Mandate, not mismanagement: PIC clarifies position on unlisted investments and Daybreak Foods
While acknowledging the inherent risks associated with these investments, the PIC asserts that it remains committed to seeking opportunities with the highest likelihood of positive results. This issue has come to public attention recently due to the challenges faced by Daybreak Foods, which the PIC acquired in 2015 for R1.2bn. This investment was intended to achieve long-term sustainable returns while contributing to food security in the country and supporting economic transformation.
The PIC emphasises that the claims against it oversimplify the complexities of long-term developmental investing and the inherent risks that come with it.
The PIC manages more than R3-trillion in assets, with about R2.5-trillion allocated for public servants through the Government Employees Pension Fund (GEPF). The remainder of the assets represents clients whose beneficiaries are contributing workers across the country.
The PIC acknowledges the seriousness of its responsibilities and operates under a clear mandate that goes beyond simply maximising financial returns. This mandate includes making investments that foster economic development, industrialisation, job creation and broader transformation in South Africa.
Unlisted investments, such as Daybreak Foods, play a crucial role in our developmental mandate. Though there are operational and governance challenges at Daybreak Foods — currently undergoing business rescue — the PIC believes the criticism it has received presents an incomplete and misleading view of the situation. The PIC asserts that the ongoing business rescue process should not be seen as a sign of impending liquidation or a total loss. Rather, they view it as a strategic and legally sound method to stabilise the company, preserve more than 3,000 jobs and ultimately recover value for its clients, primarily government pensioners. Daybreak Foods supplies 7% of South Africa's poultry, making its ongoing operations essential for national food security.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
16 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
National Gambling Board boss quits after forensic audit
The National Gambling Board's chief strategic adviser Caroline Kongwa has resigned. She earned R3.4-million last year. Caroline Kongwa, the chief strategic adviser of the National Gambling Board (NGB) for the past six years, resigned earlier this month after being informed of the findings of an independent audit. The NGB regulates the almost R60-billion gambling industry in South Africa. Audit firm TSU Investigation Services found that performance bonuses paid to Kongwa during her tenure 'were not approved in line with the NGB performance management policy and [are] thus deemed irregular expenditure'. TSU also found that expenditure relating to 'international travel' by Kongwa 'can be deemed irregular expenditure'. Trade, Industry and Competition Minister Parks Tau responded to several written parliamentary questions by DA MP Toby Chance. As to whether 'disciplinary and criminal complaints' were being considered as a result of TSU's investigation, Tau said: 'Following receipt of the investigation report, the minister has appointed legal representation to advise him on the way forward. The minister is currently engaging with legal counsel on the course of action.' Kongwa was appointed joint administrator with Tumelo Baleni after the NGB's CEO resigned in April 2014. This came after the NGB was placed under administration and its board suspended by former minister Rob Davies following a forensic audit into maladministration and wasteful expenditure. All the board members resigned. The NGB has been without a board for 11 years. Baleni resigned in 2015. In response to another question from Chance, Tau said: 'The process of selecting members to serve on the National Gambling Board is under way and has not yet been concluded.' Tau's spokesperson, Kaamil Alli, did not reply to questions from GroundUp after an earlier undertaking to respond by last Friday. Kongwa's initial appointment as a joint administrator was extended several times. Despite some internal opposition, she was appointed chief strategic adviser in 2019, a position that did not previously exist. Kongwa was paid a total of R3.4-million in 2024 (including bonuses and perks). This was R800,000 more than she was paid in 2023. For context, in 2024, South Africa's deputy president was paid R3.16-million and ministers R2.68-million, excluding perks. Besides her 2024 salary of R2.5-million, other payments she received included a 13th cheque of R212,825 and a performance bonus of R510,781. In 2023, she was paid R2.6-million, including a R196,945 13th cheque and performance bonuses totalling R212,283. Kongwa's response Kongwa responded to GroundUp: 'I can confirm I tendered my resignation. The reasons for my resignation are personal and private and not for public consumption or publication in your story. 'The rest of the issues you raise are official matters and I employ you to directly engage and seek reply from both the DTIC [Department of Trade, Industry and Competition] and the NGB to verify if what your source has told you is the truth.' 'The DTIC and NGB should and are more than capable and accountable to answer for their own statements and deal with official Government business which they make public or report to Parliament. 'I unfortunately am not able to assist you any further. I hereby reserve my rights to sue if any misrepresentations are made in your publication.' Whistle-blowers A whistle-blower, who asked to remain anonymous because they feared punishment for speaking to the media, told GroundUp last year: 'I have submissions dating back to 2018 where some senior officials in the DTIC were raising reservations to some of the decisions by the then Minister [Davies], one of which was the creation of the position of a chief strategic adviser for a specific person, the current Accounting Authority [Kongwa].' Another whistle-blower, who also requested anonymity for fear of retribution, shared a letter sent to the DTIC in 2023 about the fact that Kongwa had been at the helm of the organisation ever since the dissolution of the board in 2014. The letter states: '[I]t appears that there is no interest or agility from the side of the DTIC to appoint a Board of Directors for the entity'. This had led to 'a serious gap in governance and has created a sense of authority and power by the person who has been the accounting authority [Kongwa]'. DM
IOL News
2 days ago
- IOL News
How Deputy President Mashatile's R65 million properties contradict his income
Deputy President Paul Mashatile has come under fire after declaring ownership of the property Constantia estate in Cape Town, which he previously said was owned by his son-in-law's company. Image: X Deputy President Paul Mashatile is facing scrutiny for declaring two luxury properties worth a combined R65 million, despite an annual income of just over R3 million. Among these is a Constantia estate in Cape Town valued at R28.9 million, which he previously claimed was owned by his son-in-law's company. Within a year, Mashatile has declared at least two properties, including the Constantia estate he once denied owning. What has further raised eyebrows is that in last year's register, Mashatile declared smaller properties: a residential plot in Midrand measuring 1,000 by 1,200 square meters, and another in Sandton, measuring 600 by 800 square meters. This year, Mashatile declared three large residential properties: - A 4,000-square-meter estate in Constantia, Cape Town - A 9,300-square-meter home in Waterfall, Midrand - A 3,000-square-meter property in Kelvin, Johannesburg The Constantia and Waterfall properties are together valued at approximately R65 million. The Constantia property alone, which Mashatile previously denied owning, was confirmed by him to be worth R28.9 million. The Waterfall property is reportedly valued at R37 million. Mashatile previously said the Constantia property is registered under a company owned by his son-in-law, Nceba Nonkwelo, and was purchased in May 2023. Previously, in an October 2024 media statement, his office claimed he owned no properties in Cape Town, except for a house in Kelvin that he and his late wife purchased through a bank loan. The declarations have reignited public debate about the wealth of public servants. Mashatile earns R3.16 million annually following a 2.5% increase gazetted by the Presidency in April 2024. This includes a basic salary (60% of the total package) and R120,000 per year in non-pensionable cash allowance. Last year, the Presidency approved a 2.5% salary increase for ministers, the deputy president, deputy ministers, members of parliament, and other public representatives, effective retroactively from April 1, 2024. Other perks of office include government-funded housing, vehicles, travel benefits, and VIP protection services, all funded by taxpayers. Despite these benefits, critics argue it remains unclear how Mashatile could afford such high-value properties on his official salary alone. Mashatile's office has consistently denied that he personally owns the luxury properties. With the Waterfall case, his spokesperson Keith Khoza said that the home was purchased jointly by his sons and son-in-law, Nceba Nonkwelo, through a normal bank loan and is used as a family residence due to its enhanced security. The office also denied reports that his sons, Thabiso Mashatile and Tinyiko Mvelase, received tenders from departments Mashatile once oversaw while in the Gauteng government. 'No provincial or national department under the Deputy President's oversight has ever awarded, been accused of awarding, or investigated for awarding tenders to any companies linked to his family,' Khoza said. Khoza also denied past claims that Nonkwelo is under investigation by the Hawks for funding the Constantia purchase, saying that he is a businessman from an established entrepreneurial family. That loan and the related project were investigated by the Gauteng Department of Human Settlements in 2023. 'The Deputy President had no involvement in the loan, which was issued during his tenure as Minister of Arts and Culture and not while he was in the Gauteng government,' said Khoza. Meanwhile, questions remain about how Nonkwelo acquired money to purchase a nearly R30-million home in Cape Town. Democratic Alliance leader John Steenhuisen laid criminal charges in February 2024 at Cape Town Central Police Station against Deputy President Paul Mashatile. The charges are related to allegations of corruption, nepotism, and patronage, with Mashatile alleged to be the ultimate beneficiary. Get your news on the go, click here to join the Cape Argus News WhatsApp channel. Cape Argus
TimesLIVE
2 days ago
- TimesLIVE
Blackstone executive killed in Manhattan attack a 'kind, extraordinary' leader
Blackstone employees struggled on Tuesday to come to terms with the death of Wesley LePatner, one of the investment firm's senior executives who was gunned down late on Monday as she was leaving her Midtown Manhattan office. The 43-year-old mother of two tried to duck for cover behind a pillar in the lobby of 345 Park Avenue, the skyscraper office building that is home to Blackstone's 2,000 New York-based staff, while a gunman sprayed bullets, people with knowledge of the shooting said. LePatner's death was random. Neither she nor the firm, which invests more than $1.2-trillion (R21.4-trillion) in assets, was specifically targeted when 27-year-old Las Vegas resident Shane Tamura shot her and three others before killing himself, police told Blackstone executives. 'Beloved' was a word Blackstone executives and community leaders used to describe LePatner, a woman colleagues said had pushed into the rarefied circle of top Wall Street real estate executives traditionally dominated by men.
