Sarah has cancer but her US insurer refused her treatment. She says people are 'giving up'
"This is life or death for me."
The couple have been married since 1991. Sarah describes her relationship with Jerry as 'love at first sight'. Credit: Javafilms Living in the United States, Sarah can only afford private health insurance through the support of her husband Jerry. He works 55-hour weeks in a warehouse and often through the night to bring home US$3,000 ($4,700) each month.
He says one-third of his pay goes straight to UnitedHealthcare insurance, which was supposed to cover the cost of Sarah's treatment.
Support and sympathy Luigi Mangione has been accused of shooting dead Brian Thompson, chief executive of UnitedHealthcare, on the streets of New York City in December 2024.
Authorities allege three words were etched on the bullet casings left behind at the scene of Thompson's shooting: deny, defend, depose.
It's a strategy former employee at UnitedHealthcare Nathalie Collins believes is commonly used to reject medical compensation claims. Collins says she processed up to 180 calls per day during her time with the insurer.
"We had coaching to be able to deny it [medical claims] … we would have scripts on screen explaining what to say to get them [customers] off the call, or maybe satisfy them."
Nathalie Collins worked in the medical claims department at UnitedHealthcare for nine months. She alleges almost three months of her time at the company was spent in training. Credit: Javafilms But it was the death of her former boss that provided the catalyst for Collins to speak out online. "I definitely don't condone anyone losing their life … But also, the people that are working [dealing] with these insurance companies and healthcare systems, they are dying. "In some situations, losing limbs, losing body parts because they didn't get treatment in time … I should not be able to hit a button and make such a determination on someone's life." Led by Thompson, the insurance division at UnitedHealthcare reported US$281 billion ($437 billion) in revenue in 2023 and provided medical insurance to more than 49 million people.
The healthcare executive earned US$10.2 million ($15.8 million) in 2023, including base pay, cash and stock grants, according to The New York Times.
Mangione recently pleaded not guilty to federal murder and stalking charges, which accuse the 27-year-old of spending months planning the attack.
He now awaits further trial and a possible death sentence.
US authorities describe Brian Thompson's death as a 'premeditated, cold-blooded assassination'. But some believe, the jury is still out. Credit: Javafilms It's a case that has sparked public protests in support of Mangione. One in four US adults feel "moderate" or "a lot" of sympathy for Mangione, according to a survey by CloudResearch. In separate polling by The Generation Lab, 41 per cent of young people aged between 18 to 29 found the killing 'acceptable".
While Mangione's exact motive remains unclear, he has reportedly described the US healthcare system as "parasitic" and exploitative. He also alleges doctors postponed his spinal fusion surgery for years before he underwent the procedure in 2023.
'Unravelling a scam' In 2024, a US Senate committee investigated plans under the Medicare Advantage scheme and found UnitedHealthcare was one of three health insurance companies that intentionally denied claims.
Personal finance website Value Penguin also reported the company denied 32 per cent of insurance claims that year — a figure significantly higher than most industry averages.
UnitedHealthcare has faced recent allegations by the health outlet Stat regarding the potential use of algorithms to deny care. In December 2024, UnitedHealth Group, which owns UnitedHealthcare, released a statement regarding its history of claim denial. "Highly inaccurate and grossly misleading information has been circulated about our company's treatment of insurance claims," the statement read.
"UnitedHealthcare approves and pays about 90 per cent of medical claims upon submission."
Dr Elizabeth Potter (pictured, centre) says she is one of the last independent specialists in the Texas and services almost 40 per cent of people with breast cancer in the state. Credit: Javafilms Breast reconstruction specialist Dr Elizabeth Potter believes insurance companies are increasingly fighting "obscene" life-threatening conditions with "technicalities and turns of phrase". The Texas-based expert employs two full-time staff to build medical case files and chase insurance approvals for her patients. "I think we're all figuring out in the United States that navigating insurance feels like we're unravelling a scam," she said.
"We've been paying into a system that isn't there when we need it."
Deny, delay, defend The US is the only developed country without access to universal healthcare, according to the independent researcher The Commonwealth Fund. Instead, the system is underpinned by public and private health insurance, which may cover some or all of someone's medical expenses. In Australia by contrast, Medicare and the public hospital system provides free or subsidised access to most healthcare services.
The US Census Bureau reported that 92 per cent of people in the US had insurance for some or all of 2023. Yet surveys from that year have also found that up to 42 per cent of US adults with private insurance skipped medical care due to cost.
For decades, the Mangione name was associated with affluence. The family made a fortune in real estate in Baltimore's Little Italy but have since retreated from public life. Credit: Javafilms New York lawyer Steven Cohen has specialised in class action lawsuits against insurance companies for the past 15 years. He alleges health insurers often employ a similar tactic to the words found on Mangione's fatal bullet: deny, delay, defend. "Maybe the condition will go away. Maybe some cheaper tests emerge … Too often, people die as a result of a delay of diagnosis and treatment," he said. While Cohen calls himself a "capitalist" he also believes the US healthcare system isn't fit for purpose. "Insurance companies are private companies that are responsible for their shareholders, not to their members who get the insurance but to their shareholders to maximise profits."
Medical debt is a leading cause of personal bankruptcy in the US. About 6 per cent of adults owe over US$1,000 ($1,600) and 1 per cent of the population have more than US$10,000 ($16,000) in debt due to health costs.
'Free Luigi' protests have been taking place across the US for months. It's expected a crowd of supporters will gather in New York for Mangione's 16 September court appearance. Credit: Javafilms As Mangione prepares for his upcoming court appearance in September, his face continues to be plastered on mugs, T-shirts and flags. Sarah continues to fight her own battle. Thankfully, after three months without treatment, she has resumed chemotherapy. She says a private foundation was moved by her story and offered to cover her medical costs. "I've heard of people losing everything just to pay for their cancer treatment," she said.
"But I've also heard of people just giving up … not treating it and stopping treatment."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
2 hours ago
- ABC News
New research links hundreds more deaths to major bushfires in Los Angeles and Hawaii
Poor air quality, health care delays and a surge in suicides have been blamed for hundreds of deaths following large-scale bushfires in Los Angeles and Hawaii. That's according to three separate reports released this week by the scientific journal JAMA. The number of suicide and overdose deaths in Hawaii jumped by 46 per cent in August 2023, when fires spread across the island of Maui, according to one report. Those fires burned more than 2,200 structures and killed more than 100 people directly. Lung problems and mental health issues also increased following the disaster, according to separate research. A third paper looking into the Los Angeles wildfires in January found 440 deaths — compared to the official death toll of 30 — could be attributed to the destruction. Researchers from Boston University's Department of Global Health compared the expected weekly death rate for LA to the actual tally. They found the additional deaths likely reflected a combination of factors, including "increased exposure to poor air quality" and health care delays. The Palisades fire in California sparked up during heavy winds on January 7, ripping through the affluent LA neighbourhood. It killed at least 12 people and damaged nearly 8,000 homes, businesses and other structures. The same day, a second fire started in the eastern suburb of Altadena, killing another 17 and destroying or damaging more than 10,000 buildings. Other fires ignited across the area in the following days and weeks. The new study out of Boston University looked at the excess deaths in Los Angeles County from January 5 to February 1. For each week, they compared the expected deaths and the actual number of deaths in the area. The weekly deaths "consistently exceeded" the expected amount — with a total 6,371 deaths in that time compared to the expected 5,931. This meant, they concluded, an excess of 440 people died during the wildfires. "The findings … highlight the need for improved mortality surveillance during and after wildfire emergencies." Co-author Dr Andrew Stokes said researchers had suspected the official death toll after the fires was likely a "severe under-count". "We used an excess mortality modelling framework to obtain estimates of the wildfires on all-cause mortality," he said. "[This included] deaths associated with exposure to toxic chemicals in wildfire smoke and deaths associated with health care interruptions and delays. "These gaps are commonly found in research comparing mortality estimates to official death tolls associated with natural disasters. He added future research should investigate additional cause of death data, hospital records and administrative claims to narrow down the specific reasons for extra deaths. In August 2023, a series of wildfires broke out across the island of Maui in Hawaii. Like the Los Angeles fires, these were sparked by dry conditions and extreme winds. Four separate fires burned for weeks across the area, killing at least 102 people and destroying thousands of homes. In the wake of the fire there was also an increase in calls to Hawaii's suicide and crisis helpline, according to research out of New York University. There were 13 deaths from overdose and suicide in Maui in August 2023, and 59 in non-Maui counties of Hawaii, the highest in a 120-month time period and a 46 per cent increase on all other months. The jump in numbers was not sustained throughout the following four months. "Results show that the 2023 Maui wildfires had immediate effects on suicide and overdose deaths in Maui and across the Hawaiian islands broadly," the report said. "[The statewide rate] suggests that direct exposure to the wildfires may have increased risk of suicide and overdose death among Maui residents who migrated to neighbouring islands during or after the fires. "Indirect exposure to the wildfires [like] concerns for loved ones may have also increased the risk of death from these causes on neighbouring islands." Their report noted however that only four months of post-wildfire death data was available, adding their findings were limited by lack of information on exact dates of death and migration data. The research was supported by the National Institute on Minority Health and Health Disparities. The second Maui report found there was an increase in economic hardship, food insecurity, and lack of healthcare in the wake of the fires. Almost a quarter of the 1,043 people surveyed by researchers at the University of Hawaii were experiencing very low food security. This was more than double the pre-disaster rate. "Mental health burdens were also substantial, with depressive symptoms exceeding historical pre-wildfire estimates. "Pre-wildfire mental health prevalence in Maui County indicated baseline depression rates of 30 per cent, low self-esteem prevalence of 13 per cent, and suicidal ideation in less than 1 per cent of the population." The survey found 4.6 per cent of participants experienced suicidal ideation, 26.1 per cent reported low self-esteem and 49.4 per cent showed "clinically meaningful depressive symptoms". Their report was backed by the Hawaii Community Foundation, Kaiser Permanente, the State of Hawaii and a grant from the National Institute of Health. All three reports published by JAMA were peer-reviewed. Andrew Gissing, chief executive of Natural Hazards Research Australia, said the reports were important, but not surprising. "What you're seeing in terms of those excess death statistics, we've seen that here in Australia as well," he told the ABC. "Post-Black Summer, there's been some similar research done [which found] there were excess fatalities due to wildfire smoke in the hundreds. "The implication for wildfire management across the world is that as much as we concentrate on the actual fighting of these fires, we need to make sure that we're very much focused on the public health impacts there as well. "That messaging to stay indoors, to minimise exposure to bushfire smoke [is] obviously really key during these events." The research about ongoing mental health impacts, he said, could be attributed to the "long tail of disasters". "We often measure disasters by their direct impact, insurance losses or how many people immediately were injured or killed," he said. "What we see are these longer tail impacts due to the trauma and the physical impacts of those events." Dr Sonia Angell, from the Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health said the research highlighted the failure of current responses to extreme weather events. "Each of these studies provides a unique example of how [emergency] health measurements … such as direct fatalities do not sufficiently capture the full health impact of wildfires," she said. "Climate health impacts can occur long after an event or be unassociated with extreme events." The Australasian Fire and Emergency Services Authorities Council (AFAC) said in its latest bushfire outlook there was an "unseasonable bushfire risk" this winter. The council noted a heightened risk of fire in large parts of Victoria and in southern areas of South Australia. "[There's] this concept of worsening natural hazard risk that we're facing in Australia," Mr Gissing said. "That's been driven by climate change increasing the frequency of extremes, but it's also due to our own decisions about where we choose to live and build our homes into the future as well. "That means we're seeing some people being more frequently exposed [to disasters] than others, particularly in those high-risk areas. "And with each extreme, we know the compounding trauma of that only makes things worse.'
ABC News
20 hours ago
- ABC News
What to know before saying yes to your doctor using AI
When Melissa Street's GP and psychologist both asked if they could start using artificial intelligence to record notes and a clinical summary of her appointments, she agreed to try it. "I said yes as it allows my doctor to actually listen to me rather than being distracted trying to type everything I say," says the university student from Kabi Kabi/Sunshine Coast. Nearly one in four GPs nationally are believed to be using AI digital scribes for note-taking, according to the Australian Medical Association (AMA). Other practitioners, like psychologists and podiatrists, are also using the technology. Here's what experts say we need to be aware of when deciding whether to consent to its use. Digital scribes are software applications that turn an audio recording into text by recording the conversation between a clinician and a patient (via a phone, tablet or computer microphone, or a dedicated sensitive microphone). The AI software then uses the transcript from the conversation to generate a written summary that goes into the patient's medical record or a letter that can be forwarded to other clinicians. "We've had digital scribes for a while now," says Yves Saint James Aquino, a research fellow at the Australian Centre for Health Engagement, Evidence and Values at the University of Wollongong. "But the new stuff that we have are the scribes that are using large language models (LLM) to summarise the text. "So, it's not just transcribing exactly … they are now summarising a conversation or a clinical interaction based on [an] audio recording." He says it is up to the clinicians to check the clinical summary, letters or notes for accuracy. Jennifer Morris, a patient safety advocate from Melbourne/Naarm, has recently written a guide to the technology for consumer and community representatives. She believes one of the things that can be helpful for people deciding whether they want to use the technology is to see what it's producing. "[Patients] have the right to access their medical records and decide for themselves whether they think it's accurate enough," she says. "I've been looking at letters that it's been writing for me [in consultations] and decided it's not meeting my standard of accuracy. "So, I'm choosing not to have it in my own consultations." Experts say clinicians should be able to clearly demonstrate to patients what the digital scribe software is, how it works and where the data is being stored. "If the data is stored or processed outside of Australia, the developers and users, including clinicians, should make sure that the location outside Australia has the same level of privacy protection and privacy laws," Dr Saint James Aquino says. Dr Saint James Aquino says patients "have to be informed every time it [digital scribe technology] is being used", even if they have previously consented to it. He says most of the software apps being used aren't regulated because they "don't meet the legal definition of a medical device" by the Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA). "So, what consumers and patients should know is that a lot of AI scribes are not really tested in the same way that we expect a medical product, a pharmaceutical product or a medical device should be tested. He says while clinicians report the technology's positive benefits, such as saving time and effort and allowing more interaction with patients, further studies are needed because current evidence of its effectiveness "is very anecdotal". Last month, the TGA released a new report on how it was dealing with the "rapid innovation" of artificial intelligence in clinical settings. The Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency has also developed a code of practice for clinicians using AI. Ms Morris says AI only works well if it is trained with high-quality data. She says some large language models may not "represent diverse people" and they may also be a problem if the data they are built on is not from or about "Australia or Australians". "So, if you have AI that's trained on a population, for example, of mostly white, wealthy, middle-aged people, it may not be as effective. "Australia is, of course, a very multicultural country and that is actually important from a scientific, research and medical point of view. "Because different people from different backgrounds, ethnic backgrounds, cultural backgrounds have different needs [and] respond to health care differently. The TGA says clinicians have reported that "digital scribes frequently propose diagnosis or treatment options for patients beyond the stated diagnosis or treatment a clinician has identified during consultations". "This functionality indicates digital scribes meet the definition of a medical device and require pre-market approval and inclusion in the Australian Register of Therapeutic Goods (ARTG)." It says a review of digital scribes is needed.
ABC News
a day ago
- ABC News
NFL bans smelling salts over concussion treatment concerns previously flagged by NRL
The NFL is banning the use of smelling salts during games, saying the products are not proven to be safe and also could mask signs of a concussion. The league sent a memo to teams explaining the decision to ban smelling salts and any other ammonia inhalants during pre-game activities, games and half-time on the sideline or locker rooms. "In 2024, the FDA (Food and Drug Administration) issued a warning to companies that produce commercially available ammonia inhalants (AIs), as well as to consumers about the purchase and use of AIs, regarding the lack of evidence supporting the safety or efficacy of AIs marketed for improving mental alertness or boosting energy," the memo read. "The FDA noted potential negative effects from AI use. AIs also have the potential to mask certain neurologic signs and symptoms, including some potential signs of concussion. "As a result, the NFL Head, Neck, and Spine Committee recommended prohibiting the use of AIs for any purpose during play in the NFL." San Francisco 49ers tight end George Kittle first disclosed the ban during an interview with NFL Network, crashing an interview with teammate Fred Warner to "air a grievance" about the league's ban. "I've been distraught all day, I considered retirement," he joked, adding he used them before "every drive". "We've got to figure out a middle ground here, somebody help me out, somebody come up with a good idea." Smelling salts and other similar products have been used in numerous sports for decades, with athletes from boxing to ice hockey given them after head knocks, although usage has become less prevalent recently. The practice has been banned as a concussion treatment in rugby league for years, with official concussion management documents in 2021 saying: "Smelling salts (ammonium carbonate) or similar substances must never be used following a head injury." But many players believe they can provide a sudden jolt of energy or alertness and NRL players were seen using them as recently as this year, with a number of Bulldogs players grimacing and coughing after inhaling a powerful substance in a bottle with the label covered and being held by a trainer before a preseason game in Redcliffe. Many teams use a bucket filled with eucalyptus oil and hot water, covered with a towel, with players taking a whiff before games. Melbourne halfback Jahrome Hughes said the vapour "gives you that buzz" on an episode of the 167 Podcast he hosts with Storm teammates Ryan Papenhuyzen and Cameron Munster. They tried smelling salts in the episode to hilarious effect, with Papenhuyzen joking he felt like he had been pepper-sprayed. "I don't know if I could do that before a game," Hughes said. The NFL's memo explicitly prohibits any club personnel from providing or supplying products such as ammonia capsules, inhalers, ammonia in a cup, or any form of smelling salts. A 2023 study titled Ammonia Inhalants: Use, Misuses, and Role in Sports Performance by orthopaedic sports medicine experts from the University of Washington and Columbia University found the treatment could boost an athlete's heart rate and increase stamina, "only during repeated bouts of high-intensity exercise". "In contrast, there is no performance benefit to ammonia inhalants in a short burst of maximal effort despite elevated arousal and an associated perception of performance enhancement," the research from Dr Joshua Bender and Dr Charles Popkin found. "Importantly, ammonia inhalants have no role in medical management of head injuries, as they have the potential to exacerbate an underlying brain injury due to the involuntary withdrawal reflex associated with ammonia inhalation. "Furthermore, the signs and symptoms of a concussion or more threatening head injury may be masked by ammonia inhalation and lead to continued participation in competition, causing additional harm." The NRL and AFL have been contacted for comment. ABC/AP
