Bruce Lehrmann tries to shut down rape trial amid police conduct claims
Lehrmann, 30, is accused of raping a woman twice during the morning of October 10, 2021 after they met at a strip club the previous night in Toowoomba, west of Brisbane.
Defence lawyer Zali Burrows filed an application in Toowoomba District Court on Monday seeking a permanent stay in Lehrmann's pending trial.
In court documents seen by AAP, Burrows sought a 'declaration that intercepted calls between Lehrmann's lawyers and Queensland Police (were) illegally obtained'.
Burrows' application was in response to an affidavit by Peter Blake-Segovia, a practice manager at the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions' Toowoomba chambers.
The affidavit stated police had possession of four audio recordings of calls between a detective and Lehrmann's previous lawyers.
Blake-Segovia stated he had emailed the arresting officer in Lehrmann's case, Detective Senior Constable Ashlee Ryder, concerning material in the case.
'Can you please confirm whether a copy of anything that is relevant to the proceeding? has been disclosed?' Blake-Segovia emailed on June 17.
In the court affidavit, Blake-Segovia stated Detective Ryder had 'outlined items that were in her possession that were not provided as part of the brief to the Director of Public Prosecutions'.
The items included 'four audio recordings between the arresting officer and (Lehrmann's) previous legal representatives'.
'I will review the contents of the material to ascertain whether they ought to be disclosed,' Blake-Segovia stated to the court.
In Queensland, it is generally lawful for a person to record a phone conversation without the consent of the other people on the call.
However, Lehrmann — a former ministerial staffer to Liberal senator Linda Reynolds — has ongoing legal matters in NSW and Tasmania, where it is generally illegal to record a phone conversation without consent.
The alleged victim previously told Toowoomba Magistrates Court she consumed cocaine with Lehrmann during a night out before consensual sex at about 4am.
The woman said she was woken about 10am by Lehrmann sexually assaulting her.
Lehrmann's former defence barrister, Andrew Hoare, said at a prior hearing the alleged victim was too intoxicated to remember giving consent and Lehrmann could have mistakenly believed he had consent.
Burrows on Monday also applied for a declaration that Queensland Police did not have the discretion to determine what is relevant to the defence case and must disclose all materials.
Blake-Segovia stated to the court that police held items, in addition to the phone call recordings, that had not been disclosed.
SnapChat messaging app.
The Ipswich District Court is due to hear Burrows' application on Wednesday.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
10 hours ago
- ABC News
Queensland police charge fourth and fifth man with murder, kidnapping over death of 52-year-old man in January
Queensland police have charged two additional men with murder following an alleged assault and kidnapping at gunpoint in Brisbane earlier this year which left a 52-year-old man dead. The additional arrests takes the total number of people charged over the incident to five. Police said all five alleged offenders were known to one another. Police said they did not believe anyone else was directly involved in the incident, which they say took place in January. It's alleged the 52-year-old man was assaulted in the evening of January 5 near Rudyard Street in Inala, in the city's south-west. Speaking to the media in January, Detective Inspector Chris Knight said the 52-year-old and two others had been taken against their will and threatened with violence by the alleged offenders. He said the group was then taken to another location where they were "subject to more violence over a number of hours" before being returned to their vehicle. Police say the 52-year-old arrived at Logan Hospital in the early hours of January 6 with "significant head injuries", and despite being transferred to a specialist care facility died on January 7. In January, police charged a 31-year-old Birkdale man and a 32-year-old Griffin man with murder, grievous bodily harm, armed robbery, kidnapping and torture in connection to the man's death. Then in May, they charged a 26-year-old Cleveland man with murder and 17 other offences including armed robbery, kidnapping, torture and trafficking dangerous drugs, which police said are now before the court. On Sunday, August 3, police arrested a 26 and 29-year-old man they allege to have also been involved. Both have been charged with murder, kidnapping, torture and grievous bodily harm. In a statement, Detective Inspector Chris Knight said the additional arrests highlighted months of "exhaustive forensic examination, intelligence gathering and coordinated efforts" by specialist units. Detective Inspector Knight said investigations were ongoing, and although police did not believe anyone else was involved in the kidnapping, hoped the release of new images may lead to more information. The 26 and 29-year-old men were expected to face Brisbane Magistrates Court tomorrow.
West Australian
21 hours ago
- West Australian
'Third world conditions' in packed Top End watch houses
Detainees crammed into cells, unable to shower or brush their teeth for days on end and denied toilet privacy. Legal advocates say an overcrowding crisis in Northern Territory prisons and watch houses is prompting constant lockdowns and making it unsafe for detainees denied basic human rights and forced to accept "third world conditions". It's claimed Aboriginal children as young as 11 have been held at Palmerston Watch House, south of Darwin, and that cells there have at times been jammed with up to 17 people, with frequent cases of self harm occurring. Detainees report having to use toilets in front of others, make do with limited sanitary products, sleep under bloodied blankets and go without medication for epilepsy and other conditions. The NT police union is concerned watch house conditions are making it dangerous for both officers and detainees. Territory barrister Lyma Nguyen says the "appalling" situation reflects a justice system that appears to be breaking down. The Country Liberal Party government has been pushing through a tough-on-crime agenda, including harsher bail conditions designed to send more people to the cells to await court cases. It is unapologetic about favouring victims over offenders and has been rolling out hundreds more beds in prisons and hiring more guards to cope with the influx. But until prison capacity catches up, watch houses are often crammed and lockdowns are constant, largely due to lack of staff. "I defend many people in criminal cases who are arrested and held at watch houses over weekends before they are brought to court to see a judge," Ms Nguyen tells AAP. Some clients then find out in court on a Monday their paperwork is not ready or there are too many cases to hear that day so they are sent back to the watch house, she says. "So people are held in custody for longer than necessary in really appalling conditions; I'm told there are often 17 people to a cell." Ms Nguyen says one of her clients was in Palmerston Watch House for five days without an opportunity to shower or brush his teeth despite his family bringing him fresh clothes and supplies. The circumstances are arguably worse than in some prisons in Third World countries, she says, suggesting United Nations scrutiny of the issue is needed. Her clients who have spent time behind bars in Indonesia and elsewhere in Asia have reinforced this. Constant lockdowns mean lawyers are often barred from seeing clients, a breach of the international right to representation, Ms Nguyen says. "This would not happen in the bigger states, especially states that have a bill of human rights", she adds. NT Opposition Leader Selena Uibo says comments by the police association and Aboriginal justice agency make it clear Palmerston Watch House is unsafe for officers and those held there. A request for Labor MPs to visit the facility has yet to be granted, she says. "I understand police have changed their shifts and changed the way they look after the Palmerston Watch House so they can deal and cope with that extra pressure," Ms Uibo recently told reporters. NT Police Association president Nathan Finn agrees the facility has reached "crisis point", putting officers, prisoners and the broader community at "unacceptable risk". "The CLP government has made repeated promises to stop using police facilities for correctional purposes, yet the Palmerston Watch House is now overflowing," he says. "It's not a matter of if but when a serious custody incident occurs. "This government continues to beat its chest about locking up more offenders but it has utterly failed to plan for the consequences of its own policies." Mr Finn says police are exhausted, burnt out and being called in on overtime just to maintain basic safety. The North Australian Aboriginal Justice Agency recently highlighted the case of an 11-year-old girl held at Palmerston with "adults in surrounding cells screaming, yelling". The agency described that as a "breach of human rights" when children taken into custody should be transferred to a youth detention centre as soon as possible under court order. Police data recently released to the ABC under freedom of information laws show 19 cases of children self-harming over six months at watch houses in Palmerston, Tennant Creek, Alice Springs and Katherine. The youngest of the teens to self-harm was 13, while there were five cases featuring 14-year-olds and all but one matter involved an Indigenous teen. NT Chief Minister Lia Finocchiaro, who is also police minister, stands by authorities using watch houses to process youths taken into custody. She's told ABC Radio they employ "a lot of oversight and controls and policies and procedures" and she considers them "very safe places". The territory's police force similarly says they are managed within a strict framework that provides guidance on the care and treatment of persons in custody. "The primary consideration in relation to people in police custody is the safety and welfare of the individual," it says. Corrections Minister Gerard Maley has acknowledged the pressures at Palmerston but says his department is working as quickly as possible to get more beds online. He says the government is also easing the load on police and corrections officers by contracting private service provider G4S to take on prisoner transport and custody services.
Perth Now
21 hours ago
- Perth Now
'Third world conditions' in packed Top End watch houses
Detainees crammed into cells, unable to shower or brush their teeth for days on end and denied toilet privacy. Legal advocates say an overcrowding crisis in Northern Territory prisons and watch houses is prompting constant lockdowns and making it unsafe for detainees denied basic human rights and forced to accept "third world conditions". It's claimed Aboriginal children as young as 11 have been held at Palmerston Watch House, south of Darwin, and that cells there have at times been jammed with up to 17 people, with frequent cases of self harm occurring. Detainees report having to use toilets in front of others, make do with limited sanitary products, sleep under bloodied blankets and go without medication for epilepsy and other conditions. The NT police union is concerned watch house conditions are making it dangerous for both officers and detainees. Territory barrister Lyma Nguyen says the "appalling" situation reflects a justice system that appears to be breaking down. The Country Liberal Party government has been pushing through a tough-on-crime agenda, including harsher bail conditions designed to send more people to the cells to await court cases. It is unapologetic about favouring victims over offenders and has been rolling out hundreds more beds in prisons and hiring more guards to cope with the influx. But until prison capacity catches up, watch houses are often crammed and lockdowns are constant, largely due to lack of staff. "I defend many people in criminal cases who are arrested and held at watch houses over weekends before they are brought to court to see a judge," Ms Nguyen tells AAP. Some clients then find out in court on a Monday their paperwork is not ready or there are too many cases to hear that day so they are sent back to the watch house, she says. "So people are held in custody for longer than necessary in really appalling conditions; I'm told there are often 17 people to a cell." Ms Nguyen says one of her clients was in Palmerston Watch House for five days without an opportunity to shower or brush his teeth despite his family bringing him fresh clothes and supplies. The circumstances are arguably worse than in some prisons in Third World countries, she says, suggesting United Nations scrutiny of the issue is needed. Her clients who have spent time behind bars in Indonesia and elsewhere in Asia have reinforced this. Constant lockdowns mean lawyers are often barred from seeing clients, a breach of the international right to representation, Ms Nguyen says. "This would not happen in the bigger states, especially states that have a bill of human rights", she adds. NT Opposition Leader Selena Uibo says comments by the police association and Aboriginal justice agency make it clear Palmerston Watch House is unsafe for officers and those held there. A request for Labor MPs to visit the facility has yet to be granted, she says. "I understand police have changed their shifts and changed the way they look after the Palmerston Watch House so they can deal and cope with that extra pressure," Ms Uibo recently told reporters. NT Police Association president Nathan Finn agrees the facility has reached "crisis point", putting officers, prisoners and the broader community at "unacceptable risk". "The CLP government has made repeated promises to stop using police facilities for correctional purposes, yet the Palmerston Watch House is now overflowing," he says. "It's not a matter of if but when a serious custody incident occurs. "This government continues to beat its chest about locking up more offenders but it has utterly failed to plan for the consequences of its own policies." Mr Finn says police are exhausted, burnt out and being called in on overtime just to maintain basic safety. The North Australian Aboriginal Justice Agency recently highlighted the case of an 11-year-old girl held at Palmerston with "adults in surrounding cells screaming, yelling". The agency described that as a "breach of human rights" when children taken into custody should be transferred to a youth detention centre as soon as possible under court order. Police data recently released to the ABC under freedom of information laws show 19 cases of children self-harming over six months at watch houses in Palmerston, Tennant Creek, Alice Springs and Katherine. The youngest of the teens to self-harm was 13, while there were five cases featuring 14-year-olds and all but one matter involved an Indigenous teen. NT Chief Minister Lia Finocchiaro, who is also police minister, stands by authorities using watch houses to process youths taken into custody. She's told ABC Radio they employ "a lot of oversight and controls and policies and procedures" and she considers them "very safe places". The territory's police force similarly says they are managed within a strict framework that provides guidance on the care and treatment of persons in custody. "The primary consideration in relation to people in police custody is the safety and welfare of the individual," it says. Corrections Minister Gerard Maley has acknowledged the pressures at Palmerston but says his department is working as quickly as possible to get more beds online. He says the government is also easing the load on police and corrections officers by contracting private service provider G4S to take on prisoner transport and custody services.
