John Swinney: Labour are ruling out all options to reduce energy bills
Octopus Energy has repeatedly said the model – which would have split the UK into price regions based on proximity to energy generation – would have given Scots some of the cheapest energy in Europe because of its abundance of renewables.
But the Scottish Government has appeared reluctant to fight back against the plans being scrapped.
READ MORE: Brian Leishman makes statement after suspension from Labour
Asked why, the First Minister was adamant: 'The question isn't for me, it's for the Labour Government.'
Speaking at a media appearance in Glasgow on Wednesday, he said: 'The Labour government promised to lower people's energy bills by 300 pounds and they're now up by about 150, and they've just turned their back on zonal pricing.
'So the question isn't for me, it's for the Labour government. What are they doing? They've got the power to reduce energy bills. What are they doing about it?'
Pressed on whether this means he would support the UK Government bringing in zonal pricing, Swinney responded: 'What I'm seeing is that the Labour Government has made a promise to reduce energy bills and the question is for them to answer how they're going to do it now they're ruling out all the options.
'It's up to the UK Government to set out how they're going to lower people's fuel prices. When they've turned their back on opportunities to do so, it's for them to answer.'
(Image: Colin Mearns)
Labour energy minister Michael Shanks (above), speaking after the zonal pricing decision last week, admitted there could have been a bill discount for Scots but said it wasn't worth the "trade off".
"If you look purely at one point in time, and look at an analysis of what would have happened to household bills, there would have been a discount in Scotland because we've got a significant amount of renewable energy at the moment,' he told the Daily Record.
"But the other side of that equation is that it would hamper the investment that would be coming in to build that clean power infrastructure in the first place.
"So you've got to have a trade-off here, where there is a theoretical benefit of bill discounts years down the line, but probably an increase in bills in the short term.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
North Wales Chronicle
29 minutes ago
- North Wales Chronicle
Hotel tycoon unveils rival Heathrow expansion plan with shorter third runway
The billionaire's Arora Group said the 'primary benefit' of the plan it submitted to the Government is a shorter new runway which would avoid the costly and disruptive need to divert the M25 motorway. Building a 2,800-metre third runway instead of the full-length 3,500-metre runway planned by the airport would result in 'reduced risk' and avoid 'spiralling cost', the company said. A shorter runway could have limits on its use, although Arora Group insisted it would be able to accommodate aircraft of all sizes. Arora Group's Heathrow West proposal states the new runway could be fully operational by 2035, while a new terminal would open in two phases, in 2036 and 2040. The plan, developed with infrastructure company Bechtel, has a cost estimate of under £25 billion, not including the redevelopment of the airport's existing central area. Mr Arora, who is one of the largest landowners at Heathrow, said: 'After a decade working with our world-leading design and delivery team, I am very proud that the Arora Group can finally unveil to the UK Government our Heathrow West proposal, which directly meets and supports the United Kingdom's primary objective of unlocking economic growth at the UK's only hub airport, with a strong commitment of doing so on-budget and on-time. 'The Arora Group has a proven track record of delivering on-time and on-budget projects including in and around Heathrow airport. 'We are delighted that the Government has taken a common-sense approach to invite proposals from all interested parties for the very first time rather than granting exclusivity to the current airport operator, no matter its track record.' Mr Arora has repeatedly accused the airport of wasting money. In December 2024, French company Ardian completed a deal to become Heathrow's largest shareholder with a 23% stake, while Saudi Arabia's sovereign wealth fund purchased a 15% share. Chancellor Rachel Reeves gave her backing for a third runway in a speech on growth in January. Heathrow will submit its own expansion plan to the Government on Thursday. Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander will then review the Airports National Policy Statement, which provides the basis for decision-making on any Development Consent Order application. Heathrow is understood to be open to a discussion with airlines about building a shorter runway if it can deliver the same benefits. The airport declined to comment on the Arora Group's proposal.
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Doctor turned Labor MP and self-described Israel ally condemns Netanyahu government
The final speaker on Wednesday's motion calling Israel's blockade of Gaza a breach of international law was Labor senator Michelle Ananda-Rajah. A doctor-turned-politician who visited Israel during her first term as a Labor MP in the previous parliament, Ananda-Rajah describes herself as an 'ally of Israel' and says she will not 'rubber stamp what the Netanyahu government is doing'. 'Right now, the people of Gaza are suffering,' Ananda-Rajah said. 'There is a humanitarian catastrophe. There are no words left any more in our lexicon to describe what is going on there'
South Wales Guardian
an hour ago
- South Wales Guardian
Hotel tycoon unveils rival Heathrow expansion plan with shorter third runway
The billionaire's Arora Group said the 'primary benefit' of the plan it submitted to the Government is a shorter new runway which would avoid the costly and disruptive need to divert the M25 motorway. Building a 2,800-metre third runway instead of the full-length 3,500-metre runway planned by the airport would result in 'reduced risk' and avoid 'spiralling cost', the company said. A shorter runway could have limits on its use, although Arora Group insisted it would be able to accommodate aircraft of all sizes. Arora Group's Heathrow West proposal states the new runway could be fully operational by 2035, while a new terminal would open in two phases, in 2036 and 2040. The plan, developed with infrastructure company Bechtel, has a cost estimate of under £25 billion, not including the redevelopment of the airport's existing central area. Mr Arora, who is one of the largest landowners at Heathrow, said: 'After a decade working with our world-leading design and delivery team, I am very proud that the Arora Group can finally unveil to the UK Government our Heathrow West proposal, which directly meets and supports the United Kingdom's primary objective of unlocking economic growth at the UK's only hub airport, with a strong commitment of doing so on-budget and on-time. 'The Arora Group has a proven track record of delivering on-time and on-budget projects including in and around Heathrow airport. 'We are delighted that the Government has taken a common-sense approach to invite proposals from all interested parties for the very first time rather than granting exclusivity to the current airport operator, no matter its track record.' Mr Arora has repeatedly accused the airport of wasting money. In December 2024, French company Ardian completed a deal to become Heathrow's largest shareholder with a 23% stake, while Saudi Arabia's sovereign wealth fund purchased a 15% share. Chancellor Rachel Reeves gave her backing for a third runway in a speech on growth in January. Heathrow will submit its own expansion plan to the Government on Thursday. Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander will then review the Airports National Policy Statement, which provides the basis for decision-making on any Development Consent Order application. Heathrow is understood to be open to a discussion with airlines about building a shorter runway if it can deliver the same benefits. The airport declined to comment on the Arora Group's proposal.
