‘Troubling' courts service IT bug ‘extremely serious'
HMCTS said there is no evidence to suggest any case outcomes were affected as a result of the issues.
The bug was found in case-management software used by HMCTS and the Social Security and Child Support (SSCS) Tribunal, which handles benefit appeals, is thought to have been most affected, the BBC said.
Referred to as Judicial Case Manager, MyHMCTS or CCD, the BBC said the software is used to manage evidence and track cases, and is used by judges, lawyers, case workers and members of the public.
Documents seen by the BBC show the bug caused data to be obscured from view, meaning some evidence was sometimes not visible as part of case files used in court.
The BBC said a leaked internal report said HMCTS did not know the full extent of the data corruption, including whether or how it had affected cases.
Alex Chalk, former lord chancellor and former justice secretary, said what has happened is 'incredibly serious' and could have involved cases which determine whether a child is taken into care.
'So unbelievably serious. And, so the whistle blowers indicate, it could potentially have bled into other tribunals as well, whether it deals with divorce and so on.
'And the thing that is so troubling is that this report evidently got on to the desk of the senior leadership of HMCTS in March 2024 when I was in office, and it was never brought to my attention.
'And I am incredibly troubled by that, because any lord chancellor, of any stripe, if they discover that there's potentially a situation in the courts which is leading to injustice, then you will immediately want to investigate that, and yet in effect that was covered up and I'm afraid I think that is extremely serious,' Mr Chalk told BBC Radio 4's Today programme.
The BBC said several sources within HMCTS have likened the situation to the Horizon Post Office scandal.
Mr Chalk was asked on the Radio 4 Today programme if what has happened could be compared to the Post Office scandal, and he said: 'It could be.'
An HMCTS spokesperson said: 'Our internal investigation found no evidence that any case outcomes were affected as a result of these technical issues.
'The digitisation of our systems is vital to bring courts and tribunals into the modern era and provide quicker, simpler access to justice for all those who use our services.
'We will continue to press ahead with our important modernisation.'
It is understood that while the bug resulted in some documents not being accessible to users on the digital platform, they were in fact always present on the system.
It is also understood that because of a number of 'fail-safes', parties and judges involved in these cases always had access to the documents they needed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
3 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Strictly star calls in cops and almost quit show after crazed female stalker made ‘disgusting threats'
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) STRICTLY'S Chris Robshaw called in cops after being subjected to a terrifying campaign of harassment by a female stalker. Pals close to the England rugby legend said he had been targeted by the woman after briefly meeting her twice during work events last year, with the initial abuse starting six months after meeting him. Sign up for the Entertainment newsletter Sign up 4 Chris Robshaw, pictured with Camilla Kerslake, called in cops after being subjected to a terrifying campaign of harassment by a female stalker Credit: Paul Edwards 4 Pals said he had been targeted by the woman after briefly meeting her twice during work events last year Credit: Getty 4 The initial abuse started six months after meeting him, pictured playing for England Credit: Getty He called in police after the woman threatened him with violence and spread false allegations about him and other people he worked with. The woman, who The Sun is not naming, now appears on the National Police Wanted List. She is understood to have left the country and is being sought by cops. Those close to Chris, 39, who has two children with his wife, Opera singer Camilla Kerslake, said the BBC are aware of the ongoing issues and are supporting him. A friend said: 'Chris almost turned down Strictly because of what this woman has been putting him and his family through. 'She's made some disgusting threats. It has been awful for them. 'Chris and Camilla have been told by the police they're not alone. This woman has form for what she's been doing to them and has done it to other people too. 'Chris and Camilla are just the latest victims in a string of lives she's tried to destroy. 'He only went ahead with Strictly for his son Wilding. 'He told his dad: 'I want mummy to laugh at your dancing'. So Chris bit the bullet and went for it. Strictly Come Dancing 2025 lineup IN FULL - including Game of Thrones star & famous YouTuber 'He was honest with the BBC from the start and they've been amazing. 'They are supporting him and are aware of everything that is going on.' Chris, who retired from professional rugby in 2022, was announced as a contestant on Wednesday. He will appear on the show alongside stars including EastEnders actress Balvinda Sopal. Model Ellie Goldstein, footballer Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink and Love Island star Dani Dyer when the series begins next month. Those close to him revealed his ordeal started last July when he attended the same event as the woman. It's been absolutely terrible for Chris and Camilla. He met this woman twice, very briefly, during work events and then she started telling all sorts of awful lies about him Sun source She went on to make a series of disturbing and damning allegations about Chris and his wife Camilla, 39, as well as other people she worked with. A source said: 'It's been absolutely terrible for Chris and Camilla. 'He met this woman twice, very briefly, during work events and then she started telling all sorts of awful lies about him. 'He was never alone with her and they barely spoke so he's got no idea why she targeted him. 'The stuff she was coming up with was farcical. She then started calling companies Chris and Camilla were working with to tell them these made up lies. She is intent on trying to ruin Chris and Camilla's life. Her other victims are said to have struggled professionally, financially, and mentally. 'Chris warned police the minute his children were put into danger. This woman posted their address online and made really nasty threats against him and his family.' Chris warned police the minute his children were put into danger. This woman posted their address online and made really nasty threats against him and his family Sun source Chris, pals said, later learned that the woman was known to police. A source added: 'It's deeply frightening that no one has been able to stop her, she's fled the country, and has been clever to avoid arrest. 'They've been advised by their case officer that the minute this woman steps back onto UK soil, she will be arrested.' The Sun understands the woman was arrested in December and released with a caution. But those close to Chris said her harassment has continued and that the woman has now left the country. A friend added: 'Chris and Camilla feel sorry for this woman as something clearly isn't right. 4 Chris later learned that the woman was known to police Credit: ITV 'They tried to ignore it for as long as they could but when it turned nasty and they felt threatened, they rightly told the police. Chris will always protect his family. 'It has been incredibly concerning for them. 'Her behaviour has been terrifying at times and they have spent time looking over their shoulders.' Those close to Camilla and Chris said they believed the woman was trying to target Camilla too, despite never meeting her. A source added: 'Camilla feels this woman is intent on trying to ruin her life too. 'Only recently, she auditioned for a huge show, and this woman managed to find out about it. Chris and Camilla feel sorry for this woman as something clearly isn't right A friend 'Camilla was told that she had messaged those working at the company, to spread more false and damaging claims. 'What she is saying about Camilla and Chris is stomach churning. 'They're normally so strong but it pushed them into utter devastation. 'Their friends and family are rallying around them as they know how exhausting and upsetting it has been for them. The Sun understands the BBC have worked with Chris to ensure his safety at all times. A source added: 'Chris hates a fuss and never wants to put anyone out but he's grateful to how amazing the BBC have been with all of this. 'He wants to crack on with the competition and give it his best shot. 'Chris is doing this for his kids and just wants to make them proud.' A spokesperson for Chris said: 'This is an ongoing police investigation, and therefore we are unable to comment at this time. 'Chris will not be commenting further.'
The Sun
4 minutes ago
- The Sun
Strictly star calls in cops and almost quit show after crazed female stalker made ‘disgusting threats'
STRICTLY'S Chris Robshaw called in cops after being subjected to a terrifying campaign of harassment by a female stalker. Pals close to the England rugby legend said he had been targeted by the woman after briefly meeting her twice during work events last year, with the initial abuse starting six months after meeting him. 4 4 4 He called in police after the woman threatened him with violence and spread false allegations about him and other people he worked with. The woman, who The Sun is not naming, now appears on the National Police Wanted List. She is understood to have left the country and is being sought by cops. Those close to Chris, 39, who has two children with his wife, Opera singer Camilla Kerslake, said the BBC are aware of the ongoing issues and are supporting him. A friend said: 'Chris almost turned down Strictly because of what this woman has been putting him and his family through. 'She's made some disgusting threats. It has been awful for them. 'Chris and Camilla have been told by the police they're not alone. This woman has form for what she's been doing to them and has done it to other people too. 'Chris and Camilla are just the latest victims in a string of lives she's tried to destroy. 'He only went ahead with Strictly for his son Wilding. 'He told his dad: 'I want mummy to laugh at your dancing'. So Chris bit the bullet and went for it. 'He was honest with the BBC from the start and they've been amazing. 'They are supporting him and are aware of everything that is going on.' Chris, who retired from professional rugby in 2022, was announced as a contestant on Wednesday. He will appear on the show alongside stars including EastEnders actress Balvinda Sopal. Model Ellie Goldstein, footballer Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink and Love Island star Dani Dyer when the series begins next month. Those close to him revealed his ordeal started last July when he attended the same event as the woman. It's been absolutely terrible for Chris and Camilla. He met this woman twice, very briefly, during work events and then she started telling all sorts of awful lies about him Sun source She went on to make a series of disturbing and damning allegations about Chris and his wife Camilla, 39, as well as other people she worked with. A source said: 'It's been absolutely terrible for Chris and Camilla. 'He met this woman twice, very briefly, during work events and then she started telling all sorts of awful lies about him. 'He was never alone with her and they barely spoke so he's got no idea why she targeted him. 'The stuff she was coming up with was farcical. She then started calling companies Chris and Camilla were working with to tell them these made up lies. She is intent on trying to ruin Chris and Camilla's life. Her other victims are said to have struggled professionally, financially, and mentally. 'Chris warned police the minute his children were put into danger. This woman posted their address online and made really nasty threats against him and his family.' Chris warned police the minute his children were put into danger. This woman posted their address online and made really nasty threats against him and his family Sun source Chris, pals said, later learned that the woman was known to police. A source added: 'It's deeply frightening that no one has been able to stop her, she's fled the country, and has been clever to avoid arrest. 'They've been advised by their case officer that the minute this woman steps back onto UK soil, she will be arrested.' The Sun understands the woman was arrested in December and released with a caution. But those close to Chris said her harassment has continued and that the woman has now left the country. A friend added: 'Chris and Camilla feel sorry for this woman as something clearly isn't right. 'They tried to ignore it for as long as they could but when it turned nasty and they felt threatened, they rightly told the police. Chris will always protect his family. 'It has been incredibly concerning for them. 'Her behaviour has been terrifying at times and they have spent time looking over their shoulders.' Those close to Camilla and Chris said they believed the woman was trying to target Camilla too, despite never meeting her. A source added: 'Camilla feels this woman is intent on trying to ruin her life too. 'Only recently, she auditioned for a huge show, and this woman managed to find out about it. 'Camilla was told that she had messaged those working at the company, to spread more false and damaging claims. 'What she is saying about Camilla and Chris is stomach churning. 'They're normally so strong but it pushed them into utter devastation. 'Their friends and family are rallying around them as they know how exhausting and upsetting it has been for them. The Sun understands the BBC have worked with Chris to ensure his safety at all times. A source added: 'Chris hates a fuss and never wants to put anyone out but he's grateful to how amazing the BBC have been with all of this. 'He wants to crack on with the competition and give it his best shot. 'Chris is doing this for his kids and just wants to make them proud.' A spokesperson for Chris said: 'This is an ongoing police investigation, and therefore we are unable to comment at this time. 'Chris will not be commenting further.'
Daily Mail
4 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Normal People author Sally Rooney vows to use her BBC royalties to fund terror group Palestine Action
Novelist Sally Rooney has vowed to fund the proscribed terror group Palestine Action. The Normal People author said she would donate earnings from her books and BBC adaptations to the organisation, adding: 'If this makes me a 'supporter of terror' under UK law, so be it.' Funding terrorism carries up to 14 years' imprisonment under the Terrorism Act 2000 – the same piece of legislation used to ban Palestine Action last month. Ms Rooney, 34, wrote in an article for The Irish Times: 'My books, at least for now, are still published in Britain, and are widely available in bookshops and even supermarkets. 'In recent years the UK's state broadcaster has also televised two fine adaptations of my novels, and therefore regularly pays me residual fees. 'I want to be clear that I intend to use these proceeds of my work, as well as my public platform generally, to go on supporting Palestine Action and direct action against genocide in whatever way I can. 'If the British state considers this 'terrorism', then perhaps it should investigate the shady organisations that continue to promote my work and fund my activities, such as WHSmith and the BBC.' The Irish writer added that 'to ensure the British public is made aware of my position, I would happily publish this statement in a UK newspaper – but that would now be illegal'. The BBC adaptation of Normal People, starring Daisy Edgar-Jones and Paul Mescal, was one of the corporation's biggest hits of 2020, and it has also adapted Ms Rooney's book Conversations With Friends. Palestine Action was banned last month after it admitted breaking into RAF Brize Norton in June, when £7 million of damage was caused to two Voyager aircraft. The action, approved by both Houses of Parliament, made it a proscribed organisation, meaning it is now a crime to offer it support or be a member. Ms Rooney was referred to during a hearing at the High Court in London last month, when the co-founder of Palestine Action, Huda Ammori, unsuccessfully sought to block the proscription. Blinne Ni Ghralaigh KC, representing Ms Ammori, told the court the ban would create 'far-reaching' harm and cause people to 'self-censor'. She said that Ms Rooney 'fears the ramifications for her, for her work, for her books, for her programmes' if she showed support for Palestine Action. Ms Ni Ghralaigh asked: 'Is the Prime Minister going to denounce her, an Irish artist, as a supporter of a proscribed organisation? Will that have ramifications for her with the BBC?' More than 700 people have been arrested since the ban came into force, including hundreds who held up placards which read 'I oppose genocide. I support Palestine Action' at a demonstration in Parliament Square on August 9. The Metropolitan Police said on Friday a further 60 people will be prosecuted for supporting Palestine Action, in addition to three charges announced previously in relation to a protest on July 5. And on Saturday, Norfolk Police said 13 people were arrested at a protest in Norwich. It comes after Sir Jonathon Porritt, a former environmental adviser to the King, last week condemned the ban on Palestine Action as 'absolutely standard authoritarian tactics'.
