Mint Primer: Why Sebi wants investors to skip opinion trading
This week, the markets regulator issued a note advising investors to stay away from 'opinion trading' platforms, warning that it does not regulate these entities. Why is the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) unhappy about opinion trading?
Mint
explains.
Also Read |
Mint Primer: US GDP contracts 0.3% in Q1—why the IMF still sees no recession
Sebi told investors that 'opinion trading' platforms use the terminology and structures taken from regulated markets, including terms such as 'profits', 'stop loss', and 'trading'. These phrases make opinion trading platforms seem like they are similar to regular trading platforms allowing trade in stocks, bonds, and other financial securities. However, Sebi warned, an opinion or a Yes/No prediction to a question is not considered a financial security and cannot be legally traded like a stock. Sebi does not regulate these platforms and they operate in a legal grey area. In short: 'opinion traders' are on their own.
Also Read |
Mint Primer: What IT companies' Q4 show means for investors
Opinion (or event) trading apps allow users to place bids on the outcome of an event, such as the outcome of a cricket match, the value of assets such as Bitcoin. Globally, 'prediction markets' consider the answer to the question as a 'contract', much like a futures or an options contract. However, India's securities law does not recognise outcomes of events such as cricket matches as a valid contract. Therefore apps like Nandan Nilekani-backed Probo and Sequoia-backed MPL Opinio are not regulated by Sebi. With no specific laws, they are largely considered to be a subset of real money gaming.
Also Read |
Clicks & growls: Why AI's hearing the call of the wild
Yes, in the US. Kalshi is an opinion trading platform that is regulated by the US's Commodity Futures Trading Commission and is legal for all US residents. However, other global firms such as Polymarket are illegal in the country. An older venture named iPredict ran in New Zealand between 2008 and 2016, but shut down following legal challenges.
Opinion trading is neither legal nor illegal. But trading apps are making a case to recognise it as skill-based gaming, and not betting. Last week, two papers made this argument; the first was written by a professor from IIT Delhi and commissioned by trading firm Probo, and another by law firm Evam Law and Policy. They used mathematical evidence to show that successfully taking positions on the outcome of events—such as a cricket match—is determined by a user's skills and knowledge, and not by chance.
If they can prove it, they could be recognised as real-money skill-based games, much like fantasy cricket or online poker. But that may not resolve their regulatory problems. Last year, India imposed a 28% GST on real money gaming apps. This is applicable on their prize pool (the total amount users spend) and not on the companies' revenue. Taxation has hurt many real-money gaming companies. But Y-Combinator backed opinion trading app Better Opinions pivoted to real-money gaming after the new taxation kicked in.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
38 minutes ago
- Time of India
Fintech entry cleared: Flipkart gets RBI nod for lending licence; plans for NBFC rollout still under wraps
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now has received a lending licence from the Reserve Bank of India, paving the way for direct financing to customers, though the ecommerce firm is yet to disclose operational details. The Walmart-backed company confirmed on Thursday that it had secured a Non-Banking Financial Company (NBFC) licence from the RBI, with sources indicating the approval came in March, PTI reported. While Flipkart acknowledged the development, it did not offer details on how or when the NBFC arm would be operationalised. According to sources, the licence could enable the company to offer credit services such as EMIs or instalment-based financing directly to consumers on its platform. However, specifics of product rollout remain unconfirmed. Walmart currently owns over 80% of Flipkart, having acquired a majority stake in the company in 2018. The development comes shortly after Flipkart, which is preparing for a public listing, announced in April that it plans to shift its holding company from Singapore to India. The move, Flipkart said, aligns its structure with core Indian operations and reflects long-term commitment to the domestic market. "We are inspired by the Government of India's strong vision and proactive initiatives in fostering a thriving business environment and ease of doing business, which have significantly shaped our journey," a Flipkart spokesperson said in April. "This move represents a natural evolution, aligning our holding structure with our core operations, the vast potential of the Indian economy and our technology and innovation-driven capabilities to foster digital transformation in India. "
Mint
an hour ago
- Mint
Flipkart secures NBFC license from RBI—becomes first Indian e-comm player to offer direct lending
Flipkart has received a lending licence from the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), the Walmart-backed ecommerce company confirmed on Thursday. The nod came in March this year, according to sources. When contacted about the grant of the NBFC licence, Flipkart confirmed the development but did not divulge any details. The move could pave the way for Flipkart to offer loans directly to customers, sources said noting the specific instances in which the customers at times choose the EMI model or instalment mode to pay for products they choose. However, the company's specific plans on this, now with the NBFC licence, could not be immediately ascertained. Walmart currently holds over 80 per cent stake in Flipkart. It had bought a majority stake in the ecommerce platform back in 2018. In April this year, IPO-bound Flipkart had shared its intention to relocate its holding company from Singapore to India, a strategic decision that the homegrown e-commerce firm said reflects "deep and unwavering commitment to India and its remarkable growth". "We are inspired by the Government of India's strong vision and proactive initiatives in fostering a thriving business environment and ease of doing business, which have significantly shaped our journey. This move represents a natural evolution, aligning our holding structure with our core operations, the vast potential of the Indian economy and our technology and innovation-driven capabilities to foster digital transformation in India," a Flipkart spokesperson had said in April.
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
an hour ago
- Business Standard
Central Bank of India acquires 24.91% stake in FGIICL for ₹451 crore
The bank's strategic acquisition of 350.63 million shares in Future Generali India Insurance marks its entry into the general insurance sector New Delhi Central Bank of India has acquired a 24.91 per cent equity stake in Future Generali India Insurance Company Limited (FGIICL) for ₹451 crore. The acquisition involves the purchase of 350.63 million equity shares in cash and was completed on June 4. The move follows the issuance of a Letter of Intent dated August 20, 2024, under Regulation 29 of the Insolvency Resolution Process for Corporate Persons (IBBI) Regulations, 2016. The transaction was finalised after receiving all requisite regulatory approvals from the Competition Commission of India (CCI), Reserve Bank of India (RBI), and the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (Irdai). FGIICL performance and ownership This strategic acquisition marks Central Bank of India's entry into the general insurance sector. FGIICL reported a gross direct premium of ₹4,910.89 crore in the financial year 2023–24, providing the bank with a significant platform for expansion. Future Generali India Insurance, incorporated in 2006 and headquartered in Mumbai, operates over 150 offices nationwide. It is engaged in providing general insurance services across retail, commercial, personal, and rural segments to both individuals and corporate clients. Generali currently holds a 74 per cent stake in the company. Steady premium growth Over the past three financial years, FGIICL has posted consistent growth in its gross written premium. In FY24, the figure reached ₹4,910.89 crore, an 8 per cent rise from ₹4,546.23 crore in FY23. The previous year had also seen similar growth, increasing from ₹4,210.35 crore in FY22. This represents a steady annual growth of around 8 per cent for two consecutive years. As of 2022, the company served over 3,900 corporate clients through a network of more than 36,800 individual agents and operated over 150 branches across India. The disclosure was made in accordance with Regulation 30 of the Sebi (Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015.
