Details released after four die at Lake Tahoe party
The deadly quadruple fatal overdose happened on February 11, 2024 inside Adam Joy's house, the El Dorado County District Attorney's Office said. Joy, 35, believed he was buying cocaine for the party, not fentanyl. Joy and three others who consumed the drugs died, prosecutors said.
The three additional victims were identified by South Lake Tahoe city officials as: Clifford Joy, Abraham Lemus, and 33-year-old Keely Pereira. Adam Joy and 37-year-old Clifford Joy were brothers, the Record Courier reported.
On Monday, more than a year after the tragedy, prosecutors revealed details about the investigation and outcome of the case.
Prosecutors said they declined to file murder charges against the alleged drug dealer, Timothy Austin Pannell, because there's strong evidence Pannell 'mistakenly supplied fentanyl' instead of cocaine at the party.
The DA's office wrote, 'Mr. Pannell mistakenly supplied fentanyl — rather than the cocaine he typically sold — to Adam Joy and another individual in South Lake Tahoe. Believing the substance was cocaine, Mr. Joy shared it with friends during a Super Bowl party at his residence. Upon realizing his error, Mr. Pannell made multiple frantic attempts to warn the victims — placing at least 17 unanswered phone calls — and later drove through the victim's neighborhood in an unsuccessful effort to prevent harm.'
Clifford Joy's wife attended the fateful Super Bowl party. She told the Record Courier, 'They're not drug addicts. They're not even regular users. They just made a bad choice in a moment of wanting to have a little fun with kind of a socially acceptable party drug. This was a fentanyl poisoning.'
Prosecutors said they were unable to charge Pannell with second-degree murder because there was no evidence that the victims were killed with malice.
'To secure such a conviction, prosecutors must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant knowingly acted in conscious disregard for human life. In this case, the evidenceclearly shows Mr. Pannell believed he was distributing cocaine and made efforts to warn the victims upon discovering his mistake,' the DA's office explained.
Boulder Creek homicide victim named suspected killer before death
An investigation conducted by South Lake Tahoe Police Department detectives and FBI Special Agents involved extensive digital forensic analysis. Mobile phone communications and GPS data confirmed multiple interactions between Pannell and the victims on the night of the incident.
Instead of murder, federal prosecutors with the U.S. Attorney's Office will charge Pannell with distribution of fentanyl.
Pannell's criminal history includes felony drug convictions, prosecutors said. He received a three-year state prison sentence on April 9, 2024 for previous drug crimes that were not connected to the Super Bowl party tragedy. He was released from prison early, on April 8, 2025, due to credits earned through drug rehabilitation programs.
District Attorney Vern Pierson expressed concern Monday over California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation policies that facilitated early releases. 'Allowing Mr. Pannell back into our community prematurely, after 14 months of a 36 months sentence, underscores a significant flaw in current state policies,' Pierson said.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Fox News
a day ago
- Fox News
Super Bowl champion Tyrann Mathieu announces retirement from NFL in social media post
Super Bowl champion Tyrann Mathieu announced his retirement from the NFL in a post to social media on Tuesday. Mathieu, 33, spent the last three seasons of his 12-year career with the New Orleans Saints. Mathieu was known the "Honey Badger" throughout his career. "As I hang up my cleats, I'm filled with gratitude as I close this chapter of my life and officially retire from the game that's shaped me in every way," Mathieu wrote in his post. "From my first snap in college to my final play in the NFL, this journey has been nothing short of a blessing. Football gave me a purpose, discipline, and memories that will stay with me forever. But more than anything, it gave me a community." Mathieu burst onto the scene as an electrifying player during his college days at LSU. He finished fifth in the Heisman Trophy voting as a standout defensive back as a sophomore. In that sophomore season in 2011, Mathieu had 76 combined tackles, 1.5 sacks, two interceptions, nine passes defended, six forced fumbles, and two fumble recoveries for touchdowns. However, in August 2012, Mathieu was kicked off the team for continually failing drug tests for marijuana use. In October 2012, Mathieu was arrested for possession of marijuana. Despite being extremely talented, Mathieu fell to the third round of the 2013 NFL Draft due to his off-the-field issues before the Arizona Cardinals selected him. Mathieu ended up emerging as a star for the Cardinals, as he was named to an All-Pro team twice in his five years with the team. "To every coach who believed in me, every teammate who battled beside me, and every fan who showed up, cheered, and rode with me through the highs and lows, thank you. You gave me strength when I needed it most, and your love carried me farther than I ever imagined," Mathieu wrote. Mathieu spent one season with the Houston Texans, and then joined the Kansas City Chiefs. Mathieu was an integral part of the Chiefs' Super Bowl-winning team in 2019. The three-time Pro Bowler spent three seasons with the Chiefs before spending the last three seasons with the Saints. Mathieu played 180 games in his NFL career, and had 838 combined tackles, 11 sacks, 36 interceptions, 100 passes defended, seven forced fumbles, and eight fumble recoveries. Four of his interceptions were returned for touchdowns. "I hope I made you proud out there. This isn't goodbye – it's just the next chapter. Much love, always. Tyrann."
New York Post
a day ago
- New York Post
Disgraced NFLPA boss Lloyd Howell's O.J. Simpson love revealed in parking space drama
A bizarre parking-space request involving O.J. Simpson has added another twist to Lloyd Howell's controversial tenure with and resignation from the NFLPA. Howell, who left his post as the NFL players union's executive director last week, 'ordered' the facilities department at the union's Washington, D.C. headquarters to 'merge two spaces in the parking garage' over concern of potential door dings on his Porsche Cayenne Turbo, ESPN reported Wednesday. He then asked for the parking space numbers, 10 and 11, to be wiped out and replaced with 32 in honor of Simpson, according to the union's chief security officer, Craig Jones. 'I don't know why O.J.,' Jones told ESPN. 'Everyone has their preferences, perhaps.' 3 Former NFLPA executive director Lloyd Howell speaks at a state of the union briefing before the Super Bowl in New Orleans on Feb. 5, 2025. Getty Images A second source 'confirmed the Simpson inspiration' to the outlet. Simpson, a Hall of Fame running back who died in April 2024, was stunningly acquitted after being charged with the 1994 murders of his ex-wife, Nicole Brown, and her friend, Ron Goldman. In 2008, Simpson was sentenced up to 33 years in prison after an armed robbery and kidnapping case stemming from a sports memorabilia heist at a Las Vegas hotel and casino in 2007. He was granted parole in 2017. 3 O.J. Simpson at his parole hearing on July 20, 2017. AP The beginning of the end for Howell came a month ago, when Pablo Torre first reported that an independent arbitrator found that, while there wasn't enough evidence to prove collusion, 'there is little question that the NFL Management Council, with the blessing of the Commissioner [Roger Goodell], encouraged the 32 NFL Clubs to reduce guarantees in veteran's contracts at the March 2022 annual owner's meeting.' That meeting came shortly after quarterback Deshaun Watson received a fully guaranteed five-year, $230 million contract from the Browns. ESPN then reported earlier this month that Howell and other union leaders reached a deal with the NFL to hide details of the ruling. 3 Lloyd Howell in 2023. Pacific Press/LightRocket via Ge Dominoes continued to fall on Howell in a series of ESPN reports. One revealed that Howell was a consultant for The Carlyle Group, one of several private-equity firms approved by the NFL for ownership, raising conflict-of-interest concerns; Howell resigned from his post with Carlyle, a spokesman for the company told ESPN on Monday. Another report said Howell was sued in 2011 for sexual discrimination and retaliation by an employee at Booz Allen, where he had a 34-year career as an executive; the suit was settled in 2015. A third ESPN report said an outside investigator hired by the NFLPA found that Howell expensed two visits to strip clubs, one of which included a $738.82 car service from an airport and $2,426 in charges during a separate visit that included ATM withdrawals and the use of 'VIP rooms.'
USA Today
3 days ago
- USA Today
Bengals owner wants to make Shemar Stewart a test subject for slimy contract precedent
After the NFLPA collusion scandal over guaranteed money, you would think NFL owners could show a little more public tact about not wanting to pay their players what they're worth. Unfortunately, you'd be wrong. While the Dallas Cowboys' Jerry Jones showed his whole [expletive] over not wanting to pay his high-profile employees money that they've earned, the Cincinnati Bengals' Mike Brown was busy discussing two pertinent contract situations hanging over the ostensible Super Bowl contender like a wrinkled dress shirt with an iron mark conspicuously burned into one of the sleeves. I'm talking, of course, about ongoing negotiations with veteran pass-rusher Trey Hendrickson, who led the NFL in sacks last year, and rookie first-round pick Shemar Stewart, who hasn't participated in a single workout with Cincinnati since he got drafted in April. The different tenor and language with which Brown discussed both situations is not lost on me. While yes, Cincinnati still has to actually pay him, when it comes to Hendrickson, he "deserves" a raise and is "important" to the Bengals. That's a strong (kind of complimentary?) choice of words to use with a veteran player who has been holding out and criticizing team leadership since before the spring ... isn't it? When the discussion shifted to Stewart, Brown was strangely more on the offensive. He explained that the holdup over signing Stewart has to do with a hypothetical (and perhaps kind of racist with a Black player?) grievance he's made up in his own head about having to pay Stewart if he ever ... went to prison. That's not a typo, dearest readers. Please note that Stewart, to date, has never had a single major legal issue of this sort. He appears to be a model citizen. Never mind that the NFL also already has a "conduct detrimental to the team" provision in its rulebook, which should essentially make Brown's farfetched concern trolling moot. I hate that it has to be said out loud like this, but no one sitting in prison gets money from an NFL team. Full stop. Brown will never admit it, but he almost certainly has an ulterior motive for highlighting disciplinary conduct for players as a reason for delaying Stewart's contract signing. As former NFL executive Andrew Brandt posited, Brown is likely taking this path because he wants a new avenue to void guaranteed money in rookie contracts. If Brown can somehow sneak a new unclear voiding provision related to discipline into Stewart's deal, then it would seemingly allow Cincinnati to follow suit with all future young players in the same position. That's (partly) why Brown discussed Hendrickson differently. As a veteran with an established history of signed NFL deals, he's not a test subject for the Bengals owner to find a way to weasel his way out of paying his workers: If I were Stewart, I would hold my ground. Giving in to Brown's and the Bengals' demands here would not only make life harder for him, it would open the door to Cincinnati (and potentially other NFL teams) trying to take advantage of young players in a new, sinister way. It would be a Pandora's Box that could never be closed. Kudos to Stewart for standing up for his labor rights because he knows what he's worth. Have the Bengals tried to low-ball other recent players? Yes! I'm glad you asked! Cincinnati was famously in an extended holding period over Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins' first contract extensions after their rookie deals. In some ways, while Stewart might be dealing with something more nefarious, that situation was probably more mind-boggling given how productive and young Chase and Higgins still are, even now. If they, of all star duos, had to fight to get paid in Cincinnati, that meant anyone could. The Bengals would eventually relent and sign both Chase and Higgins at the same time, but not without some unflattering barbs being traded in the news cycle from time to time. If there's one thing the Bengals have mastered over the years, it's irritating their best players at the negotiating table.
