Expert turns tables on Dem critics after Musk accuses Social Security of being 'Ponzi scheme'
Democrats have pushed back after Elon Musk claimed that social security operates like a "Ponzi scheme" as he continues to argue for cuts to the federal bureaucracy, but one expert tells Fox News Digital that Musk is on track with his criticism of the agency.
"Musk's statement about Social Security being the world's biggest Ponzi scheme does have validity," James Agresti, president of the nonprofit research institute Just Facts, told Fox News Digital in response to pushback from Elon Musk's claim, which included a "false" rating from Politifact.
"A Ponzi scheme operates by taking money from new investors to pay current investors. That's the definition given by the SEC, and contrary to popular belief, that's exactly how Social Security operates."
Agresti explained to Fox News Digital that Social Security, believed to be a target of Musk's efforts at DOGE, "doesn't take our money and save it for us, as many people believe, and then give it to us when we're older" like many Americans might believe.
Expert Reveals Massive Levels Of Waste Doge Can Slash From Entitlements, Pet Projects: 'A Lot Of Fat'
"What it does is, it transfers money when we are young and working and paying into Social Security taxes," Agresti said. "That money, the vast bulk of it, goes immediately out the door to people who are currently receiving benefits. Now there is a trust fund, but in 90 years of operation, that trust fund currently has enough money to fund two years of program operations."
Read On The Fox News App
The trust fund only being able to last for two years is not a result of the fund being "looted," Agresti explained, but rather it was put in place to "put surpluses in it" from money that Social Security collects in taxes that it doesn't pay out immediately and pays interest on.
"The interest that's been paid on that has been higher than the rate of inflation," Agresti said. "So, the problem isn't that the trust fund has been looted. The problem is that Social Security operates like a Ponzi scheme."
Doge's Plans To Offload Government Buildings Supported By Former Gsa Official
One of the top Social Security criticisms from Republicans, including President Trump, has been a concern that individuals who are dead or listed with an age well over 100 years old are on the rolls and receiving benefits.
Agresti told Fox News Digital that there are legitimate reasons to be concerned about that issue.
"What's unclear to me at this moment is whether or not the people who are on the books are actually receiving checks," Agresti said.
"Back during the Obama administration, there was a stimulus, and the Obama administration sent out stimulus checks via Social Security numbers to 80,000 people who were dead, and about 70,000 of them, the Social Security Administration knew they were dead. So I don't know if they've remedied that situation since then, but clearly the system is not keeping up with the pace of current data, and that provides an opportunity for fraud."
Democrats have also made the case that Musk is attempting to strip away benefits that senior citizens have rightfully earned. Agresti told Fox News Digital that is not what is happening.
"There's been a lot of misinformation about that as of late," Agresti said. "You know, when DOGE came in and suggested that the Social Security Administration cut, I think it was about 10,000 workers, Democrats erupted that this is going to weaken Social Security. But the fact of the matter is that Social Security pays those workers who are for administrative overhead from the Social Security trust fund. So, by cutting out the money that they're paying them, you actually strengthen the program financially."
Agresti told Fox News Digital that the current administrative overhead for Social Security is $6.7 billion per year, which is enough to pay more than 300,000 retirees the average old age benefit.
Questions have emerged from critics in recent years as to whether Social Security, in its current form, is even capable of remaining solvent to pay benefits to Americans who have paid in over the past few decades.
Agresti told Fox News Digital that the program will "become insolvent" as soon as 2035 if changes are not made.
"To give you a feel of how disconnected Social Security is from a fully funded pension plan, if to keep the program solvent and put it on the same firm financial footing as a real pension plan, it would require an extra $272,000 in additional payroll taxes from every person paying payroll taxes right now," Agresti told Fox News Digital.
"I'll give you another way in which more numbers prove this point. If you retired in 1980, it took about three years of receiving Social Security benefits to get back the value of your payroll taxes plus interest. If you retired in 2000, it took 17 years. If you retired in 2020. it will take 22 years, assuming the program has enough money to pay those benefits, which it won't without another increase in taxes on another generation of Americans."Original article source: Expert turns tables on Dem critics after Musk accuses Social Security of being 'Ponzi scheme'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
17 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Recent survey shows the fear Americans have over inflation decreased last month
SPRINGFIELD, Mass. (WWLP) – The fear Americans have over inflation decreased last month, according to a recent survey. This being prompted by the president's decision to back off on his tariff proposals. Mass. clean cement company hopes to win back $87M federal award With tariff threats easing and reports of trade negotiations heating up, this survey by the Fed shows people are starting to worry less about inflation. In the New York Federal Reserve's Survey of Consumer Expectations, inflation expectations declined in May. This comes after surging higher in March and April over concerns about tariffs. Right now, inflation stands at 2.3%. 'It's good, because the economy is struggling as it already is. So it's good for us to see those numbers dwindle,' said Angel Amaro of Springfield. The improving expectations come as the tariff policy has changed. Initial tariffs were set at 10 percent on all US imports, and dozens of nations faced reciprocal duties. President Donald Trump later backed off on the tariffs, opting for a 90-day negotiation period that ends in July. While inflation is coming down, AIC economics professor John Rogers explains it's still above the Fed's 2% annual target rate. 'It's sort of that last mile is difficult to get to, but it's it's going in the right direction,' said Rogers. The survey showed that expectations dipped across most price groups, but saw food prices rising to 5.5 percent over the next year. Rogers says the survey also showed people are optimistic about the job market. 'They feel that the number of people who feel that their jobs are at under threat or at stake is going down. So that's good news. So that gives people confidence if they're confident, they go out and spend money, it's consumer spending that keeps the economy humming along,' added Rogers. And Rogers noted that the Bond market is another area for people to question, asking themselves whether the US can service all of its debt. He says it's up to $37 trillion, and it's growing at almost $2 trillion every year. The survey also shows increased gas prices easing to just 2.7 percent. Medical care, college education, and rent increases were also lower every month. WWLP-22News, an NBC affiliate, began broadcasting in March 1953 to provide local news, network, syndicated, and local programming to western Massachusetts. Watch the 22News Digital Edition weekdays at 4 p.m. on Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
17 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Naturalization ceremony at Clinton Presidential Library, 39 new citizens welcomed by former President Bill Clinton
LITTLE ROCK, Ark. — Thirty-nine individuals from 18 different countries and nationalities were officially sworn in as United States citizens Monday afternoon during a naturalization ceremony held at the Clinton Presidential Library. The event was made even more special by the presence of former President Bill Clinton, who addressed the new Americans with words of encouragement, gratitude and hope for their futures. The ceremony celebrated the journeys of men and women who, after navigating the immigration process and demonstrating knowledge of U.S. history, government and civic values, took their oaths of allegiance to become full participants in the American democratic system. Former President Bill Clinton welcomes new U.S. citizens at naturalization ceremony in Little Rock One of those new citizens, Selen Strickland, originally from Turkey, reflected on her six-year journey to citizenship. 'It's a very big accomplishment,' she said. 'I came to the U.S. six years ago to pursue my master's degree. After my studies, I decided to stay, moved to Little Rock five years ago, met my husband, and now we have a one-year-old daughter. I feel very proud—this is a big achievement and a major milestone in my life.' Former President Clinton, the 42nd President of the United States, welcomed the group with heartfelt remarks, commending their resilience and the diversity they bring to the nation. 'Thank you for bringing your talents, perseverance, and your dreams to the United States,' Clinton said. 'There is nothing more important than what people decide to do with their lives, their minds and their hearts every new day.' Clinton urged the newly naturalized citizens to embrace education, civic participation and the responsibilities of their new status. 'You now hold the cards to forge a new future for yourselves and your families,' he said. 'As a country, we welcome the heritage you bring. Together, we continue to form a more perfect union.' Many attendees had the chance to meet and shake hands with the former president, who emphasized that being American is not about background but about shared values and commitment to the community. 'Whatever your nationality, as long as you follow the law, show up, work hard, pay your taxes and do all the things that are burdens of citizenship—we're glad you're here,' Clinton concluded. Immigrants from 22 countries become U.S. citizens in Little Rock As the event came to a close, emotions ran high among the new citizens who now call the United States their home. For many, including Strickland, the moment marked the culmination of years of perseverance and the start of a new chapter in the American story. 'After all the sacrifices and everything, I think this is the reward that I'm getting today, becoming an American citizen,' she said through tears. The ceremony served not only as a celebration of individual achievement but also as a powerful reminder of the enduring promise of the American dream. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
21 minutes ago
- Yahoo
See North Jersey 2025 primary results for Bergen, Essex, Passaic and Morris counties
EDITOR'S NOTE: Results will be added as they become available after polls close at 8 p.m. on Tuesday, June 10. Check back often as we update results as they become available. The focus of the June 10 primary election has been the gubernatorial race, however, there were numerous local contested races in Bergen, Passaic, Essex and Morris counties. This was New Jersey's first primary where all 21 counties used a black ballot design for both parties instead of the "county line." The line traditionally gave candidates endorsed by the county's political party a preferred ballot placement, but it was dismantled by a federal judge in 2024. As of May 1, New Jersey had 6,565,285 registered voters, which includes 2,449,526 Democrats and 1,621,669 Republicans. More than 691,000 vote-by-mail ballots were sent out across the state and about 234,000 were returned, according to state officials. To vote in New Jersey's primary election, voters are required to be affiliated with a party. The latest numbers show that almost 37 percent, or 2.4 million, of the state's voters are registered as undeclared. Undeclared voters may declare a party at the polls on the day of the election if they wish to vote. Vote-by-mail ballots must be postmarked by June 10. NJ Primary Election 2025: Our complete guide to voting, governor candidates, local races The following were all the North Jersey contested races listed by county and party. An asterisk denotes incumbents. Members of the Bergen County Board of Commissioners (Vote for three three-year seats) Bergen County Democrats for Change: Chris Chung — John Vitale — Dolores Witko — Democratic Committee of Bergen County: Thomas J. Sullivan * — Mary Amoroso * — Germaine M. Ortiz * — CRESSKILL Mayor (Unexpired two-year term) Skyler Cohen — Better spending. Better schools. Better Cresskill — Leslie Kaplan — Democratic Committee of Bergen County — GLEN ROCK Borough Council (Vote for two three-year terms) — Jonathan Hendl – Putting Residents First — Seth M. Rosenstein* – Glen Rock Democrats for Council — Rachel C. Madley – Glen Rock Democrats for Council — MOONACHIE Borough Council (Vote for two three-year terms) Robert J. Bauer Sr. – Democratic Committee of Bergen County — James D. Campbell – Democratic Committee of Bergen County — Giovanni A. Brattoli – Your Voice, Our Future! — RIDGEFIELD Borough Council (Vote for two three-year terms) Joanna Congalton-Hali* – Democratic Committee of Bergen County — James V. Kontolios* – Democratic Committee of Bergen County — Andrew J. Borek – People Who Love Ridgefield — RUTHERFORD Borough Council (Vote for two three-year terms) Edward C. Narucki – Eddie – Alt Indie Democrat — Douglas J. Hoffman – Rutherforward — Richard H. Hussey – Rutherforward — Christie Delrey-Cone* – Democratic Committee of Bergen County — Dennis F. Mazone – Democratic Committee of Bergen County — Susan E. Quatrone* – Democratic Councilwoman Serving Rutherford — FRANKLIN LAKES Borough Council (Vote for two three-year terms) Joseph S. Conte – Trusted. Responsible. Dedicated — Joseph L. Rosano – Trusted. Responsible. Dedicated — Joel D. Ansh* – Bergen County Republican Endorsed Candidates — Michael A. Kazimir – Bergen County Republican Endorsed Candidates — HILLSDALE Borough Council — (Vote for two three-year terms) Anthony J. DeRosa — Hillsdale Republicans — Louis A. Casale — Bergen County Republican Endorsed Candidates — Stephen B. Riordan — Bergen County Republican Endorsed Candidates — WALDWICK Borough Council (Vote for two three-year terms) Nadia M. Luppino — Bergen County Republican Endorsed Candidates — Charles F. Asta — Bergen County Republican Endorsed Candidates — Michele S. Weber* — Bergen County Republicans — Mark J. Ramundo* – Bergen County Republicans — BLOOMFIELD Township Council (Democrats, vote for three three-year terms, serving at-large): Jill Fischman — Satenik Margaryan — Monica Charris-Tabares* — Tracy Toler-Phillips — Widney Polynice* — MILLBURN Township Committee (Democrats, vote for two three-year terms,serving at-large): Michael Cohen* — Jeffrey Feld — Annette Romano* — WANAQUE Borough Council (Republican, vote for two three-year terms): Dominick Cortellessa* — Passaic County Regular Republican Organization Inc — Angela Demetriou — Community: Stronger Together — Edward Leonard* — Passaic County Regular Republican Organization Inc — WAYNE Mayor (Democrats, vote for one four-year term): James R. Freeswick — Democrat — Donald Robert Pavlak Jr. — Passaic County Democratic Organization Endorsed Candidate — DOVER COUNCIL (Democrat) Ward 1 (Vote for one four-year term): Claudia Toro* — Daniele Mendez — Ward 2 (Vote for one four-year term): Sergio Rodriguez — Judy Rugg — Ward 3 (Vote for one four-year term): Michael Scarneo — Christopher Almada — MENDHAM BOROUGH COUNCIL (Republican) (Vote for two three-year terms): Robert Mason — Bruce LaFera* — Neil Sullivan — MONTVILLE COMMITTEE (Republican) (Vote for two three-year terms): Daria Senaldi — Chris Fano — Thomas Mazzaccaro — James Sandham Jr. — PARSIPPANY (Republican): Mayor (Vote for one four-year term): James Barberio* — Justin Musella — Council (Vote for two four-year terms): Frank Neglia — Jigar Shah — Casey Parikh — John Bielen — ROCKAWAY BOROUGH (Republican): Council (Vote for two three-year terms): Robert DeVito — Andrew Agliata* — Thomas Slockbower* — ROCKAWAY TWP. COMMITTEE (Republican): Ward 6 (Vote for one four-year term): Rachael Brookes* — Tucker Kelley — WASHINGTON COMMITTEE (Republican) (Vote for two three-year terms): Michael Marino* — Michael Starr — Lawrence Bajek — This article originally appeared on NJ primary election results 2025 for Bergen, Essex, Morris, Passaic
