Fact check: Grok gets it wrong on Gaza's malnourished kids – DW – 08/01/2025
"Hey @Grok, is this true?" – the question has become a go-to for X users trying to fact-check viral posts. Since its launch in November 2023, Elon Musk's AI chatbot Grok has been used as a rapid-response fact-checker for users on the platform.
In July, xAI, Musk's artificial intelligence company, came under fire after Grok generated controversial responses, including ones flagged as anti-Semitic. This came just weeks after Musk announced he would rebuild the bot, saying it had become too politically correct. Soon after, xAI promised major upgrades to improve Grok's performance "within a few days."
But now, as images and videos of malnourished children from Gaza circulate online, Grok has repeatedly provided misleading or false claims about the origin.
DW Fact check reviewed Grok's claims and found several inaccuracies in posts it responded to.
Claim: A viral image shared by many online, of a young girl begging for food in Gaza was wrongly identified by Grok as a photo from Iraq taken in 2014.
The image was shared by an X account with nearly 2 million followers, claiming it showed the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. A user replied to the post, tagging Grok and asking for verification.
To which Grok responded:Following this, Grok's claim flooded X with many echoing Grok's assessment, dismissing the image as misinformation and lie.
DW Fact check: False
A reverse image search on Google traced the photo back to the Associated Press. The image is indeed recent and from Gaza. It was taken by an Associated Press photographer, Abdel Kareem Han, on July 26, 2025, in Gaza City.
It is part of a verified set of 11 photographs showing Palestinians struggling to get donated food at a community kitchen in the northern Gaza Strip. Another image uploaded by AP shows the girl from another perspective.
The photo in question appears in agency databases with clear metadata confirming the time, place, and context. The scene depicted reflects the severe food shortages amid ongoing conflict, contradicting claims that the image is unrelated to Gaza.
Grok's claim is therefore incorrect. The image is authentic, recent, and taken in Gaza and not Iraq. As misinformation spreads during humanitarian crises, relying solely on AI tools like Grok can lead to false conclusions. In this case, many online used it to claim the hunger crisis in Gaza was not as bad as claimed on the ground, as the pictures used to report about it were either not real, or taken out of context from other regions.
Claim: A picture of a Gazan child is actually of a child in Yemen, taken in 2016. That was Grok's response to a user inquiry about images of a Gaza child and his mother shared in a post by US Senator Bernie Sanders.
Sanders wrote: "Netanyahu says there 'is no starvation in Gaza.' That's a lie. Trump and Congress must decide: Will you continue to support the starvation of children, or are you willing to use all possible US leverage to stop this horrific humanitarian disaster?"
Below his post, a user asked: "What year are these images from?"
To which Grok responded:Sander's post then got flooded with users repeating Grok's assessment that the picture is unrelated to Gaza.
Grok has repeated the same baseless assessment in other languages, including French.
DW Fact check: False
The picture is recent and does show a family in Gaza.
The images have been widely shared on social media amid growing public concern over starvation in Gaza.
The photo is available through agencies such as the Associated Press. Metadata confirms:
Yazan reportedly suffers from a genetic disease and malnutrition. On July 24, AP published a detailed story on Yazan's life in the Shati refugee camp in Gaza City, highlighting the fact that the boy does not receive the nourishment he needs.
To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video
Both images, misattributed by Grok to other crises above, were published by the Associated Press on July 29 to draw attention to what experts now call the worst starvation crisis in Gaza.
According to a new alert by the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC), the "worst-case scenario of famine is currently playing out in the Gaza Strip," with predictions of "widespread death" unless urgent action is taken. The report cites intensified Israeli blockades as a major factor worsening an already dire situation.
This is not the first time Grok has sparked controversy. In June, users were left confused by the chatbot's contradictory answers about a photo showing troop deployments to protests in Los Angeles.
According to some estimates, Grok now has around 6.7 million daily users.
As AI tools like Grok become more popular for on-the-go fact-checking, one reminder stands firm: don't skip the actual fact-check.
To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Int'l Business Times
4 hours ago
- Int'l Business Times
Tesla Approves $29 Bn In Shares To Musk As Court Case Rumbles On
Tesla announced an "interim" compensation award worth about $29 billion for Elon Musk on Monday, asserting the need to retain the controversial CEO at a moment of fierce competition for top talent. The electric vehicle maker said in a statement it will award a distribution of 96 million Tesla shares to Musk as it "intends to compensate its CEO for his future services commensurate with his contributions to our company and shareholders." The award comes as Tesla challenges a Delaware court ruling that struck down a 2018 package of about $55.8 billion. With that appeal dragging out, Monday's announcement marks an interim step while the company develops a "longer-term CEO compensation strategy," Tesla said in a letter to shareholders. "We have recommended this award as a first step, 'good faith' payment," said the letter. "Retaining Elon is more important than ever before." The move comes amid a fierce battle for top engineering talent as companies like Google and Meta compete for leadership on artificial intelligence. The Tesla letter, signed by Tesla board members Robyn Denholm and Kathleen Wilson-Thompson, described Musk as a "magnet for hiring and retaining talent at Tesla," noting that Tesla is transitioning from its electric vehicle focus "to grow towards becoming a leader in AI, robotics and related services." Musk is viewed within the business world as a unique talent after his success with building Tesla and SpaceX into major global companies. But his stewardship at Tesla has come under scrutiny in the last year as car sales and profits have tumbled. This trend has been partly due to Musk's support for far-right political causes, but also is related to a sluggish rollout of new auto models after the polarizing Cybertruck sold poorly. In a July 23 Tesla earnings call, Musk warned of more potentially "rough" quarters ahead before the company's robotics and AI ventures pay off. On the call, Musk reiterated his concern about the current framework in which he holds about 13 percent of Tesla shares prior to Monday's award. "As I've mentioned before, I think my control over Tesla should be enough to ensure that it goes in a good direction, but not so much control that I can't be thrown out if I go crazy," Musk said. Tesla's statement did not explicitly mention Musk's foray into politics, which has sparked consumer boycotts and vandalism. But the letter by Denholm and Wilson-Thompson alluded to concerns that Musk's attention had drifted from the company, calling the interim package a step towards "keeping Elon's energies focused on Tesla." The massive pay package comes eight months after the judge in a Delaware court rejected Musk's even larger compensation at Tesla, denying an attempt to restore the pay deal through a shareholder vote. Musk would be required to forfeit the new compensation package should the appeals court rule in his favor and grant him the full 2018 compensation, which at the time was valued at $55.8 billion. The new payout is sure to fuel concerns about the compensation for Musk, already the world's richest man, and whether the Tesla board is placing a sufficient check on the company's chief executive. Tesla shares rose 2.4 percent Monday in early trading.
DW
3 days ago
- DW
Fact check: Grok gets it wrong on Gaza's malnourished kids – DW – 08/01/2025
As horrifying images from Gaza go viral, Grok's flawed responses on X risk rewriting reality. DW Fact check breaks down the evidence. "Hey @Grok, is this true?" – the question has become a go-to for X users trying to fact-check viral posts. Since its launch in November 2023, Elon Musk's AI chatbot Grok has been used as a rapid-response fact-checker for users on the platform. In July, xAI, Musk's artificial intelligence company, came under fire after Grok generated controversial responses, including ones flagged as anti-Semitic. This came just weeks after Musk announced he would rebuild the bot, saying it had become too politically correct. Soon after, xAI promised major upgrades to improve Grok's performance "within a few days." But now, as images and videos of malnourished children from Gaza circulate online, Grok has repeatedly provided misleading or false claims about the origin. DW Fact check reviewed Grok's claims and found several inaccuracies in posts it responded to. Claim: A viral image shared by many online, of a young girl begging for food in Gaza was wrongly identified by Grok as a photo from Iraq taken in 2014. The image was shared by an X account with nearly 2 million followers, claiming it showed the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. A user replied to the post, tagging Grok and asking for verification. To which Grok responded:Following this, Grok's claim flooded X with many echoing Grok's assessment, dismissing the image as misinformation and lie. DW Fact check: False A reverse image search on Google traced the photo back to the Associated Press. The image is indeed recent and from Gaza. It was taken by an Associated Press photographer, Abdel Kareem Han, on July 26, 2025, in Gaza City. It is part of a verified set of 11 photographs showing Palestinians struggling to get donated food at a community kitchen in the northern Gaza Strip. Another image uploaded by AP shows the girl from another perspective. The photo in question appears in agency databases with clear metadata confirming the time, place, and context. The scene depicted reflects the severe food shortages amid ongoing conflict, contradicting claims that the image is unrelated to Gaza. Grok's claim is therefore incorrect. The image is authentic, recent, and taken in Gaza and not Iraq. As misinformation spreads during humanitarian crises, relying solely on AI tools like Grok can lead to false conclusions. In this case, many online used it to claim the hunger crisis in Gaza was not as bad as claimed on the ground, as the pictures used to report about it were either not real, or taken out of context from other regions. Claim: A picture of a Gazan child is actually of a child in Yemen, taken in 2016. That was Grok's response to a user inquiry about images of a Gaza child and his mother shared in a post by US Senator Bernie Sanders. Sanders wrote: "Netanyahu says there 'is no starvation in Gaza.' That's a lie. Trump and Congress must decide: Will you continue to support the starvation of children, or are you willing to use all possible US leverage to stop this horrific humanitarian disaster?" Below his post, a user asked: "What year are these images from?" To which Grok responded:Sander's post then got flooded with users repeating Grok's assessment that the picture is unrelated to Gaza. Grok has repeated the same baseless assessment in other languages, including French. DW Fact check: False The picture is recent and does show a family in Gaza. The images have been widely shared on social media amid growing public concern over starvation in Gaza. The photo is available through agencies such as the Associated Press. Metadata confirms: Yazan reportedly suffers from a genetic disease and malnutrition. On July 24, AP published a detailed story on Yazan's life in the Shati refugee camp in Gaza City, highlighting the fact that the boy does not receive the nourishment he needs. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Both images, misattributed by Grok to other crises above, were published by the Associated Press on July 29 to draw attention to what experts now call the worst starvation crisis in Gaza. According to a new alert by the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC), the "worst-case scenario of famine is currently playing out in the Gaza Strip," with predictions of "widespread death" unless urgent action is taken. The report cites intensified Israeli blockades as a major factor worsening an already dire situation. This is not the first time Grok has sparked controversy. In June, users were left confused by the chatbot's contradictory answers about a photo showing troop deployments to protests in Los Angeles. According to some estimates, Grok now has around 6.7 million daily users. As AI tools like Grok become more popular for on-the-go fact-checking, one reminder stands firm: don't skip the actual fact-check. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video
DW
5 days ago
- DW
Germany: Government bet on big spending to spur growth – DW – 07/30/2025
The draft budget of €520.5 billion includes increased spending on infrastructure and defense. Meanwhile, one of Germany's most recognizable car manufacturers experienced a difficult first half of the year. DW has more. The German government is expected to approve the 2026 draft budget later on Wednesday, which includes planned investments totaling €126.7 billion and borrowing of €174.3 billion. It comes with a warning from Finance Minister Lars Klingbeil that significant austerity measures will likely be needed starting in 2027.A rescue mission is underway in northern Pakistan for German Olympic biathlon champion Laura Dahlmeier, who was seriously injured in a rockfall on Laila Peak in the Karakoram mountain range. The 30-year-old was climbing at around 5,700 metres when falling rocks swept her away. Her climbing partner raised the alarm after being rescued. Officials say helicopter access is impossible. "The conditions at the altitude where she was injured are extremely challenging, and a team of foreign climbers will launch a ground rescue mission today," Areeb Ahmed Mukhtar, a senior local official in Ghanche district, said. Dahlmeier, a seasoned mountaineer, made history at the 2018 Winter Olympics, winning both the sprint and pursuit events. German news channel Welt TV is launching a weekly program entirely produced and hosted by artificial intelligence. Titled KI-Welt, the show covers topics like AI, robotics, and future tech, with all editorial processes, from research to presentation, handled by AI with human supervision. Jan Philipp Burgard, Welt TV's editor-in-chief, said the experimental show is to show what is already possible with AI. "We won't be able to stop the AI revolution, so we should embrace it and help shape it," he said. A computer-generated avatar anchors the show. The first episode will air on Thursday. Profits at German carmaker Mercedes-Benz have fallen by 55.8% in the first half of the year, the company says. The Stuttgart-based carmaker said post-tax earnings plummeted from €6.1 billion to around €2.7 billion in the first half of the year. The business cited tariffs, lower sales volumes, and costs linked to efficiency measures as reasons for the decline. Looking ahead, Mercedes now expects full-year group revenue to fall significantly below last year's level. The German government is expected to approve the 2026 draft budget on Wednesday, which outlines spending of €520.5 billion ($600.3 billion) and new borrowing totaling about €174 billion. Finance Minister Lars Klingbeil's budget includes €126.7 billion in investments earmarked for modernizing the country. The government, in office since May, has pledged to increase spending to upgrade infrastructure and strengthen the military. Officials also hope the budget will help improve the economic climate, which is projected to recover noticeably in 2025 and 2026 after two years of stagnation. Klingbeil, however, warned this week that significant austerity measures will likely be needed starting in 2027, when a funding gap of approximately €172 billion is expected. Guten Morgen from the Bonn newsroom, still staffed by humans. That's no longer the case over at Welt TV, where a new weekly program will soon be produced and presented entirely by artificial intelligence. Meanwhile, the German government is tackling the 2026 draft budget the old-fashioned way, without AI assistance, at least as far as we know. In a notable shift from its long-standing tradition of fiscal restraint, Germany is now spending big: aiming to jumpstart the economy, modernize its aging infrastructure, and boost military investment. We'll be keeping an eye on those stories, and more, right here in this blog.
