SC pulls up UP jail dept for violating liberty of a person; orders to pay ' Rs 5 lakh to man detained for month despite bail
NEW DELHI: Lambasting the UP prisons department for illegally detaining a man for 28 days despite his release on bail, Supreme Court on Wednesday asked the state to pay an interim compensation of Rs 5 lakh to him and ordered a judicial inquiry into lapses on the part of Ghaziabad jail officials.
Taking a hyper-technical approach - the bail order mentioned Section 5 instead of Section 5(1) of UP Prohibition of Unlawful Conversion of Religion Act and the same typo was repeated in the additional sessions and district judge's release order of May 27 - jail authorities had refused to release Aftab, who had converted to Hinduism to marry a Hindu girl.
With the director general (prisons) logged on virtually to the proceedings and jail superintendent Sitaram Sharma present in the courtroom, a bench of Justices K V Viswanathan and N Kotiswar Singh said, "The whole incident to say the least is unfortunate.
Each one of the stakeholders in the process was aware as to what the offence was, what the crime number was and the sections under which the man was charged with and the punishment section.
"
Noting that Aftab was released on Tuesday only after the SC took umbrage to denial of liberty based on a hyper-technicality, the bench said, "Aftab was sent on a spin and notwithstanding the order of the SC of April 29 (order of a bench headed by the CJI), and the release order of May 27 (by additional sessions and district judge), which is clear to us as daylight, the applicant has been released only on June 24.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
경고: 이 게임 진짜 중독성 쩔어요. 지금 해봐!
Hero Wars
플레이하기
Undo
"Liberty is a very valuable and precious right guaranteed to a person under the Constitution. It cannot be martyred on these useless technicalities. We only hope that no other convict or undertrial is languishing in jail on account of similar technicalities. The DG (prisons) has assured us that no one will suffer because of such technicality in future and that he will sensitise the entire jail staff." The bench noted that UP prisons had 90,000 inmates.
The SC asked the Ghaziabad district judge to complete the inquiry into the episode by Aug 18 and told the DG (prisons) to understand and implement the need to respect court orders and sensitise jail staff about the importance of liberty to ensure such incidents are not repeated.
The bench said if it found from the inquiry that jail officials were at fault for delay in Aftab's release despite valid bail orders, it would impose cost on individual officers.
It asked the UP govt to pay the compensation of Rs 5 lakh by Friday.
UP's advocate general Garima Prasad informed the court that jail authorities had moved the trial court on May 28 for correction in the released order to include Section 5(1) of the anti-conversion law, but the trial court did so only on June 24, following which Aftab was released on Tuesday evening.
The SC asked the state not to look for typographical errors in matters relating to liberty and said, "Otherwise, we (judges) in the SC will be doing proof-reading while most of the country will be behind bars."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
19 minutes ago
- Time of India
'Nefarious agenda': India slams Pakistan at UNSC; says it shelled civilians, supports terror
India's Permanent Representative to the UN, Ambassador Parvathaneni Harish addresses the UN Security Council Open Debate on civilian safety and accountability in conflict zones. NEW DELHI: India on Thursday strongly rejected Pakistan's remarks at the United Nations Security Council (UNSC), accusing Islamabad of misusing the platform to push a "nefarious agenda" and deflect attention from its own child rights violations and cross-border terrorism. India's permanent representative to the UN, ambassador Parvathaneni Harish, made a detailed statement during the UNSC's open debate on Children and Armed Conflict (CAAC), responding to Pakistan's comments. "Pakistan is casting unwarranted aspersions over UN processes and also smearing India at various discussions to pursue its nefarious agenda. We reject this attempt by Pakistan to deflect attention from the atrocities committed against children in their country, as highlighted in the Secretary-General's report, as well as their rampant cross-border terrorism," said Harish. He also referred to the April 22 attack in Pahalgam, Jammu and Kashmir, in which 26 tourists were killed, and highlighted India's retaliatory strikes under Operation Sindoor. "The world has not forgotten the targeted attacks by Pakistani and Pakistani-trained terrorists killing 26 tourists in Pahalgam, Jammu and Kashmir on 22 April 2025. The security council had issued a press statement on 25 April which underlined the need to hold perpetrators, organizers, financiers and sponsors of this reprehensible act accountable and bring them to justice. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Buy Brass Laxmi Ji Idol For Wealth, Peace & Happiness Luxeartisanship Shop Now Undo India had undertaken non escalatory, proportionate and focused attacks that targeted nine terrorist infrastructure sites on 7 May 2025 in response through Operation Sindoor. The terrorists killed in these attacks were given straight funerals by Pakistan and yet they tried to preach to others," Permanent Representative of India to the UN said. Harish also referred to findings in the secretary-general's report on Children and Armed Conflict. "The secretary general's report on CAAC provides details of serious violations against children in armed conflict in Pakistan. Secretary General has expressed concern at the rise in such grave violations reported including attacks against schools, particularly girls' schools, against health workers, and about the incidents in the border areas with Afghanistan where a series of killing and maiming of Afghan children was directly attributed to cross border shelling and air strikes by Pakistani armed forces! The Pakistani army also deliberately shelled our border villages in May 2025, killing and injuring a number of civilians. To preach at this body after such behaviour is grossly hypocritical," he said.
Time of India
24 minutes ago
- Time of India
South Delhi farmhouse heist: Businessman held hostage, robbed of Rs 30 lakh; taken to Gurgaon CNG pump for more cash
Representative Image NEW DELHI: A city businessman was held hostage and robbed of over Rs 30 lakh in cash by four armed robbers at his farmhouse in south Delhi's Ghitorni on Monday night. They also took the businessman hostage in his car and went to his office in Gurgaon where they robbed him of more cash. The police are learned to have apprehended two suspects and raids are on to nab others. According to police, the incident occurred on Monday night when four armed robbers arrived at the farmhouse of Karan Chopra, CEO of a naturan gas firm, and took him and his guard hostage at gunpoint. The robbers tied the guard's hands and feet and entered the farmhouse, where they found Chopra alone. His parents had travelled abroad a few days ago, leaving him behind. The robbers looted Rs10 lakh from the farmhouse, ransacking premises & searching for valuables. Farmhouse robbery: Police investigating role of security guard You Can Also Check: Delhi AQI | Weather in Delhi | Bank Holidays in Delhi | Public Holidays in Delhi After gathering whatever they could find, the robbers forced Chopra into his car and took him to his CNG pump collection centre in Sikandarpur, Gurgaon. There, they stole an additional Rs 20 lakh in cash, bringing the total loot to Rs 30 lakh. After the robbery, the armed men abandoned Chopra on the way and fled. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Giao dịch vàng CFDs với sàn môi giới tin cậy IC Markets Tìm hiểu thêm Undo Both Delhi and Gurgaon police were alerted due to the incident occurring in two jurisdictions. The Vasant Kunj (South) police station has registered a case under various sections, including armed robbery, and begun an investigation. When TOI visited the spot, they found heavy security in the area and at the farmhouse. In a statement, Delhi Police said: "On June 23, information regarding robbery was received after which the SHO and his team rushed to the spot and met with the complainant, Karan Chopra, who is engaged in the business of city gas distribution. In his complaint, he said that 3-4 persons forcefully entered his house and looted around Rs 30 lakh. Forensic team was called at the scene for crime spot inspection and a case was registered. Some suspects have been traced while others have been located and raids are on to catch them." The police are also investigating the role of a security guard, who was also held hostage, and questioning him. The cops suspect the possibility of an inside job, as the robbers seemed to know about the collection centre and the large sum of money that could be obtained there. The cops are reviewing the records of workers who have been employed at the farmhouse over the past two years, as construction work has been ongoing. They are also questioning local residents and gathering CCTV footage to get clues about the suspects. The police have reviewed the security of the area and stepped up patrolling. The entry and exit points are being monitored, they said.
The Print
25 minutes ago
- The Print
Minor among four held for throwing ‘ganja balls' in Goa jail
The balls were found were lying in a passage area of the inner corridor between two watch towers, he said. Security guards at the jail, located in Colvale area, on Tuesday found seven balls containing 1.397 gm of the contraband, valued at Rs 1.4 lakh, in the premises, Superintendent of Police (North) Rahul Gupta told reporters on Wednesday. Panaji, Jun 26 (PTI) Police have arrested three men and detained a minor boy for allegedly throwing ganja rolled into balls in the premises of the high-security Central Jail in North Goa district, officials said. An investigation indicated that four persons, including a minor boy, threw the 'ganja balls' in the jail premises from outside the compound wall in the wee hours of Tuesday, he said. The police have arrested Gautam Talwar, Samuel Pujari and Jaffer Mulla, all from Mapusa town in North Goa, and apprehended the juvenile in this connection, the official said. The accused have been booked under provisions of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act, the police added. PTI RPS GK This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.
