Calls to ban cow fighting instigates France's latest culture war
A bill to make cow fighting illegal has been tabled in the National Assembly for the first time. Unlike bullfighting and cockfighting, which are banned in most of France, cow fighting is not a blood sport, according to enthusiasts.
The two cows, with blunted horns, engage in a pushing contest until one backs away. The loser from each round is eliminated and taken out of the competition until only one is left and declared the overall winner.
The contests, which aficionados call combats de reines, or queen fights, exploit cows' natural instinct to fight for dominance in a herd. Hérens cattle, an Alpine breed known for their combative temperament, are said to make the best fighters.
Jean-François Coulomme, the left-wing MP from the Savoie region bordering Switzerland who introduced the bill, said the practice was barbaric. He claimed both cows and spectators risked injury.
'This form of entertainment was only imported into the French Alps less than 30 years ago and cannot claim to be a traditional practice,' Coulomme said.
Fans, however, insist that it is an ancestral tradition dating back hundreds of years.
Coulomme's private members' bill has been signed by 74 MPs from across the hard-left party France Unbowed, the Greens and President Macron's Renaissance party.
Animal rights activists claim pregnant cows are often made to take part in the contests because they are thought to fight more intensely.
'These fights between 800kg animals can be very violent,' said Pauline Di Nicolantonio, the head of the Savoie Association for Animal Justice. 'Videos of the fights are shocking, and it's even more shocking that the cows have to be pregnant to fight better.'
Fans of cow fighting, including farmers, residents of the French Alps and a number of local MPs, describe those opposing the practice as city-dwellers who are out of touch with countryside traditions and values.
'Those who are against queen fights are deepening urban-rural divisions because of a lack of understanding,' said Jérôme Garcin, a farmer from Les Houches, a village near Mont Blanc.
'In the high Chamonix valley, these natural contests have been organised for many generations,' Garcin added. 'I can understand that it is shocking for people from places where it hasn't been practised for centuries, but I encourage anyone to come and see how we pamper our cows and treat them like high-level sports contestants.'
Xavier Roseren, a centre-right MP for the Mont Blanc area, also described cow fighting as 'part of our living cultural heritage' and said that participating cows were very rarely injured.
Bullfighting and cockfighting are banned in France except in areas where there is 'an uninterrupted local tradition'.
Cockfighting is therefore allowed in parts of northern France and several overseas territories in the Caribbean and the Indian Ocean. Bullfighting is permitted in parts of southern France where it has been practised for centuries.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
37 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Fewer green energy tariffs offered as British households opt for cheaper deals
The number of green energy tariffs available to British households has plummeted during the cost of living crisis as bill payers choose affordability over sustainability, according to industry data. Energy suppliers have pulled tariffs advertised as 'green' from the market since Russia's invasion of Ukraine in February 2022 triggered a global energy crisis that pushed gas and electricity bills to record highs. Green tariffs, which are typically more expensive than standard deals, made up about 85% of the UK's supply market in 2022 as climate-conscious households opted to pay a premium for deals backed by renewable energy. But industry data, commissioned by the Guardian, has revealed that energy suppliers have radically scaled back their green offerings, which now make up about a fifth of the tariffs on the market. William Mann-Belotti, an analyst at Cornwall Insight, an energy consultancy, said demand for tariffs backed by renewable energy had fallen because 'green credentials aren't a higher priority than cost … Amid a cost of living crisis, it becomes difficult to sell pure green tariffs at a premium'. Energy tariffs marketed as green typically promise to supply renewable energy rather than power from a mix of sources provided to the UK's power grids, either by matching each unit of energy sold with a renewable energy certificate bought in an open market, or through a direct deal with a renewable energy generator. The consultancy found that the number of green dual-fuel tariffs has halved in the last year alone. Last month there were 13 dual-fuel green tariffs available to consumers out of 57, compared with last summer when there were 24 green tariffs on offer out of 56 dual-fuel energy deals. All the energy deals now advertised as 'green' on the uSwitch price comparison website, including dual-fuel and separate gas and electricity tariffs, have made up just 18% of the overall total this year, data from the switching service shows. Before Russia's invasion of Ukraine, green energy deals made up 85% of all energy tariffs on offer on the price comparison site, according to uSwitch data. 'Consumer choice plays a strong role in what is offered on the market, so cost concerns might see people switching away from more expensive green tariffs. This would therefore reduce the demand for them,' Mann-Belotti said. 'Also, there are other ways for people to reduce their carbon footprint, with quite the increase in solar PV installations in recent years.' Sign up to Business Today Get set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morning after newsletter promotion However, the Uswitch data revealed some good news for climate-conscious households. Although there are fewer green tariffs on the market today, the deals available are 'greener' than they used to be. Uswitch grades each tariff marketed as green to help customers avoid greenwashed deals. In 2021, fewer than 15% of tariffs received a gold- or silver-standard rating from the switching service, but last year nine of the 10 green tariffs on its site were ranked at this level, leaving a single tariff ranked bronze. The stronger green credentials behind these tariffs reflect a shift away from using renewable energy certificates to guarantee the origin of the electricity – called 'greenwashing' by consumer groups and investigated by the government. Instead, suppliers are opting to buy clean energy directly from renewable energy projects. Others sell energy that is cheaper when there is more renewable energy across the country as an incentive to use more clean power when it is available.
The Independent
2 hours ago
- The Independent
Ukrainian anti-corruption agencies uncover drone procurement graft scheme
Ukraine's anti-corruption agencies said they had uncovered a major graft scheme involving inflated military procurement contracts, just two days after Ukraine's parliament voted to restore the agencies' independence. In a joint statement published Saturday on social media, the National Anti-Corruption Bureau (NABU) and the Specialized Anti-Corruption Prosecutor's Office (SAPO) said the suspects had taken bribes in a scheme that used state funds to buy drones and other military equipment at inflated prices. 'The essence of the scheme was to conclude state contracts with supplier companies at deliberately inflated prices,' the statement said, adding that offenders had received kickbacks of up to 30% of the contracts' value. The anti-corruption bodies did not identify the detainees, but said a Ukrainian lawmaker, local district and city officials, and National Guard servicemen were involved. Four people have been arrested so far, they said. The Interior Ministry said the National Guard personnel implicated in the case were removed from their positions. Drones have become a crucial asset in modern warfare for both Ukraine and Russia, enhancing military reconnaissance, precision strikes, and strategic flexibility on the battlefield. The majority of Russian military assets destroyed by Ukrainian forces, including manpower and heavy weaponry, have been targeted by drones. Drone production is also a key aspect of Kyiv 's hopes to expand domestic military production and export markets. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy addressed the development in his nightly address on Saturday, calling the graft scheme 'absolutely immoral' and thanking the anti-corruption agencies for their work. 'Unfortunately, these corruption schemes involved the procurement of electronic warfare systems and FPV drones ... There must be full and fair accountability for this,' he said in his address, posted to X. In an earlier post, which also included photos of him meeting with the agency heads, Zelenskyy said it is 'important that anti-corruption institutions operate independently,' adding that 'the law passed on Thursday guarantees them all the tools necessary for a real fight against corruption.' The exposure of the graft scheme by NABU and SAPO came just two days after Ukraine's parliament voted to restore their independence. Ukraine's Parliament on Thursday overwhelmingly approved the bill presented by Zelenskyy, reversing his earlier contentious move that curbed their power and sparked a backlash, including street protests, a rarity in wartime. Last week's measure to place the watchdogs under the oversight of the prosecutor-general prompted rebukes from Ukrainians, the European Union and international rights groups. It raised fears that the government could meddle in investigations and potentially shield its supporters from scrutiny. Fighting entrenched corruption is crucial for Ukraine's aspirations to join the European Union and maintain access to billions of dollars of vital Western aid in the all-out war, now in its fourth year. It's also an effort that enjoys broad public support. ___
BreakingNews.ie
2 hours ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Pope tells crowd of one million young Catholics ‘a different world is possible'
Pope Leo has told more than a million Catholic youths at a closing Mass for a week-long encounter with the next generation of faithful that they are 'the sign that a different world is possible', where conflicts can be resolved with dialogue, not weapons. In his closing blessing for the Jubilee of Youth, Leo remembered the young people of Gaza and Ukraine and other countries 'bloodied by war' who could not join the celebration. Advertisement 'We are closer than ever to young people who suffer the most serious evils, which are caused by other human beings,' Leo said. 'We are with the young people of Gaza. We are with the young people of Ukraine, with those of every land bloodied by war. 'My young brothers and sisters, you are the sign that a different world is possible. A world of fraternity and friendship, where conflicts are not resolved with weapons, but with dialogue.' Young people wake up after spending the night at the Tor Vergata field in Rome as part of the event (Andrew Medichini/AP) The young people camped in sprawling fields south-east of Rome overnight after attending a vigil service for the Jubilee of Youth on Saturday, also presided by Leo – who has been ferried to and from Vatican City by helicopter. The Vatican said more than one million young people were present, along with 7,000 priests and 450 bishops. Advertisement The special Jubilee celebration is part of the Holy Year that is expected to draw 32 million people to the Vatican for the centuries-old pilgrimage to the seat of Catholicism. During the Sunday homily, Leo urged participants to 'spread your enthusiasm and the witness of your faith' when they return home to some 150 countries. 'Aspire to great things, to holiness, wherever you are,' Leo urged them. 'Do not settle for less. You will then see the light of the Gospel growing every day, in you and around you.' Leo led Mass with an estimated one million people (Andrew Medichini/AP) Leo reminded the crowd their next encounter will be for World Youth Day, set for August 3-8 in 2027, in Seoul, South Korea. Advertisement The week has been a joyous gathering marked by bands of youths singing hymns as they move down cobblestoned streets, praying rosaries in piazzas and standing for hours at the Circus Maximus to confess their sins to priests offering the sacrament in a dozen languages. Leo also shared tragic news on Saturday. Two young people who had made the pilgrimage to Rome had died, one reportedly of cardiac arrest, while a third was in hospital. Rain overnight awakened the faithful but did not dampen their spirits. Soemil Rios, 20, from Puerto Rico, said: 'At least we were a little covered, but we still got a bit wet. We lost our voices a little. It was cold, but we woke up to a beautiful sun and view. Advertisement 'Despite the difficulties, it was very nice and very special to have been part of this historic moment.'
