZ First colleague Jenny Marcroft, it gave him an opportunity both to promote a $600m investment from the upcoming budget to rail upgrades, and slam the Green Party's alternative budget. It was alarming, Peters declared, to see a proposal to build light rail in Christchurch, Auckland and Wellington to the tune of $11bn – only for Brownlee to remind the deputy prime minister that a supplementary question cannot be used as ammo against another party.
Peters, well aware of the rules of parliament as he had just last week described it as a 'House of Chaos', returned to his notes with a lack of sincerity, but appeared to get a kick out of the charade: 'If they want an education, pull into the station,' he finished.
Te Pāti Māori co-leader Debbie Ngarewa Packer was ninth up in oral questions, asking the prime minister about recent comments made about Māorification with Newstalk ZB's Mike Hosking, and his sentiment that 'where we see it, we call it out'. Well, Luxon replied, that isn't quite what I said, and said media outlet has since corrected my comments – but I do still have issues with a stop-go sign being in te reo Māori.
They bickered and Luxon ummed, ahhed and stuttered, until Rangatira Peters (that's what Matua Shane Jones calls him) rose for a supplementary to save the day. 'In the question on the issue of 'Māorification,'' he asked the prime minister, 'would it be 'Māorification' if every Thursday I went down and got myself a suntan?'
It was equal parts cringe, offensive and hilarious to the opposition benches. 'You're embarrassing yourself, geez,' Te Pāti Māori MP Mariameno Kapa Kingi called. 'It would help,' Te Pāti Māori co-leader Rawiri Waititi joked.
It was enough to get Peters booted out of the House altogether. 'I'll be back, don't you worry,' he warned the speaker. 'That's something everyone has noticed through your whole career,' Brownlee replied.
Following question time, the MPs (Peters included) were straight into the debate over Te Pāti Māori's suspension, delivered by the privileges committee. The chair of that committee, minister Judith Collins, told the House that never in her 23 years in parliament had she seen such a 'serious incident'. There were plenty of cutting remarks, but the only interjections from Te Pāti Māori's benches were corrections to Collins' pronunciation of their names.
The day's circus was all for nothing. After Labour leader Chris Hipkins left his left bloc allies in the lurch with no plans of filibustering but a whole lot to say about democracy hanging by a thread, minister Chris Bishop – after his party had promised there would be no concessions for Te Pāti Māori – set an adjournment motion until June 5.
The mythological filibuster never came to fruition. Speaker Gerry Brownlee will have to close the public gallery again in a few weeks. But, the silver lining: it all ended just in time for Te Pāti Māori to walk outside, see their few hundred supporters perform a haka, and relish in having – at least for now – the last laugh.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
'It's a matter of when not if' New Zealand recognises a Palestinian state, David Seymour says
David Seymour says there would be some hope of a discussion about recognising Palestine as state if Hamas released the Israeli hostages and demilitarised. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii Deputy Prime Minister David Seymour says recognising Palestine as a state is a complex decision that should not be rushed, but "it's a matter of when not if" New Zealand does so. Seymour said there would be some hope of starting a discussion about recognising a Palestinian state if Hamas released the Israeli hostages and demilitarised. "New Zealand's government position remains the same as it always has been, it's a matter of when not if we recognise a two state solution and we will be having discussions over the next fortnight or so over whether there should be any change on that position." France, the United Kingdom, Canada and now Australia , have all declared an intention to recognise a Palestinian state at a United Nations summit next month. Asked why New Zealand was delaying this decision, Seymour said "we shouldn't assume that other countries are right". It was a very complex situation and it was important to take time to come to a sound decision, he said. "It's not just a question of what are you actually recognising, what conditions do you place around that, it's also a question of okay so after you've done this what happens next?" It was easy to by horrified by the violence in the Palestinian territories shown on television and social media and to be driven to want to take action, he said. "It doesn't mean that any old solution is the correct one." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Newsroom
3 hours ago
- Newsroom
Given the Wayne Brown silent treatment, Leoni finds her voice
Kerrin Leoni might not get to debate the incumbent Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown this campaign, but she's not going to stay silent on what she sees as his deficiencies as a leader. Leoni, the 45-year-old first-term councillor who is challenging Brown after others around the council table declined, has some serious questions over whether he is the best Auckland can come up with. She's already proactively outed Brown as declining to attend the first candidates' debate, and his intimation that he might not participate in any. 'I mean, it's the most important job in the city and that's the least you can do as a candidate is show up, you know. I think it's shocking. As a sitting mayor, he should be attending all debates.' As a lesser-known challenger, she would say that. But Brown's indications that he might seek to deny Leoni and the other seven candidates the oxygen of his presence at campaign events would be rare for Auckland politics. His Super City predecessors Phil Goff and Len Brown engaged in debates after their first terms in office. Leoni sees the Brown tactic as representing a wider withdrawal by the mayor from the types of duties and expectations on city leaders. She alleges he removes himself regularly to his Northland home base, leaving Deputy Mayor Desley Simpson to pick up the community appearances so assiduously attended by Goff and Len Brown. 'When I've been out in places from Pukekohe to Warkworth, in so many areas, they've said they just don't see him. 'We should be providing leadership that's actually seen. The role of the mayor is not just to be making decisions up in the ivory tower.' Leoni, who represents the Whau ward based around Avondale and the inner west, says she thinks Brown is also focused on what's wrong with the city, rather than a vision for what it could become. 'I'm focused on the long-term plan of this, because I think it's easy to come in and say, 'these are all the things that are bad about what's happening with Auckland and the council. 'We need to have someone that's actually got a balance. I'm saying, 'Sort what's wrong, but what should we be doing to plan for the future of our city'.' Her campaign's initial slogan is Kerrin Leoni – 'The new energy Auckland needs'. Auckland mayoral candidate Kerrin Leoni Ngāti Pāoa, Ngāi Takoto, Ngāti Kuri Councillor, Whau ward 2022-25 Local Board member, Waitematā 2019-22 Age: 45 Mother to twins Atarangi and Kahu, aged 8 Brought up: Mt Roskill and Waiheke Island School: Waiheke High School University: AUT (MA in social services and Māori development), King's College, London (MA in economics and international politics) Worked as: social worker, property investor, own consultancy and charity organiser (UK) She also marks down Brown for his verbal treatment of councillors around the Governing Body table, his targeting of individual councillors by challenging them under his Fix Auckland banner and his suitability at age 79 to take a city like Auckland forward. Leoni questions just what Brown wants to achieve in a second term, into his 80s. 'I mean, if we were going into another term where there were clear predictions about what his policies were going to be for the next term … but I haven't seen any of his policies except for he wants to continue with reining in Auckland Transport, which, you know, I already agree with that.' In late 2024 she indicated to the mayor she might challenge him, she says, and 'he was more than happy for me to stand, not that I needed his permission. He just said 'There's a few more things that I feel I need to do'. I said 'Well, what are they that you'd need another whole term for?' But he didn't identify anything else and he hasn't.' Hat in the ring Leoni (Ngāti Paoa, Ngāi Takoto and Ngāti Kuri) served a term on the Waitematā Local Board before narrowly claiming the Ward council seat in 2022, giving her six years as an elected member of the Auckland Council set-up. She has not been a high-profile councillor regionally, is not one of the 20 who need to hear the sound of their own voices endlessly at every council meeting, and was something of a surprise when she emerged as the leading candidate for the 'left' in this election. She tells Newsroom she asked other councillors if they would stand against Brown and when none stepped up, she stepped forward. 'My focus was to make sure Aucklanders had a good candidate who they could vote for. 'I did ask other councillors whether they were interested in standing – and ones that have more experience than me – and they were not interested. But obviously, you know, I don't feel you have to be in local government for 20 years or 50 years to do a good job. I think it's really important, actually, that I'm coming in with fresh eyes.' She's not flying the Labour Party banner that got her elected by 260 votes three years ago in Whau, the ward she's standing down from by standing for the mayor's chair. 'You know, as mayor, you've got to be seen as impartial to all Aucklanders. I'm definitely standing as an independent. 'So I'm just going to do the best that we can and I don't want to be seen as just the Labour candidate, or just any candidate. I want to be seen as the candidate for all of Auckland.' She has not sought formal endorsements from a political party, unions or left-wing luminaries, but cites former Labour PM Helen Clark and the late Labour figure and mayor Cath Tizard as political inspirations. She joined Labour when she returned from the UK because 'I've always wanted to look at ways that we could help people that haven't had great opportunities.' Policy platform When the Deputy Mayor, Desley Simpson, announced she would not challenge Brown, but instead act as his Fix Auckland running mate, she revealed her team had failed to identify a political platform sufficiently different to what Brown currently occupies. Leoni thinks the vision for a future Auckland is the missing link in what Brown has delivered – and something he cannot offer. 'I'll be campaigning on a 30-year plan for the city, not just short-term fixes.' She promises to announce a couple of policies a week through the key campaign weeks (postal voting opens on Tuesday September 9 ahead of the Saturday, October 11 election date). She lived for many years in the UK and believes Auckland needs to embrace some big infrastructure projects such as a rail link all the way to the airport, beyond the current train to bus interchange at the Puhinui station in Manukau, and passenger rail to both Huapai in the west, and from south to west from Southdown to Avondale to bring communities together. Leoni is not promising a showstopper policy platform like previous mayoral candidate John Tamihere, with a second tier and rail added to the existing Auckland Harbour Bridge. 'I think I'm going to be the more realistic candidate.' She favours a second bridge, side by side with the current structure, catering for mid-term needs ahead of any plan for a cross harbour tunnel. 'I know the tunnel is very expensive and I know central government does not have the money to actually pay for that. Even the cost to do the side by side raises a question mark. But we know it's more effective to get that done first if we can.' Leoni was deputy chair of the Waitematā local board in her first stint in local government. Photo: Auckland Council Leoni says as a councillor she signed up for the council's Long-term Plan and its projected average rates increase for next year of 7.9 percent (after this year's average 5.8 percent), and to keep future rises under double digits. 'Definitely be keeping them under 10 percent. 'If there are going to be any changes in that budget probably the rates won't be affected, but we know we have to keep the rates down, the feedback we're getting is that is definitely one of the top priorities as people are just struggling.' She believes the current $50 cap on public transport fares weekly might have been set too high, and there could be scope to lower it, possibly as far as $30 to encourage people to keep using buses and trains. On debt, (which despite Brown condemning the council's indebtedness before his election of around $11 billion is set to rise towards $14b) Leoni says only that she's 'not a supporter of debt going up when it doesn't need to, and we need to continue to keep the debt as low as possible. We've got to be accountable for every dollar we spend.' She promises to implement a policy that if the council encounters an 'overspend that's going to happen, then it's going to come out of the budget somewhere else. I've got a very strong view that we've got to stop overspending as a council. We've got to be clear that's not going to happen any more.' To a suggestion she's saying the same thing as her opponent, Leoni says 'I think that there would be an assumption given that I have got a left-leaning history that I wouldn't continue that. But I'm making it clear that I would.' One personal focus for her would be council contracting costs, particularly functions out-sourced to international conglomerates. 'My understanding is that a significant amount of the tier 1 contractors are actually Australian-owned businesses. That profit is going overseas and we should be bringing that profit back into Auckland, into our circular economy.' She thinks procurement contracts at the local board should be examined for potential cost savings. 'If that means we have to scale down some of the criteria and review the whole system, we should. We need to localise some of that contracting there to save money.' The counter argument would be that large contractors across the region bring economies of scale, but Leoni, who studied economics and international politics for her second master's degree, at King's College, London, says it hasn't been so in reality. 'Why have we continued to have overspends?' Leoni with her children Atarangi and Kahu at a Blues match at Eden Park this year. Photo: Supplied Social media and women in politics As a relatively new figure in city politics, a woman, of Māori and Italian/Irish descent, Leoni perhaps surprisingly hasn't yet been a serious target of social media trolling or abuse that afflicts so many in her position. 'I'm not getting it yet. I've been waiting for it, actually, but the reality is people are probably not going to put it onto my page anyway. 'But, I'm mentally prepared for it and I'm practising my responses and not to be too reactive, because you've got to expect it is likely to happen. 'I mean, to any male who would say, well 'You can't run a city', I'm like 'Well, we're already running the city. I'm a regional councillor, I'm already making decisions,' she says. 'The only difference between our job and the mayor is that he sets a budget, which we get to sign off anyway and he's got to get a majority of the vote for. 'And he's supposed to be the leader and a visionary for the city, which I don't think he does that well.' She says she's been relatively un-targeted by the mayor in council meetings because she has been 'quite direct' with him since the start of the term. 'He probably hasn't singled me out as much as I've seen him single out others. 'But he's made inappropriate comments to me; like, I think one was that if I was going to vote for the sale of the airport shares, I'd never be an MP [Leoni stood for Labour in 2020 in the blue-riband National seat of Waikato]. And I thought, 'You don't have control over that'.' From the moment she announced her candidacy, Leoni has heard and seen comments likening her to another single Māori woman mayor, Wellington's outgoing leader Tory Whanau, who faced intense personal criticism over her private and political conduct. 'I think it is quite sad that our country and our city might think like that,' the councillor says. 'But I guess that was my frustration when I came back from living in the UK, [in 2015] it felt like I'd come back to the 1950s in terms of our thinking and those things around racism and sexism and everything else – and the expectation that you have to be an old white male to be able to make decisions for the city. I mean, it's just appalling.' She spoke to Whanau about the pressures directly. 'She admits, and I think she's said this in media elsewhere, that it would have been helpful for her to do a term first [as a councillor] before becoming mayor. We had that conversation and I said to her, well, I've done two terms in local government. It was helpful.' Five years ago Leoni took on the un-winnable National Waikato seat for Labour at the general election, narrowing National's majority from 15,000 to 5000 as part of the Labour landslide. Grander ambitions Because of her candidacy for Parliament in 2020, Leoni also faces repeated quips about her stand for the mayoralty being driven by seeking profile towards a decent spot on the Labour Party's list for the 2026 general election. She shrugs that off, focusing on Brown's job. 'I actually love local government and the experiences I've had have been very positive. Local government is where it's at for our communities. 'I mean, central government is always going to be there and I'm only 45 years old. Look at Wayne, he's 78 or 79. So I've got many years ahead of me in politics. You look at Winston Peters, and you know, Shane Jones. I'm not in any rush to get into central government. 'My concern is doing the best for Auckland and providing the best leadership.' Nine weeks to go Winning the Auckland mayoralty is a high-cost exercise, with Brown using a considerable sum from his own funds in 2022. Without union or party backing explicitly, how does Leoni see a path to increasing her name, face and vote recognition? 'The fundraising has been a bit of a challenge, and I think that's more of a cultural thing for me. In the past I've been able to fund some of it and done some fundraising.' For the mayoralty, region-wide and trying to grab profile on motorway billboards and the like, 'we do need to take it up a level. But we've got the basics of the campaign, the billboards, the people who are happy to give out the leaflets and door knock, which I think is great.' She is a confident figure, right back to her high school days winning an award from then-Auckland mayor Les Mills, through to buying her first home from age 21 and trading property ever since, studying in the UK and forming her own consultancy and charity. She's raising her eight-year-old twins while a councillor and acting as landlord for three properties. But she is not sounding over-confident of being able to knock off a well-heeled incumbent mayor. She knows, like the late Efeso Collins at the last election, she'll need votes from beyond traditional left-leaning districts. The voting-heavy districts of north and east Auckland will need special attention. Leoni says she learned during her bid for Parliament in the National stronghold of Waikato that: 'Make sure you don't assume that the people that you think aren't going to vote for you won't actually vote for you. You've got to put yourself in front of everyone.' Asked what success would look like for her in nine weeks, when the polling is done, Leoni does not mention the word 'winning'. 'Success is making sure that we do get right across the city and that we have policies that are clear for Aucklanders. 'It's about having good policies that Aucklanders see as good for them, having good leadership for every single group. 'So yeah, looking back at it at the end and saying that regardless of whatever the outcome that we've had a good campaign and that we've done a great job and I think that's all we can expect, you know. Given that I don't have $50 million.'
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Clearing out the confusion over NCEA changes
Photo: 123RF It is billed as the most significant overhaul of NCEA in more than two decades, but there are questions being raised in the education industry about whether it is a bold step forward or a risky roll of the dice. The government's sweeping changes to the national qualification aim to lift standards, streamline the way students are assessed, and restore confidence. RNZ education correspondent John Gerritsen tells The Detail the bold move comes with both hope and hesitation. "There is a sort of sense that maybe this new system is trying to apply a way of working that might suit the kids in the leafy suburbs and not so much the kids in the poorer areas," he says. The changes should be in place by 2030. If you never understood NCEA, or you are unsure of what the changes involve, this is the podcast to listen to as Gerritsen takes us through what's going on. NCEA Level 1 - which typically takes place in Year 11 - will be abolished, with students being required to take English and mathematics and to sit a new 'Foundational Skills Award' test that documents achievement in literacy and numeracy. Two new qualifications will replace NCEA Level 2 and Level 3, for Year 12 and 13 students respectively. They will now qualify with the New Zealand Certificate of Education (NZCE) and the New Zealand Advanced Certificate of Education (NZACE), respectively. Students will be required to take five subjects, and will have to pass at least four, to attain each certificate in Years 12 and 13. A to E pass-fail grades will replace the "excellent, merit, achieved, and not achieved" rankings. Supporters of the changes say this is exactly what NCEA needs. Employers have long voiced concerns that school leavers do not always have the basic skills needed for the workforce . With literacy and numeracy now the focus, that gap could start to close. And by reducing assessment overload, that means less pressure on students and more time for actual learning. Some parents also claim it should be easier for them to understand what their child is learning - and why. "On one level, you'd have to say, a qualification system that has been in place since 2002, so over 20 years, and still confuses people probably needs to be revised pretty heavily," says Gerritsen. "Some of the way the language, the way this has been described - it's been a bit obtuse, and people have struggled to understand it over the years." But for every person applauding the changes, another is sounding the alarm. Some principals and parents worry that standalone literacy and numeracy tests risk leaving behind students with learning differences or who are from non-English-speaking backgrounds. "There is a whole swathe of young people who struggle with exams," Gerritsen tells The Detail . "Some of them may have dyslexia, others may just simply have anxiety about doing exams. "There are also issues around increasing shifts to computer-based exams for students who don't have much to do with computers, so this is definitely going to become an issue." And then there is the equity question. Will all schools - urban, rural, well-resourced, or underfunded - be ready to deliver under this new scheme? Or will the gaps further widen? "When talking to principals from poorer communities, they're really worried that a system that has helped their communities achieve success is going to be got rid of and replaced with something with big question marks around it," Gerritsen says. "There are worries that young people from poorer backgrounds are going to be disadvantaged by this, and they will be less likely to leave school with some sort of qualification." The consultation process closes in less than five weeks. And when it comes to the future of every New Zealand student, there is no room for error. Check out how to listen to and follow The Detail here . You can also stay up-to-date by liking us on Facebook
