BBC ‘failed' to ask the right questions regarding Gaza documentary, says executive
BBC
News executive has said the broadcaster 'failed' to ask the right questions regarding the documentary
Gaza
: How To Survive A Warzone.
It comes after a report looking into the documentary, which was removed from BBC iPlayer in February after it emerged that the child narrator was the son of a
Hamas
official, found that it breached BBC editorial guidelines on accuracy.
The review, published on Monday, was conducted by Peter Johnston, the director of editorial complaints and reviews which is independent of BBC News, and found that the programme was in breach of accuracy for 'failing to disclose information about the child narrator's father's position within the Hamas-run government'.
It did not, however, find any other breaches of editorial guidelines, including breaches of impartiality, and also found no evidence that 'outside interests' 'inappropriately impacted on the programme'.
READ MORE
Speaking on BBC's Radio 4 World At One programme, Deborah Turness, chief executive of BBC News, said: 'Our current affairs teams, day in, day out, week in, week out, are creating and pushing out incredibly controversial, difficult, complex documentaries.
'We have really good, best-in-class systems in place, but in this we failed, and we must put in place new processes which will enable us to continue with our courageous journalism with confidence.'
She also added: 'It's about accountability. And I think what you can see today is that the BBC has taken this incredibly seriously. We have led a full and thorough investigation, which we are publishing full and transparently.
'Everything is out there, and we share the action plan that we're now putting into place to prevent this kind of mistake happening again.
'We are responsible for everything that we publish and everything we broadcast. We take it incredibly seriously, and we didn't run those questions to ground.'
Ms Turness also addressed a second Gaza documentary, Gaza: Doctors Under Attack, which was originally commissioned by the broadcaster from an independent production company called Basement Films.
However, the corporation delayed airing it until the review into Gaza: How To Survive A Warzone was released.
The documentary, which includes witness accounts from frontline
Palestinian
health workers in Gaza and documents attacks on hospitals and clinics, was later pulled entirely and aired on Channel 4 earlier this month.
Ms Turness said: 'We want to tell the stories of Gaza. We are telling the stories of Gaza.
'We've got long form projects in the pipeline. We are covering Gaza, and we're covering it with courage and without fear or favour.
'During that production, the BBC raised concerns around the social media activity of one of the journalists. Obviously, we are incredibly protective and conscious of our impartiality and our very high standards of impartiality, and we were concerned about the activity of the journalist concerned.
'We decided, in the light of those concerns, that we would pause broadcast of that documentary while waiting to see what the Peter Johnston report would bring us.
'The film company weren't happy with that pause, and they wanted the journalism to air sooner. So we were trying to find a way around that, trying to find a way without airing the documentary, to put the journalism and the voice of the doctors on our platforms.
'And then came a moment where the lead journalist went on the Today programme to talk about Israel's attacks on Iran and used language around Israel that was really not compatible with the BBC standards of impartiality and made it impossible for us to continue with the project.
'It was very difficult to imagine that it could meet the BBC standards of impartiality, and that it would have created at least a perception of partiality, had we aired it.
'And the right thing to do at that time was to walk away, because no BBC journalist could have said what that journalist said on air, and therefore we have to apply some of the same standards to those who work with us from the outside.' – PA
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Government ‘feckless' with public money, Social Democrats claim in budget row
The Government has been 'reckless and feckless' with public money and is following a 'cynical giveaway budget ' last year by now 'moralising' on fiscal responsibility, a Social Democrats TD has claimed. Tánaiste Simon Harris however accused Jennifer Whitmore of 'hypocrisy' and asked which one-off payment from Budget 2025 the Social Democrats would have cut from double child benefit payments, carer's allowance or fuel allowance. But Ms Whitmore said her party had called for 'targeted' supports last year and would not have spent €100 million on energy credits for holiday homes as she accused the Government of being 'epic wasters'. During testy exchanges on the last day of the Dáil before the summer recess, the budget and the cost of living dominated Leaders' Questions for the third day this week. READ MORE Sinn Féin finance spokesman Pearse Doherty insisted there had to be a cost-of-living package as he pointed to a 63,000 increase in the past four months in the number of people in arrears on their electricity bills. The energy regulator issued figures showing more than 300,000 people are behind on their electricity and a further 175,000 are in arrears on their gas bill. Irish consumers are paying 'far and above' what other European Union countries are paying for energy. Families 'simply can't absorb this type of shock to their finances' and the Government plan is to 'cancel the energy credits they so desperately need and relied on', Mr Doherty said, accusing the Government of having 'all the wrong priorities'. The Tánaiste insisted the Government is helping households 'in the here and now', retaining the 9 per cent VAT rate on gas and electricity, expanding the fuel allowance to thousands more people, reducing childcare costs, providing free school meals, books and footwear allowances and increasing public-sector pay. [ Irish Times poll: Support for Government parties holds steady as Sinn Féin slumps Opens in new window ] He also claimed there had been an 'air of unreality' to Sinn Féin's contributions. Mr Harris said Mr Doherty spent a lot of time saying to the Government ''You don't understand. You're out of touch'' but he said he knows 'who owns SuperValu ' and it was not an American multinational. He was referring to comments Mr Doherty made during a cost-of-living debate when he said the supermarket chain was owned by a US company United Foods. Mr Harris said: 'You'd have to go back a very long time to find a summer recess in which we have seen a moment of greater economic uncertainty.' He claimed Sinn Féin did not want to talk about trade or tariffs or the '48,000 people who work in pharma in this country' and global uncertainty. 'You've never seen something you don't want to spend more money on. But we have to be honest with the Irish people. We can't just keep saying 'spend, spend, spend'.' Mr Doherty said the cost-of-living crisis had widened significantly and 'prices across the board are pushing households to the brink'. He added 'it's not lost' on families 'being hammered by rip-off prices' that the energy companies are recording bumper profits, with the ESB recording profits of more than €1 billion in 2023 and 2024, while SSE Airtricity made 'hundreds of millions' in the past two years. Ms Whitmore told the Tánaiste that 'having splashed the cash in an attempt to buy votes last year, your message suddenly changed. Now that an election is no longer on the cards, one-off payments are a bad idea.' But Mr Harris said the one-off measures served a purpose 'at a time of extraordinarily high inflation'.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Ibec head labels Occupied Territories Bill ‘symbolism and moral positioning'
The Republic's stand against Israel over Gaza and its failure to spend properly on defence are damaging its interests in the United States and with other EU member states, the head of Irish employers' association Ibec has warned. The Government's plan to pass legislation banning 'tiny' sums of trade with the Occupied Territories Bill is 'hypocritical', said Danny McCoy, the director general of Ibec . Last year, the State bought just €240,000 worth of goods from the Occupied Territories, he told the Patrick MacGill Summer School in Glenties, Co Donegal. 'We're not talking about millions here,' he said, adding: 'This is not about actually helping in any material way. It's symbolism and moral positioning, and so on. However, with moral positions, you can also reveal hypocrisy.' His comments follow a series of criticisms of the Bill by at least 10 members of the US Congress. The US ambassador to Israel, Mike Huckabee, accused Ireland of suffering from 'diplomatic intoxication' in progressing something as 'stupid' as this Bill. READ MORE Taoiseach Micheál Martin yesterday rejected the ambassador's comments and outlined the 'very serious' situation in Gaza. [ Taoiseach rejects US politicians' claims that Occupied Territories Bill is 'diplomatic intoxication' Opens in new window ] However, he said legislation to boycott, divest or sanction activity against Israel could 'inadvertently' affect companies. It would be 'counterproductive' for Irish companies to be punished, he said, adding that the Government will consider and take a legal opinion on this. The proposed Bill is expected to go before the Dáil in the autumn. The legislation would prohibit trading with companies operating in illegal settlements in the West Bank and other occupied territories. At the summer school on Thursday, Mr McCoy said the State's stand on Israel is 'well-intentioned' but 'causing us significant damage'. The consequences are not just from the United States and the Israeli position, he said. 'We've been completely insensitive to our other European colleagues who've also had really significant issues.' All of them have had struggles with anti-Semitism and Islamophobia in their societies in recent years: 'They have to go sensitively through that, and particularly in Europe as well. But we seem to be insensitive to that kind of dynamic.' He said he has personally experienced the Republic's fall in standing among fellow EU member states over the issues. Meanwhile, Irish attitudes to its own defence spending, but also to the defence spending of others, is losing the Republic support among EU states. 'We don't have many supporters,' Mr McCoy said. 'In terms of the business and economics, our goodwill is eroding significantly and substantially.' Also speaking at the summer school, Prof Brigid Laffan, chancellor of Limerick University, said Ireland should be 'more hard-nosed' and not endanger its diplomatic capital by passing the Occupied Territories Bill. 'We're a small state. We've limited influence. We must use our influence cleverly,' she said. 'Symbolic politics might make us feel good about the world. But unless it changes people's lives on the ground, you should not expend hard-earned diplomatic capacity.' . She added: 'In a world of such utter uncertainty, drawing attention to yourself in Washington might not be smart.' Often people in Ireland want to 'assure ourselves that we're good people', but we need to be 'a bit more hard-nosed', she said. 'I know the reaction saying things like this in this country gets, but I think we have to be able to have those conversations.'
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
John Torode was sacked by BBC MasterChef ‘after using worst racial slur there is' Richard Osman claims
JOHN Torode was sacked from MasterChef for using the 'worst racial slur there is', a fellow BBC star has claimed. The top TV chef, 59, was said to be heartbroken after the BBC and production firm Banijay confirmed his 3 John Torode is said to be heartbroken after the claims against him and said he was blindsided by the BBC firing Credit: Getty 3 Richard Osman, pictured at the 2025 BAFTA Television Awards, claims Torode used the 'worst racial slur there is' Credit: Getty The broadcaster confirmed the host's contract would not be renewed after a report found he had used an 'extremely offensive racist term' during drinks after filming. Torode has denied the claims and said he has 'no recollection' of the event. He also revealed that he had been told the person with whom he was speaking "did not believe it was intended in a malicious way". The BBC was unable to specify the time or date of the allegation, narrowing it down to '2018 or 2019'. According to the MailOnline, Ex-Pointless presenter Richard Osman described the language used as the 'worst racial slur there is'. He added both the Beeb and Banijay believe the allegation is 'watertight' and will stand up in court if the Australia-born star took legal action. Osman said: "He used I think probably the worst racial slur there is and they found that to be substantively true. They found evidence they were happy with. He said that he couldn't remember it. But that one was upheld." It comes after a source Most read in News TV And allegedly read about it first on the BBC website. Rival ITV, however, are understood 'Devastated' Gregg Wallace FIRED by BBC over MasterChef sexual comments The Sun understands the broadcaster held crisis talks yesterday about whether or not to air this Saturday's episode of John And Lisa's Weekend Kitchen. A source said: 'There are a lot of moving parts when it comes to John but ITV are standing by him.' His axing came after Beeb chief Tim Davie said The Corporation said: 'John Torode has identified himself as having an upheld 'This allegation — which involves an extremely offensive racist term being used in the workplace — was investigated and substantiated by the independent investigation led by law firm Lewis Silkin. 'John Torode denies the allegation. 'We will not tolerate racist language of any kind and, as we have already said, we told Banijay UK, the makers of MasterChef, that action must be taken. 'John Torode's contract will not be renewed.' A source said: 'John's agent received a call 11 minutes before the statements went out and hadn't had a chance to call him. 'He 'Obviously he's heartbroken. 'He feels he's been made a scapegoat off the back of the Another source told The Sun the Australian chef planned to quit at the end of this week. In an Instagram post John said: 'Although I haven't heard from anyone at the BBC or Banijay — I am seeing and reading that I've been 'sacked' from MasterChef and I repeat that I have no recollection of what I'm accused of. 'I have loved every minute working on MasterChef, but it's time to pass the cutlery to someone else.' Dad of four Torode said: 'The allegation is I did so sometime between 2018 or 2019, in a social situation, and the person I was speaking with did not believe it was intended in a malicious way and I apologised immediately afterwards. 'I have absolutely no recollection of any of this, and I do not believe that it happened Read more on the Irish Sun 'However, I want to be clear that I've always had the view that any racial language is wholly unacceptable in any environment. 'I'm shocked and saddened by the allegation as I would never wish to cause anyone any offence.' 3 Both John Torode and Gregg Wallace have been let go from their roles at the BBC Credit: PA
