Why are some in Japan calling to dismantle Finance Ministry?
Question: I hear there are people calling for the dismantling of the Finance Ministry? Is this true?
Answer: Yes. The Ministry of Finance ("Zaimu-sho" in Japanese), which manages national taxes and their allocation, is facing such calls online. A book that criticizes the state of the public being "brainwashed" by the ministry's ideas, labeling it "Zaimu Shinrikyo," likening it to a cult, has become a bestseller, and some people are even staging protests.
Q: What criticisms are being leveled against it?
A: The concept of fiscal rehabilitation, aimed at curbing wasteful government spending, increasing tax revenue and reducing government debt, is being blamed for stalling the Japanese economy. There are accusations that the Finance Ministry uses influential politicians and the media to steer the nation in that direction. Additionally, there is a lot of criticism without clear evidence, such as claims that retired ministry officials are distorting economic policies through "amakudari," the practice of securing postretirement jobs in private companies.
Q: Would it really be OK to dismantle the ministry?
A: The national budget is based on tax revenue, and while funds are limited, elected politicians tend to favor policies that are popular among the public, like tax cuts. The debt used to cover budget shortfalls continues to grow, and sometimes the Ministry of Finance needs to play the unpopular role of tightening the national purse strings.
Q: What can the ministry do to avoid calls for its dismantlement?
A: A steady effort to alleviate public distrust is essential. This involves providing thorough explanations to the public not only about the tax system and Japan's fiscal condition but also about the current state of "amakudari," thereby enhancing transparency.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
21 minutes ago
Ishiba Vows Not to Create Political Vacuum
News from Japan Politics Jul 28, 2025 17:57 (JST) Tokyo, July 28 (Jiji Press)--Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba on Monday reiterated his intention to stay in office after his ruling party's crushing defeat in a parliamentary election earlier this month, saying that he would not create a political vacuum. "I will fulfill my responsibility to the nation and the people so that a political vacuum will never be created," Ishiba told a meeting of members of his Liberal Democratic Party. At the beginning of the meeting, Ishiba said, "I deeply and sincerely apologize that many fellow lawmakers lost their seats" in the July 20 House of Councillors election. "I will make all-out efforts for the steady implementation" of the Japan-U.S. trade agreement reached last week, he said. He added: "I will do my best for the nation and the people with my sincere heart. I will work with that in the future." [Copyright The Jiji Press, Ltd.] Jiji Press
Asahi Shimbun
21 minutes ago
- Asahi Shimbun
Poll: 48% of voters say ‘Japanese First' works for them
Sanseito leader Sohei Kamiya, center, waves to supporters in Tokyo on July 21, a day after the Upper House election. (Asahi Shimbun file photo) Just over half of Japanese voters approve of the surge by Sanseito, an Asahi Shimbun poll found, after the party known for its antiforeign sentiment won a slew of seats in the Upper House this month. Fifty-two percent of voters polled said it was good that Sanseito gained so many seats in the July 20 election, while 34 percent expressed concern about the result. Sanseito, which champions a 'Japanese First' policy, captured 14 Upper House seats, in third place among opposition parties behind the Constitutional Democratic Party of Japan and the Democratic Party for the People. The result was seen as a surge because the party had only one seat up for re-election. Among its policies, Sanseito has advocated tighter immigration controls, suspension of welfare payments to foreign residents and restrictions on the provision of the medical insurance program. Forty-eight percent of respondents to the nationwide telephone survey on July 26-27 said they appreciate the Japanese First policy, compared with 41 percent who said they do not. Broken down by gender, male respondents were more supportive of the policy. Fifty-five percent of men said they value it, with only 38 percent opposed. Women were almost evenly split: 42 percent favored the policy, with 43 percent against it. The survey indicates that younger generations form a key support base for Sanseito. Seventy-one percent of respondents between the ages 18 and 29 said they appreciate the policy, versus 27 percent who said they do not. But only 29 percent of those 70 or older said the policy works for them, while 53 percent said it does not sit well with them. Similar patterns are found regarding the question about Sanseito substantially increasing the number of Upper House seats. Fifty-nine percent of men said it is a good move, nearly double the 30 percent who disagreed with this. Of women, 46 percent agreed, a little more than the 38 percent who did not. And the generational divide remained. About 60 percent of respondents in their 50s and in lower age brackets said the gains were good, but only about 40 percent of those 70 or older said they agreed. A similar ratio was seen in those who expressed unease with Sanseito's rise. More than 70 percent of men in their 30s or younger said they welcome the party's gains. Among all respondents who said it was good, 72 percent said they appreciate the Japanese First policy. Of those who said the rise is bad, 77 percent said they are uncomfortable with the policy. The survey was conducted through calls to randomly generated telephone numbers. There were 497 valid responses from voters contacted by landlines, or 50 percent of the total, and 753 valid responses from those contacted by cellphones, or 40 percent.
The Mainichi
an hour ago
- The Mainichi
Xenophobia worries and a ban on smiling: Our 5 most-read stories from last week
We've listed our five most read stories on The Mainichi news site, from top to bottom, that were published between July 19 and 27. The first story was viewed by 30.1% of our regular readers. (The Mainichi) Naturalized linguist in Japan laments recent political trend to blame foreigners MUNAKATA, Fukuoka -- An American-born linguist who acquired Japanese nationality two years ago is concerned about the trend that was recently seen in the lead-up to the July 20 House of Councillors election in Japan. With one political party promoting a "Japanese First" agenda and misinformation spreading online, the scholar compared it to the division seen in the U.S. Interviewed before the upper house election, she said she planned to vote to support harmony. Full story. Blameless but facing deportation: Japan immigration law's inexplicable provision One day a foreign woman living in Japan suddenly received a visit from a police officer at her workplace. She had come under suspicion of aiding the illegal work of a Vietnamese man. The woman herself had come to Japan to work, but she had no recollection of ever having helped someone work illegally, and half a year later, the criminal charges were dropped. Full story. LDP's Mio Sugita loses upper house seat after backlash over discriminatory remarks TOKYO -- Former House of Representatives member Mio Sugita failed to secure a seat in the July 20 House of Councillors election after facing increasing criticism over her repeated discriminatory remarks. Full story. West Japan town's 'kappa' folklore creature to be replaced after years of scaring tourists FUKUSAKI, Hyogo -- A popular statue of a "kappa" river creature from Japanese folklore in this western Japan town will be replaced after becoming worn out from years of "work" by popping out of a pond to surprise tourists. Full story. Japan high school baseball team banned from smiling, waving in tourney entrance march HIROSAKI, Aomori -- A high school baseball team that smiled and waved as they marched during the summer 2024 Aomori Prefecture tournament's opening ceremony had to abandon doing the same this year as the prefectural baseball federation asked the players to follow tradition. Full story.
