Metro contractors threaten BMC with contempt of court in property tax dispute
MUMBAI: Two Metro Rail contractors have sent a legal notice to the BMC and the Mumbai Metro Rail Corporation Ltd (MMRCL), demanding that their withheld payments over alleged non-payment of property tax dues be released, failing which they will file for contempt of court.
The contractors' contention is that no property tax is applicable, as Section 184 of the Railways Act, 1989 exempts the casting yard used for working on Metro Rail projects from property taxes. Their legal notice adds that the action of the BMC and MMRCL is in violation of a Bombay high court order that granted ad interim reliefs to them against the coercive recovery of property taxes.
Of the two contractors, HCC MMS (JV) was slapped with a property tax bill of ₹53.17crore while Dogus Soma (JV) received a bill of ₹97.17 crore for utilising a plot that belonged to the BMC. The plot, situated at the Wadala Truck Terminal, is being used by the contractors as a casting yard for the Metro Line 3 project (Colaba-Bandra-SEEPZ). The contractors have also stated in their notice dated April 21 that they will halt the Metro construction work if the payments are not released soon by MMRCL.
HT was the first to report, on March 18, that the contractors had been issued a notice by MMRCL to clear the property tax due to the BMC, failing which their payments would be withheld by MMRCL.
Last year, after additional municipal commissioner (city) Ashwini Joshi passed speaking orders on March 27, 2024 that the contractors were liable to pay the property tax, the contractors moved the HC against the BMC's notice and secured a stay in April. The stay was extended from time to time. The matter came up for hearing on October 25, 2024, and the court directed that the ad interim relief would continue till the next hearing, which is yet to take place.
On January 31, 2025, the BMC sent a notice to MMRCL, asking it to recover the dues from the contractors. MMRCL, in turn, sent a notice to the contractors on March 13 that it would withhold payments if property tax dues were not paid. The notice stated that the action was being taken to safeguard the interests of MMRCL and to ensure compliance with all legal and financial obligations.
Aggrieved by MMRCL's notice, the two contractors have now issued notices to the BMC, requesting the release of their payments, failing which action will be initiated for contempt of court.
Advocate Prerak Choudhary who issued the contempt notice on behalf of the two contractors, told HT, 'The actions of the BMC and MMRCL are not only a violation of law, being contrary to Section 184 of the Railways Act, but also a blatant violation of the ad interim orders of the high court. Such action is nothing short of contempt of court, and if payments are not released, the contractors will take such further legal action as may be required, including filing a contempt petition before the HC.'
Ashwini Joshi, when contacted, said she had not yet received a copy of the contempt notice. 'It is MMRCL that has stopped their payment,' she said. 'So why are they issuing a contempt notice to the BMC? Their agreement with MMRCL states that the burden of property tax lies with them. The BMC is just doing its duty by issuing property tax bills.'
MMRCL didnot respond to request for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
7 hours ago
- The Hindu
Chennai Metro Rail to build leisure facilities, workplaces at Phase II's Thirumangalam station
Like Kokura Station in Japan or Chongqing in China, Thirumangalam station will emerge as a place where people can shop, dine, or work on one floor and then catch a ride on the Chennai Metro Rail network on another. In a couple of months, Chennai Metro Rail Limited (CMRL) will start the construction of four towers in Thirumangalam. According to CMRL officials, they have floated bids for the massive project, which is located opposite to the Anna Nagar West Depot, near the Phase I Thirumangalam Metro station. Sprawling over 3.85 acres, the project will comprise the Phase II Thirumangalam Metro station and four towers. While Towers A and C will have three basements, a ground floor, and nine upper floors, the station will be in Tower B, which will have a ground floor and nine upper floors. Tower D will have a ground floor and two upper floors. In Tower B, the third floor will have the concourse and the platforms will be on the fourth floor. While ground floors will have retail and convenience stores in Towers A, B, and C, the first and second floors have been earmarked for commercial development similar to malls, and floors five to nine will have dedicated office spaces. T. Archunan, Director (projects), CMRL, said they drew inspiration from mass rapid transit systems in Japan. 'Kokura Station is a classic example for transit-oriented development. Based on the land availability, we are taking efforts to incorporate this strategy in as many locations as possible. But Thirumangalam will stand out as a great example for transit-oriented development since trains pass through buildings, making the commute seamless for people. All they have to do is switch floors to take the train,' he added. Manoharan Nambiar of Thirumangalam said that since there were apartments, a mall, and business establishments, the area suffered from traffic congestion both on weekdays and during weekends. 'Hence, two Metro Rail stations in Thirumangalam is a great boon to commuters. If commercial development and office spaces are planned alongside a mass rapid transport, it substantially improves mobility and does not add to congestion on the road,' he said. A. Shankar, India Head, Government Advisory and Infrastructure Solutions, Jones Lang LaSalle Property Consultants, said Metro systems across the world were being developed from the perspective of transit-oriented development. 'At a time when there is a great demand for office spaces, building them in the same tower with a Metro Rail system will be a great way to do it. Companies will prefer it and take them since they don't have to spend on providing transport for their workers,' he added. Sangami Nagarajan, an urban planner, said mix-use development always worked and would significantly aid in gradually nudging people to shift public transport in the future. 'Integrated development such as this are baby steps that will ensure that more people prefer public transport,' she added. 'Take for instance, the malls in the city. The one in Vadapalani has Metro Rail access, whereas the one in Velachery does not. Hence, the pressure on parking space is manyfold in the latter's case. Also, when stations are located close to the workplace or within the same tower, patronage for the transit system will be high, since people will readily opt for taking trains instead of their vehicles,' Ms. Nagarajan said.
The Hindu
8 hours ago
- The Hindu
Chennai Metro Rail Limited to incorporate leisure facilities, workplaces at Phase II's Thirumangalam station
Like Kokura Station in Japan or Chongqing in China, Thirumangalam station will emerge as a place where people can shop, dine, or work on one floor and then catch a ride on the Chennai Metro Rail network on another. In a couple of months, Chennai Metro Rail Limited (CMRL) will start the construction of four towers in Thirumangalam. According to CMRL officials, they have floated bids for the massive project, which is located opposite to the Anna Nagar West Depot, near the Phase I Thirumangalam Metro station. Sprawling over 3.85 acres, the project will comprise the Phase II Thirumangalam Metro station and four towers. While Towers A and C will have three basements, a ground floor, and nine upper floors, the station will be in Tower B, which will have a ground floor and nine upper floors. Tower D will have a ground floor and two upper floors. In Tower B, the third floor will have the concourse and the platforms will be on the fourth floor. While ground floors will have retail and convenience stores in Towers A, B, and C, the first and second floors have been earmarked for commercial development similar to malls, and floors five to nine will have dedicated office spaces. T. Archunan, Director (projects), CMRL, said they drew inspiration from mass rapid transit systems in Japan. 'Kokura Station is a classic example for transit-oriented development. Based on the land availability, we are taking efforts to incorporate this strategy in as many locations as possible. But Thirumangalam will stand out as a great example for transit-oriented development since trains pass through buildings, making the commute seamless for people. All they have to do is switch floors to take the train,' he added. Manoharan Nambiar of Thirumangalam said that since there were apartments, a mall, and business establishments, the area suffered from traffic congestion both on weekdays and during weekends. 'Hence, two Metro Rail stations in Thirumangalam is a great boon to commuters. If commercial development and office spaces are planned alongside a mass rapid transport, it substantially improves mobility and does not add to congestion on the road,' he said. A. Shankar, India Head, Government Advisory and Infrastructure Solutions, Jones Lang LaSalle Property Consultants, said Metro systems across the world were being developed from the perspective of transit-oriented development. 'At a time when there is a great demand for office spaces, building them in the same tower with a Metro Rail system will be a great way to do it. Companies will prefer it and take them since they don't have to spend on providing transport for their workers,' he added. Sangami Nagarajan, an urban planner, said mix-use development always worked and would significantly aid in gradually nudging people to shift public transport in the future. 'Integrated development such as this are baby steps that will ensure that more people prefer public transport,' she added. 'Take for instance, the malls in the city. The one in Vadapalani has Metro Rail access, whereas the one in Velachery does not. Hence, the pressure on parking space is manyfold in the latter's case. Also, when stations are located close to the workplace or within the same tower, patronage for the transit system will be high, since people will readily opt for taking trains instead of their vehicles,' Ms. Nagarajan said.
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
13 hours ago
- Business Standard
Kalpataru Projects shares jump 7% on securing ₹3,789 crore worth new orders
Shares of Kalpataru Projects International Ltd. soared over 7 per cent in intraday trade on Monday, after the company and its subsidiaries landed fresh orders worth ₹3,789 crore. The company's stock rose as much as 7.32 per cent during the day to ₹1,234 per share, the biggest intraday gain since May 12 this year. The stock pared gains to trade 4 per cent higher at ₹1,195.3 apiece, compared to a 0.47 per cent advance in Nifty 50 as of 11:36 AM. Shares of the company have risen nearly 12 per cent from their recent lows of ₹1,074, which it hit last month. The counter has risen 7.3 per cent this year, compared to a 6.25 per cent advance in the benchmark Nifty 50. Kalpataru Projects has a total market capitalisation of ₹20,548.21 crore. Track LIVE Stock Market Updates Here Kalpataru Projects lands ₹3,789 crore fresh orders Kalpataru Projects, along with its international subsidiaries, has secured new orders worth approximately ₹3,789 crore, according to an exchange filing on Monday. The orders include major contracts in the Buildings and Factories (B&F) segment in India, featuring the company's largest-ever B&F order for the development of over 12 million square feet of residential buildings and associated facilities on a design-build basis. Additionally, KPIL has won power transmission and distribution (T&D) orders in overseas markets. "We feel privileged to announce the receipt of the orders, especially the largest ever B&F order received by us on design and build basis, which is a testament to our strong EPC capabilities in the B&F business," Manish Mohnot, managing director and chief executive officer. "This prestigious achievement also has been on several counts – intensive efforts that we have been putting in past several years on improving our ability to win large-sized projects, and improving competitiveness in the focused markets on the back of capex and execution capabilities. We look forward to many such opportunities in future.' About Kalpataru Projects Kalpataru Projects is a leading Engineering, Procurement, and Construction (EPC) company, specialising in Power Transmission & Distribution, Buildings & Factories, Water Supply & Irrigation, Railways, Oil & Gas Pipelines, Urban Mobility (including Flyovers & Metro Rail), Highways, and Airports. With ongoing projects in over 30 countries and a presence in 75 countries worldwide, KPIL has established a strong global footprint.
