War of words breaks out between CPI(M), Church leadership in Kerala over ‘Sangh Parivar affinity'
The current battle centres around the CPI(M)'s repeated accusation that certain bishops broadcast a predilection towards Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Union Home Minister Amit Shah, while 'expediently turning a blind eye to' spiralling attacks against Christians and the clergy by Hindu right-wing organisations in Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)-ruled States in north India.
CPI(M) State secretary M.V. Govindan singled out Archbishop Mar Joseph Pamplany of Thalassery for criticism at a public meeting in Thaliparambu on Monday (August 11, 2025).
Mr. Govindan said he was intentionally naming Bishop Pamplany to spotlight the prelate's 'vacillating positions' vis-à-vis the Sangh Parivar.
He stated that Bishop Pamplany mooted a rethink of the Church's relationship with the Central government after 'the Sangh Parivar-controlled BJP government' in Chhattisgarh arrested and incarcerated two Kerala nuns after Bajrang Dal activists accused them of human trafficking for conversion to Christianity.
'When the court belatedly released the nuns on bail, the Bishop praised Modi and Shah, conveniently papering over the BJP's culpability in the nuns' ordeal', he stated.
Mr. Govindan alleged that Church representatives went with cakes to the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) office in Kannur. 'Such brazen opportunism does not augur well for secularism, democracy or minority rights,' he said.
Earlier, Democratic Youth Federation of India (DYFI) State secretary V.K. Sanoj said 'the fate of Martin Niemöller' awaited Bishop Pamplany. He said the German protestant pastor and self-declared anti-semite backed Adolf Hitler, only to be jailed by the Nazi leader after the priest served the fascist regime's purpose.
Bishop Pamplany's expression of gratitude to the Centre had come in for sharp reactions on social media platforms, with the netizens pooh-poohing the gesture using memes and satirical remarks.
Last week, CPI(M) leader and former Minister A.K. Balan had accused Bishop Pamplany of pursuing a transactional mode of politics by promising the BJP a parliamentary toehold in Kerala if the Centre raised the floor price of rubber to ₹300 per kg in the run-up to the 2024 General Elections.
Thalassery Archdiocese pushes back
Meanwhile, the Thalassery Archdiocese has pushed back firmly. In a statement, the bishopric termed Mr. Govindan's words 'second-rate.'
It said Bishop Pamplany did not require 'AKG Centre's writ' to expound the Church's position. The Church had ignored the DYFI's attempt to disparage the prelate. However, attacks against the Bishop had escalated, it pointed out.
The Archdiocese said the Bishop had thanked parties across the political spectrum, including the Central government, for their respective interventions to 'ensure justice' for the nuns.
'Opportunism has become a byword for Mr. Govindan's political vacillations. His condemnable statements have exposed the party secretary's fascist nature. Mr. Govindan's distortion of the Bishop's words is aimed at putting the Chief Minister and CPI(M) on the defensive', the bishopric stated.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
22 minutes ago
- First Post
FirstUp: EU leaders to hold virtual meeting with Zelenskyy and Trump and other top news
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy will take part in a virtual meeting today with US President Donald Trump, US Vice President JD Vance and several European Union leaders. Officials from Finland, France, Germany, Italy, Poland, the UK, as well as the EU and Nato, will speak with Zelenskyy first before he joins a separate call with Trump and Vance It is a packed day with several important events lined up. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz will hold virtual talks between EU leaders and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy. The two will speak first before he joins US President Donald Trump and his Vice President JD Vance. The third round of the India-Singapore Ministerial Roundtable (ISMR) will take place in New Delhi. CTUs-SKM, a joint platform of ten Central Trade Unions and the Samyukt Kisan Morcha, plan to stage a nationwide protest today against Trump's tariff warnings and the India-UK CETA. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD A court is set to deliver its verdict for J-pop star Kenshin Kamimura, who faces sexual assault charges during a celebration dinner. Let's take a look at the events: EU leaders' virtual meetings with Trump and Zelenskyy Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy is scheduled to join a virtual meeting today with US President Donald Trump, US Vice President JD Vance and several European Union leaders. According to The Guardian, representatives from Finland, France, Germany, Italy, Poland, the UK, along with the EU and Nato, will first hold discussions with Zelenskyy before he joins a separate call with Trump and Vance. Representatives from Finland, France, Germany, Italy, Poland, the UK, along with the EU and Nato, will first hold discussions with Zelenskyy. Reuters/File Photo Germany has said that Chancellor Friedrich Merz will host the talks, which will also include EU presidents Ursula von der Leyen and Antonio Costa, as well as Nato Secretary General Mark Rutte. The discussions come amid rising concern among European leaders about being left out of the Trump-Putin summit in Alaska this Friday. India, Singapore to hold 3rd ministerial roundtable The third round of the India-Singapore Ministerial Roundtable (ISMR) will take place in New Delhi today, the Ministry of External Affairs said on Tuesday. From India, the meeting will be attended by Union Finance and Corporate Affairs Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar, Commerce and Industry Minister Piyush Goyal, and Railways, Information and Broadcasting, and Electronics and IT Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw. Singapore will be represented by Deputy Prime Minister and Trade and Industry Minister Gan Kim Yong, Coordinating Minister for National Security and Home Affairs Minister K Shanmugam, Foreign Minister Vivian Balakrishnan, Digital Development and Information Minister Josephine Teo and others. Notably, the ISMR serves as a platform to set new goals for cooperation between India and Singapore. Its first meeting was held in New Delhi in September 2022, followed by the second in Singapore in August 2024. The two countries share a Comprehensive Strategic Partnership. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Trade unions, farmers to hold nationwide protest CTUs-SKM, a joint platform of ten Central Trade Unions and the Samyukt Kisan Morcha, is set to hold a nationwide protest today against US President Donald Trump's tariff threats and the India-UK CETA. In a statement, the group condemned Trump's recent warning to impose 25 per cent tariffs on India and his call for a punitive tax on the oil trade deal with Russia. They said India should reject the tariff threats and uphold its right to trade with all countries, including Russia. They also demanded an immediate review and changes to the India-UK CETA, and called for all talks on a US-India trade agreement to be stopped to avoid what they described as corporate exploitation. Japanese actor Kenshin Kamimura to receive verdict in sexual assault case J-pop singer Kenshin Kamimura is expected to receive the verdict in his sexual assault case today. The 25-year-old, formerly part of the boy band ONE N' ONLY, is accused of assaulting a local female interpreter during a celebration dinner in March at a Hong Kong restaurant following a fan meeting. Kenshin Kamimura at the West Kowloon Magistrates' Courts in Hong Kong. Reuters/File Photo In Hong Kong, the offence of indecent assault can lead to a prison term of up to 10 years. With inputs from agencies
The Hindu
an hour ago
- The Hindu
Tamil Nadu's history of political silence on murders driven by caste hatred
Two weeks ago in Tirunelveli, Kavin Selvaganesh — a Scheduled Caste youth and employee at a leading IT firm — was brutally murdered by the brother of a caste Hindu girl he was in love with. Chief Minister M.K. Stalin, who readily condemned the arrest of Kerala nuns in distant Chhattisgarh, has not yet spoken on this gory crime driven by caste hatred. Leader of Opposition Edappadi K. Palaniswami, who visited the family of Ajithkumar, a security guard killed in illegal police custody, has not met Kavin's family — he merely condemned the Stalin government for the 'honour' crime. Actor Vijay, the Tamilaga Vettri Kazhagam founder and Chief Minister aspirant, who met protesting conservancy workers in Chennai, has maintained silence on the murder. Such studied silence by politicians is not new. While voters from socially marginalised communities are wooed, they are often used as political doormats. On the other hand, political parties display little hesitation in assiduously cultivating the dominant communities belonging to the Backward and Most Backward Classes. Although leaders such as former Chief Ministers M. Karunanidhi and Jayalalithaa had endeared themselves to all communities, they too were reluctant to stick their necks out and speak out against killing in the name of caste pride. Karunanidhi, personally, transcended caste barriers by performing several inter-caste weddings in his own extended family. On the electoral battlefield, Jayalalithaa had resorted to social re-engineering tactics like fielding Scheduled Caste candidates from general constituencies and getting them elected. Yet, the two leaders did not react in July 2003, when a young couple, Kannagi (a Vanniyar woman) and Murugesan (Scheduled Caste), were force-fed poison and set ablaze in front of a large gathering of villagers in Vriddhachalam in Cuddalore district. The murder itself came to light several days later when the Dalit Panthers of India (now Viduthalai Chiruthaigal Katchi) and the Communist Party of India (Marxist) raised a red flag. This was the first time the term 'honour killing' was used in Tamil Nadu to describe a crime driven by caste hatred. 'If you thought, since Murugesan and Kannagi were killed openly in front of villagers, there would not have been any complication in delivery of justice, you are wrong,' writes senior journalist Ilangovan Rajasekaran, in the chapter 'Naththai Vegathil Neethi' (Justice at Snail's Pace) in his book 'Saathiyin Peyaraal – Aanava Kolaigalin Pathivu' (In the name of Caste – A Record of Honour Killings). It took 18 years for the trial court to deliver its verdict in the case and another four years for the Supreme Court to uphold justice. A factor that restricts political response is that in the party's districts units, the leadership is often vested in the hands of leaders hailing from the dominant caste groups of the region. Even during election campaigns, it is common for mainstream parties to use Scheduled Caste leaders of allied parties canvass for votes only in the habitats of the marginalised sections. They are requested to stay off the streets of caste Hindus, fearing the latter would resent the presence of a Scheduled Caste leader. Another disturbing feature is that of mainstream parties courting political outfits formed in the name of emancipating their community but actually promote caste pride. There are, however, rare occasions where leaders have vocally expressed themselves against caste killings. For instance in November 2018, Mr. Stalin, who had taken over as DMK president just three months earlier, exhorted his party cadre to work towards eliminating caste-based discrimination and atrocities and ensure that social justice prevailed in Tamil Nadu as envisioned by the Justice Party. Pointing out that social justice was at the forefront of the Dravidian Movement, he wrote: 'But it is now being challenged by the growing number of caste murders in the State. The killing of young couples in the name of caste pride is equivalent to destroying ourselves.' Citing the murder of an inter-caste couple in Krishnagiri, he said, 'Tamil Nadu is a State which prides itself on goodwill and being peaceful. It is unacceptable that the number of people who are blood-thirsty in the name of caste is increasing; this should not be allowed.' However, that was when the DMK was in Opposition benches. Though Mr. Stalin had assured that once his party formed the government, 'we will take all steps to prevent such caste killings and take strict legal action against such killings,' nothing much has changed on the ground in the last four years since he became Chief Minister. DMK sympathisers, however, cite 'grassroot realities' to defend Mr. Stalin's current measured silence. 'Ahead of the last Assembly elections, the DMK in its manifesto promised to renew an existing scheme to encourage inter-caste marriages — where the bride or groom is a Scheduled Caste — and enhance the financial support for the beneficiaries. However, parties in the opposite camp had whipped up a campaign saying the DMK was giving incentives to Scheduled Caste youth to lure girls from other communities. One BJP supporter, who was followed on X by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, warned: 'This is going to incite caste clashes in TN instead of healing the wounds.' The DMK had to move the Election Commission against such deliberately misleading campaign, said a party sympathiser. But is that reason enough to remain silent in the face of murder? That is a question mainstream leaders — and aspiring Chief Ministers — must seriously ask themselves. Until then, the silence will continue to speak louder than words.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
BJP accuses Siddaramaiah, Shivakumar of abetting RCB stampede
Bengaluru: The opposition BJP accused the govt of "abetting" the stampede that occurred during Royal Challengers Bengaluru's (RCB) IPL victory celebrations at M Chinnaswamy stadium on June 4, and demanded a CBI investigation. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Eleven people died in the incident. The accusation came during a discussion under Rule 69, with opposition leader R Ashoka and BJP veteran S Suresh Kumar leading the attack. Ashoka, in a two-and-a-half-hour speech, alleged the govt was complacent and failed to anticipate the massive turnout despite repeated warnings from all quarters. "In your hurried intent to lap up popularity and affection of the people, you rushed into the celebratory event… If it was not so, then why did traffic police decide to draw up traffic diversions around the stadium?" he asked. Drawing a parallel with suicide cases, Kumar said: "This govt is an abettor in this tragedy." BJP demanded a joint house committee and a CBI inquiry, along with "an unconditional apology from the govt" to families of the victims. Ashoka called it a total failure of crowd management, saying, "Who gave permission for the celebration? Who finalised the SOP? Were ambulances kept ready?" He insisted a case of negligence causing death should have been filed, adding, "I fail to understand what the CM and deputy CM were doing." He criticised the IPL, alleging it fuels betting among the poor: "My own cook indulged in theft to get money for betting," Ashoka said. He accused the govt of seeking political mileage, while presenting govt letters to top officials as evidence of official permission. "Without directions from the CM and deputy CM, it would have been impossible for DPAR to permit the event," he said. Quoting Justice Michael D'Cunha's report, he said directions from the CMO to RCB and event managers were documented. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now "If the govt had spent just five minutes thinking about it on June 4, the tragedy could have been prevented," Ashoka said. Yatnal berates Ashoka Suspended BJP MLA Basangouda Patil Yatnal, meanwhile, castigated opposition leader R Ashoka during the debate on the stampede, for shying away from directly blaming CM Siddaramaiah and his deputy DK Shivakumar. "I have heard you since morning speaking about the faults of the administration, but nowhere are you fixing blame on the political leadership of this govt," Yatnal said, intervening in the discussion. "Say it in plain words that the CM and DCM are directly responsible for the tragedy." Yatnal was suspended from BJP for six years for alleged anti-party activities.
