Why Modi govt may reject F-35A, Su-57E offers from US & Russia? India may opt for…
News
Why Modi govt may reject F-35A, Su-57E offers from US & Russia? India may opt for…
Why Modi govt may reject F-35A, Su-57E offers from US & Russia? India may opt for…
Many defense experts believe that until the AMCA is ready to fly, an immediate interim solution is needed to balance the growing airpower of China and Pakistan. Platforms like the Su-57 can give India this interim edge, but the F-35 is more powerful.
Why Modi govt may reject F-35A, Su-57E offers from US & Russia? India may opt for...
India's Defence Secretary RK Singh indicated that India is seriously considering the option of purchasing fifth generation fighter aircraft to meet short-term needs. He said that such purchases from 'friendly countries' are being seen as a strategic option. This statement of the Defence Secretary comes at a time when Russian President Vladimir Putin is about to visit India. India is also building its own indigenous AMCA (Advanced Medium Combat Aircraft) fifth generation fighter aircraft, but it will take at least 8 to 10 years for it to be built and inducted into the Indian Air Force.
What has US offered to India?
Meanwhile, US has offered F-35 and Russia has offered SU-57 fifth generation fighter aircraft to India. It has not been disclosed yet whether India is currently eyeing the Russian Su-57 or the American F-35 . Moscow considers the SU-57 stealth fighter jet to be one of the most advanced fighter jets in the world. The Su-57 is a twin-engine multi-role stealth jet, equipped with supersonic speed, advanced avionics and electronic warfare capabilities. India has previously shown interest in this jet, but the deal could not move forward due to some technical and partnership disputes.
Russian President Vladimir Putin is going to visit Delhi in September this year to attend the 'India-Russia Summit' held every year. Many defense experts believe that until the AMCA is ready to fly, an interim solution is urgently needed to balance the growing airpower of China and Pakistan.
What Su-57 can give India?
Platforms like Su-57 can give India this interim edge, especially if Russia shows flexibility on its transfer of technology or 'Make in India' provisions. Russia has offered to transfer the technology of the SU-57 fighter aircraft to India as well as hand over the source code. Russia has also offered India that if India buys SU-57, it will provide technological help in India's AMCA program.
Why is fifth-generation fighter aircraft important?
According to defense experts, choosing a fifth-generation fighter aircraft for countries like India has now become a question of not just technology but also strategy and geopolitics. In such a situation, India has only Russia's SU-57 and US F-35 Lightning II as the most prominent options. SU-57 is Russia's twin-engine stealth fighter known for supersonic speed, supermaneuverability and long-range missile attack capability. It has superior dogfighting capabilities and can play multi-roles, from air dominance to ground attack. On the other hand, F-35 is US single-engine stealth fighter known for network-centric warfare, sensor fusion and electronic warfare.
Its stealth capabilities are considered to be more than SU-57, but its mobility is slightly limited. In terms of geo-politics, access to F-35 is limited only to close US allies, while Russia offers SU-57 on more open terms. So the question for India is whether it will lean towards the West for technological superiority or towards Russia for strategic independence?
For breaking news and live news updates, like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter and Instagram. Read more on Latest India News on India.com.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
34 minutes ago
- India Today
PM Modi, Amit Shah meet President amid Parliament logjam, Veep election announcement
Prime Minister Narendra Modi met President Droupadi Murmu at Rashtrapati Bhavan on Sunday. While the official agenda of the meeting has not been disclosed, the high-level engagement is seen as politically after PM Modi, Union Home Minister Amit Shah also called on President Murmu at Rashtrapati Bhavan on August 3. The unexpected nature of Shah's meeting has sparked speculation and stirred political activity in the meetings come at a time when the process for electing the next Vice President has formally begun. The Election Commission announced the schedule for the Vice President election on August 1, with voting to be held on September 9. Meanwhile, tensions continue in Parliament over the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) process of the Election Commission in Bihar. Opposition parties are demanding a debate on the issue, but the government's reluctance has led to disruptions in the House to the geopolitical backdrop, the meetings follow US President Donald Trump's recent announcement of a 25% tariff on Indian goods, along with proposed penalties over India's continued defense and energy engagements with Modi had previously met President Droupadi Murmu at the Rashtrapati Bhavan on July 16, before the start of the monsoon session of the precise reasons behind Sunday's meetings remain undisclosed, the timing has raised eyebrows across political and diplomatic circles.- EndsMust Watch
India.com
4 hours ago
- India.com
MEA Shuts Down Rumours And Rejects Claims of India Suspending US Bilateral Agreements
As the tariff row between India and the US continues, the Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) on Sunday fact-checked reports that are making rounds on social media stating that the Indian government is reviewing the list of United States products exempted from tariffs. In a post on X, the fact-check unit of MEA has debunked the fake claims. This comes days after the United States President Donald Trump signed the executive order imposing revised tariffs for 70 countries, including India and Pakistan. Tariffs imposed on India's neighbouring countries are less than India's 25 percent, except for Myanmar at 40 percent. The new tariff for Pakistan is 19 percent, Afghanistan 15 percent, Bangladesh 20 percent, Indonesia 19 percent, Japan 15 percent, and Sri Lanka 20 percent. This is FAKE News!#MEAFactCheck — MEA FactCheck (@MEAFactCheck) August 3, 2025 In another post on the fact-check handle, MEA also refuted the claims that India is considering suspending or reviewing certain bilateral agreements with the U.S. "Disinformation being spread on X," the post read. Disinformation being spread on X.#MEAFactCheck — MEA FactCheck (@MEAFactCheck) August 3, 2025 No India-US F-35 Discussion? Earlier, Union Minister of State (MoS) for External Affairs Kirti Vardhan Singh informed the Lok Sabha in a written reply that there has been no formal discussion on F-35 fighter jets with the US. Singh was responding to questions raised by Congress MP Balwant Baswant Wankhade, who enquired about the relationship with the US on military assistance. On the role of American diplomats to stop hostilities between India and Pakistan, MoS Singh stated that there were a number of diplomatic conversations with various countries, including the US. He added that the discussion to cease military action took place directly between the two nations, and it was initiated at Islamabad's request. Trump's Oil Deal With Pakistan After Trump announced a trade agreement with Pakistan to explore a 'massive oil reserve,' a prominent Baloch leader, Mir Yar Baloch, publicly rejected Islamabad's claim over the resource-rich territory, asserting that the oil, gas, and mineral reserves lie within the sovereign territory of Balochistan, not Pakistan. In a letter addressed to Trump and shared via X, Mir Yar Baloch declared that Pakistan is making false claims to access the region's mineral wealth for financial gain. He emphasised that the resources, including rare earth elements, copper, lithium, uranium, and oil, belong exclusively to the Baloch people and cannot be bartered or sold by the Pakistani state. India's Oil Purchase Earlier, Trump on Friday (local time) claimed that India may cease purchasing Russian oil, calling it "a good step" if confirmed. However, ANI reported, citing sources, that Indian oil refiners continue to source oil from Russian suppliers.
India.com
4 hours ago
- India.com
PM Modi, HM Shah Meet President Murmu At Rashtrapati Bhavan
Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Home Minister Amit Shah on Sunday separately called on President Droupadi Murmu at the Rashtrapati Bhavan here. The meetings came just a day before the ongoing Monsoon Session of the Parliament resumes on Monday. Taking to X, the Rashtrapati Bhavan posted: "Prime Minister Shri @narendramodi called on President Droupadi Murmu at Rashtrapati Bhavan." It shared pictures of PM Modi and President Murmu. Another post read: "Union Minister for Home Affairs and Cooperation, Shri Amit Shah called on President Droupadi Murmu at Rashtrapati Bhavan." Details related to either of the meetings were not immediately available. The meetings came against the backdrop of heated exchanges witnessed in the Parliament over the Special Intensive Revision process in Bihar ahead of the Assembly elections in the eastern state. PM Modi met President Murmu just a day after he said that the welfare of farmers, small industries, and youth remains the government's 'top priority' as the country stays on track to become the world's third-largest economy, even as US President Donald Trump announced that 25 per cent tariffs would be imposed on India from August 7. PM Modi reaffirmed the resilience of the Indian economy amid turbulence triggered by US tariff hikes, saying that the country must remain vigilant about its economic interests and adopt 'swadeshi' products. 'There is an atmosphere of global instability. All countries are focusing on their individual interests. India is going to become the third biggest economy in the world, and this is why India will have to stay alert as far as its economic interests are concerned,' the Prime Minister said during a rally in Varanasi on Saturday. Earlier this week, Trump announced 25 per cent reciprocal tariffs on Indian goods. He said India would also face an additional tariff penalty for buying Russian oil. The Parliament has seen little business since the Monsoon Session commenced on July 21.
