Irregularities in Greater Noida land allotments led to ₹3,600-cr loss: CAG
According to the CAG report tabled on Wednesday, the authority suffered a ₹800-crore loss in industrial allotments and around ₹2,800 crore in the allotment of group housing land under the Sports City and Recreational Entertainment Park (REP) schemes.
Between January 1991 and March 2021, the authority allotted 2,580 industrial plots covering 1,130 hectares — roughly one-fifth of all its distributed land. But by April 2021, only 1,341 plots (52%) were functional, and most of them became operational years late. Just 147 units — about 11% — met the deadlines specified in their allotment terms.
Of the allottees, 972 defaulted on payments, leaving ₹630 crore unpaid in land premium, lease rent, and interest. A major chunk of this — ₹374 crore — related to plots allotted between 2005-06 and 2020-21. Instead of cancelling long-defunct allotments, the authority allowed defaulters to retain land, in some cases even profiting through transfers.
One example cited was the allotment of 193 plots in Sector Ecotech-XI between 2007-08 and 2016-17 before the sector had basic infrastructure. The land was under litigation over acquisition and farmer compensation, delaying roads and power supply. Lease deeds for 139 plots were never executed, but rather than scrap the allotments, the authority waived penalties and extended deadlines — costing ₹142 crore in potential revenue as deeds were later signed at outdated rates.
The CAG also flagged delays of 223 to 1,804 days in issuing lease deed checklists in 10 cases, causing another ₹4-crore loss in rent. Charges worth ₹15 crore for changes in shareholding went uncollected in seven cases since 2015-16. Until 2018, the absence of strict eligibility criteria encouraged speculative trading, with five of 41 sampled allotments transferred via shareholding changes before any industrial work began.
Sports City: promised stadiums, delivered apartments
The Sports City scheme, launched in February 2011 as an integrated township with golf courses, cricket academies, stadiums, and other international-standard sports facilities, was meant to place Greater Noida on the global sports map.
Between 2011 and 2014, the authority allotted four massive plots: Sports City-1 in Sector Techzone IV to MMR Construction, Sports City-2 in Sector 27 to Supertech, REP-1 in Sector 27 to RBA Buildtech, and REP-2 in Sector 27 to Ultra Home Construction — together covering 535 acres. Rules required 70–75% of the land for sports and recreation, with tight limits on commercial and residential use.
By April 2021, 19 of 20 sub-allottees had defaulted on payments, leaving ₹2,330 crore unpaid. By March 2022, not one project was complete. Instead of world-class stadiums, the land now houses premium residential complexes with token facilities like small pools and tennis courts — little different from those in ordinary gated communities.
The audit said eligibility criteria prioritised real estate experience over sports infrastructure expertise, and bidders were not required to submit detailed project reports. Consortium bidding rules and subdivision approvals enabled otherwise ineligible firms to secure land, with lead members often exiting soon after allotment.
By approving layouts that broke up land meant for large sports facilities, the authority made proper infrastructure impossible. It also granted extra Floor Area Ratio and ground coverage for housing, giving undue benefits worth ₹470 crore, and underpriced land, causing another ₹690 crore in losses.
Vinod Kumar, general manager (finance) of the Greater Noida Authority, said corrective steps had been taken in light of the audit. 'The CAG observed irregularities in old group housing allotments and suggested corrections. We have revised our allotment policy to prevent future errors, and our staff is taking effective measures to recover dues in line with CAG suggestions,' he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
CAG flags irregularities in Gr Noida farmhouse plot allotments
The Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) in its audit report revealed that Greater Noida authority commissioned major irregularities in the allotment of farmhouse plots , resulting in a revenue loss of ₹645 crore and violation of environmental norms, including illegal construction in the Hindon river floodplain. The audit also flagged that plots were alloted without confirming clear possession of land. The CAG said that the authority entrusted with protecting ecological zones and floodplains, itself got involved in selling farmhouse plots in prohibited zones of Hindon. The authority had in 2011 launched the Institutional Farm Houses scheme meant for planned agricultural use and to maintain open green spaces. Large plots above 75 acres were allotted to developers, who were allowed to sub-lease smaller farmhouse plots for limited activities like dwelling units, swimming pools, nurseries, and dairy farming. 'Three massive plots measuring 13.47 lakh sqm (over 330 acres) were allotted to SDS Infratech Pvt Ltd (as lead member of a consortium), Gaursons India Ltd and Gaursons Hi-tech Infrastructure Ltd at a premium of ₹ 371.64 crore. However, dues of ₹ 597.6 crore piled up as developers defaulted. In the case related to SDS, allotment was cancelled in 2017 over the dues of ₹204 crore, but the matter remains sub-judice,' the report said. Despite repeated attempts, these developers were not available for a comment. The authority had in 2015 launched Krishi Farm Houses scheme for farmers whose land was acquired for the development. It offered small plots ranging (4,000 to 10,000 sqm) for cultivating fruits, vegetables, and medicinal plants, with only temporary structures permitted, the CAG said. 'However, in reality, permanent houses, shops, and polluting workshops cropped up on these lands,' said report. In Haibatpur village, plots were approved just 130 to 550 metres from the Hindon river, despite the Regional Plan 2021 classifying the floodplain as a 'Natural Conservation Zone', allowing only 0.5% of land area for construction. Government orders issued in March 2010 had also clearly prohibited construction in floodplain areas and directed authorities to mark these zones in master plans. Satellite imagery and joint verification in December 2019 confirmed widespread encroachments on Krishi Farm House found dense illegal occupation, including permanent residences, shops, garages, and kiosks. The board decided to scrap the scheme and refund deposits to allottees with 4% interest. Refunds were processed for eight of nine allottees between January 2020 and March 2021. The audit also flagged that plots were alloted without confirming clear possession of land, even when portions were under litigation or unacquired. For instance, in FH-03, nearly 17,568 sqm was not acquired at the time of allotment. The authority also allowed developers to mortgage farmhouse plots to raise loans despite having massive dues pending, a practice the Supreme Court has earlier criticised as collusion between builders and authorities. The CAG concluded that both schemes violated state government directives, regional planning norms, and environmental safeguards. Instead of safeguarding floodplains and green buffers, GNIDA actively facilitated their exploitation. During the audit exit conference in January 2021, the Uttar Pradesh government accepted the findings and assured that it would review the farmhouse schemes, recover dues, and take steps to restore the Hindon's floodplain. 'The authority will take corrective measures in this regard and improve the allotment guidelines in view of the CAG audit suggestions,' said Vinod Kumar, general manager of the Greater Noida authority.
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
Saryu Nahar Pariyojana: Cost escalates from ₹299 cr to ₹10K cr in nearly 40 yrs, CAG report flags lapses
The Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) has detected lapses in the launch of the Saryu Nahar Pariyojana (SNP) that led to an increase in the estimated project cost from ₹ 299.20 crore in 1982 to the actual cost of ₹10,003.11 crore in 2021, when the canal was commissioned. The SNP was formulated in 1982 at an estimated cost of ₹ 299.20 cr by enlarging the scope of the left bank Ghaghara canal project. (For Representation) The state government should fix responsibility for lapses and delays in the project execution, the CAG audit report said, adding that awarding of contracts and quality of construction works should be probed. Even after the launch, the project failed to provide desired benefits to the farmers as many of the canals and their distribution system remained incomplete, the report said. Uttar Pradesh parliamentary affairs minister Suresh Kumar Khanna tabled the report during the Monsoon session of the state assembly that concluded on August 14. The performance audit focused on the execution of works from April 2017 to March 2022. The SNP was formulated in 1982 at an estimated cost of ₹ 299.20 crore by enlarging the scope of the left bank Ghaghara canal project, which was conceptualised by the state government in 1978 to irrigate 3.54 lakh hectare area of the trans-Ghaghra region in eastern Uttar Pradesh, the CAG said A culturable command area (CCA) of 11.29 lakh hectare was to be created under the project, covering nine eastern districts of Uttar Pradesh. Irrigation potential of 14.04 lakh hectare was to be generated in this area. SNP was commissioned in December 2021 at an expenditure of ₹10,003.11 crore. SNP received funds from the state government resources, central assistance from Government of India under the Accelerated Irrigation Benefit Programmes, National Project and Pradhan Mantri Krishi Sinchayee Yojana and loan from the National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development (NABARD), the CAG report said. The CAG report observed that the project suffered due to delay in acquisition/purchase of land and funding. The CAG report also noticed that detailed estimates were prepared without approval to longitudinal sections of canals and drawings of the masonry structures, which led to significant changes in the scope of contracts. Cost estimates were not prepared as per the norms prescribed in the Schedule of Rates and in the Detailed Project Reports, due to which there were cases of overestimation in the works estimates. Contract management was weak and tenders were invited without technical sanctions, the report said. Insufficient time was given to bidders to submit the bids and instances of excess expenditure and undue advantage to contractors were noticed, the report added. The project was commissioned in December 2021 after nearly 40 years from the date of start of work. However, many of the canals were incomplete/not taken up for construction. The Rapti Main Canal and its distribution system were not utilised for want of outlets and sumps, the report said. Command area development works were completed only in 20 per cent CCA hindering the flow of water from canals to fields, the CAG report said. The CAG urged the state government to investigate the reasons for incorrect assessment of requirements of the project leading to significant variations in the scope of works during execution and consequential delays in the completion of project. 'The state government should carry out comprehensive field surveys to determine the actual area covered with the Saryu Nahar Pariyojana for correct assessment of required development work and for effective irrigation planning,' the CAG report said.
Time of India
6 hours ago
- Time of India
Andhra Pradesh mops up 61% of annual GST revenue target in four months this fiscal
Vijayawada: Andhra Pradesh registered a record revenue in GST collection and other tax revenues in the first four months of the current fiscal. The Comptroller and Auditor General's (CAG) latest report revealed that the state mopped up 61% of the GST revenue target set for the entire financial year in the first four months itself. The state's fiscal health is almost on track, with bumper revenues from other sectors as well. The state govt estimated that it could fetch around 27,477 crore through GST during the 2025-26 financial year in its annual budget. It pooled up nearly 16,754 crore in the first four months of the current fiscal. This is nearly 61% of the anticipated revenue of the entire financial year. Besides economic activity picking up, the tax authorities have intensified surveillance and prevented tax evasion. The govt projected the total revenue during the current financial year at 2,17,976 crore from all sources. It, however, recorded nearly 49,052 crore from April-July, which translates to 22% of the total target. Usually, govt tax revenue reflect massive growth in the last quarter of the fiscal as many taxpayers clear their dues just before the deadline, i.e. March-end. In fact, the total revenue, including debts, crossed the 1 lakh crore-mark by July. Chief minister N Chandrababu Naidu has been insisting that tax authorities implement smart tools to pool up the taxes instead of coercive measures on taxpayers. He had also suggested to make use of advanced technologies such as AI to track tax evasion, officials said. However, the increasing revenue deficit has become a major cause for concern for the state finance department. While the state budget projected the revenue deficit at 33,185 crore in the first four months, it touched 36,741 crore. This took the revenue deficit to 110%. The revenue expenditure jumped to an all-time high of 85,793 crore against the revenue of 49,052 crore. This left a deficit of 36,741 crore. According to CAG, the state govt secured loans of 49,198 crore in the first four months. The state govt spent 8,579 crore as capital expenditure of the total spending from the exchequer. It spent close to 20,000 crore to clear debts and payment of interest on debts. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
