Quizzing mums over toxic waste 'made things worse'
The barrister who represented Corby Borough Council in the toxic waste court hearings says the questions he put to parents of children with birth defects "probably made things worse".
Stephen Grime KC has spoken out for the first time about his role in the case for a BBC audio documentary series released to coincide with the release of a Netflix TV drama based on the story.
Mr Grime said cross-examining mothers had been "the worst aspect" of the case.
A group of Corby parents took the council to court in 2010 over birth deformities linked to the clear-up of the town's steelworks.
During the court hearings, Mr Grime told the High Court the numbers of children with deformities in Corby was "normal" for the town's size.
He also told the court there was a danger in being seduced by the idea of "clusters of cases".
Looking back for the BBC series In Detail: The Toxic Waste Scandal, Mr Grime said the "worst aspect was having to cross-examine mothers of the children - women who suffered deeply.
"In some instances, I had to suggest to them that their memories about the dust or what the lorries were doing - things like that - were wrong."
He added that his role was particularly difficult "when one knows very well that the witness you have is an honest person who's had a terrible time; whose child is injured; whose whole family's had a terrible time.
"The questioning probably did make things worse."
He revealed that he had since read some parts of the court transcript but "this is one bit that I just haven't felt that I wanted to go back to because I feared I would find that maybe I had been somewhat brusque or somewhat difficult when maybe I shouldn't have been.
"But you can't change things after so very long."
Mr Grime prepared 140 points of appeal against the court's decision that the council was negligent, but a settlement was reached with the families and the appeal was dropped.
He said the appeal document was not only the longest he had ever drafted, but also the longest he had ever seen.
Follow Northamptonshire news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.
'He was born navy blue': Real-life stories behind Toxic Town Netflix series
Netflix shines light on true story 'that's been buried for a long time'
What is the story behind Netflix's Toxic Town?
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
42 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Secret Syrian intelligence files show missing US journalist was imprisoned by Assad regime
Top secret intelligence files uncovered by the BBC confirm for the first time that missing American journalist Austin Tice was imprisoned by the regime of the now-deposed Syrian President Bashar al-Assad. Former Syrian officials have also confirmed Mr Tice's detention to the BBC. The US government has previously stated that it believed Mr Tice had been held by the Syrian government, but the Assad regime continuously denied this, and nothing was known about the details of his detention. The intelligence files - along with testimony from several former regime officials - now reveal what happened to Mr Tice after his abduction. Mr Tice vanished near the Syrian capital of Damascus in August 2012, just days after his 31st birthday. He had been working as a freelance journalist. Around seven weeks later, a video posted online showed him blindfolded and with his hands bound being forced to recite an Islamic declaration of faith by a group of armed men. However, the impression given - that Mr Tice had been abducted by a jihadist group - was quickly questioned by analysts and US officials, who said the scene "may have been staged". No group or government has ever claimed responsibility for his disappearance and he has not been heard from since, fuelling widespread speculation as to his whereabouts. Missing US journalist's mother visits Syria to renew search The BBC uncovered the material as part of an ongoing investigation that began over a year ago for a Radio 4 podcast series, while accompanying a Syrian investigator to an intelligence facility. The intelligence files are the first evidence to surface of the Syrian regime's detention of Mr Tice since search efforts began to find him following the fall of Bashar al-Assad in early December 2024. The files labelled "Austin Tice" comprise of communications from different branches of Syrian intelligence. Their authenticity has been verified by the BBC and law enforcement. One communication, marked "top secret" shows Mr Tice was held in a detention facility in the capital of Damascus in 2012. Additional sources confirmed this to be in Tahouneh and a former senior Syrian intelligence officer, also confirmed that Mr Tice had been held in Damascus by a paramilitary group. The fallen regime consistently denied knowing of Mr Tice's whereabouts; the BBC investigation proves this was false. Mr Tice is understood to have been arrested near the Damascus suburb of Darayya, and then held by members of a paramilitary force loyal to President Assad called the National Defence Forces (NDF). A Syrian official confirmed to the BBC that Mr Tice was there until at least February of 2013. At that time, Mr Tice developed stomach issues and was treated by a doctor at least twice. Blood tests are said to have revealed he was suffering from a viral infection at the time. A man who visited the facility where Mr Tice was held and saw him told the BBC that he was treated better than the Syrian detainees, but that "he looked sad, and that the joy had gone from his face". Separately, a former member of the NDF with intimate knowledge of Austin's detention told the BBC "that Austin's value was understood" and that he was a "card" that could be played in diplomatic negotiations with the US. Mr Tice is reported to have briefly escaped his captivity by squeezing through a window in his cell, but was later recaptured. He was also interrogated at least twice by a Syrian government intelligence officer. The incident is believed to have taken place between late 2012 and early 2013. When Assad was ousted in December 2024, then-US President Joe Biden said he believed Mr Tice was still alive. Two days previously, Mr Tice's mother, Debra Tice, said that a "significant source" had confirmed that Mr Tice was alive and being "treated well". But when prisons were emptied after the fall of the government, there was no sign of Mr Tice and his whereabouts are still unknown. The Tice family are aware of the existence of these intelligence files seen by the BBC, as are the US authorities, and also a Syrian group that is working to gather information on crimes committed by the Assad regime. Mr Tice is believed to be one of the longest-held American hostages. His mother, Debra and father, Marc. have led a tireless campaign to highlight their son's disappearance. Their son is a former US marine captain who served in both Iraq and Afghanistan and was a law student at the prestigious Georgetown University in Washington DC. In 2012 he travelled to Syria to report on the civil war as a freelance journalist. Mr Tice vanished into a vast and complex system of detention. The UK-based monitoring group the Syrian Network for Human Rights estimates that 100,000 people disappeared under the Assad regime. US says reporter missing since 2012 held in Syria US military flies freed captive Travis Timmerman out of Syria
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Fire at block of flats forces residents from homes
People living in a block of flats were forced to leave after a fire spread through three floors and the roof. Firefighters were called to the building in Charlton Road, Andover, on Sunday at about 16:00 BST. Crews from Hampshire and Dorset tackled the fire through the night, with 13 fire engines, two aerial ladder platforms and two water carriers sent. Residents living nearby were advised to close their doors and windows due to the smoke. You can follow BBC Hampshire & Isle of Wight on Facebook, X, or Instagram. Hampshire & Isle of Wight Fire & Rescue Service
Yahoo
12 hours ago
- Yahoo
‘Wednesday' Season 2 Clip Reveals Haley Joel Osment as a Doll-Collecting Serial Killer
Fresh foes and woes await Wednesday Addams this August. Netflix released a clip of the first six minutes of 'Wednesday' Season 2 at fan event Tudum on Saturday — which revealed that Haley Joel Osment will be playing a serial killer called the Kansas City Scalper. 'I'm tied up in a serial killer's basement. Who said nightmares don't come true?' Wednesday (Jenna Oretga) says at the beginning of the clip, surrounded by creepy dolls. In voice-over, she goes on to explain that she spent her summer vacation hunting down the Kansas City Scalper. After she confronts him, he restrains her, then shows her a doll he's made to look like her. 'Let me show you some of my own handiwork,' she says before using her psychic abilities to free herself and attack him. More from Variety 'Stranger Things' Season 5 Gets Three-Part Release, Series Finale Set for New Year's Eve 'One Piece' Casts Mikaela Hoover as Tony Tony Chopper; Netflix to Release Season 2 in 2026 Netflix and Brazilian Tourism Board Embratur Announce Cooperation Agreement to Boost Film-TV Tourism in Brazil Along with Ortega, cast members returning to 'Wednesday' are Emma Myers, Joy Sunday, Moosa Mostafa, Georgie Farmer, Victor Dorobantu, Catherine Zeta-Jones, Luis Guzmán, Luyanda Unati Lewis-Nyawo, Jamie McShane and Fred Armisen. Season 2 will also feature new series regulars Steve Buscemi, Billie Piper, Evie Templeton, Owen Painter and Noah Taylor. Besides Osment, guest stars are Christopher Lloyd, Joanna Lumley, Thandiwe Newton, Frances O'Connor, Heather Matarazzo and Joonas Suotamo will appear as guest stars. Lady Gaga is also joining the cast. According to Netflix, Gaga plays Rosaline Rotwood — a legendary Nevermore teacher who crosses paths with Wednesday. 'Wednesday' became a massive hit for Netflix when it debuted in November 2022, eventually becoming the streamer's most-watched TV season of all time. Part 1 of Season 2 premieres Aug. 6, followed by Part 2 on Sept. 3. See the beginning of the new season below. Best of Variety What's Coming to Netflix in June 2025 New Movies Out Now in Theaters: What to See This Week 'Harry Potter' TV Show Cast Guide: Who's Who in Hogwarts?
