logo
Penalty burden eases on private university that built campus illegally in Aravalis

Penalty burden eases on private university that built campus illegally in Aravalis

Time of India14-07-2025
Gurgaon: The penalty on a private university for using over 13 hectares of protected forest land in Faridabad without full permission is likely to come down sharply after the Centre decided to apply its new, relaxed rules in the case.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
The Aravali land, located along the Badkhal-Surajkund Road, was protected under Punjab Land Preservation Act (PLPA), 1900. The university — Manav Rachna International Institute of Research and Studies (MRIIRS) — used this land for construction before getting prior clearance, as mandated, under the Forest Conservation Act, 1980. But after the FCA was amended in 2023, the campus became among the first to get post facto approval.
During a meeting on June 12, the Union environment ministry's advisory committee recommended applying the 2023 forest rules for calculating the fine, replacing the stricter 2019 guidelines. Under the 2019 guidelines, the penal Net Present Value (NPV) — a form of financial compensation — was calculated from the actual date the forest land was used, with an additional 12% simple interest for each year of violation until payment was made.
This meant that if an agency began using the land without formal clearance in 2019, it would incur a penalty for each subsequent year, significantly increasing the financial burden.
However, under the revised 2023 guidelines, the Union environment ministry introduced a key change — penal interest would now be applied only from the date the penalty demand was officially raised, not from the date of the original violation.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
This adjustment substantially reduces the total payable amount in delayed cases.
After this change was implemented, the Haryana govt sought clarification from the Centre on which set of rules should apply to the Manav Rachna forest diversion case, where the land was used before final approvals were granted.
The state govt specifically enquired if the stricter 2019 rules or more lenient 2023 norms should govern the calculation of the penal NPV — a decision with financial implications.
This query was a focal point in the June 2025 meeting of the forest advisory committee, where the ministry reaffirmed its Nov 2024 clarification in favour of applying the 2023 norms.
Approval & penalty reduction:
The Centre had granted in-principle approval for the land diversion on Dec 29, 2023, but also flagged that the university violated forest norms by starting work prematurely. The main query was how much the varsity should pay as a penalty (NPV) for using forest land without permission.
This recommendation was made because construction of the university began in 1991, well before the 1996 cut-off date. Last year, Parliament revised the Forest Conservation Act (FCA), stating if construction occurred prior to Dec 12, 1996, the Act would not be applicable.
Under the 2019 rules, the penalty would have been calculated from the year the land was first used — potentially as early as 2019 or 2020 — and would include 12% annual interest, resulting in a total fine of approximately ₹20 crore.
However, under the new 2023 rules, interest is counted only from the date the fine was officially demanded, reducing the fine by 2.5 times — around 60% less than what the institute would have paid earlier.
Activists flag green concerns:
While the move provides relief to the university, it has raised concerns among environmental activists. They argued that it could encourage more illegal use of protected land, particularly in fragile zones like Aravalis.
Former forest conservator (south Haryana) RP Balwan criticised the decision, stating it violates the Supreme Court orders from 2008 and 2019, which prohibit construction in the Aravalis. "The Centre, too, has acknowledged the protected status of Aravali land earlier.
In 2008 and 2009, reports by the Central Empowered Committee (CEC), which guides the govt on key decisions, said the entire Aravali region of Gurgaon and Faridabad are prohibited zones under FCA and construction can only be allowed to install power lines and build village link roads.
So, entertaining the FCA case is wrong, forget about reducing penalties," said Balwan.
Activists also said reducing the penalty by 2.5 times sends a message that violations can be rectified with money, weakening forest land protection. Chetan Agarwal, a forest analyst, said, "The land in question is village Shamlat common land that appears to have been dubiously privatised. The govt should restore the land to the gram panchayat or Faridabad corporation in line with SC judgments in Jagpal Singh v.
State of Punjab (2012) and Jai Singh v.
State of Haryana (2022) and take possession of the buildings in public interest." He proposed that any forest clearance granted to Manav Rachna University should be provisional, subject to the outcome of ongoing or future ownership cases.
What's next?
Before receiving the final clearance, the university must fulfil several conditions. It should plant trees on an equivalent area of non-forest land (14ha), repair damage on 0.19 ha of encroached land, properly mark the diverted land with boundary pillars and comply with the Forest Rights Act and Environment Protection Act. Till these requirements aren't met, the land cannot be legally transferred to the varsity.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Centre's move for coal plants to hit environment: Think tank
Centre's move for coal plants to hit environment: Think tank

Time of India

time21 minutes ago

  • Time of India

Centre's move for coal plants to hit environment: Think tank

1 2 Ranchi: The Union ministry of environment, forest and climate change (MoEFCC)'s decision to exempt nearly 78% of India's thermal power plants (TPPs) from installing 'flue gas desulphurisation' (FGD) system would further wreak with the air quality of Jharkhand, where the power plants are thermal based. This was stated by the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air (CREA), an independent research body. Earlier this month, MoEFCC announced its move to exempt FGD installation for 'Category C' power plants. These plants are not located within 10 km radius of critically polluted areas (CPAs) or non-attainment cities. 'Category B' plants will be assessed on a case-to-case basis by the environmental appraisal committee while 2027 deadline for 'Category A' stays in place. CREA senior analyst Manoj Kumar said, "We have studied this decision's impact on all states with coal. Jharkhand would face the worst problems as it has 13 thermal power units, totaling 4,250 MW. All these units fall under 'Category C'. Of the 13 power plants, only two owned by the Central sector has installed FGD system." The govt's move to exempt FGD installation for 'Category C' plantsm despite proven benefits in reducing sulfur dioxide (SO₂), PM 2.5, and mercury emissions, and producing reusable gypsum for the cement industry, are unwarranted. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like No annual fees for life UnionBank Credit Card Apply Now Undo "India is the world's largest emitter of SO₂, contributing nearly 20% of global anthropogenic SO₂ emissions. Coal-fired power plants account for 60% of India's SO₂ output, as they burn 70% of the country's coal. Emission norms introduced in 2015 mandated the use of FGD systems to cut SO₂ emissions from power plants, but a July 2025 notification has diluted these requirements," it added. Citing health impacts, it noted that power plants are responsible for up to 2,200 premature deaths annually in Jharkhand during 2018. "Studies show PM2.5 from power plants is twice as toxic as that from other sources," it said. An official at the Jharkhand State Pollution Control Board said, "We don't have much role to play in the policy changes made by the Union govt. We will ensure compliance of all the prescribed norms to arrest all kinds of pollution." CREA further said that air quality in Jharkhand is already under stress. "IIT Delhi assessed the impact of power plants in all airsheds of India and found that 3-8 % is contributed by power plants in Jharkhand airsheds. Further, IIT Bombay assessed at city level and found that 4 to 24 % of PM2.5 is from the power sector in the Ranchi, Jamshedpur and Dhanbad cities. All these three cities are under the National Clean Air Programme (NCAP). Exempting compliance will further delay the achievement of up to 40% reduction in pollution levels in NCAP cities," it said.

Residents urge CM to halt PMRDA's auction of amenity plots, demand land be used for civic purposes
Residents urge CM to halt PMRDA's auction of amenity plots, demand land be used for civic purposes

Time of India

timean hour ago

  • Time of India

Residents urge CM to halt PMRDA's auction of amenity plots, demand land be used for civic purposes

1 2 Pune: Citizen groups from Hinjewadi–Maan–Marunji region have urged chief minister Devendra Fadnavis to stop auctioning of 35 public amenity plots in their area by PMRDA. They said if these plots are auctioned it would deprive over 1.5 lakh residents of essential infrastructure. In their representation to Fadnavis, who also chairs Pune Metropolitan Region Development Authority (PMRDA), the Hinjewadi Residents Welfare Association (HRWA) and Hinjewadi Employees and Residents Trust (HERT) have demanded a complete halt to the auction. They have called for an investigation into past allotments, citing possible violation of planning laws. You Can Also Check: Pune AQI | Weather in Pune | Bank Holidays in Pune | Public Holidays in Pune "These are not surplus plots — they are needed for setting up water supply system, substations, public gardens, parking, health centres, schools, ITIs, police chowkis etc," said Ravindra Sinha from HRWA. "If these lands go to private developers, where will such facilities come up?" Dnyanendra Hulsure from HERT said they are hoping that the CM would intervene as chairman of PMRDA and issue necessary orders staying the auction process for these crucial public lands. "The decision to hand over prime public lands is deeply concerning and detrimental to the welfare of the community,'' said Hulsure. The groups alleged that PMRDA's auction process has bypassed the participatory planning mandated by Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning (MRTP) Act and Urban and Regional Development Plans Formulation and Implementation (URDPFI) Guidelines. These guidelines designate amenity plots as "deemed reservations" meant to serve the public and decided through community consultation. PMRDA has announced e-auction of 35 plots across Mulshi, Maval, Haveli, and Khed, with a total base value of ₹91 crore. Earnest money deposits for the plots range from ₹84,000 to ₹25 lakh. PMRDA officials said the process is in line with the Unified Development Control and Promotion Regulations (UDCPR), and some plots are reserved for public libraries and music schools. "All planning authorities auction amenity spaces to generate revenue, often at rates below the market value. Reservations are marked and the space will be auctioned as per the reservation," a senior PMRDA official said, adding that 32 such plots were auctioned earlier as well. "This is not just about compliance — it's about priorities. Should essential public land be sold off for commercial use?" said one of the residents. The groups have been writing to various authorities since 2021 to stop auctioning of amenity plots.

ORERA notifies formation of CDR cell for resolving disputes
ORERA notifies formation of CDR cell for resolving disputes

Time of India

timean hour ago

  • Time of India

ORERA notifies formation of CDR cell for resolving disputes

Bhubaneswar: Odisha Real Estate Regulatory Authority (ORERA) has notified the formation of a Conciliation and Dispute Resolution (CDR) cell at its office here. The CDR cell will be a platform for distressed homebuyers and promoters to amicably resolve disputes, thus, saving both parties from entering any further legal battles. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now ORERA made a similar attempt in Jan last year, but the cell couldn't become operational as it lacked govt approval. This time ORERA notified the cell after approval of the housing and urban development department. "In accordance with the provisions under Section 32 (g) of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, a conciliation and dispute resolution cell has been constituted in ORERA with the approval of the housing and urban development department," read the ORERA notice. As per the notice, the cell has five members who will hear the cases brought by the promoters and allottees. The secretary of ORERA will be the primary member in the cell, followed by the joint secretary of finance in ORERA and the consultant in the legal cell of the real estate body. The cell will also have a representative from a developers' association and another from an allottee's association. "To nominate a representative from a registered association of allottees, all interested associations registered under the Odisha Apartment (Ownership and Management) Act, 2023 and Rules, 2024 are hereby invited to nominate one suitable member from their association," the notice reads. All registered associations have been asked to submit their nominations by July 30, 2025. ORERA has also shared a format according to which the associations of allottees will submit their nominations. "This is a step in the right direction. Such a CDR cell will help save a lot of time and resources for both buyers and sellers. People should know about the cell so that they are benefitted from it," Subash Jena, a real estate analyst, said.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store