Man charged in hate crime attack on 2 Jewish students at DePaul University to stay in jail
hate crime attack on two Jewish students at DePaul University
last fall was ordered held in jail while he awaits trial.
Adam Erkan, 20, of Hoffman Estates, Illinois, has been charged with two counts of aggravated battery and two counts of hate crime. He made his first court appearance on Thursday, when a Cook County judge ordered him detained.
Prosecutors said they have video evidence and cell phone data that links Erkan to
the scene of the attack on Nov. 6
in front of the student center on DePaul's Lincoln Park campus.
Max Long, a reservist in the Israel Defense Forces, has said he was leading a campus discussion about the war between Israel and Hamas, when he was attacked by two masked men. Michael Kaminsky, a founding member of the DePaul chapter of Students Standing with Israel, has said he stepped in to help Long, and also was injured in the attack.
According to a Chicago police arrest report, both Kaminsky and Long were wearing clothing that clearly identified them as Jewish. Kaminsky was wearing a "Bring Them Home" necklace referring to Israelis held hostage by Hamas, and Long was wearing a sweater that said "Curb Your Antisemitism" and a sign that said, "Come talk about Israel with an IDF soldier."
Police said Erkan approached Long while wearing a black ski mask and began talking to him about Israel, while his accomplice came up from behind and began beating Long, causing a concussion. When Kaminsky stepped in to help, Erkan allegedly attacked him, causing a fractured wrist.
Police said Erkan and his accomplice shouted antisemitic remarks during the attack.
Erkan allegedly drove there in a car owned by his father, who identified him as one of the two men who attacked Long and Kaminsky
Police were still searching for the second attacker.
Erkan's father, visiting from New Jersey, didn't want to speak about his son's case, but stood in support of his son as he faced a judge for the first time on Thursday.
"As a victim of a hate crime, and a heinous hate crime, the biggest challenge is not looking over my shoulder, wondering, 'Hey, is my safety going to be at risk?'" Kaminsky said.
Kaminsky said the attack left him with a fractured wrist.
Long suffered a concussion in the attack and might require surgery.
"It's definitely a process. It's a with the physical injuries; but also the, you know, the psychological side," Long said.
Prosecutors said phone call data shows Erkan shared three calls with the other attacker on the day of the incident, and video shows video Erkan getting out of a silver Toyota Rav4 without a mask after traveling to DePaul's campus from Hoffman Estates. The other attacker came from Tinley Park.
Defense attorneys said Erkan is a student at Triton College, where he is studying cybersecurity and a few credits short of graduation.
Attorneys said Erkan does not have a previous criminal record.
He was due back in court on April 22.
"One of the more important things is speaking out, and really making sure that this does not get brushed under the rug, because this is happening all over the country," Long said.
Meantime, Long and Kaminsky
have filed a civil lawsuit against DePaul
, accusing the university of failing to protect them from the attack. They have said a DePaul public safety officer was standing just 10 feet away from them at the time of the attack, but did nothing to stop it.
Their lawsuit also claims Long had complained to school officials about being harassed and threatened at earlier campus discussions about the war between Israel and Hamas. Nonetheless, Long and Kaminsky said DePaul canceled a contract it had with a private security firm to help secure its campus just two days before the attack, and did not replace them with other equivalent safety measures, only to rehire the private security firm after the attack.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC News
4 hours ago
- NBC News
U.N. chief puts Israel and Russia 'on notice' over conflict-related sexual violence accusations
UNITED NATIONS — United Nations Secretary-General Antonio Guterres warned Israel and Russia on Tuesday that he has significant concerns about patterns of certain forms of sexual violence by their armed and security forces, according to a report seen by Reuters. The alleged crimes included incidents of genital violence, prolonged forced nudity of captives, and abusive and degrading strip searches aimed at humiliation and interrogation. In his annual report to the Security Council on conflict-related sexual violence, Guterres put Israel and Russia 'on notice' that they could be listed next year among parties 'credibly suspected of committing or being responsible for patterns of rape or other forms of sexual violence.' The warning resulted from 'significant concerns regarding patterns of certain forms of sexual violence that have been consistently documented by the United Nations,' he wrote. Israel's U.N. Ambassador Danny Danon described the concerns as baseless accusations. 'The U.N. must focus on the shocking war crimes and sexual violence of Hamas and the release of all hostages. Israel will not shy away from protecting its citizens and will continue to act in accordance with international law,' Danon said in a statement. Palestinian militants Hamas — whose Oct. 7, 2023, attack on southern Israel triggered the current war in Gaza — were listed in Guterres' report on Tuesday as a group 'credibly suspected of committing or being responsible for patterns of rape or other forms of sexual violence' in armed conflict. 'We categorically reject all these allegations,' senior Hamas official Basem Naim told Reuters, adding in reference to Israeli remarks: 'These are certainly new attempts to use lies to divert attention from the ongoing brutal crimes committed by this fascist government and its army against our people in Gaza.' In his warning to Israel, Guterres said he was 'gravely concerned about credible information of violations by Israeli armed and security forces' against Palestinians in several prisons, a detention center and a military base. 'Cases documented by the United Nations indicate patterns of sexual violence such as genital violence, prolonged forced nudity and repeated strip searches conducted in an abusive and degrading manner,' he wrote in the report. While Israeli authorities had engaged with his special envoy on sexual violence in conflict over the past year, Guterres said 'limited information has been provided on accountability measures undertaken in relation to alleged incidents of sexual violence, despite witness testimony and digital evidence of Israeli soldiers committing such violations.' Russia's mission to the U.N. in New York did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the report. Guterres said Russian authorities have not engaged with his special envoy. Guterres wrote that he was 'gravely concerned about credible information of violations by Russian armed and security forces and affiliated armed groups' primarily against Ukrainian prisoners of war, in 50 official and 22 unofficial detention facilities in Ukraine and Russia. 'These cases comprised a significant number of documented incidents of genital violence, including electrocution, beatings and burns to the genitals, and forced stripping and prolonged nudity, used to humiliate and elicit confessions or information,' he said.
New York Times
5 hours ago
- New York Times
Israel Hasn't Prosecuted a Single Suspect for the Oct. 7 Attack
It has been almost two years since the Palestinian militant group Hamas led the deadliest attack on Israel in the country's history. Not a single person has been charged or prosecuted for it and the entire subject is shrouded in secrecy. Several hundred Palestinians have been detained on suspicion of direct involvement, and at least 200 of them remain in custody, according to public records. Israeli military officials have said that at least several dozen Palestinians were arrested in or near Israeli territory around the time of the attack on Oct. 7, 2023. In addition to those detainees, Israel is holding roughly 2,700 other Palestinians who were rounded up in the Gaza Strip over the 21 months since the attack, according to government data. They are suspected of affiliation with Hamas or other militant groups in Gaza, but not necessarily of direct involvement in the Oct. 7 attack. Israel has killed many of the senior Hamas figures from Gaza who were seen as masterminds of the attack. But some in the country worry that the extensive delays in prosecuting the suspects in custody will allow some perpetrators to escape justice. Palestinians and rights groups have other concerns. They say Israel has systematically violated the detainees' rights by holding them without charge or trial in harsh conditions, with limited access to legal counsel. Sweeping gag orders keep most details of their cases under wraps and for most of these detainees, there is no trace of them in any public records. The way Israel detains those prisoners 'effectively erases these individuals from public awareness and strips them of fundamental rights,' said Nadine Abu Arafeh, a lawyer who has represented detainees from Gaza in other cases in Israeli courts. 'Families in Gaza live with questions: Are their loved ones alive?' Israel's Justice Ministry declined to comment. The delays in moving the Oct. 7 cases forward are at least partly because of the chaotic way that law enforcement agents, stretched beyond capacity, collected evidence right after the attack, according to Moran Gez, a former senior prosecutor who oversaw cases of detainees suspected of involvement in the attack, and Yulia Malinovsky, an opposition lawmaker briefed on the issue. The regular criminal justice system was ill-suited to handle the sheer volume of evidence and the compromised state of some of it, they said. Ms. Gez said she retired to open up a private practice. Israel has extensively documented the atrocities of Oct. 7, in some cases based on footage recorded by the attackers themselves. Several thousand Palestinian militants from Gaza took part in the assault, according to the Israeli military. They stormed more than a dozen communities, a music festival attended by thousands of people, and several military bases in southern Israel. They killed about 1,200 people and took roughly 250 hostages back to Gaza, in an attack that, according to the United Nations, involved war crimes and possibly crimes against humanity. Amid upheaval and shock across Israel in the aftermath, investigators skipped many steps in the collection of evidence, according to Ms. Gez and Ms. Malinovsky. Some bodies were swiftly buried before forensic examination. The volume of killings made it nearly impossible for ballistic experts to trace bullets to specific weapons. Survivors who witnessed the events often did not immediately report their experiences to the legal authorities, and they quickly scattered across the country before the authorities could contact them, said Ms. Gez. Simcha Rothman, a lawmaker from Israel's governing coalition, blamed state prosecutors for failing to find ways to adapt legal proceedings to the unusual scale and nature of the attack. Other considerations may have contributed to the delay in prosecutions. Israeli security agencies objected to having the cases of attack suspects move forward earlier in the Gaza war, according to Mr. Rothman. But they have since dropped that objection, he said in an interview. Ms. Malinovsky, the opposition lawmaker, said she believes that senior Israeli officials feared that pursuing the cases could intensify public scrutiny of the failures by the government and military or undermine negotiations to exchange Palestinian detainees for Israeli hostages. 'They don't want that discourse,' she said of the government. The prime minister's office declined to comment on the reasons for the delay in prosecutions. The prison service and Justice Ministry would not provide any information on the detainees. Lawmakers in Israel recently took a first step toward putting some of those suspected of direct involvement on trial. The Knesset, or parliament, passed an initial vote in late May to establish a dedicated tribunal to try suspects in the attack. But the bill requires several more votes, and it will likely be months before the first detainees go to court. Mr. Rothman and Ms. Malinovsky were co-authors of the bill, which was meant to bypass legal hurdles to prosecutions by establishing a special tribunal of 15 judges with some capacity to override the ordinary criminal system. The bill proposes charging participants in the attack with offenses of genocide, which are punishable by death under Israeli law. Other countries have created similar tribunals in response to war or mass atrocities, said Yuval Shany, a senior researcher with the Israel Democracy Institute, a Jerusalem-based research group. For example, U.S. military commissions were set up to prosecute Al Qaeda suspects after the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks on the United States, he said. Mr. Shany said international law experts are generally critical of such special courts as they often lead to an erosion of legal standards. All of the roughly 2,700 Palestinians detainees who were rounded up in Gaza over the course of the war are designated as 'unlawful combatants,' which, according to Israel law, means they can be held without charge or trial. Under the terms of a cease-fire earlier this year, Israel released about 1,000 of the 'unlawful combatants' to Gaza, in addition to women and minors detained in Gaza over the course of the war. If negotiations between Israel and Hamas over a new cease-fire progress to a deal, some of the remaining detainees could potentially be exchanged for the remaining hostages in Gaza. The lengthy detention of so many people without trial 'risks becoming a life sentence without the usual protections of the criminal process,' said Monica Hakimi, a Columbia Law School professor and an expert on international law. At least 48 of these Palestinian detainees have died in custody, according to data from the military and prison service provided in response to freedom of information requests filed by Physicians for Human Rights — Israel, a rights group. Former detainees told The New York Times last year that they were punched, kicked and beaten with batons, rifle butts and a hand-held metal detector while in custody. Two said their bones were broken and three said they had received electric shocks during their interrogations. The Israeli military denied that 'systemic abuse' had happened in a base where thousands of Gazan detainees had been held earlier in the war. The Shin Bet, Israel's domestic intelligence agency, said that all of its interrogations were 'conducted in accordance with the law.' In February, the Israeli military charged at least five soldiers who served in that base with abuse of a detainee. Itamar Ben-Gvir, Israel's minister of national security who oversees the country's prison service, posted two videos in January of a facility where some Gazan detainees suspected of involvement in the Oct. 7 were held. The videos showed a subterranean prison ward in Ramla, a town in central Israel. 'I won't forget the murders and horrors,' Mr. Ben-Gvir said in one of the videos, suggesting that the prisoners were connected to the attack. He then pointed at three handcuffed men kneeling in brown uniforms, their heads bowed. 'Look at them now, how cowardly they are.' In late July, Israeli lawmakers extended emergency provisions that allow the ongoing detentions of prisoners suspected of involvement in the attack in detention awaiting prosecution through January 2026 — an indication that they may not face charges for at least six more months. 'This is a problem,' Mr. Rothman told lawmakers before the extensions.. 'It's a malfunction.' Patrick Kingsley,Aaron Boxerman and Natan Odenheimer contributed reporting.
UPI
9 hours ago
- UPI
N.Y. man who fired shotgun in front of synagogue in 2023 gets 10 yrs
A New York man is sentenced to 10 years in prison on Tuesday for firing a shotgun in front of an Albany synagogue in December of 2023. File Photo by Bonnie Cash/UPI | License Photo Aug. 13 (UPI) -- A New York man has been sentenced to a decade behind bars for firing a shotgun outside of an Albany synagogue and yelling "free Palestine" before the start of Hanukkah in 2023. Mufid Fawaz Alkhader, 29, of Schenectady, N.Y., was sentenced to 10 years' imprisonment on Tuesday, months after he pleaded guilty to civil rights and firearms charges in February. "The Department of Justice stands firmly against anti-Semitism and all hate crimes," Assistant Attorney General Harmeet Dhillon of the Justice Department's Civil Rights Division said in a statement. The incident occurred Dec. 7, 2023, outside Albany's Temple Israel, mere hours before the start of Hanukkah later that evening. Prosecutors said Alkhader took an Uber from his home to the synagogue, where at about 2 p.m. EDT he walked to the entrance of Temple Israel, pulled out the Kel-Tec KS7 12-gauge pump-action shotgun and fired two shots while yelling "free Palestine." On attempting to fire a third round, the shotgun jammed on Alkhader, who then attempted to rip an Israeli flag from a flagpole in front of the synagogue. Alkhader was then arrested by Albany police near a nearby hospital. The incident prompted the synagogue to cancel a concert and celebratory candle-lighting ceremony that night for Hanukkah, according to the Justice Department, which said the shooting made congregants afraid to return to their place of worship. "Mr. Alkhader's violent actions were fueled by hatred for individuals simply because of their faith," Special Agent in Charge Craig Tremaroli of the FBI Albany Field Office said. "That hatred caused tremendous terror within the Temple Israel community -- and the Jewish community as a whole -- as they were preparing for the first night of Hanukkah." Andrew Miller, the man who sold Alkhader the weapon on Nov. 5, received 14 months' imprisonment in October followed by three years supervised release. The shooting happened amid a spike in anti-Semitic and anti-Muslim incidents in the United States during the first few months of Israel's war in Gaza. According to FBI statistics for 2023, there were 1,832 anti-Jewish bias crimes in the United States as well as 236 involving anti-Muslim sentiment.
