2020 Delhi Riots: Court Says WhatsApp Chats Cannot be Substantive Evidence in Murder Cases
Real journalism holds power accountable
Since 2015, The Wire has done just that.
But we can continue only with your support.
Contribute Now
New Delhi: A Delhi court has ruled that WhatsApp chats cannot be 'substantive evidence' and said that at best, such chats can be used as 'a corroborative piece of evidence'.
The court made the ruling in relation to five murder cases lodged during the 2020 northeast Delhi riots. In all five cases, 12 accused were common and the prosecution had relied heavily on WhatsApp chats as evidence, reported Indian Express.
The five cases are among nine cases which were filed for the murder of nine men, whose bodies were recovered a week after the riots. Till now, of the remaining four cases, one has ended in acquittal while trial is ongoing in the rest three.
The Delhi Police had primarily relied on the chats of a WhatsApp group named 'Kattar Hindu Ekta' in all five cases. Multiple chargesheets also named this group.
According to the chargesheet, one of the accused, Lokesh Solanki, allegedly wrote on the WhatsApp group: 'Your brother has killed 2 Muslim men at 9 o'clock.'
Solanki's questioning had led to the arrest of other persons, who were eventually accused of the nine murders.
'Such posts may be put in the group solely with the intention of becoming a hero in the estimation of other members of the group. It could be a boast, without truth. Therefore, the relied upon chats cannot be substantive evidence to show that the accused… had actually killed two Muslim persons. These chats at the most could be used as a corroborative piece of evidence,' said additional sessions judge Pulastya Pramachala of Karkardooma Court while acquitting the accused.
Earlier, the court had said in another judgement on April 30 that in connection with a case pertaining to the murder of one Hashim Ali, there were no eyewitnesses to the murder, and subsequently acquitted 12 accused.
'They (WhatsApp chats) cannot form the sole basis for conviction due to their inherent weaknesses and they must be supported by independent, reliable evidence,' the court had said.
It added that except for one witness, no one else claimed to have seen the incident.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
31 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Prince of Arcot Nawab Mohammed Abdul Ali urges CM Stalin to appoint Chief Kazi
The Prince of Arcot Nawab Mohammed Abdul Ali, on Wednesday appealed to Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M.K. Stalin to appoint a new Chief Kazi to the State government following the recent death of incumbent Mufti Salahuddin Mohammed Ayub. Highlighting the community's concern, Mr. Ali said the absence of a Chief Kazi for the past three months has caused considerable difficulties for the Muslim community. The role of the Chief Kazi is of vital importance, as it involves solemnising marriages, issuing fatwas and carrying out various responsibilities connected with Islamic Shariah. Traditionally, the position of Chief Kazi has been held within the same family since its inception and that Maulana Mohammed Akbar, son-in-law of the late Chief Kazi, had been trained and prepared in all aspects of Islamic Shariah, makes him well qualified to assume the role. Mr. Ali urged the Chief Minister to appoint Maulana Mohammed Akbar as the Chief Kazi of the State government at the earliest, in the interest of the community and the continuity of this important office.
Indian Express
an hour ago
- Indian Express
Two from Maharashtra arrested in Rs 77-lakh digital arrest scam
The Cyber Crime Police of Chandigarh has arrested two persons from Maharashtra for allegedly duping a city woman of over Rs 77 lakh in a 'digital arrest' scam. The accused have been identified as Sajid Ahmed A Patel (30), and Shayeed Rafiq Mullah (37), who have been booked in a FIR registered on July 15, at the police station in Cyber Crime, Chandigarh. According to the complaint, the victim received a call on July 10 from a fraudster posing as a crime branch official, who alleged her Aadhaar Card had been misused in a money laundering case linked to Jet Airways CEO Naresh Goyal. The caller, along with accomplices posing as police officers, intimidated her with fake arrest warrants and forged Supreme Court orders over WhatsApp calls. Fearing arrest and threats to her family, she transferred Rs 77,42,420, via four RTGS transactions from her accounts in Canara Bank, PNB, SBI, and HDFC. The police traced the trail through bank KYC and telecom data, identifying Patel's role. On August 14, a police team raided locations in Maharashtra, arresting Patel and recovering a Vivo mobile phone with SIMs, a PAN card, and an SBI ATM card. Based on his disclosure, police arrested Shayeed Mullah and recovered two Samsung Fold 5 phones, an Oppo phone, Aadhaar and PAN cards, a Federal Bank ATM card, and a driving licence. Police have secured a lien amount of Rs 20,16,300 in the accused bank accounts. Custody has been sought for forensic analysis of recovered devices to trace the larger nexus.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Screenshots of murder accused's chats go viral
Ahmedabad: Screenshots of WhatsApp chats between the accused in the murder of Class 10 student Nayan Satani and his friend have gone viral on social media, shedding light on the aftermath of the crime. In the chats, written in Hindi but typed in English, the accused allegedly admitted to stabbing Nayan. When asked by his friend if he had attacked the victim with a knife, the accused replied, "Haan to" (yes, so). He also identified the victim by name. One of the chats reportedly showed the accused saying, "Are meko bolra tha ki koh hain kya karlega tu" (he was saying who are you, what will you do). The friend, in response, abused him and told him he should not have attacked Nayan with a knife. You Can Also Check: Ahmedabad AQI | Weather in Ahmedabad | Bank Holidays in Ahmedabad | Public Holidays in Ahmedabad | Gold Rates Today in Ahmedabad | Silver Rates Today in Ahmedabad Nearly six screenshots of the exchanges have circulated widely. In the messages, the friend advises the accused to delete the chats and go underground, saying, "Jo hua so hua" (whatever has happened, has happened). Police are examining the authenticity of the viral chats as part of their ongoing investigation into the case. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
