Businessmen reject both budgets
After condemning both the federal and Sindh budgets for 2025-26, business leaders called for mandatory amendments before their approval.
They said neither budget fulfills serious commitments nor offers direct financial relief to micro and small businesses. They demanded substantial revisions to increase allocations for Karachi-centric development projects. The prosperity of Pakistan is tied to Karachi's, they said, warning that neglecting the city amounts to sabotaging the national economy.
Businessmen Group (BMG) Chairman Zubair Motiwala and Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KCCI) President Muhammad Jawed Bilwani blasted the federal and Sindh budgets for sidestepping Karachi's needs. Condemning the budgets as deeply disappointing and discriminatory towards Karachi, the country's economic hub, they expressed serious concern over the continued neglect and denial of essential development funds to Karachi and Sindh at large.
Motiwala and Bilwani warned that chronic underinvestment and token budget allocations will worsen the city's infrastructure, civic conditions, and business confidence.
They stressed that Karachi contributes 67% to the national exchequer, 90% to the provincial revenue, and 54% of the country's exports. Denying it fair development funds is not just a regional injustice but a national threat, they lamented. They called on both the federal and provincial governments to revise their priorities and ensure Karachi receives its due share. The time for symbolic allocations is over. Karachi's citizens and business community now demand concrete action, adequate funding, and political will.
The two leaders also highlighted underfunding of the Sukkur-Hyderabad Motorway, a key project for Sindh and Karachi's connectivity. Though the project's cost exceeds Rs400 billion, the federal budget allocates only Rs15 billion — an amount they said reflects disregard for Sindh's development priorities.
Karachi, Pakistan's commercial capital, would benefit directly from the project's completion, making the lack of funding more concerning. Similarily, they pointed to the stalled K-IV Water Supply Project. Despite being critical for a water-starved Karachi, the project remains in limbo.
Though top officials, including the prime minister, have repeatedly promised support, the federal government has allocated only Rs3.2 billion of the Rs150 billion needed.
This minimal allocation, they said, casts doubt on the government's seriousness about solving Karachi's water crisis.
KCCI leaders expressed disappointment with the Sindh Budget 2025-26, saying the provincial government has also failed to address Karachi's needs. In its development outlay, the Sindh government allocated only Rs100 million for the K-IV project and Rs15 billion for the Sukkur-Hyderabad Motorway — amounts they called meaningless for project execution.
Alarmingly, they said, this marks the third year without a single new mega project for Karachi. The only move was an Rs8 billion allocation to continue earlier projects, most of which are progressing at a snail's pace. They criticised the ongoing delay in the K-IV project. Despite growing water demand, the city's main lifeline remains stalled. Meanwhile, millions of gallons are wasted and discharged into the sea, while residents and industries suffer water shortages.
Federal B Area Association of Trade & Industry (FBATI) President Shaikh Muhammad Tehseen also criticised the inadequate allocations by both governments for Karachi's industrial sector, infrastructure, and water projects.
The budget reflects no serious effort to resolve chronic industrial issues such as crumbling infrastructure, water scarcity, and power instability — all of which undermine productivity and investor confidence, he said. He urged both governments to revisit their budgetary decisions and allocate sufficient resources to support the revival of the industrial sector. Former president of the Hyderabad Chamber of Small Traders & Small Industry (HCSTSI), Muhammad Farooq Shaikhani, said the federal budget includes digital reforms and SME policy initiatives that sound good on paper but offer no direct financial relief for micro and small businesses.
He said the new taxes on digital services and cash-on-delivery (COD) are premature and will burden small enterprises. While the Sindh budget includes funds for infrastructure and social sectors, it does not prioritise industrial zones or SME support.
Both budgets, he said, focus on macroeconomic goals but ignore grassroots business sustainability. There is a clear gap between the government's documentation drive and the actual incentives offered to small traders and manufacturers.
Shaikhani added that both budgets fail to create a conducive environment for small businesses.
The federal budget introduces new taxes — on digital services, cash on delivery (COD), and higher withholding rates — without providing simplified schemes or financial support for small enterprises. The Sindh budget also neglects trade infrastructure and offers no tax relief or subsidies for SMEs. It fails to address the rising cost of energy and unaffordable raw materials, he said.
Without practical incentives or consultations with affected sectors, both budgets appear more focused on revenue collection than on industrial or trade development, he added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
9 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Industrial zone on PSM land planned
The government on Wednesday decided to establish a new industrial estate on the land of the closed Pakistan Steel Mills (PSM) and also sanctioned the diversion of Rs2.9 billion in publicity funds for the upgradation of an English news channel operated by the Pakistan Television Corporation (PTV). The decisions were taken by the Economic Coordination Committee (ECC) of the Cabinet, which met under the chairmanship of Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb. The ECC approved the establishment of the industrial estate on 3,200 acres of PSM land by changing its designated use from steel mills to industrial. The decision followed discussions with the Sindh government and deliberations in the apex committee of the Special Investment Facilitation Council (SIFC). The ECC also rescinded its two-and-a-half-year-old decision banning the lease of PSM land to any industry, organisation, group, or individual, a move aimed at facilitating the development of the new industrial estate over the 3,200 acres. The government is also attempting to revive the closed PSM with assistance from Russia. Last month, Special Assistant to the Prime Minister (SAPM) on Industries Haroon Akhtar Khan visited Russia and held talks on the mill's revival. According to Khan, the Russians expressed willingness to finance and conduct a feasibility study for the project. The matter of pricing PSM land remains open, although the SIFC has already instructed that instead of selling land for industrial purposes, the concerned entities should issue licenses, a step that would substantially reduce costs for setting up new factories. The ECC directed the Board of Investment (BOI) to develop clear criteria and terms and conditions for the allotment of land to industrial units and private developers for the establishment of the industrial estate within one month. The government maintains that the industrial estate should not be developed using taxpayers' money and that private developers should be engaged instead. PSM owns about 19,013 acres of land in Karachi. Of this, 6,409 acres are available for setting up an industrial estate. However, the Sindh government has stated that establishing such an estate would require a change in land use from steel mills to industrial. The Ministry of Industries informed the ECC that Pakistan's regional competitors are offering a wide range of incentives to attract investment in the manufacturing sector, extending far beyond the provision of land at subsidised rates. Furthermore, comparatively higher costs of energy, power, and taxes constitute major impediments that could be offset by granting land through licenses. The ministry also noted that the PSM has accrued liabilities of around Rs400 billion and that land remains the primary source to offset these. Since the current proposal does not involve transferring ownership of the land, the option to leverage it to offset PSM liabilities at an appropriate stage would remain intact, it added. The ECC also approved a supplementary grant of Rs2.9 billion for upgrading PTV World, the English news channel owned by the state-run PTV Corporation. The decision was influenced by the context of the India-Pakistan war. Both military and civilian authorities believe the country requires more English-language channels to convey the state's narrative to foreign audiences and the diplomatic corps in Pakistan. The Rs2.9 billion will be used to modernise PTV World's infrastructure, enhancing its capacity for high-quality national and international broadcasting, the ECC was informed. The Ministry of Information told the ECC that, through its special wartime transmissions, PTV World had made a vital contribution to safeguarding national and ideological interests, boosting public morale, and projecting the courage and professionalism of Pakistan's Armed Forces on the international stage. Based on this experience, the PTV Corporation emphasised the urgent need to upgrade and modernise PTV World's infrastructure to meet the demands of emerging broadcast technologies. However, due to severe financial constraints and limited internal resources, the corporation cannot undertake this initiative independently. The government has decided to divert Rs2.9 billion from the Rs5 billion allocated in the budget for government publicity and advertisement expenditure. The finance ministry also agreed to reallocate the funds from the publicity budget. The finance ministry stated that the ECC had sanctioned Rs2.9 billion for the upgradation of its English news channel to improve broadcast quality and expand outreach to global audiences. The ECC further urged the ministry to develop a comprehensive business plan to make the channel self-sufficient and financially sustainable, thereby reducing dependence on federal grants in the future. The ECC also approved the removal of the requirement for Health Quarantine Certificates on the import and export of leather, a step aimed at facilitating the leather industry and enhancing its competitiveness in international markets, according to a Ministry of Finance announcement after the meeting. The committee additionally approved a supplementary grant for the Ministry of Climate Change and Environmental Coordination for the current financial year 2025-26, enabling the ministry to strengthen initiatives for environmental protection and climate resilience through participation in the upcoming 30th Session of the Conference of Parties (COP-30) to be held in Brazil later this year.
Business Recorder
10 hours ago
- Business Recorder
KCCI support hailed: Sindh CM says commited to improve business environment
KARACHI: Sindh Chief Minister Syed Murad Ali Shah, while commending the Karachi Chamber for its steadfast support to the province's development agenda, reaffirmed the Sindh government's commitment to improving the quality of life and business environment in Karachi. Speaking at the Flag Hoisting and Independence Day Ceremony at the Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KCCI) on Wednesday, the Chief Minister announced that the newly constructed 100 MGD Hub Canal, along with the rehabilitation of the existing canal, was inaugurated by Chairman PPP Bilawal Bhutto Zardari today, significantly boosting Karachi's water supply. Furthermore, development work on K-IV water supply scheme will also be completed soon whereas Sindh government is also in the process of effluent water treatment plants so that the water being dumped into the ocean can be utilized by Karachiites to overcome their water needs, he added. The event was attended by Sindh Minister for Industries Jam Ikramullah Khan Dharejo, Mayor Karachi Barrister Murtaza Wahab, Chairman BMG Zubair Motiwala, President KCCI Muhammad Jawed Bilwani, Senior Vice President Zia ul Arfeen, Vice President Faisal Khalil Ahmed, members of the Managing Committee, and former Presidents of KCCI. CM Sindh praised KCCI for embracing this year's Independence Day theme, 'Marka-e-Haq,' calling it a reflection of the nation's quest for dignity and justice. He also lauded the restoration of KCCI's historic building, describing it as a landmark of Karachi's economic heritage, and congratulated Chairman Zubair Motiwala and his team for reviving its grandeur. The Chief Minister assured that surrounding streets will be rehabilitated by Mayor Karachi and reaffirmed the Sindh Government's commitment to resolving Karachi's civic and business challenges in close partnership with KCCI. While addressing the gathering, CM Shah reflected on the unity displayed by Pakistanis in the face of recent hostilities by India. He recalled that when India cast an aggressive eye towards Pakistan, the nation stood shoulder to shoulder with the Armed Forces, compelling the adversary to declare a ceasefire within hours. He stressed that Pakistan remains a peace-loving nation but will always respond with strength to safeguard its sovereignty. He further remarked that Pakistan is no longer in isolation, as countries around the world are seeking stronger ties with it. Chairman Businessmen Group, Zubair Motiwala, in his remarks, said that August 14 is a remarkable day that set Pakistan free from colonial rule and must be celebrated with full zeal while remembering the two million people who sacrificed their lives for independence. He paid glowing tribute to Quaid-e-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah for creating Pakistan and lauded the Armed Forces for their exemplary response to Indian aggression, leaving no choice but for the adversary to raise the white flag. He also expressed his firm belief that Kashmir will one day become part of Pakistan, reaffirming it as a national pledge. President KCCI, Muhammad Jawed Bilwani, extended heartfelt congratulations to the nation on Pakistan's 78th Independence Day and paid homage to the sacrifices of those who made freedom possible. He praised the Sindh Government's 'Marka-e-Haq' theme as resonating with the spirit of the independence struggle. Highlighting the historic significance of KCCI's building, he noted that it had undergone its second major renovation after a gap of 16 years with the aim of preserving its original grandeur. He expressed deep appreciation for the leadership of the Businessmen Group, particularly Chairman Zubair Motiwala, for keeping KCCI strong, united, and proactive in safeguarding the interests of the business community. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
10 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Bilawal inaugurates new canal from Karachi
KARACHI: Pakistan People's Party (PPP) Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari criticised Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif, dubbing him 'Shehbaz Slow' when it comes to uplift works in Karachi. While inaugurating a 100-million-gallon water project in Hub on Wednesday, the PPP chairman launched a scathing attack on the prime minister and sarcastically called him 'Shehbaz Slow' for delays in the K-IV water project. 'We expected Shehbaz Speed [for Karachi's uplift], but got Shehbaz Slow. Sindh govt decides to initiate 'Hub Canal', other projects It cannot be that Punjab gets Shehbaz Speed while Karachi is left with Shehbaz Slow,' Bilawal added while requesting the prime minister to fulfil his promises regarding the K-IV water project in Karachi. Turning his criticism to India, Bilawal said that the Modi government has conspired to block Pakistan's water supply, likening his tactics to those of Netanyahu. He condemned India's alleged plan to violate the Indus Waters Treaty by constructing dams, calling it 'the biggest historical attack on the Indus River.' 'Karachi's people know how to defend the Sindhu Darya [Indus River]. We will confront India diplomatically and, if needed, on the battlefield,' the PPP chairman warned. Speaking on the occasion, Sindh Chief Minister Syed Murad Ali Shah declared the project a major gift for Karachi on Independence Day. He said that Karachi's federal water quota would be raised to 200 MGD by December. 'We inaugurated the project on August 13 as promised,' he said, adding that the main beneficiaries would be West Wharf, Keamari, and Central Karachi. The new canal, he said, would bring an additional 100 million gallons per day (MGD) of water to the city, doubling the capacity previously carried by the old canal. Murad said that the old canal could not transport even 60 MGD effectively, but the new infrastructure would overcome that limitation. 'We built this canal within the fixed time and budget, without any cost escalation,' he stated. 'This is a gift to Karachiites ahead of Independence Day.' The chief minister also announced that the restoration of the old canal would be completed by December, further boosting the city's water capacity to 140 MGD. He added that the provincial government was negotiating with the federal government to increase Sindh and Balochistan's water quota, citing improved water availability due to climate change. Murad said a 35 MGD water treatment plant would also be completed in September to supply industries, freeing up potable water for domestic use. Once the augmentation phase of K-IV is completed through arrangements with the World Bank, Karachi will receive 550 MGD of water, significantly easing shortages. The New Hub Canal spans 21.8 kilometres and includes 11 aqueducts, 19 culverts, and four bridges, with a total capacity of 130 MGD. Phase II of the project involves restoring the old canal, with 21.8 km of its section already closed for accelerated work. The Manghopir pumping station's 150 MGD capacity is also being restored, alongside the refurbishment of the filtration plant.
