Parties in PA yet to deliver on promises
It has been over a year since the general elections were held in the country. In Sindh, the Pakistan People's Party (PPP), Muttahida Qaumi Movement Pakistan (MQM-P), Jamaat-e-Islami (JI), and Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) presented their manifestos, in which promises were made to the people, including solutions to their problems. After the elections, the PPP came to power in Sindh.
Parliamentary analysts claim that despite receiving salaries and benefits, public representatives in the Sindh Assembly are not playing an active role in solving public problems. Instead, analysts are of the opinion that the government and the opposition will have to play a comprehensive and coordinated role in solving public problems, instead of blaming each other.
Express compiled a report on the manifestos of political parties and the performance of members of the Sindh Assembly. Dr Nasreen Aslam Shah, a former professor of the Department of Social Work at the University of Karachi, said that political parties present their manifestos in every general election, and those held on February 8, 2024, saw the PML-N and its allied parties forming the government at the center, the PPP forming the provincial government in Sindh, and the people electing members of the Sindh Assembly with their votes. However, if the manifestos of the members of the Sindh Assembly and parliamentary parties are reviewed in general, most political analysts believe that the people will not be satisfied with their performance.
Dr Shah stated that the members of the Sindh Assembly belonging to the opposition need to raise a unified voice in the assembly to solve public problems because they can convey the voice of the people to the rulers, while the members of the ruling party should also further strengthen their role in this regard, as the people are not interested in politics but in solving their problems. Hence, the PPP will have to take more steps to fulfill its promises, while the opposition needs to be more politically active to solve public problems.
According to the Sindh Assembly website, the total number of members is 168, including 117 from the PPP, 37 from the MQM-P, 9 independent members supported by the PTI and one member from JI. The number of members supported by the PTI is likely to increase due to the change in reserved seats after the Supreme Court's decision. Further, assembly members receive a monthly salary of Rs153,000 including allowances, while a daily travel allowance of Rs2,000 is also given during the session. The total annual salary expenditure is Rs300 million. However, according to analysts, the salaries of members of the Sindh Assembly remain lower than those of other provinces.
Further, senior journalist and parliamentary analyst, Muniruddin, said that the manifesto of parliamentary parties remained of utmost importance in past elections as the election campaign was run on the basis of this manifesto, but the manifesto had become a mere ritual in the general elections held from 2008 to 2024. The election campaign in 2024 was not based on the manifesto but on accusations.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
7 hours ago
- Express Tribune
NA Budget Debate sees tensions flare between PPP and MQM
Listen to article The debate on Pakistan's proposed budget for the upcoming fiscal year in the National Assembly intensified on Tuesday as tensions flared between Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) and (Muttahida Qaumi Movement) MQM members. PPP's Shazia Marri, in her address, called criticised the government's failure to announce minimum wages for workers and called for a reasonable increase in government employees' salaries. Her speech took a unexpected turn when a heated exchange broke out between PPP and MQM members, escalating tensions in the assembly. As Shazia stressed the importance of Karachi remaining an integral part of Sindh, MQM's Asiya Ishaq approached PPP members, leading to an intervention by Aseefa Bhutto, Sahar Kamran, and others. Read: Budget: will it power tech economy or stall its promise? This led to a tense exchange of harsh words between both parties. Javed Hanif remarked, "You people have abandoned Karachi, and now you threaten us." Meanhile Shazia also condemned the Israeli attacks on Iran, as well as Israel's aggression against Palestinians and India's actions. She also praised the Iranian Parliament for expressing gratitude towards Pakistan. She highlighted the Prime Minister's decision to send a delegation abroad, which was led by Bilawal Bhutto. She lauded Bilawal Bhutto for effectively representing Pakistan on the global stage, stating, "Bilawal Bhutto has fought Pakistan's case everywhere, and his success is our success. Bilawal has made us all proud." Shazia Marri also criticised the government for failing to address rising inflation and not announcing a minimum wage in the budget. She acknowledged that PPP had raised salaries but pointed out the government's internal divisions over the budget. She strongly opposed the 18% tax on solar panels, calling it unacceptable and stating that PPP does not support it. Lastly, she remarked on the opposition government's performance, saying, "Everyone has witnessed the government of this opposition. You have taken the highest amount of loans in history." Read more: Essential items' prices soar after federal budget Mian Khan Bugti, belonging to the Pakistan Muslims League - Nawaz (PML-N) commended the government for allocating Rs 250 billion for the development of Balochistan, highlighting the focus on vital connectivity projects in the province. Syed Amin-ul-Haque pointed to positive economic indicators, such as a reduction in inflation and growth in foreign exchange reserves and remittances. He noted that global financial institutions are recognizing the country's economic recovery. Shahida Begum raised concerns over the inadequacy of the budget for education and healthcare, urging the government to increase allocations for these sectors to 4% of GDP. Read more: Teachers decry budget, demand upgrades Ibrar Ahmed, in his speech, declared the budget as people-friendly, stating that it outlines a vision for national development. Engineer Amir Muqam, Minister for Kashmir Affairs and Gilgit-Baltistan, highlighted the relief provided to employees and the public in the budget. Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) Chairman Barrister Gohar Ali Khan emphasised the need for innovative solutions to help the people and proposed tax exemptions for employees earning up to Rs 2.2 million annually. Syed Hussain Tariq stressed the importance of supporting the agriculture sector to ensure food security for the country. Other members also shared their perspectives on the budget. Mian Khan Bugti praised the allocation of Rs 250 billion for Balochistan's development, with a focus on essential connectivity projects in the province.
Express Tribune
20 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Education, health get big boost
Punjab Finance Minister Mian Mujtaba Shujaur Rehman on Monday presented a Rs5,335 billion surplus budget for financial year 2025-26 in the provincial assembly amid strong protest by the opposition. In the next fiscal year, the government estimated Rs4,062.2 billion federal transfers from the Federal Divisible Pool, while Rs828.2 billion would be generated from the province's own resources under the head of provincial revenue. The government allocated Rs2,706.5 billion for the non-development expenditures – a 6% increase over expenditures in the outgoing fiscal year – which included salaries, pensions, PFC transfers and service delivery. The current capital expenditures was estimated at Rs590.2 billion. "I am glad to inform that the Punjab government is going to present a record development budget of Rs1,240 billion which is 23% of the total budget and 47% higher than the current year's development outlay," the finance minister said in his speech. He added that it was a matter of satisfaction that the proposed expenditures under Account-II (Food) had come to Rs58.3 billiona decline of 88% compared to fiscal 2024-25. "And its prime reason is the reduction in financial burden from national exchequer through payment of the circular debts accumulated over several decades which is glaring evidence of our government's best economic planning and that also caused 94% decrease in payments of the internal debts." Empowering the local governments, the minister told the house, the provincial government allocated Rs764.2 billion under the head of the PFC Award. Rs150 billion were earmarked for waste management and municipal corporations. Education The provincial government has allocated Rs661 billion for education which is 24.4% of the total non-development expenditures. While Rs148 billion has been allocated under the head of development in coming fiscal year for the education sector which is 127% higher than 2024-25. The government had awarded laptops to 40,000 students of universities and colleges through the Chief Minister Punjab Laptop Scheme initiated with Rs27 billion and Rs10 billion, respectively. To promote digital education, the government also earmarked Rs15.1 billion for this purpose through which 112,000 students will be given laptops in the coming year. An amount of Rs15 billion was allocated for the Honahar Scholarship Programme wherein efficient and deserving students will be given opportunities of the best education. For the first time, the government has allocated Rs40 billion for renovation of the dilapidated buildings, missing facilities, IT Labs, extra class rooms in government schools through the school management councils under the Punjab Education Initiative Management Authority (PEIMA). Rs35 billion has been earmarked for the provision of education through private participation under Punjab Education Foundation (PEF). With Rs3 billion, a project of establishing the Nawaz Sharif Centre of Excellence for early childhood education is being started in 10 divisions. Eight new government-affiliated colleges for girls are being established in the province with Rs2 billion. For the first time in Punjab's history, that provincial government earmarked Rs25 billion for universities for the promotion of higher education. Rs2billion has been allocated for Mian Nawaz Sharif Engineering and Technology University. Health The government earmarked Rs181 billion for health sector under the head of development in the next fiscal year, which is 131% higher than the current fiscal year. Under the non-development head, the government allocated Rs450 billion for next fiscal year which is 16% of the total non-development expenditures. The government earmarked Rs109 billion for for establishment of Nawaz Sharif Medical District and Land Acquisition. Under this medical district, Rs54billion will be spent on seven new projects being initiated in Lahore City. The new projects include Children Hospital-II and Institute of Genetic Blood Diseases; Institute of Surgical Orthopaedic and Medical Rehabilitation; Specialised Medical Hospital and Medical College; 1,000-bedded Cardiac Institute; Medical University; State-of-the-art diagnostic lab; and Centre of Excellence for Nursing Education. The government allocates Rs16 billion for establishing medical colleges in Narowal, Okara and Layyah. The project of establishing burn units in Bahawalpur and Rahimyar-Khan at a cost of Rs4 billion has also been made part of this budget. Rs79.5 billion has been allocated for free medicines at government hospitals. In 2024-25, Rs56 billion was earmarked for this purpose, through which over 20 million patients were benefitted with free medicines worth Rs11.1billion. The provision of quality medical treatment with Rs25 billion under the Universal Health Insurance Programme is also included in the priorities of this budget. Rs3.2billion has been earmarked for the Chief Minister's Paediatric Heart Surgery Programme, Rs3.6billion for the Chief Minister's Special Initiative for Transport Programme, Rs8.7billion for the Chief Minister's Dialysis Programme, Rs3billion for Cath Labs, Rs9 billion for the Maryam Nawaz Health Clinics Programme and Rs12.6 billion for the Maryam Nawaz Community Health Programme through the community health inspectors. Two projects of worth Rs20billion has been made part of this budget aimed at upgradation of the BHUs across Punjab. The government earmarked Rs2billion for provision of fire services in 39 tehsils and Rs2billion for establishing the rescue stations in 33 new tehsils and towns. Agriculture The government earmarked Rs123 billion under the development head and Rs56.2 billion under the non-development head in the coming fiscal year for agriculture, livestock, irrigation and water. The government allocated Rs80 billion for agriculture sector, which is 24% higher than the current fiscal year. Green Tractor Scheme's Phase-II will be initiated with Rs5.5 billion and a new project under the banner of High-Power Tractor Programme will be initiated with Rs10 billion. For the Kisan Card, the government earmarked Rs6.3 billion, while Rs8.7 billion for solarisation of agriculture tube-wells schemes. The government earmarked Rs8 billion for Chief Minister's Water Efficient Agriculture (2025-27) – a project which is being initiated for the construction, conservation and efficient utilisation of water resources for agriculture purposes to help line the watercourses. Rs25 billion has been earmarked for three projects – establishment of water reservoirs; water conservation and water use efficiency; and the water infrastructure development and establishment of water storage. The government estimated Rs9 billion to meet the water's deficiency at Kasur with a project titled the New Ravi Syphon. A dam will also be constructed at Rawalpindi with Rs4.2 billion for watering 2,280 acres of agriculture land. Climate resilience To implement the Climate Resilient Punjab Vision, different projects have been made part of the climate budget, tagging a framework of Rs795 billion which is 64% of the total development budget. Out of which Rs277.4 billion is allocated for climate adaption, Rs371.7 billion for climate mitigation, Rs146 billion for environment protection. Rs40 billion under the development head and Rs12.9 billion under the non- development head have been earmarked for environment protection, forest and wildlife. To deal with environment dangers like smog, the government earmarked Rs5.7 billion for the Punjab Clean Air Programme. Governance and law, order The government allocated Rs35 billion under the development head and Rs4 billion under the non-development head for governance and IT sectors. The government earmarked Rs10 billion under the development and Rs290 billion under non-development head. To enhance efficiency of the police department, the government allocated Rs200 billion under non-development head. A new 'Crime Control Department' is being established with Rs3.3 billion under non-development head, while Rs3.24 billion under the development head to stop heinous nature crimes. Other allocations The government allocated Rs336 billion to infrastructure development sector, which is 27% of the total development budget. Rs4 billion is earmarked for the energy sector; Rs31.4 billion under development and Rs107.3 billion under non-development head for the social protection and welfare. The government allocated Rs19.2 billion for 62 development schemes for the welfare of the women. The government allocated Rs28 billion under the development head and Rs1.3 billion under the non-development head to the tourism, archaeology and museums. Opposition protest As the budget speech started, the opposition lawmakers assembled near the chair of the speaker. They tore up the budget books and chanted slogans against the budget, terming it anti-poor people. Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz was present in the House. The Opposition tried its best to disrupt the finance minister's speech through their noisy protest but all in vain as Rehman continued his speech.
Express Tribune
20 hours ago
- Express Tribune
'ECP justified in case of 41 candidates'
The constitutional bench (CB) of the Supreme Court on Monday issued notices to respondents on a petition filed by the PTI led Khyber Pakhtunkhwa government to become a party in a case related to allocation of reserved seats to Imran Khan's party. During the hearing, the counsel for the Sunni Ittehad Council (SIC)a party comprising PTI-backed independent parliamentariansstated that the SIC intended to file a review petition against the CB's decision to dismiss its objections to the bench. The eleven-member CB, led by Justice Aminuddin Khan, heard the petitions challenging the SC's July 2024 majority order for allocation of reserved seats to the PTI. At the outset, Justice Khan remarked that the SC granted a relief to the PTI initially meant for the SIC. On January 13, 2024, a three-member SC bench upheld the Election Commission of Pakistan's (ECP) December 22, 2023 order declaring the PTI's intra-party polls null and void. Later, the PTI candidates had to contest the February 8, 2024 general elections as independents. Eighty such independent candidates reached the National Assembly and later joined the SIC in an apparent bid to claim reserved seats for women and minorities. The ECP, however, refused to allocate the seats to the party, a decision that the SIC challenged in the Supreme Court. On July 12, 2024, a full bench of the apex court through a majority of 8 to 5 resurrected the PTI as a parliamentary party, noting that 39 of the lawmakers who had submitted certificates of their affiliation with the PTI along with their nomination papers were already PTI lawmakers. The SC ruled that the remaining 41 lawmakers who had not submitted the affiliation certificates at the time of nomination papers' submission could do that now within a period of 15 days. The ruling coalition later filed a review petition against the SC ruling, which the CB took up in May. During the hearing, Justice Jamal Khan Mandokhail observed that the SC verdict came on January 13, whereas nomination papers were submitted in December, and many candidates had then declared their independent status. Siddiqi responded that the ECP had withdrawn PTI's symbol on December 22, 2023. He said all 11 judges of the SC larger bench had stated the ECP's decision to declare PTI members as independents was illegal. Justice Mandokhail remarked that the agreement among the 11 judges applied only to those members who had submitted nomination papers and party tickets from the PTI. "Only 14 PTI candidates had submitted the party certificate but we assumed that perhaps others had also submitted it and it may have been misplaced. That was why we considered 39 members." The court adjourned the hearing until today. Siddiqi will resume his arguments on behalf of the SIC.
