Revenue will target estate agents found ‘scamming' Help to Buy
It comes after estate agent Sherry FitzGerald reportedly told a couple the price of a home had been split into two payments in order to bypass the rules of the subsidy scheme.
The HTB scheme offers first-time buyers the chance to claim back €30,000 from their income tax on properties where the value is above what they can afford under Central Bank lending rules, but only on properties valued at €500,000 or less. Revenue will investigate real estate agents who attempt to 'scam' the Help to Buy (HTB) scheme, Minister for Housing James Browne has warned. Pic: File
According to reports, a Limerick estate agent offered to split the cost of a property valued at €525,000 in two – a €500,000 payment for the house and an extra €25,000 in 'flooring costs'.
This allowed the couple to avail of the HTB scheme under a falsified home value of €500,000, The Irish Times reported last week. Yesterday, Minister Browne warned: 'Anybody scamming that system, Revenue Commissioners are going to investigate that because that is a scam.'
He added that splitting of house prices to bypass the cap was 'absolutely unacceptable'. 'It is outside of the terms of that agreement,' he told RTÉ's The Week In Politics. Revenue will investigate real estate agents who attempt to 'scam' the Help to Buy (HTB) scheme, Minister for Housing James Browne has warned. Pic: Stephen Collins / Collins Photos
The Fianna Fáil TD warned that 'people are taking very high risks in terms of effectively defrauding the system'. The Property Services Regulatory Authority (PSRA) has said it has the power to issue minor and major sanctions, including suspensions and fines, to people attempting to bypass the HTB cap.
The PSRA told the Irish Examiner it encourages 'first-time buyers who are approached by estate agents to enter into this practice to make a complaint to the PSRA'. Following the report, a Sherry FitzGerald spokeswoman told The Irish Times: 'At this point, we believe that this is an isolated incident relating to a single property.'
She confirmed Sherry FitzGerald would be launching a formal investigation into the matter, adding: 'Following the conclusion of our investigation, we will take whatever steps are necessary to ensure that such a situation cannot occur again.' In the first four months of the year, 17,144 applications were received for the Help To Buy scheme.Pic:In the first four months of the year, 17,144 applications were received for the HTB scheme. There were 5,000 more than in the same period of 2024. Minister Browne also addressed concerns about decreases in employment in the construction sector.
The Business Post reported yesterday that construction firm MKN Property Group has cut more than half its workforce because it has 'run out of work'. Labour housing spokesman Conor Sheehan said: 'We have apprentices at the moment who are still on sub-minimum wage… We need to do a huge job in workforce planning, in terms of scaling up the construction industry.'
Mr Browne called the issue a 'funny balance', saying: 'If you increase pay too much you will end up with less apprentices.' Eoin Ó Broin, Sinn Féin housing spokesman, told the minister: 'The problem isn't a skills shortage, it's how you're handling this.' Minister Browne also fielded questions on the limitations of Uisce Éireann. Eoin Ó Broin, Sinn Féin housing spokesman, told the minister: 'The problem isn't a skills shortage, it's how you're handling this.' Pic: Leah Farrell/RollingNews.ie
The utility provider has repeatedly warned it does not have the capacity to connect proposed housing projects to the water pipeline. Minister Browne was asked why Uisce Éireann has no statutory obligation to provide water infrastructure for new housing projects.
Rory Hearne, Social Democrats housing spokesman, called for statutory guidelines to be provided to Uisce Éireann, saying: 'The Government has to give them that, in terms of actually saying they have a responsibility as well.'
The minister responded: 'There is no point in having statutory guidelines if a body doesn't actually have the capacity to do so; what we're doing is actually giving them the capacity. 'We're going to give them more funding specifically ringfenced to deliver the housing infrastructure we need'.
Minister Browne was reluctant to provide more details on the funding except to say that specifications would be outlined in the National Planning Framework, the National Development Plan, and his own housing plan. He wouldn't give a timeline but insisted it would be new money not previously announced.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
Irish influencer ‘unaware of Central Bank probe' into promotion of unregulated offshore trading platform T4Trade
Irish influencer Jonathan Finlay has said he is 'not aware of any ongoing investigation by the Central Bank into his affairs' or his promotion of an unregulated trading platform.
Irish Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Irish Dad still waiting to come home two months after release from Iraq prison
It will be two months next week since 'innocent' Robert Pether was released from prison in Iraq – but he has still not been allowed to return home to Ireland. Tánaiste Simon Harris's Department of Foreign Affairs confirmed to the Irish Mirror on Friday that the family in Ireland of engineer Robert are still waiting for his return, four years after he was locked up. People close to the situation told the Irish Mirror that there could be developments as soon as 'next week', with Tuesday (August 5) marking exactly two months since he was released. Mr Pether was arrested in Baghdad in April 2021 amid a €20 million contract row between his Dubai-based employer and Iraq's Central Bank. After a high-profile campaign that was reported throughout by the Irish Mirror, it was finally announced on June 5 that Rob, 49, was being released. Robert Pether pictured with his three children But wife Desree, 53 and kids Flynn, 21, Oscar, 20 and Nala, 12, are still waiting for him at their family home in Elphin, Co Roscommon. When Rob - who previously survived melanoma cancer and now has prostate cancer - was released almost two months ago, Desree said jail had left her husband looking 'unrecognisable'. Desree, who cannot speak to the media amid the ongoing situation in Iraq, has written online about husband not being allowed to return to Ireland. She said: 'It has been weeks since he was released from prison, extremely unwell mentally and physically, barely able to walk or eat. 'He should have been on the first available plane home and straight into hospital. Absolutely horrendous treatment of an innocent man.' The family of Robert Pether said his health was deteriorating rapidly behind bars before his release Desree appealed for help from supporters and wrote: 'We need help urgently. As this farce drags on, we have to now also pay for accommodation and food for Robert. 'We don't know how we will do that for even another month and there is our own expenses with no income. 'We've been living very frugally. We have nothing left in savings. Not a cent. We've lost our car and our health insurance. 'We are isolated in the country in Ireland. This has had a massive impact on our family. If you can help in any way or share we would be grateful.' A GoFundMe account in the name of Robert Pether has been set up and has so far raised over €17,000 of a €30,000 target. Desree, who has never spoken publicly about the behind-the-scenes efforts to have her husband freed, insisted online in recent days that Rob is 'innocent'. She wrote: 'There was absolutely no grounds for his arrest on 7th April 2021. He is a hostage. Three international court rulings found him innocent. 'A UN report published March 2022 finding he is in arbitrary detention, unlawfully detained and held for leverage.' She added recently: 'The entire case would be immediately thrown out in any regular court that follows due process, right back when he was first trapped and arrested. Every accusation fabricated and unsubstantiated.' In recent months, the family has experienced tumultuous upheaval amid the ongoing struggle to get Rob home to Roscommon. Youngest child Nala finished her childhood education with Rob still detained in Iraq. Desree said: 'And just like that, she's finished primary school. Off to high school in September. Absolutely in awe of her strength these past four-and-a-half years.' Rob, who is from Australia but his home is in Roscommon, was arrested and jailed on fraud charges, which he denied and which the UN claimed were false. The Department of Foreign Affairs is aware of Mr Pether's situation and has been providing assistance to his family in Roscommon throughout his detention in Iraq. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here. The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Five things investors should ponder on crypto
A decade ago half a dozen mavericks assembled in a Swiss house to launch ethereum – a piece of the crypto ecosystem that acts as a distributed computing platform, using the ether token. It initially looked likely to fail: the founding tribe imploded after bitter internal fights; ethereum suffered a large cyber hack; scandals erupted and, like bitcoin, ether's price became crazily volatile, surging from nothing to $5,000, before collapsing. But this week something striking occurred: just as the White House was issuing a report about the Golden Age of Crypto, the Nasdaq exchange celebrated ethereum's 10th birthday. 'Ethereum has demonstrated itself ... as the definition of antifragile,' enthused Joe Lubin, one former inhabitant of that founding house, who presents the platform as 'a reliable trust layer for our fast-growing digital world'. Cynics will undoubtedly wince in horror, while enthusiasts will cheer. No wonder: crypto is arguably the single most divisive issue in finance today. [ Crypto investors need more detailed warnings about risks involved - Central Bank Opens in new window ] However, I would suggest that this anniversary should spark a more realistic – and subtle – judgment. For the past decade has revealed at least five key points about crypto that investors should ponder. First, and most obviously, digital assets are not homogenous (even if detractors hate them all). Bitcoin is a one-dimensional phenomenon that fans liken to 'digital gold', while ethereum is a multifaceted infrastructure. Memecoins (like $TRUMP) only float on crazy hype, but stablecoins are supposed to be backed by assets, like treasuries. This matters. Second, we need to move beyond black-and-white thinking with crypto. The evangelists who declared a decade ago that distributed finance would transform the world were wrong – thus far digital assets are still too clunky, costly and energy-guzzling to displace most mainstream payment options, and too volatile to be a reliable store of value. Criminality has been rife. Just think of the saga of Sam Bankman-Fried, or regulatory censure of the tether stablecoin. But doomsayers who predicted crypto's demise were equally wrong. Digital asset prices have just soared (again), pushing ethereum and bitcoin's market capitalisation up to $455 billion (€398.6 billion) and $2.3 trillion respectively. And the $270 billion-odd worth of stablecoins in circulation are supported by as many transactions as the Visa credit card network in the last year, as Glenn Hutchins, a long-time tech investor, tells me. Why? Greed (or speculation) is one factor. But crypto is founded on an interesting innovation (blockchain) that can sometimes be useful (say, for some cross-border payments). Moreover, some key players and regulators are raising standards in response to past scandals and networks like ethereum are slashing energy usage. [ A lesson from The Godfather as Wall Street backs crypto assets it once dismissed as a 'fraud' Opens in new window ] Third, mainstream finance is moving in. This is ironic, given that early crypto evangelists promised that distributed finance would depose incumbents. But it is driving the current boom. Consider the fact that a top BlackRock executive has just joined an ethereum investment group; or that traditional asset managers like Fidelity, BlackRock and Vanguard are launching crypto funds; or how mainstream investors are increasingly using crypto as a diversification play, while banks such as JPMorgan are running their own blockchains and launching stablecoins. Fourth, the geopolitics of crypto are shifting – fast. In the past decade, most innovation occurred outside the United States, in places such as Hong Kong. But this week Paul Atkins, chairman of the Securities and Exchange Commission, said he wanted to pull it onshore. Why? One reason is that the Trump family itself is invested in crypto. Another is grubby politics: crypto groups were such big Trump donors in 2024 that luminaries tell me they won the election for him. But geofinance matters too. Treasury secretary Scott Bessent hopes that dollar-based stablecoins will create a new source of demand for treasuries, and promote more dollar usage around the world. Consider this a new policy twist on Bretton Woods in the Silicon Valley age. Finally, crypto's second-order effects could turn out to be even more striking than the digital assets themselves. For what the innovation does is enable us to imagine alternatives to the financial and geopolitical status quo – for instance, by asking if we need to rely on the Swift payment system, or dollar dominance. Don't get me wrong: by making these five points, I am not downplaying the risks. The Trump administration's conflicts of interest with crypto are shameful. The potential for consumer harm is real. There are financial stability risks due to crypto's growing links with mainstream finance, and the use of treasuries to back stablecoins. Criminality and grift exists. But it is possible to worry about these risks – and want better regulation – but at the same time to recognise that the underlying technology can be useful as a geopolitical and financial diversification tool. For these reasons, ethereum's 'birthday' should prompt enthusiasts and doomsayers alike to realise that neither of them is entirely right. Life is rarely black and white – in finance or anywhere else. That will not change even if (or when) ethereum turns 20. – Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2025
