
Penalty burden eases on private university that built campus illegally in Aravalis
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
The Aravali land, located along the Badkhal-Surajkund Road, was protected under Punjab Land Preservation Act (PLPA), 1900. The university — Manav Rachna International Institute of Research and Studies (MRIIRS) — used this land for construction before getting prior clearance, as mandated, under the Forest Conservation Act, 1980. But after the FCA was amended in 2023, the campus became among the first to get post facto approval.
During a meeting on June 12, the Union environment ministry's advisory committee recommended applying the 2023 forest rules for calculating the fine, replacing the stricter 2019 guidelines. Under the 2019 guidelines, the penal Net Present Value (NPV) — a form of financial compensation — was calculated from the actual date the forest land was used, with an additional 12% simple interest for each year of violation until payment was made.
This meant that if an agency began using the land without formal clearance in 2019, it would incur a penalty for each subsequent year, significantly increasing the financial burden.
However, under the revised 2023 guidelines, the Union environment ministry introduced a key change — penal interest would now be applied only from the date the penalty demand was officially raised, not from the date of the original violation.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
This adjustment substantially reduces the total payable amount in delayed cases.
After this change was implemented, the Haryana govt sought clarification from the Centre on which set of rules should apply to the Manav Rachna forest diversion case, where the land was used before final approvals were granted.
The state govt specifically enquired if the stricter 2019 rules or more lenient 2023 norms should govern the calculation of the penal NPV — a decision with financial implications.
This query was a focal point in the June 2025 meeting of the forest advisory committee, where the ministry reaffirmed its Nov 2024 clarification in favour of applying the 2023 norms.
Approval & penalty reduction:
The Centre had granted in-principle approval for the land diversion on Dec 29, 2023, but also flagged that the university violated forest norms by starting work prematurely. The main query was how much the varsity should pay as a penalty (NPV) for using forest land without permission.
This recommendation was made because construction of the university began in 1991, well before the 1996 cut-off date. Last year, Parliament revised the Forest Conservation Act (FCA), stating if construction occurred prior to Dec 12, 1996, the Act would not be applicable.
Under the 2019 rules, the penalty would have been calculated from the year the land was first used — potentially as early as 2019 or 2020 — and would include 12% annual interest, resulting in a total fine of approximately ₹20 crore.
However, under the new 2023 rules, interest is counted only from the date the fine was officially demanded, reducing the fine by 2.5 times — around 60% less than what the institute would have paid earlier.
Activists flag green concerns:
While the move provides relief to the university, it has raised concerns among environmental activists. They argued that it could encourage more illegal use of protected land, particularly in fragile zones like Aravalis.
Former forest conservator (south Haryana) RP Balwan criticised the decision, stating it violates the Supreme Court orders from 2008 and 2019, which prohibit construction in the Aravalis. "The Centre, too, has acknowledged the protected status of Aravali land earlier.
In 2008 and 2009, reports by the Central Empowered Committee (CEC), which guides the govt on key decisions, said the entire Aravali region of Gurgaon and Faridabad are prohibited zones under FCA and construction can only be allowed to install power lines and build village link roads.
So, entertaining the FCA case is wrong, forget about reducing penalties," said Balwan.
Activists also said reducing the penalty by 2.5 times sends a message that violations can be rectified with money, weakening forest land protection. Chetan Agarwal, a forest analyst, said, "The land in question is village Shamlat common land that appears to have been dubiously privatised. The govt should restore the land to the gram panchayat or Faridabad corporation in line with SC judgments in Jagpal Singh v.
State of Punjab (2012) and Jai Singh v.
State of Haryana (2022) and take possession of the buildings in public interest." He proposed that any forest clearance granted to Manav Rachna University should be provisional, subject to the outcome of ongoing or future ownership cases.
What's next?
Before receiving the final clearance, the university must fulfil several conditions. It should plant trees on an equivalent area of non-forest land (14ha), repair damage on 0.19 ha of encroached land, properly mark the diverted land with boundary pillars and comply with the Forest Rights Act and Environment Protection Act. Till these requirements aren't met, the land cannot be legally transferred to the varsity.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Mint
an hour ago
- Mint
The week in charts: GDP projections, Centre's financial discrepancy
Amid global uncertainty and weak domestic demand, agencies are downgrading India's gross domestic product (GDP) growth for 2025-26. Meanwhile, a report by the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) has found discrepancies in the Centre's financials, and Jagdeep Dhankhar resigned as vice president of India. Growth downgrade The Asian Development Bank (ADB) has released its latest estimates for India's GDP projection, lowering the growth forecast for 2025-26 to 6.5% from its earlier estimate of 6.7% given in April. The downward revision reflects the negative impact of US tariff policies and a weakened demand and investment climate. India Ratings and Research has lowered its projections even lower to 6.3%, cutting 30 basis points from an earlier estimate. With this, GDP growth is estimated to be 6.2-6.5% in 2025-26 by all major agencies. Export dependency India exported electronic goods worth $40.9 billion in 2024-25, but imported $102.6 billion, making it a net importer by a huge margin. AMintanalysis of trade data shows that electronics exports are highly concentrated, with the US accounting for 37.3% of total exports, dramatically up from about 14% in 2010-11. Other top destinations include the UAE, Netherlands, UK, and Italy, but their shares remain modest at 4.8-9% in 2024-25, showing little growth over the past 15 years despite India's export push. Fiscal conundrum ₹21.3 trillion: That is the unrealized tax revenue for 2022-23, marking an increase of ₹5.47 trillion from the previous year,Mintreported, quoting the latest CAG report presented in Parliament. The audit report highlights gaps in transparency and data consistency regarding compliance with the Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management (FRBM) Act. The report noted that there was a discrepancy of ₹18,000 crore in the fiscal deficit figure between Union government finance accounts (UGFA) for 2022-23 and the budget at a glance (BAG) for 2024-25. Sudden resignation In the midst of the ongoing monsoon session, vice president Jagdeep Dhankhar tendered his resignation to the President, citing health reasons, cutting short his term scheduled to end in August 2027. He was the 14th sitting vice president of India and also served as the chairman of the upper house of Parliament. With the sudden resignation, Dhankhar has become one of three vice presidents to quit mid-term. With a tenure of two years and 344 days, his presidency is also the third shortest in the history of independent India. Investor sell-off After three months of fund inflow, foreign investors turned net sellers for most of July due to US-India trade tensions and mixed corporate financial results, PTI reported. According to the latest NSDL data, foreign portfolio investors (FPIs) pulled out ₹4,508 crore from equities this month (until 24 July). This follows net inflow of ₹14,590 crore in June, ₹19,860 crore in May, and ₹4,223 crore in April. Earlier, FPIs withdrew ₹3,973 crore in March, ₹34,574 crore in February, and ₹78,027 crore in January. Domestic driven ₹60,681 crore: That is the forex savings from nearly 8% year-on-year decline in coal imports during 2024-25, the coal ministry said this week. India imported 243.62 million tonnes of coal in 2024-25, down from 264.53 million tonnes in 2023-24, which resulted in a reduction in forex savings, coal and mines minister G. Kishan Reddy said. This decline in imports comes amid rising domestic coal production, which increased 5% to 1.05 billion tonnes in 2024-25. Cost advantage Indian companies overcame persistent weakness in demand as profits surged at the fastest pace in at least five quarters during the June quarter, driven by falling raw material costs, showed a Mint analysis. Among 182 companies that declared their first quarter results of 2025-26, aggregate revenue rose 5.4% year-on-year, but net profits jumped 23% as raw material costs declined 14% over the year—the steepest drop in eight quarters. Excluding BFSI companies, net profits soared nearly 40% from the previous year. Chart of the week: Digital revolution Mobile phones have emerged as the growing investment tool for retail investors, accounting for over a quarter of all monthly transactions since April 2024, according to BSE data. This represents a dramatic surge from just 5% in June 2019 and 10% in June 2020, with mobile trading peaking at nearly 29% in May 2025. Follow our data stories on the'In Charts" and'Plain Facts" pages on


Hans India
an hour ago
- Hans India
Govt to invite tenders for Vij, Visakha Metro today
Vijayawada: In a significant step towards boosting urban transportation infrastructure, the state government is all set to initiate work on the Vijayawada and Visakhapatnam Metro Rail Projects, with the formal tender process scheduled to begin on Friday. According to official sources, the first phase of the Vijayawada Metro Rail Project is estimated to cost Rs 10,118 crore, while the Visakhapatnam Metro Rail project is projected at Rs 11,498 crore. These high-value tenders will mark a crucial step in realising long-pending metro ambitions in the two key cities of the state. The metro rail projects are jointly funded by the Centre and the state government, under the public-private partnership (PPP) and viability gap funding (VGF) models. The Centre is expected to extend financial support under the Metro Rail Policy 2017, which encourages state governments to plan urban mass transit systems based on economic feasibility and sustainable urban development. As part of its financial commitment, the Capital Region Development Authority (CRDA) will allocate Rs 3,497 crore for the Vijayawada metro, while the Visakhapatnam Metropolitan Region Development Authority (VMRDA) will contribute Rs 4,101 crore for the Visakhapatnam metro. The Vijayawada metro, originally proposed during the bifurcation of Andhra Pradesh, is intended to decongest city traffic and improve connectivity in the rapidly urbanising Amaravati capital region. The first phase is likely to cover around 26 kilometers, connecting key city nodes including the Pandit Nehru Bus Station (PNBS), Vijayawada Railway Station, and surrounding urban clusters. On the other hand, the Visakhapatnam metro project, planned in three corridors spanning a total of 76.9 kilometers, aims to integrate the city's industrial, educational, and coastal belts. The first phase will cover the 28-kilometre stretch from Steel Plant to Kommadi, passing through heavily populated urban areas and key junctions like Gajuwaka, NAD Junction, and Maddilapalem.


Hans India
an hour ago
- Hans India
India, UK ink historic FTA
London: India and the UK on Thursday inked a landmark free trade agreement that seeks to boost both the economies, slash tariff lines across 99 per cent of Indian exports, unlock thousands of jobs and cut tariffs on British whisky, cars and an array of other items. The pact, officially named as the Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA), was signed by Union Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal and British Trade Secretary Jonathan Reynolds in the presence of the prime ministers of India and the UK. The mega deal was formalised shortly after British PM Keir Starmer hosted his Indian counterpart Narendra Modi at Chequers, the countryside residence of the British PM that is located 50 kms northwest of London. The CETA, firmed up after three years of negotiations, is expected to ensure comprehensive market access for Indian goods across all sectors and India will gain from tariff elimination on about 99 per cent of tariff lines (product categories) covering almost 100 per cent of the trade values, officials said. "I'm really pleased and privileged to welcome you here today on what I consider to be a historic day for both of our countries, and the delivery of the commitment that we made to each other," said Starmer, as he greeted PM Modi. In his remarks to the media, Modi said the UK and India are "natural partners" and said the nations were "writing a new chapter" in their history. He highlighted Indian textiles, footwear, gems and jewellery, seafood and engineering goods will get better market access in the UK, with agricultural products and processed food industry winning new opportunities for growth following the trade deal. "This agreement will prove especially beneficial for India's youth, farmers, fishermen and MSME sector. On the other hand, people and industries in India will be able to access products made in the UK such as medical devices and aerospace parts at affordable and attractive prices," Modi said. "Along with this agreement, we have also reached a consensus on the Double Contributions Convention (DCC). This will inject new energy into the services sectors of both countries, especially in technology and finance. It will promote ease of doing business, reduce cost of doing business and increase the confidence of doing business," Modi said.