Pete Carroll will always oppose re-seeding the playoffs after a big win in Seattle
For decades, NFL division winners have earned the right to open the playoffs on their home fields, regardless of their records, while wild card teams hit the road. A proposal this offseason suggested that if a division winner had a losing record, the wild card could be the home team when they met in the playoffs. Carroll's 2010 Seahawks went 7-9 in the regular season but won the NFC West, faced the 11-5 Saints in the first round of the playoffs, and won an upset in Seattle.
That game is best remembered for Seahawks running back Marshawn Lynch's iconic 'Beast Quake' touchdown run, one of the greatest plays in NFL history, and Carroll reminisced about it on Lynch's podcast with fellow former Seahawk Mike Robinson.
'I wasn't voting for that other rule. I was voting for the division winners,' Carroll said. 'I like the structure and I like the championship within the championship. That's just part of it. Remember? Own the NFC West was our deal, and own the AFC West is what it is now.'
Carroll said anyone who thinks a division winner with a losing record can't make noise in the playoffs need only remember what those 7-9 Seahawks did.
'Remember what we did with it? Remember that freaking game? Nobody ever thought — they were saying, 'This is the worst matchup in the history of the NFL, and we were going to get murdered,'' Carroll said.
For this year, the playoff seeding will be unchanged. It's possible that the NFL could revisit the rule next year. If so, expect Carroll to be a voice at the league meeting in favor of guaranteeing division winners home-field advantage.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
11 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Giants-Jets joint practices: Day 2 live updates
The New York Giants return to East Rutherford for the second day of joint practices with the New York Jets. Today's practices will be hosted by the Giants at the Quest Diagnostics Training Center facility, after spending yesterday at the Jets' facilities at Florham Park. Yesterday's practices were a defensive duel, as both offenses struggled to move the ball against the opposing defense. The Jets' offense got out to a quick start that quickly cooled as Brian Burns and Abdul Carter made life miserable for the Jets' blockers. The Giants, meanwhile, had a shaky offensive performance, but finished strong with touchdowns in team red zone drills. We'll be watching to see if the Giants' offense can rebound after their slow start. Likewise, we'll be looking to see if the defense can build on yesterday's performance. We'll also be on the lookout to see who does, or does not, practice today. The Giants were missing OT Andrew Thomas, OG Evan Neal, WR Malik Nabers, WR Jalin Hyatt, WR Da'Quan Felton, RB Cam Skattebo, and CB Dru Phillips due to injury. We'll be watching to see if any are able to get on the practice field today. Injury updates Not an injury, in fact the opposite: We have another baby Giant! Jermaine Eluemunor is absent for the birth of his second child, which will also bump Marcus Mbow into the starting lineup. Congratulations to the Eluemunor family! In actual injury news, WR Jalin Hyatt, G Evan Neal, and CB Dru Phillips will return to practice. CB Deonte Banks (who left the field late in practice yesterday), and TE Chris Manhertz will not practice. Live updates The teams play a preseason game at MetLife Stadium on Saturday. Kickoff is at 7 p.m., with the Giants as the home team.
Yahoo
11 minutes ago
- Yahoo
James Cook agrees to 4-year, $48 million extension with Bills, ending hold-in
There was a reason Buffalo Bills running back James Cook returned to practice Tuesday. Turns out, Cook and the Bills had something in the works behind the scenes, as the 25-year-old running back inked a four-year, $48 million extension Wednesday, according to multiple reports. The deal reportedly contains $30 million in guaranteed money, per ESPN's Adam Schefter. The Bills confirmed the deal, though did not mention the financials in their post. Bills general manager Brandon Beane also confirmed the deal Wednesday, saying he was proud to extend another Bills draft pick. He added that the deal came together late Tuesday night. Entering Wednesday, Cook was one of the two biggest offensive names staging a hold-in until he received a new contract. While Cook reported to training camp, he did not take part in practice until Tuesday as he awaited a new contract. He was, however, involved in team meetings and walkthroughs. With Cook signed, Washington Commanders wideout Terry McLaurin is now the lone offensive star still waiting on a new deal. Prior to Wednesday's extension, Cook was set to enter the final year of his contract in 2025. The running back made it clear during the offseason that he wanted a long-term deal with the Bills, hinting that his asking price was $15 million per year. That figure would have made Cook the third highest-paid running back in annual value, behind Christian McCaffrey and Saquon Barkley. While Cook's new extension doesn't reach those heights, it's possible the $30 million in guaranteed money made up the difference. The deal ensures Cook will remain with the Bills for the long-term, and allows the team to retain one of its core offensive players. After inking Cook on Wednesday, the Bills now have Cook, Josh Allen and Khalil Shakir under contract for multiple seasons. After being selected by the Bills in the second round of the 2022 NFL Draft, Cook turned in a promising rookie season, rushing for 507 yards and three combined scores. He took a major step forward in his second year, rushing for a career-high 1,122 yards and scoring six combined touchdowns. He rushed for fewer yards last season, coming in at 1,009, but exploded for a league-leading 16 rushing touchdowns. With Cook now under contract, the Bills can focus on winning the team's first Super Bowl in franchise history. Should the Bills finally get the job done, Cook — and Allen, of course — will almost certainly play a major role in the team finally getting over the hump.
Yahoo
11 minutes ago
- Yahoo
'Storybook Struggles': Cowboys' Brian Schottenheimer Reveals Brutal Truth About Debut
'Storybook Struggles': Cowboys' Brian Schottenheimer Reveals Brutal Truth About Debut originally appeared on Athlon Sports. Brian Schottenheimer's first game as head coach/play-caller for the Dallas Cowboys ended in a 31-21 defeat to the Los Angeles Rams at SoFi Stadium. In what was a poor start, the Cowboys were down 14-0 early with back-to-back three-and-outs for the offense, while the defense couldn't stop Stetson Bennett and L.A.'s offense. At one point, it was 160 total yards to one, and Schottenheimer's beginning to life in the big chair didn't start the best. And in review of the game? The new boss offered up some brutal truths. 'It's definitely not a storybook beginning, that's for sure,' Schottenheimer said. 'We just struggled. I think it was 25 plays to six or something at one point, and that's obviously not a great way to start. I think Joe (Milton) was throwing some fastballs out there early and I'm proud of our guys the way they settled down, but certainly not the right way to start the game." After the first quarter, the offense and Dak Prescott backup QB Milton appeared to settle down and began moving the ball, while the defense made a couple of plays as well. Granted, it was the first preseason game. But there will be plenty to fix after reviewing the film; make no mistake about it. "You learn from it; we got to clean some stuff up," Schottenheimer added. "We can't have the penalties. At the end of the day, we put ourselves in a chance in the second half to maybe make a run and we just couldn't gain the momentum. We got to play better complementary football.' Now, how much stock you put into the performance is in the eye of the beholder, with the Cowboys not showing anything of substance, but still, some players saw their stock go up, while others struggled. Again, it is preseason, so there will be no definitive statements made, but one that can be is that this wasn't the storybook beginning for Schotty's head coaching tenure that he likely envisioned. This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Aug 11, 2025, where it first appeared.
