US judge: AI training on books is fair use, partly
District Court Judge William Alsup ruled on Monday that the company's training of its Claude AI models with books bought or pirated was allowed under the 'fair use' doctrine in the US Copyright Act.
'Use of the books at issue to train Claude and its precursors was exceedingly transformative and was a fair use,' Alsup wrote in his decision.
'The technology at issue was among the most transformative many of us will see in our lifetimes,' Alsup added in his 32-page decision, comparing AI training to how humans learn by reading books.
Tremendous amounts of data are needed to train large language models powering generative AI.
Musicians, book authors, visual artists and news publications have sued various AI companies that used their data without permission or payment.
AI companies generally defend their practices by claiming fair use, arguing that training AI on large datasets fundamentally transforms the original content and is necessary for innovation.
'We are pleased that the court recognized that using 'works to train LLMs was transformative,'' an Anthropic spokesperson said in response to an AFP query.
The judge's decision is 'consistent with copyright's purpose in enabling creativity and fostering scientific progress,' the spokesperson added.
- Blanket protection rejected -
The ruling stems from a class-action lawsuit filed by authors Andrea Bartz, Charles Graeber, and Kirk Wallace Johnson, who accused Anthropic of illegally copying their books to train Claude, the company's AI chatbot that rivals ChatGPT.
However, Alsup rejected Anthropic's bid for blanket protection, ruling that the company's practice of downloading millions of pirated books to build a permanent digital library was not justified by fair use protections.
Along with downloading books from websites offering pirated works, Anthropic bought copyrighted books, scanned the pages and stored them in digital formats, according to court documents.
Anthropic's aim was to amass a library of 'all the books in the world' for training AI models on content as deemed fit, the judge said in his ruling.
While training AI models on the pirated content posed no legal violation, downloading pirated copies to build a general-purpose library constituted copyright infringement, the judge ruled, regardless of eventual training use.
The case will now proceed to trial on damages related to the pirated library copies, with potential penalties including financial damages.
Anthropic said it disagreed with going to trial on this part of the decision and was evaluating its legal options.
'Judge Alsup's decision is a mixed bag,' said Keith Kupferschmid, chief executive of US nonprofit Copyright Alliance.
'In some instances AI companies should be happy with the decision and in other instances copyright owners should be happy.'
Valued at $61.5 billion and heavily backed by Amazon, Anthropic was founded in 2021 by former OpenAI executives.
The company, known for its Claude chatbot and AI models, positions itself as focused on AI safety and responsible development.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
5 hours ago
- The Star
India cenbank committee recommends AI framework for finance sector
MUMBAI (Reuters) -A Reserve Bank of India committee has recommended a framework for developing AI capabilities for the country's financial sector, while safeguarding it against associated risks, according to a report released on Wednesday. The committee has recommended setting up a digital infrastructure to help build indigenous AI models and a multi-stakeholder standing committee to evaluate risks and opportunities. It also suggested building a fund to incentivise the development of homegrown AI models tailored for the needs of India's financial services sector. "The report envisions a financial ecosystem where encouraging innovation is in harmony, and not at odds, with mitigation of risk," the RBI said in a statement. The report contains 26 recommendations under six categories including infrastructure, capacity, policy, governance, protection and assurance. Other key recommendations by the eight-member committee headed by Pushpak Bhattacharyya, a computer scientist at IIT Bombay, include issuing of an enabling framework to integrate AI with existing digital public platforms such as instant payment system UPI, and designing audit frameworks. The central bank had set up the committee in December to develop a Framework for Responsible and Ethical Enablement of Artificial Intelligence (FREEAI) for the finance sector. "The challenge with regulating AI is in striking the right balance, making sure that society stands to gain from what this technology has to offer, while mitigating its risks," according to the report. (Reporting by Ashwin Manikandan; Editing by Shinjini Ganguli)
New Straits Times
6 hours ago
- New Straits Times
Swiss pilot surpasses solar-powered plane altitude record
GENEVA: Swiss pilot Raphael Domjan beat the altitude record for a solar-powered electric plane in a flight that took him soaring to 9,521 metres, his team announced today. The SolarStratos plane made the landmark flight from Sion airport in southwest Switzerland on Tuesday, taking advantage of warm air thermals to go beyond the record that has stood for 15 years. The certified altitude record for a solar plane stands at 9,235 metres (30,298 feet). The achievement is "one of those unforgettable peaks that define great human and technological adventures", the SolarStratos mission said in a statement. Domjan's flight lasted five hours and nine minutes. "I share this moment of joy with all the people who have been preparing for this achievement for years," the 53-year-old "eco-explorer" said. The data will be sent to the World Air Sports Federation governing body, which will decide whether to validate the new record. "It is the pressure altitude corrected to standard density altitude that is recognised as the official reference for aviation altitude records," the SolarStratos team said. Domjan is aiming to be the first to take a solar-powered plane above 10,000 metres – flying at the same altitude as airliners. If this barrier is broken, the team hopes to go on and make a first manned solar-powered flight into the stratosphere, which at Switzerland's latitude begins at around 12,000 metres. "This achievement marks a major milestone on the path toward reaching the stratosphere using only solar power – and already fulfils the mission's goal: to capture imaginations with emblematic, spectacular challenges that promote solar energy and the protection of our biosphere and planet," SolarStratos said. The front-mounted single propeller plane, registration HB-SXA, is made of carbon fibre to ensure lightness and strength. SolarStratos is 9.6 metres long, and its huge wingspan of 24.8 metres accommodates the 22 square metres of high-spec solar panels topping the wings, and allows for flying at low speeds. The plane can take off at low speeds, from 50 kilometres per hour upwards. Its maximum speed is 140 kph, while its cruising speed is around 80 kph. In 2012, the pioneering Domjan became the first person to sail around the world in a fully solar-powered boat. "It's important to demonstrate what we can achieve with solar energy," the adventurer told AFP. "The dream of flight is probably the oldest dream of mankind. "My goal is to show to the young generation of today and tomorrow that tomorrow it will still be possible to fly without burning any fossil energies, with emitting any carbon dioxide. "This is what we want to achieve: it's really to show that the world of tomorrow can be better than what we have today." A warm-up flight on July 31 got to 6,589 metres – surpassing the plane's previous best in 2024. A first attempt on Friday was quickly abandoned when the forecast thermals failed to materialise, saving the batteries for Sunday when the plane got to 8,224 metres. During the first phase of record attempts, the aircraft has to make maximum use of rising warm air currents to climb to around 4,000-5,000 metres. It then has to recharge its batteries at this altitude before climbing again. If the flight is to be certified as a record, all the energy used during the flight must have been produced by the solar cells. Before take-off, the batteries must be fully charged using solar energy, and the plane has to land under its own power – it cannot glide back in on zero charge – and have at least 16 per cent charge in the batteries. The current record was set in 2010 by the Solar Impulse experimental plane, with Swiss pilot Andre Borschberg at the controls. The project's promoter, Swiss explorer Bertrand Piccard, then built a second solar aircraft which successfully made a round-the-world trip, in stages, between March 2015 and July 2016. - AFP
The Sun
7 hours ago
- The Sun
Malaysia's 13MP focuses on AI and 5G for digital transformation
KUALA LUMPUR: The 13th Malaysia Plan (13MP) places strong emphasis on technology, particularly artificial intelligence (AI), to accelerate the nation's digital transformation. Digital Minister Gobind Singh Deo stated that Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim has prioritised the AI Nation Framework as a key initiative. The framework aims to maximise Malaysia's 5G network for digital solutions, including smart city projects using existing data. Gobind noted that the 13MP also introduces the concept of a data commission to strengthen digital trust. He described these measures as crucial steps toward achieving AI nation status in the near future. The minister shared these insights after launching the 5G Enterprise and AI City Grant. The initiative will be showcased at the Smart City Expo Kuala Lumpur 2025 (SCEKL25) from Sept 17–19. The event will highlight Malaysia's smart city progress and encourage collaboration among stakeholders. Digital Nasional Bhd (DNB) and Malaysia Digital Economy Corporation (MDEC) are leading the AI Cities initiative. This effort complements the Smart Cities programme under the Ministry of Housing and Local Government. Gobind expressed confidence that these initiatives will drive actionable innovation nationwide. He stressed the importance of aligning policy with practical implementation for tangible local impact. The 5G Enterprise and AI City Grant was awarded to 14 recipients, including universities, companies, and local authorities. Selected proposals focus on sectors like agriculture, healthcare, logistics, manufacturing, and education. These projects leverage AI and 5G to solve real-world challenges with scalable solutions. Examples include autonomous drone corridors, AI-powered dashboards, and intelligent transport systems. The initiatives also aim to empower SMEs and public institutions, ensuring wider access to innovation.
