.png&w=3840&q=100)
Bad tires on rental car led to man's deadly crash, Ohio widow says in lawsuit
An Ohio woman is suing after she said her husband died as a result of reckless driving and bad tires on a rental car.
The federal lawsuit was filed April 10 against Avis Car Rental, Hutchinson Inc. and Jules Toussaint.
McClatchy News reached out to Avis Car Rental and Hutchinson Inc. for comment May 19 but did not immediately hear back.
Toussaint was driving a 2023 Dodge Charger in Brighton Township on Jan. 18 at the direction of his employer, Hutchinson Inc., according to the lawsuit.
The car had been rented by Avis Car Rental, according to the civil complaint.
According to the lawsuit, the car's tires were 'worn with little to no tread' and the tread depth was below the legal limit, 'making it exceptionally dangerous to operate.'
This, the lawsuit said, is what led to the death of 69-year-old Robert Bilbrey.
Bilbrey was driving a 2005 Toyota Corolla in Brighton Township on Jan. 18. It was raining and the roads were 'wet with a slush buildup on the pavement,' the complaint said.
Toussaint was driving 'in a negligent, reckless, and wanton manner,' the lawsuit said.
He lost control of the vehicle and crashed head-on into Bilbrey's car, according to the complaint.
Fire crews had to remove Bilbrey from his vehicle because of the severity of the crash, the lawsuit said. He died from his injuries, the complaint said.
Bilbrey was 'a friend to all and helped wherever needed,' according to his obituary. He loved hunting, golfing, watching westerns and being with his family.
Toussaint was charged with misdemeanor vehicular manslaughter, according to Cleveland.com. His attorney declined the outlet's request for comment due to the pending case.
The complaint said it was a combination of the condition of the car's tires, Hutchinson Inc.'s trust in Avis Car Rental and Toussaint's reckless driving that led to Bilbrey's death.
'We were deeply saddened by this incident, and we extend our sincerest condolences to the family impacted. Given pending litigation, we are unable to provide further comment,' Avis told Cleveland.com.
The lawsuit is asking for over $75,000 in punitive damages and more than $75,000 in compensatory damages, in addition to attorney fees, costs and expenses.
Brighton Township is about a 45-mile drive southwest from Cleveland.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
2 hours ago
Two driver arrested for racing, speeding in Duluth
The Brief Two drivers were arrested for racing at 80 mph in a 45 mph zone on Pleasant Hill Road, observed by Duluth Police using a Dragon Eye Lidar device. Jonathan Mendez and James Baltimore received a total of seven citations, including racing, speeding, and vehicle registration violations. Both drivers were released at the scene with a mandatory court date, as Duluth Police emphasized their commitment to enforcing reckless driving laws. DULUTH, Ga. - Two drivers were arrested after allegedly racing at 80 miles per hour in a 45 mph zone on Pleasant Hill Road, according to the Duluth Police Department. What we know Officers say the incident occurred around 9:55 a.m. on May 26, when a Duluth officer using a speed-detection device observed two white vehicles speeding eastbound, side by side, on Pleasant Hill Road. The officer was able to confirm both vehicles were traveling at 80 mph—one at a distance of 1,100 feet and the other at 1,156 feet. The officer initiated a traffic stop, and both vehicles pulled into the parking lot of a business at the corner of McClure Bridge Road. The drivers were identified as Jonathan Mendez of Norcross and 19-year-old James Baltimore of Alpharetta. Mendez, who was driving a Toyota Corolla, told the officer he did not know the other driver. He was issued three citations for racing, speeding, and having an illegal tag cover. Baltimore, who did not have his driver's license on him, was found to possess only a Class CP permit. He was cited for speeding, racing, failing to register his vehicle within 30 days of residency, and driving without a license on his person. What we don't know It is not clear what prompted the incident. What's next Both drivers received a total of seven citations and were released at the scene after being informed of their mandatory court date. What they're saying "Reckless driving isn't a game, and we're not slowing down on enforcement," the department said in a statement. The Source The Duluth Police Department provided the details, image, and statement for this article.
11 hours ago
Officials remind drivers to ‘move over' after patrol vehicles hit in northeast GA
Authorities said when you see emergency lights on the road, remember two things: slow down and move over. [DOWNLOAD: Free WSB-TV News app for alerts as news breaks] The reminder comes after a Habersham County deputy patrol car was hit by another vehicle Saturday night. The sheriff's office said the deputy's Dodge Charger was providing lights for a road construction project on Georgia 365 southbound near James Short Tractor in Alto. TRENDING STORIES: Atlanta Public Schools approves new $1.3 billion budget, will cut 135 positions Chase in DeKalb ends in crash on Peachtree Blvd by I-285 ramp Man sentenced for kidnapping, raping woman in DeKalb nearly 40 years ago Officials said, while helping with the first wreck, a Demorest police officer's patrol vehicle was hit by another car as he tried to conduct a traffic stop on Georgia 365 near the Double Bridge Connector. The Georgia State Patrol is investigating both crashes. [SIGN UP: WSB-TV Daily Headlines Newsletter] 'These collisions serve as an urgent reminder of the importance of slowing down whenever you see emergency lights or utility vehicles working on or near a roadway,' said Habersham County Sheriff Robin Krockum. 'This is not the first time one of our vehicles has been struck trying to keep work crews safe in that area of Ga. 365, but thankfully our personnel and others involved have not been injured in the collisions.' Georgia's Move Over Law requires drivers to move over one lane when possible if an emergency vehicle with flashing lights is parked on the shoulder of the highway. If traffic is too heavy, authorities ask drivers to slow down and be prepared to stop.
13 hours ago
WARMINGTON: Peel cops find two murder suspects in B.C., wanted for Brampton killing
Two 21-year-old men from India who are in Canada on international student visas have been accused of first-degree murder in the fatal shooting of a Brampton man. The fact that Aman Aman and Digvijay Digvijay — both of Delta, B.C. — were captured out west and flown back to the GTA where Peel Regional Police officers charged them Sunday was already a major development in the May 16 slaying of 51-year-old Harjeet Dhadda. But public sector sources told The Toronto Sun that each of these men were in Canada on education visas and have been so for two years. It's not known why they travelled to the GTA and were allegedly here when this shocking murder occurred near Pearson International Airport. 'On Wednesday, May 14, 2025, at approximately 11:49 a.m., Harjeet Dhadda, a 51-year-old commercial insurance broker from Brampton, was (allegedly) approached by the suspect and shot multiple times while in a parking lot near Tranmere Drive and Telford Way in Mississauga,' contended Peel Regional Police. 'The victim later succumbed to his injuries (two days later) at a local hospital.' Police said a stolen Dodge Charger was used as a get-away vehicle following the fatal shooting. On that day, all police had to work with was a man shot outside of his truck and a car fleeing the scene. With the help of some security video footage, police said they determined 'the suspects fled in a stolen 2018 Black Dodge Challenger, which was recovered shortly following the incident.' But that was about it. The killers seemed to vanish into thin air. Peel Homicide detectives got involved and started doing some old-fashioned gumshoe work. With the help of this victim's family and other leads, their investigation took them to B.C. In just two weeks, they had suspects in custody. 'After an intensive investigation, two suspects were identified and tracked to Delta, B.C.,' said police. 'On May 28, Peel Regional Police, with assistance from officers with the Delta Police Department, Abbotsford Police, Surrey Police and the Royal Canadian Mounted Police, located and arrested Aman and Digvijay, 21-year-old men from Delta, B.C.' The allegations have not been tested in court. This was a very fast turnaround considering police had to locate and detain suspects as well as build a case that detectives alleged justifies pre-meditated murder charges. 'Despite the suspects' (alleged) efforts to evade capture, our teams remained focused and relentless,' said Chief Nishan Duraiappah. 'This outcome sends a clear message — no matter how far you run, our teams will find you.' Sometimes criminals forget, policing works in a coast-to-coast, 24/7 network. 'This arrest is a testament to the unwavering perseverance and diligence of our homicide investigators,' said Duraiappah. 'The strong collaboration with policing partners allows this family to take the next step toward justice for the loss of their loved one.' And this family needed that. This was hell for them. After the homicide, the victim's devastated daughter, Gurlin Dhadda, turned to social media to post: 'For the past few years, my father was receiving repeated threat and extortion calls. In April 2023, we even faced a possible attack.' The family had expressed frustration, saying they did not get enough protection for Dhadda. And while this arrest will not bring back their beloved family member, it does offer an opportunity at justice and provide some learning opportunities for government and police. Peel Police have really focused on that. In a video, Supt. David Kennedy acknowledged the hardship this senseless murder has had on the community and guarantees this investigation will continue. Meanwhile, questions need to be asked about the vetting process of students from abroad and also the issue of ensuring the safety of people potentially at risk from those wanting to settle scores from their home countries. In this case, authorities have not revealed the alleged motive, and this investigation is still very much underway. Perhaps more arrests could come. CRIME SCENE: Suspect's identity sought after man gunned down in Mississauga
