Does today's rate environment make HELOCs too risky? Here's what experts say.
We may receive commissions from some links to products on this page. Promotions are subject to availability and retailer terms.
Homeowners should carefully calculate the trajectory of HELOC interest rates before borrowing equity right now.
Getty Images
Inflation and elevated interest rates continue to squeeze household budgets in 2025. Despite these financial hurdles, many homeowners are sitting on a valuable resource — the equity they've built in their homes.
Getting a home equity line of credit (HELOC) has become a popular way to tap into this wealth. It offers lower interest rates than credit cards while providing flexibility similar to the use of a credit card. And that rate is variable and subject to change monthly for borrowers, meaning it could become even cheaper if interest rates continue to decline as they have.
But the same features that make HELOCs attractive can also create financial risks. Are they too risky right now? We asked three home equity experts to share their insights on when HELOCs make sense, when they don't and what alternatives could be better right now.
See how low your HELOC rate offers are here now.
Does today's rate environment make HELOCs too risky?
"With the prime rate at 7.5% and home prices having appreciated nationwide, I don't think HELOCs are too risky today," says Karen Mayfield, national head of originations at Multiply Mortgage, a mortgage-as-a-benefit provider.
Debbie Calixto, sales manager at mortgage lender loanDepot, echoes a similar sentiment. "Households are feeling the pressure of rising living expenses," she observes. HELOCs offer a valuable alternative to high-interest credit card debt.
However, Steven Glick, director of mortgage sales at real estate investment fintech company HomeAbroad, offers a more nuanced view. "HELOCs aren't inherently too risky, but they come with risks that depend on [your] situation," he explains. While home equity loan interest rates have dipped below 9%, he cautions that variable HELOC rates can climb if economic conditions change.
When HELOCs make financial sense now
Glick says a HELOC makes the most sense if you find yourself in one or more of these situations now:
Get started with a HELOC online today.
When HELOCs may not make financial sense now
Here are situations where a HELOC could cause more harm than good if secured now, experts say:
You have unstable income: "If your job's shaky or your DTI is above 43%, a variable-rate HELOC could stretch you thin, especially if rates rise," cautions Glick.
"If your job's shaky or your DTI is above 43%, a variable-rate HELOC could stretch you thin, especially if rates rise," cautions Glick. You lack a clear purpose: "If you're borrowing for vague reasons or lifestyle expenses [such as] vacations, you're setting yourself up for trouble," warns Glick.
"If you're borrowing for vague reasons or lifestyle expenses [such as] vacations, you're setting yourself up for trouble," warns Glick. The housing market is declining: If local home prices are dropping, overborrowing could leave you underwater if you need to sell.
If local home prices are dropping, overborrowing could leave you underwater if you need to sell. You're on a tight budget: A HELOC's variable rate is risky if you're on a fixed budget where a $200 monthly payment increase would hurt you, according to Glick.
A HELOC's variable rate is risky if you're on a fixed budget where a $200 monthly payment increase would hurt you, according to Glick. You already owe a lot: "If [you owe] a substantial amount on [your] home, it can be risky maxing out [your] entire, or a bulk, of [your] home equity," Mayfield says.
Alternative home equity borrowing options to consider
If a HELOC doesn't work for your circumstances right now, experts recommend these alternatives:
Home equity loans
Cash-out refinance loans : This replaces your existing mortgage with a larger one. Calixto notes that "even if the new mortgage is a bit higher than your current one, your borrowing costs might still be lower when everything's combined."
This replaces your existing mortgage with a larger one. Calixto notes that "even if the new mortgage is a bit higher than your current one, your borrowing costs might still be lower when everything's combined." Reverse mortgages : "For homeowners 62 [of age and up], this lets you borrow against equity without monthly payments (repaid when you sell or pass away)," explains Glick. Seniors with limited income may choose this option.
The bottom line
HELOCs offer flexible access to your home's equity. But they work well when you have a clear purpose, stable finances and a plan for managing variable payments. Calixto advises taking a conservative approach. "Borrow only what you truly need and think carefully about how your home's value might change over time," she says. With careful planning, a HELOC can be a powerful financial tool rather than a risky burden.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Insider
an hour ago
- Business Insider
I was running out of cash and needed to make ends meet. My home equity agreement saved me.
This as-told-to essay is based on a conversation with Eileen Perry, a 57-year-old from North Carolina. Perry entered a home equity agreement with the financial services company Unlock to access her home equity. This conversation has been edited for length and clarity. I'm originally from New Jersey, where I lived with my husband and my son. In 2023, my husband passed away suddenly from pancreatic cancer. He left me well-off enough that I was able to buy a home in North Carolina for $260,000 outright, in cash. Unfortunately, timing is everything. I had an on-the-job injury; I broke my back, and I'm still suffering from back issues. I'm currently waiting for my permanent disability Social Security, so I have no income. My son, who lives with me — he's 27 — is also disabled and unable to work right now. So the two of us have no income. We've been in North Carolina for almost two years, and my sister has supported us. But I didn't want to keep relying on her. I knew I owned 100% of my home's equity and thought, "Maybe there's something I can do with this." I tried to get a home equity loan, or a Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC). But because I have no income, and had fallen behind on all my credit cards and bills, my credit score took a major dive. I couldn't qualify. I even tried to get a loan with a cosigner, but my application was denied. It felt like everyone was closing a door in my face, but I still thought, "There has to be someone out there who can help me." An HEA was the right solution for me I was scouring the internet when a home equity company, Unlock, popped up. I started researching home equity agreements and thought it could be a perfect fit for me. Unlock's home equity agreement (HEA) is different from a loan, HELOC, or reverse mortgage, which typically has an age requirement. Instead of owning the deed or title to a home, they place a lien on the property. Homeowners access their equity by receiving an investment payment from Unlock. In exchange, the company receives a percentage of the home's value. There are no monthly payments, and homeowners can buy out their agreement at any point within 10 years, either with partial payments or all at once. For many homeowners, the equity buy-back happens when they sell their home. To qualify for an agreement, I needed a valid ID, proof of ownership of my home, and a credit score of at least 500, which was great for me. I also needed current and up-to-date homeowner's insurance. My $45,000 home equity agreement became effective in September 2024. After paying $2,205 to Unlock for an origination fee, $340 for the home's appraisal, and $720 for settlement costs, I received $41,735 in October for my first HEA. In May 2025, I needed more funds for day-to-day expenses, so I canceled the original HEA balance and replaced it with a new HEA agreement totaling $93,500. My funds have paid off outstanding property taxes and other bills I wouldn't have been able to cover. They also helped us afford everyday expenses like groceries and gas. I finally have peace of mind and can sleep at night. An HEA has changed my life for the better It's been almost two years since my husband passed away. There were days when I didn't know how my son and I were going to eat, whether we would be sitting in the dark, or where we were going to live. Having a home equity agreement has truly been a gift — call it divine intervention. I'm now selling my house to move back to New Jersey. Of course, certain things are required to put your home on the market or pass inspection, like having an air conditioning system and bathrooms with good plumbing. In February, the plumbing in my house went out completely. I had no shower or toilet for almost two months. The bathrooms had to be completely remodeled because of severe water damage. The influx of money helped me pay for a new line when my homeowner's insurance wouldn't cover it. That line alone cost nearly $6,000, just for the plumbing. Without the money from the home equity agreement, I doubt I'd be able to sell my home. In May, my home was appraised at $290,000. Since I received a $93,500 investment — about 32.24% of the home's value — if I sell this month, I'd owe about $94,000 of my home's equity. Initially, my friends and family were hesitant about me taking on a home equity agreement because they feared I might get a much higher interest rate, or they were concerned about how I was going to pay the money back. But I knew I wasn't going to be staying in North Carolina forever, and putting my house on the market was going to be the next option. I didn't think getting an HEA agreement would be a problem because I would have a profit left over after I sold my home. This experience has been life-changing.
New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
China eases stranglehold on rare minerals in welcome news for GM, Ford: report
China has granted temporary export licenses to rare-earth suppliers of the top three US automakers, two sources familiar with the matter said, as supply chain disruptions begin to surface from Beijing's export curbs on those materials. At least some of the licenses are valid for six months, the two sources said, declining to be named because the information is not public. It was not immediately clear what quantity or items are covered by the approval or whether the move signals China is preparing to ease the rare-earths licensing process, which industry groups say is cumbersome and has created a supply bottleneck. Advertisement On Thursday, President Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping had a lengthy phone call to iron out trade differences. 3 China has granted temporary export licenses to rare-earth suppliers of the top three US automakers, sources said. GM cars, above. Getty Images Trump said in social-media post that 'there should no longer be any questions respecting the complexity of Rare Earth products.' Both sides said teams will meet again soon. Advertisement China's decision in April to restrict exports of a wide range of rare earths and related magnets has tripped up the supply chains central to automakers, aerospace manufacturers, semiconductor companies and military contractors around the world. China's dominance of the critical mineral industry, key to the green energy transition, is increasingly viewed as a key point of leverage for Beijing in its trade war with the US. China produces around 90% of the world's rare earths, and auto industry representatives have warned of increasing threats to production due to their dependency on it for those parts. Advertisement Suppliers of three big US automakers, General Motors, Ford and Jeep-maker Stellantis got clearance for some rare earth export licenses on Monday, one of the two sources said. GM and Ford each declined to comment. Stellantis said it is working with suppliers 'to ensure an efficient licensing process' and that so far the company has been able to 'address immediate production concerns without major disruptions.' China's Ministry of Commerce did not immediately respond to a faxed request for comment. 3 Chinese President Xi Jinping and President Trump had a lengthy phone call on Thursday to iron out trade differences. Getty Images Advertisement China's critical-mineral export controls have become a focus on Trump's criticism of Beijing, which he says has violated the truce reached last month to roll back tariffs and trade restrictions. US auto companies are already feeling the impact of the restrictions. Ford shut down production of its Explorer SUV at its Chicago plant for a week in May because of a rare-earth shortage, the company said. The approval for the auto suppliers follows a green light granted to a US electronics firm's suppliers last week and another one issued earlier this week to suppliers of a US non-auto company, the first person said, declining to name the companies. 3 China produces around 90% of the world's rare earths, and auto industry representatives have warned of increasing threats to production due to their dependency on it for those parts. The Bayan Obo mine in Inner Mongolia, above. REUTERS 'We have to give the Chinese the benefit of the doubt that they're working through this. It's up to them to show that they are not weaponizing it,' said the person. Reuters reported on Wednesday that China has introduced a tracking system for its rare earth magnet sector in a move to improve its control over the sector and crackdown on smuggling.
New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
Tesla shares jump 5% after all-out Trump-Musk feud wipes out $150B market value
Tesla shares jumped more than 5% Friday — a day after an all-out feud between CEO Elon Musk and President Trump tanked the stock and wiped out $152 billion in market value. Investors were hopeful for signs that the two might reconcile after Tesla suffered its worst single-day drop in more than four years, though Trump said Friday he has no interest in speaking with his former top ally. 'You mean the man who has lost his mind?' Trump told ABC News when asked about the possibility that the pair would speak on a call. 3 President Trump and Elon Musk speak in the Oval Office before leaving the White House in March. AFP via Getty Images Musk, the world's richest person, lost about $27 billion on Thursday as he taunted Trump, saying he wouldn't have won the election without his help. The president fired back by threatening to kill his companies' government contracts. Despite Thursday financial hit, the Tesla and SpaceX boss remains the richest person in the world with a net worth of $395.8 billion, according to Forbes. Tesla short sellers, meanwhile, reaped $4 billion in profits Thursday in one of their largest single-day gains ever, according to estimates from S3 Partners. So far this year, investors have made $7 billion betting against the carmaker. Tesla is currently the second most shorted stock in the US by total value of the position. 'Musk needs Trump and Trump needs Musk for many reasons and these two becoming friends again will be a huge relief for Tesla shares,' Wedbush Securities analyst Dan Ives wrote in a note Friday morning. Musk's attacks on Thursday took aim at the Trump-backed spending bill that narrowly passed through the House and awaits Senate approval. The tax package would end EV tax credits worth as much as $7,500 for buyers – threatening to dock Tesla's annual profit by $1.2 billion, JPMorgan analysts said Thursday. 3 Trump and Musk have been in the middle of an all-out feud. AFP via Getty Images It would also impose a new annual $250 fee on EV drivers. Meanwhile, the Senate recently moved to block California's EV sales mandates, which could slice another $2 billion off Tesla's sales, according to JPMorgan. Those measures combined threaten to erase about half of the more than $6 billion in earnings before interest and taxes that Tesla is expected to report this year, analysts led by Ryan Brinkman wrote in a report last month. 3 Musk has been taunting the president on social media. AFP via Getty Images Tesla sales have plummeted in major markets across Europe, allowing Chinese rival BYD to overtake Tesla in some countries. The brand's reputation has also taken a beating as protests broke out across the country – and some Tesla showrooms and vehicles were vandalized or set ablaze – as demonstrators decried Musk's role in slashing government spending, including funds for the Department of Education and US Agency for International Development.
