Social media users fall for AI-generated clip of flooding in northern India
It also shares a clip that appears to show a group of people on the roof of a building and buffaloes walking in floodwater, with Hindi-language text on the clip largely repeating the false claim.
Image
Screenshot of the false post taken on July 25, 2025, with the red X mark added by AFP
The posts surfaced as torrential rain hit Himachal Pradesh and Uttarakhand -- two states that neighbour Uttar Pradesh -- in June and July, killing at least 69 people (archived link).
Floods later affected Uttar Pradesh in August, displacing more than 11,000 people and damaging over 300 homes (archived link).
India's annual monsoon season from June to September offers respite from the intense summer heat and is crucial for replenishing water supplies, but also brings widespread death and destruction.
The false clip also spread on Facebook and X, and some users appear to believe the clip was filmed in Uttar Pradesh.
One user wrote, "No one can escape the fierce form of nature."
"Nature is angry," another commented.
and the video is AI-generated.
A reverse image search led to more false posts, but Google's "About this image" feature identified the video as having been made with AI.
The ability to detect AI-generated images is based on Google's SynthID technology, which was launched by its DeepMind AI lab in 2023.
Image
Screenshot of the image with a caption showing it is made with Google AI
Several clear visual inconsistencies can also be seen in the clip -- telltale signs that it was made with AI.
A person in white clothes sitting on the roof at the beginning of the video disappears later, while another man not visible at the beginning appears later in the video.
Wooden "charpoy" beds also appear to be at the same height as buffaloes, when in reality they would be lower.
Image
Visual inconsistencies of the false video highlighted by AFP
A reverse image search has also revealed the video was originally uploaded on July 3 to a TikTok account, which publishes other clips with similar visual inconsistencies (archived link).
AFP has debunked other false claims sharing fabricated content created with AI here.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
AFP
6 hours ago
- AFP
Major climate-GDP study under review after facing challenge
But a re-analysis by Stanford University researchers in California, released August 6, 2025, challenges the conclusion of the climate paper (archived here and here). It found the projected hit to be about three times smaller and broadly in line with earlier estimates, after excluding an anomalous result tied to Uzbekistan (archived here). The saga may culminate in a rare retraction, with Nature telling AFP August 6 it will have "further information to share soon" -- a move seized upon by climate-change skeptics following the publication of the re-analysis and pre-print correction of the paper. Both the original authors -- who have acknowledged errors in their methodology and data processing -- and the Stanford team hoped the transparency of the review process would bolster, rather than undermine public confidence in science. Climate scientist Maximilian Kotz and co-authors at the renowned Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research (PIK) published the original research in April 2024, using datasets from 83 countries to assess how changes in temperature and precipitation affect economic growth (archived here). Influential paper It became the second most cited climate paper of the year, according to the UK-based Carbon Brief outlet, and informed policy at the World Bank, International Monetary Fund, US federal government and others (archived here and here). AFP was among numerous media outlets to report on it. Yet the eye-popping claim that global GDP would be lowered by 62 percent by the year 2100 under a high emissions scenario soon drew scrutiny. "That's why our eyebrows went up because most people think that 20 percent is a very big number," scientist and economist Solomon Hsiang, one of the researchers behind the re-analysis, also published in Nature, told AFP August 5, 2025 (archived here). When they tried to replicate the results, Hsiang and his Stanford colleagues spotted serious anomalies in the data surrounding Uzbekistan. Specifically, there was a glaring mismatch in the provincial growth figures cited in the Potsdam paper and the national numbers reported for the same periods by the World Bank. "When we dropped Uzbekistan, suddenly everything changed. And we were like, 'whoa, that's not supposed to happen,'" Hsiang said. "We felt like we had to document it in this form because it's been used so widely in policy making." The authors of the 2024 paper acknowledged methodological flaws, including currency exchange issues, and on August 6 uploaded a corrected version, which has not yet been peer-reviewed. "We're waiting for Nature to announce their further decision on what will happen next," Kotz told AFP. He stressed that while "there can be methodological issues and debate within the scientific community," the bigger picture was unchanged: climate change will have substantial economic impacts in the decades ahead. Undeniable climate impact Frances Moore, an associate professor in environmental economics at the University of California, Davis, who was not involved in either the original paper or the re-analysis, agreed (archived here). She told AFP on August 5 that the paper's correction did not alter overall policy implications. Projections of an economic slowdown by the year 2100 are "extremely bad" regardless of the Kotz-led study, she explained, and "greatly exceed the costs of reducing greenhouse gas emissions to stabilize the climate, many times over." "Future work to identify specific mechanisms by which variation in climate affects economic output over the medium and long-term is critical to both better understand these findings and prepare society to respond to coming climate disruption," she also noted. Image Riverbank dwellers carry banana produce over the dry Solimoes riverbed in the Pesqueiro community in Manacapuru, Amazonas state, northern Brazil, on September 30, 2024 (AFP / MICHAEL DANTAS, MICHAEL DANTAS) Hsiang said even smaller impacts on GDP should be considered "enough that it makes a lot of sense to invest in reducing climate change." "It's very cost effective," he told AFP. Heat stress on the economy manifests through various mechanisms, he said. For example, workforce productivity dips at high temperatures, risks of potential health complications rise, while machinery also deteriorates (archived here, here and here). "The very hottest countries in the world, near the tropics, we see this effect even more magnified," Hsiang said. "Every one degree of warming for them is a much larger impact on their economy." 'Final stages' Asked whether Nature would be retracting the Potsdam paper, Karl Ziemelis, the journal's physical sciences editor, did not answer directly but said an editor's note was added to the paper in November 2024 "as soon as we became aware of an issue" with the data and methodology (archived here). "We are in the final stages of this process and will have further information to share soon," he told AFP August 6. The episode comes at a delicate time for climate science, under heavy fire from the US government under President Donald Trump's second term, as misinformation about the impacts of human-driven greenhouse gases abounds. Yet even in this environment, Hsiang argued, the episode showed the robust nature of the scientific method. "One team of scientists checking other scientists' work and finding mistakes, the other team acknowledging it, correcting the record, this is the best version of science," he said. AFP has previously reported on other flawed reports and predatory studies on climate change.
AFP
2 days ago
- AFP
Baseless posts of stranded whales 'warning about Russian earthquake' spread online
"The animals have warned us -- but we couldn't understand," reads part of the post shared on X on the day. "Yesterday, five beluga whales washed ashore in Russia's Kamchatka, which was the of today's record-breaking 8.8 magnitude earthquake. Nature always knows first," it added. Image Screenshot of the false post taken on July 31, 2025, with the red X mark added by AFP The post surfaced as an 8.8 magnitud Storm surges of up to four metres (12 feet) were predicted for some parts of the Pacific with more than a dozen nations -- from Japan to the United States to Ecuador -- evacuating citizens from coastal regions. The warnings were later lifted, allowing millions of temporary evacuees to return home, including in Kamchatka. The only reported fatality was a woman killed when her car fell off a cliff in Japan as she tried to escape, local media reported. The video was shared with similar claims on X and Facebook. A Google reverse image search using keyframes led to a longer, horizontally flipped version of the video uploaded to YouTube on August 13, 2023, with a title saying it shows residents of Kamchatka saving a family of belugas (archived link). Image Screenshot comparison of the false post (L) and the 2023 video on YouTube Kamchatka Inform, which reported on August 13, 2023 that a family of beluga whales -- four adults and one calf -- were stranded at the mouth of the Tigil River during a strong low tide (archived here). The reports said all of them survived and managed to return to the sea on their own during high tide. While there are anecdotes of bizarre animal behaviour before seismic activities, there is no mechanism that can scientifically explain the connection, according to the United States Geological Survey (archived here). AFP has also debunked other false claims related to the Russian earthquake here.
AFP
3 days ago
- AFP
Social media users fall for AI-generated clip of flooding in northern India
"Rain in Uttar Pradesh submerged many houses," reads the Instagram post published on July 4, 2025. It also shares a clip that appears to show a group of people on the roof of a building and buffaloes walking in floodwater, with Hindi-language text on the clip largely repeating the false claim. Image Screenshot of the false post taken on July 25, 2025, with the red X mark added by AFP The posts surfaced as torrential rain hit Himachal Pradesh and Uttarakhand -- two states that neighbour Uttar Pradesh -- in June and July, killing at least 69 people (archived link). Floods later affected Uttar Pradesh in August, displacing more than 11,000 people and damaging over 300 homes (archived link). India's annual monsoon season from June to September offers respite from the intense summer heat and is crucial for replenishing water supplies, but also brings widespread death and destruction. The false clip also spread on Facebook and X, and some users appear to believe the clip was filmed in Uttar Pradesh. One user wrote, "No one can escape the fierce form of nature." "Nature is angry," another commented. and the video is AI-generated. A reverse image search led to more false posts, but Google's "About this image" feature identified the video as having been made with AI. The ability to detect AI-generated images is based on Google's SynthID technology, which was launched by its DeepMind AI lab in 2023. Image Screenshot of the image with a caption showing it is made with Google AI Several clear visual inconsistencies can also be seen in the clip -- telltale signs that it was made with AI. A person in white clothes sitting on the roof at the beginning of the video disappears later, while another man not visible at the beginning appears later in the video. Wooden "charpoy" beds also appear to be at the same height as buffaloes, when in reality they would be lower. Image Visual inconsistencies of the false video highlighted by AFP A reverse image search has also revealed the video was originally uploaded on July 3 to a TikTok account, which publishes other clips with similar visual inconsistencies (archived link). AFP has debunked other false claims sharing fabricated content created with AI here.
