Can Panchayat Season 4 Rise Above Its Average Season 3?
In the finale episode of season one, Sachivji went to the rooftop of the paani ki tanki and tried to explore the beauty of the village.
"Same hi toh dikhta hai, alag kya hai?" was his first reaction.
The reactions suddenly changed when a female voice was heard around him.
He met Rinki [Pradhanji's daughter, played by Sanvikaa] for the first time.
And these words echoed in the background, " Aap ek bar tanki ki chhat se dekh lo Phulera, pyar toh ho hi jayega (If you watch Phulera from the rooftop of the tank, you'll surely fall in love)."
Back in April 2020, the world just woke up to the COVID-19 pandemic. People had no clue how to deal with loss, death and uncertainty that shrouded their everyday lives. Around that time, Panchayat season one [the Amazon Prime Original series], directly made its way to the viewers' hearts like a lease of new love.
Through the eyes of Sachivji, the OTT viewers were transported to a village of the Hindi hinterland, which appeared to be TVF's [The Viral Factory, the production company] new figment of imagination.
No complaints though.
Phulera and its likeable characters [inspired from folklore or Aesop's Fables] proved their longevity over the five years in an OTT market, dominated by rampant crime and whodunnit shows.
Ahead of its season four release on June 24, 2025, let's look back and decode why season three received mixed reactions, what worked for the first two seasons and why season three didn't end on a "look-forward-to" note.
Elevating Endings (Missing In Season Three)
Panchayat season one and two became fan favourite due to its lofty endings. The last 10-20 minutes of the finale episodes (both in season one and two) had uplifted the series to a certain level, where nationalistic fervour and storytelling combined had a cathartic effect on the minds of the viewers.
In season one, Manju Devi (played by Neena Gupta) who's the actual Pradhan of the village Phulera, hoisted the National Flag in front of the District Magistrate, who happens to be a woman, and the village. She also sang the National Anthem Jana Gana Mana after rehearsing it for two days with Sachivji. When Manju Devi was fumbling with the words of the National Anthem, her husband AKA Pradhan-Pati (Brij Bhushan Dubey, played by Raghubir Yadav) gave her cues, so that she didn't feel nervous.
Or talk about that scene, when Manju Devi wanted to rehearse the lines by sitting on a chair. Sachivji, with a firm voice, said, "We can't sit as you have to sing the song standing alone. Let's practise that way only."
These were the moments that stayed with the viewers long after the season ended.
Season two treaded the path a step further. This time, the makers, wanted the audience to shed a few drop of tears after smiling all through. Upa-Pradhan Prahlad (played by Faisal Malik) lost his only son Rahul; he is killed in action on the border and the whole Phulera wept with him when he was cremated with full state honours.
"My parents died long ago. My wife died. Now my only son died. I have become so lonely," an inconsolable Prahladcha told Pradhanji.
Even if you haven't seen loss in your immediate circle, the sheer magnitude of loss would strike a chord with you. And it did. Quite impactfully.
Deviating from the last two seasons, the finale of season three descended into chaos, violence and an abrupt hooliganism which the Panchayat audiences were not ready for.
Pradhanji was shot at in broad daylight. All eyes were on MLA Chandrakishore Singh who came with arms and guns to attack the village Phulera earlier.
The season ended on a note that elections were nearing and both parties would resort to violence (which is a sole quality that disntinguishes Panchayat from other shows).
If a show, which earlier solved disputes with a lauki (bottle gourd), sometimes with a moving chair, didn't find any other discourse than violence as the go-to solution, it would certainly distance its loyal fanbase. And, it did (badly).
Season 3 Lacked Insightful Characters, Solid Life Lessons
In season two, two guest characters made lasting impressions with their powerful dialogues - full of insight and precision.
When Abhishek asked a dancer (season two, episode 1) why she didn't quit dancing as a profession as she was injured in a duel, her reply was, "Do you like the job you do?" Abhishek replied with a simple "No".
" Saab, sabhi kahi na kahi toh nach hi rahe hain (Everyone is dancing to someone's tunes one way or the other)," the village girl summed up.
It made Sachivji pause for a moment.
Remember the drunk driver who predicted Sachivji would become a drunkard too later in his life?
" Saab, jab 20,000 main sansar chalana hoga na, tab nashe main rehena hi acha lagta hain... (If you have to run the household of four with 20,000 rupess, you wanted to be a drunkard)," the driver said.
Though season three had one dadi character, who hatched a plan with his son to get a new house under the scheme of Pradhanmantri Avaas Yojna, she became an episode in herself, tickling the funny bone more than parting a lesson.
Can Panchayat Afford To Have Violence?
Panchayat is no Mirzapur (The Amazon Prime series infamous for its very graphic violence). At least, the makers envisoned a Uttar Pradesh town devoid of violence and made the audience believe in its reality.
Of course, there's a banraakas (the terrific Bhushan played by Durgesh Kumar), his wife Kranti devi (Sunita Rajwar) a pradhan aspirant, and their hangers-on Madhav and Binod, the political tussle between paschim (west) and purab (east) Phulera - but all these elements didn't tarnish the naive image of Phulera.
In season three, the MLA character was developed with gruesome details - he was accused of mudering a pet dog (rumoured to have eaten its meat as well) and a pigeon died in his hands. The intention was violent; so was the tonality of the storytelling. And, perhaps, it was the root of a sense of detachment that the viewers felt after watching the third instalment.
The Timing Of The Release Of Panchayat Season 4
From 2020 to 2025, the world has walked into a timezone divided by the pandemic. A piece of art, which appealed to the masses during the pandemic five years ago, may not lead to a similar response today.
A year, which has already seen catastrophes such as the Pahalgam terror attack and the Air India plane crash, is desperately hoping to breathe in some fresh air, once offered by Phulera and the characters in Panchayat.
If season four gets entangled in electoral politics - propelled by bandook - Phulera will not feel like Phulera.
A land, devoid of violence in its ugliest form, will go back to becoming just a figment of imagination.
The makers imagined Phulera, the audience made it a reality. They are not ready to say good bye; so early, so abruptly.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
23 minutes ago
- Mint
Why quality mental health support is still some ways away for the LGBTQIA+ community
In recent times, we've had movies like Kaathal – The Core (Malayalam) and Gulmohar (Hindi) that had prominent actors like Mammootty and Sharmila Tagore play gay and lesbian characters, respectively. The mental struggle these characters face has been portrayed adeptly too– Mathew's resistance to divorce his wife and Kusum's eagerness to let go of the home her husband built, in their own way showcase denial and defiance. In reality, however, the LGBTQIA+ community continues to face difficulties when it comes to address mental health issues. Based on conversations Lounge has had with members from the community, 'accessibility" and 'sensitisation" seem to be the main problems here. 'Queerness continues to be pathologized here even by mental health practitioners. The idea that it is something that needs to be 'cured' or 'treated' is still prevalent. Can you imagine how difficult it then becomes to even take those initial steps for help when you realise that these so-called 'safe' spaces themselves can be dehumanising?" wonders Srishti Pandey, 26, who identifies herself as asexual. 'Queer people, especially outside the major metros, face glaringly hostile environments and harmful, violent and illegal attempts to 'cure' queer people. There is little safety available in mental healthcare institutes, and often, it is quasi-religious places that offer anything close to care and they can be very hurtful places," says Bengaluru-based counsellor Mahesh Natarajan who identifies as gay. Pandey, who has tried therapy and found it helpful, shares that while her family and friends have been supportive, she has received biased reactions from others. Currently residing in England, she also reveals that life as an asexual has been relatively easier for her in the UK. 'Everyone faces challenges, it is just that the intensity with which members from the community face them is more, and the resources available for us are less," notes Aryan Somaiya, a Goa-based psychotherapist who identifies as a transman. As 34-year-old scientist Soham (last name withheld upon request) from Bengaluru points out, therapy can be expensive and out of reach for several people in the queer community. Listing out the issues the LGBTQ+ community faces while seeking therapy, he says, 'There are many people who prefer online consultations because going in person would mean taking time off work. Then there's the question of whether the therapist you are seeing has knowledge about the queer community, knows people who belong to the community, and is sensitised to the issues faced by queer people." But that's not all. In a society where being comfortable in your skin is still a struggle for many, those belonging to the queer community have it doubly hard. 'I know of quite a few people, myself included, who tend to, at times, lead double lives," says Edwin Daniel, a Bengaluru-based entrepreneur who is gay. 'I have been lucky, because most of my colleagues and co-workers are comfortable with my identity. But, when there's a business meeting or I am meeting someone new for work-related purposes, I tend to do 'straight acting' or regulate the way I behave to meet heteronormative roles. But, for a lot of my counterparts, it is one kind of life from 10-7, and another life after 7pm," he adds. HAMPERED BY THE LACK OF A STABLE SOCIAL STRUCTURE According to Daniel, one of the main problems the LGBTQ+ community in India faces is the absence of a stable social structure. 'Since same-sex marriages aren't legal in India, unlike heterosexual people, we don't have milestones like getting married and having kids. This tends to take a huge toll on our mental health," he says. Soham concurs. 'Since these milestones are absent for us, the onus of creating a structure falls on us," he says. He also resonates with Daniel when he says that it is quite difficult, yet important, to find a therapist who is queer-sensitised and understands problems of the community. Finding that therapist, as Daniel notes, is not easy. 'One goes through numerous therapists, before landing on someone who understands you and suits your needs." After seeking therapy for five years, he reveals that he's only recently found a counsellor who 'understands me, what I am going through and helps me accordingly." Bengaluru-based entrepreneur Prasenjit Chaudhari, 41, knew he was gay right from childhood but chose to hide it in a bid to belong, fit in. 'This attempt to hide your identity takes a toll on your mental health and the scars remain for a long time," he confesses. This is precisely why finding the right therapist becomes crucial, he says, but in a city where the community is small that can pose a problem. 'I came to Bengaluru in 2007 and have literally watched the community grow. I know nearly everyone in the community, and so, even if I do find a therapist who is queer, I know them on a personal level and that is something I try to avoid." As a therapist, Natarajan says that he chooses to not counsel members from the community who are closely connected to his personal life. But for those who are strictly his clients, he says, 'We protect the client's privacy and confidentiality as fully as possible. It helps for the client to know that we are part of the community and not too distant from their realities." According to Natarajan, a typical green flag when seeking a therapist from within the community is to check if they are well regarded for their general ethical practice. It's a big no-no if they have in any way breached client confidentiality or canvassed for influence. A good way to verify a therapist's ability is to reach out to (other members from the community) who have previously sought help from the said therapist, Natarajan advises. The conversations do get louder every year during Pride Month in June but they barely scratch the surface. Issues like chem sex that can prove fatal to queer members are not explored in depth. 'While chem sex is common for everyone, it is a deeper issue for the queer community. It is not just loneliness that makes it a problem. Lack of safe resources, worries of being outed, health concerns, abandonment by family and other issues are all part of the problem," Natarajan says. There's a lot of distance to be covered for sure, but every individual Lounge spoke to clings to glimmers of hope. 'The main thing that affects mental health for the LGBTQ community is social stigma and the feeling of being 'othered'. With greater integration and community building, people will flourish," Natarajan says. 'Broadly speaking, I want therapy to be easily accessible and destigmatized. And most importantly, I want (more) resources for patients and counsellors who are catering to LGBTQ folks because our struggles are widely different," says Daniel. Sumitra Nair is an independent journalist based in Kochi.
The Hindu
an hour ago
- The Hindu
‘War 2' movie review: Hrithik Roshan and Jr NTR battle it out to keep this bloated sequel afloat
In childhood, we were attracted to comic digests by their girth. One used to believe that the more the stories, the more the fun. The pages were glossy, and the packaging used to be fetching. However, the excitement often dissipated into disappointment when one discovered that it was a marketing gimmick, where the publishers added only a couple of new adventures of our favourite characters, the rest were just a repetition. Ayan Mukerji's sequel to War gives the same feeling of a recycled product that shines. It starts with a bang but soon becomes a rudderless star vehicle. In the race to populate the spy universe, screenwriters have compromised on substance, indulging in hero worship and flag-waving to pass the box office test. Yes, the trailer looks attractive, the stars shine bright, and the post-credit scenes are appetizing. However, when it comes to telling a story, the makers prove more successful in highlighting Kiara Advani's curves than in conveying the contours of the storyline. It features a variety of stunts with a script that appears to be powered by artificial intelligence. War 2 (Hindi) Director: Ayan Mukerji Cast: Hrithik Roshan, Jr NTR, Kiara Advani, Anil Kapoor, Ashutosh Rana Runtime: 170 minutes Storyline: Secret agent Kabir is accused of betraying the nation when he infiltrates a cartel, and his erstwhile mate Vikram is assigned the task of catching him Hrithik Roshan returns as Kabir, a secret agent like no other, who infiltrates a powerful global syndicate that wants to rule the world. The film feebly suggests that democracy is an outdated idea for the corporate villain. For a change, it promises to put Hrithik in a morally ambiguous space, but as the mood is jingoistic and the star wants to play safe, the not-so-secret sauce of the script is 'nation first'. ALSO READ: 'War' review: Astonishing action, slick screenplay and a killer Hrithik-Tiger bromance Soon, the narrative takes a straitjacketed, predictable path where the only obstacle in Kabir's way is agent Vikram. The two have a history, and as they take on each other, sparks fly. Jr NTR. makes a bombastic entry into Bollywood. He impresses with his screen presence and emotional depth, but he needs to work on his diction. The two jostle on land, air, and water to match the screen time, not realising that stunts too demand a script and parity in screen time paralyses the narrative. None of the stars seems to be interested in testing their image. So the writers contort the story to keep serving their purpose. While the gist of the story is 'nation before self,' the crux of this kind of filmmaking is 'star before story,' with makers prioritising fans over the audience. The story takes root in the second half, when we learn the backstory of Kabir and Vikram. One hails from the gentry, and the other comes from the road. Here is a passage where writers Shridhar Raghavan and Abbas Tyrewala make their presence felt, as an interesting battle of two points of view promises to unfold. However, the conflict remains cosmetic. It doesn't grow on us and gradually devolves into a mere rhetorical war of words. Hrithik tries to be a brooding Bond, but the writing doesn't give him enough emotional heft to translate his elasticity on the dance floor into the character's spine. He has been consistently eye-catching, but there is more to him than his larger-than-life persona, which needs to be tapped. In a short screen time, veteran Anil Kapoor shows how to look menacing and sound meaningful with hollow words. ALSO READ: Jr NTR-Prashanth Neel movie gets a release date You can see that a lot of money has been spent on choreographing action sequences in global tourist hotspots, but none of them have the intensity that could bring one to the edge of one's seat. Curiously, the camera cuts to Jr. NTR's face in the middle of the action, slowing down the sequence unnecessarily. The face-offs between Kabir and Vikram look like variants of a soft drink commercial, where the star would come up with a punchline about winning over your fear. It's cinema without fizz! War 2 is currently running in theatres.
Indian Express
an hour ago
- Indian Express
When Rakesh Roshan lauded his son Hrithik Roshan's sincerity, said he doesn't go to discos: ‘His first preference is work'
When Kaho Naa… Pyaar Hai hit the silver screen, Hrithik Roshan became the heartthrob of the nation almost overnight. His debut created waves across the country, making him a household name and setting a benchmark that few debutants have come close to matching. From his striking looks to his impeccable dancing skills and undeniable acting talent, Hrithik quickly became the complete package in the eyes of the audience. In an old interview with Lehren Retro, filmmaker Rakesh Roshan, Hrithik's father and the director of Kaho Naa… Pyaar Hai, opened up about what it was like working with a newcomer who also happened to be his son. Reflecting on the experience, Rakesh said, 'See, he is a newcomer, but when I was working with him, I never felt that. He was so full of energy and talent that, at no point, did I feel I was working with a newcomer. Whenever I used to go on set there never used to be this tension that I'm working with a newcomer, what will happen now… or whether he would be able to do this scene or not. Whatever I wanted, he gave me much more than that. And I'm not saying this because he is my son. But he is genuinely very talented.' Also Read | War 2 Movie Review: Hrithik Roshan, Jr NTR, Kiara Advani spy saga is so limp, you're left looking for zing In the same conversation, Rakesh Roshan also touched upon what he believes is Hrithik Roshan's greatest strength as an actor: 'I would say his sincerity. That is the biggest plus point. He considers work as his topmost priority. When he is working, you can see the character in the eyes, and that is very essential for an actor, a big achievement. If you are in the character, then half the battle is done. He is not a boy to go to discos, to take a car and drive down here and there. His first preference is work. He gets up in the morning and thinks about his work. Whatever he does, he takes it as a challenge. Even in school, he always wanted to come first in class and always stood first, even in college. That is in him. Whatever he does, he wants to do his best.' Kaho Naa… Pyaar Hai went on to become the biggest hit of the year and was ranked as the second highest-grossing Hindi film of 2000. The film won big at major award ceremonies, and Hrithik Roshan made history by winning both Best Actor and Best Male Debut at the Filmfare Awards. And, thus, began Hrithik's journey in the film industry.
