Can't blame doctors for every death during treatment, rules Kerala high court
The court further observed that only in cases involving a gross lack of competence, inaction, or wanton indifference to a patient's safety — arising from gross ignorance or gross negligence — could a doctor be compelled to face trial for
criminal negligence
. Justice G Gireesh made these observations while allowing a petition filed by a gastroenterologist at a private hospital in Ernakulam seeking to quash the final report and further proceedings in a case alleging
medical negligence
that allegedly resulted in a patient's death.
According to prosecution, a young man who had undergone renal transplantation later died at the hospital while under treatment for an intestinal ailment in the early hours of May 26, 2012. As his condition worsened during the night, the duty nurse contacted the petitioner, who then prescribed medicines over the phone. Later that night, the patient was shifted to the Nephrology Intensive Care Unit, where he succumbed to renal complications.
The allegation against the petitioner was that by administering treatment over the telephone instead of directing the nurse to have the patient examined by a nephrologist, he caused the patient's death due to renal failure.
Despite two expert committee reports stating that the patient appeared to have received reasonable medical and nursing care, the investigating officer sought a further opinion from the state-level apex medical body, which found fault with the petitioner and directed that he be investigated for criminal negligence.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Trade Bitcoin & Ethereum – No Wallet Needed!
IC Markets
Start Now
Undo
While considering the petition, HC observed that none of the expert panel members found fault with the medicines prescribed by the petitioner. It held that under no circumstances could the treatment provided be considered an act of criminal negligence attracting Section 304A of the IPC. The court reiterated that even where a patient's death results from an error of judgment or accident, no criminal liability arises.
Mere inadvertence or some degree of lack of care and caution may give rise to civil liability but is insufficient to impose criminal responsibility on a medical professional.
The court also cited a Supreme Court judgment, which warned that if courts were to impose criminal liability on hospitals and doctors for every untoward outcome, it would lead to doctors being more concerned about their safety than providing the best possible care to patients. This, the apex court had cautioned, could erode the mutual trust essential in the doctor-patient relationship.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
39 minutes ago
- Time of India
Govt planning to set up organ retrieval centres at MCHs
Bhubaneswar: Odisha govt has decided to set up non-transplant organ retrieval centres at medical colleges and hospitals (MCH)s, Umakant Satapathy, nodal officer for organ transplant and additional director of medical education and training (DMET), said on Monday. Among state-run hospitals, only SCB Medical College and Hospital, Cuttack, has this facility. "After the brain stem death of a person, a team from SCB will visit the MCH immediately, and with the help of the concerned MCH doctors, organs will be retrieved from the brain-dead patient. Later, they can be transplanted at SCB and other hospitals. The organ retrieval centres will immensely help us to get organs from deceased donors," Satapathy said. He said the govt is prepared to start heart transplant at SCB soon. "This type of transplantation is not a scheduled event like a planned surgery. Screening for heart transplantation is ongoing. We will conduct the transplant whenever we get a deceased donor and an eligible receiver," he added. The govt signed an MoU with a Chennai-based hospital on Oct 23 last year to start heart transplant at SCB. The Chennai-based healthcare institution has provided training to five doctors, two perfusionists and two nursing officers to make the heart transplant unit of the hospital functional. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like It's Great for My Business [Explore] SearchPad Learn More Undo "The private agency will conduct the first 10 transplants for free as per the agreement," Satapathy said. On July 31, Orissa high court had directed the govt to take urgent steps to resume liver transplant at SCB, which was stopped in April following the expiry of the MoU with a Hyderabad-based institute. The court also sought a report from the govt regarding proper functioning of bone marrow transplant (BMT) procedures. Satapathy said the govt will follow the high court order and soon resume liver transplant at SCB. "The earlier agency from Hyderabad, whose agreement ended a few months ago, is not showing interest in another MoU to continue the liver transplant activities at SCB. The govt is exploring other ways, like roping in an experienced hospital in Chennai, to resume the transplant work," he added. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
Time of India
39 minutes ago
- Time of India
Telangana high court seeks action plans on Kaleshwaram safety
Hyderabad: The Telangana high court on Tuesday issued key directions to the state govt on three separate public interest litigations concerning public safety, welfare, and infrastructure. A bench of Chief Justice Aparesh Kumar Singh and Justice GM Mohiuddin directed the state to submit, within two weeks, details of measures being taken to safeguard the Kaleshwaram irrigation project and protect people from potential flood-related disasters during the ongoing monsoon. The bench was hearing a 2020 PIL filed by Cheruku Sudhakar and another petitioner, initially focused on remedial measures under the Disaster Management Act during the heavy rains and floods of that year. Counsel Chikkudu Prabhakar recently filed a memo seeking similar safeguards for Kaleshwaram, citing the National Dam Safety Authority's report and earlier court directives. The petitioners expressed concern that low-lying areas downstream face imminent risk. The case will be reviewed on Aug 28. You Can Also Check: Hyderabad AQI | Weather in Hyderabad | Bank Holidays in Hyderabad | Public Holidays in Hyderabad | Gold Rates Today in Hyderabad | Silver Rates Today in Hyderabad Hostel food-poisoning In a separate matter, the same bench sought an explanation within three weeks from the state and its welfare wing on the food-poisoning incident due to which 110 students fell ill at the Jyotiba Phule BC Residential School in Uyyalawada, Nagarkurnool district. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like They Were So Beautiful Before; Now Look At Them; Number 10 Will Shock You Reportingly Undo Hearing a PIL by K Akhil Sriguru Teja, the court was told by counsel Prabhakar that welfare hostels require urgent improvements, including adequate toilets and hygienic, nutritious food. The bench fixed Sept 3 to review the compliance status. OGH relocation dispute The high court also asked the state govt to file a detailed report on its decision to relocate Osmania General Hospital (OGH) to Goshamahal Stadium. The petition, filed by local resident G Ramu, contended that the stadium land is reserved for sports and cannot be repurposed. Counsel argued that GO 45, transferring the land to the medical and health department, was issued without considering public objections. Advocate general A Sudarshan Reddy informed the court that the transfer process was complete and a nearby govt school had been relocated to accommodate the move. The bench granted one week to file a counter affidavit and posted the matter to Sept 26, directing that the report be submitted before that date. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
Time of India
39 minutes ago
- Time of India
PMC launches campaign to control stray dog population amid rising bite cases
1 2 Prayagraj: The Prayagraj Municipal Corporation (PMC) has launched a largescale campaign to sterilise the city's over 1.13 lakh stray canine population amid increasing dog bite cases. The action follows a National Rabies Control Programme (NRCP) data that showed a staggering 1,98,964 people were bitten by dogs in the city over the last two years. Of these, 58,948 were reported in 2023 and a whopping 1,40,016 in 2024, showing a concerning surge. In 2023, dog scratches accounted for 31,237 cases, 24,152 victims suffered bleeding injuries and 3,559 were severely wounded. In 2024, the numbers grew more alarming with 33,258 people getting scratched, 97,893 sustaining bleeding injuries and 8,865 seriously injured. February 2024 alone recorded 2,800 serious dog bite injuries, the highest in any month. The rising number of incidents has highlighted the challenge of managing stray dog populations. To handle the situation, the PMC is setting up an animal birth control (ABC) centre in Shams Nagar Kareli (Haddigodam) where sterilisation and vaccination procedures would begin this month. According to Rohit Kumar, the project manager from C&DS, the centre was built at a cost of Rs1.85 crore. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Learn 57+ Languages Easily with AI [Join] Talkpal AI Sign Up Undo It includes an operation theatre, kennel space, pantry, community kitchen, salon, dormitory and park. The facility can sterilise up to 32 dogs per day. In addition, a largescale vaccination and sterilisation campaign has been launched, with the tendering process already underway. Dr Vijay Amritraj, veterinary and welfare officer of PMC, said the centre has the capacity to house 200 to 250 dogs at a time. "Currently, Prayagraj has an estimated 1.13 lakh stray dogs, out of which only 4,540 have undergone vaccination and sterilisation. The city has also completed construction of two dog shelter homes, which are set to be operated by specialised agencies chosen through a tender process," said the official. Authorities have assured that laws that prevent cruelty towards animals will be strictly followed in these facilities, he added. Sources at PMC said catching stray dogs is no easy task, with municipal teams often facing resistance from locals and animal welfare groups. These confrontations have made it difficult for municipal corporation to efficiently carry out sterilisation and relocation drives. But now efforts are in full swing to ensure the safety of the city residents while maintaining ethical treatment of animals. The municipal corporation's plan aims to strike a balance between public safety and animal welfare by combining sterilisation, vaccination and controlled sheltering. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
