logo
Supreme Court orders another hearing of challenge over fraudulent online email account scheme

Supreme Court orders another hearing of challenge over fraudulent online email account scheme

Irish Times16-07-2025
The
Supreme Court
has ruled there should be another hearing of a
Swedish
man's
High Court
challenge over a finding that $651,000 (€557,000) held in an Irish bank account represented the proceeds of a fraudulent online email account scheme.
An appeal by Harry Zeman, a director of Swedish firm Routeback Media AB, to the Court of Appeal (CoA) over the High Court decision was dismissed in 2022.
A five-judge Supreme Court heard a further appeal last April and in a unanimous decision on Tuesday, with one judge dissenting in part, it allowed the appeal and ordered the case go back to the High Court so that fresh evidence could be considered.
The original High Court application to have the money declared the proceeds of crime was brought by the
Criminal Assets Bureau
(Cab).
READ MORE
That court heard the money was collected by Routeback, trading as Local Mart, over just four days as part of a scam primarily targeting card holders in the United States.
The Cab claimed Swedish police sent information regarding Mr Zeman's alleged ties to organised crime, the court also heard.
The High Court ordered in 2011 that Routeback and Mr Zeman could not dispose of or deal in the asset pending further order, under Section 3.1 of the Proceeds of Crime Act 1996.
That decision was not appealed in time and seven years later, in 2018, the Cab sought a final disposal order of the money, forfeiting it to the State, under Section 4 of the 1996 Act.
At this final disposal hearing, Mr Zeman claimed procedural unfairness and that he had new evidence. The High Court ultimately made a final disposal order in 2022.
The Supreme Court ruled that while a non disposal/non dealing Section 3.1 order was final in nature, there remained scope under the legislation for the respondent to raise fresh evidence but only in strictly limited and justified circumstances. It did not change the fact that litigants must present their full case at the earliest possible opportunity, it said.
It said it was allowing the appeal for the case to be remitted to the High Court for a limited hearing focused solely on genuinely new evidence. The burden is on Mr Zeman to prove the assets did not derive from criminal activity or that making a disposal order would be unjust, it said.
In a judgment with which Justices Gerard Hogan, Séamus Woulfe and Maurice Collins agreed, Mr Justice Peter Charleton said an unjust order should not be made where there may be claims that an uninvolved party's assets have been mixed with criminal property.
Alternatively, if a respondent failed to contest the original non disposal/non dealing order due to, for instance, illness, duress or lack of awareness, but now presents tenable evidence, then such a case may raise interests of justice, he said.
He also said there is no automatic right to cross-examine deponents in proceeds of crime cases. Cross-examination is under the court's oversight and is limited to issues where new evidence, with factual disputes, require it and with the focus remaining on what is necessary for an efficient and just resolution, he said.
Mr Justice Collins also gave a judgment in which he agreed with Mr Justice Charleton and disposition of the appeal.
Mr Justice Brian Murray agreed the appeal should be allowed, but dissented in part in a separate judgment. He outlined in nine points the proper relationship between applications made under the relevant Section 3 and 4 of the Proceeds of Crime Act.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Wife 'decapitated by husband who then carried her head to police station'
Wife 'decapitated by husband who then carried her head to police station'

Irish Daily Mirror

time4 minutes ago

  • Irish Daily Mirror

Wife 'decapitated by husband who then carried her head to police station'

A horrific incident has occurred in India where a man allegedly decapitated his wife and then presented her severed head to the police. Shankar, 28, from Hennagara near Bengaluru, is accused of committing the gruesome act after he reportedly found his wife in a compromising position with another man at their rented home. Local police sources have described the couple as having a "loving marriage" before they moved to the area recently. On June 3, Shankar is said to have gone to work and returned late to find his spouse allegedly with another man. Following an alleged attack on both parties, he is claimed to have beheaded his wife and then turned himself in at the Suryanagar Police Station. There are reports suggesting the couple was experiencing marital problems. The wife had reportedly expressed a wish to separate but still visited the house frequently, leading to ongoing disputes, neighbours say. The final argument on Thursday is reported to have escalated, culminating in the tragic killing, reports the Mirror. After the deed, Shankar is said to have ridden his motorcycle to the local police station with his wife's severed head and gave himself up to the authorities. Suryanagar police are conducting an inquiry into the matter, with more information to be released in time. Following a gruesome event in South Dakota, US, 34-year-old Bowen Fladland is accused of decapitating his 70-year-old mother, Marlene Fladland, and burying her remains in the front garden of his residence. He faces charges of first-degree and second-degree murder earlier this month. Police discovered the victim's body on July 8, although investigators suspect she met her untimely death at least three days prior. In another shocking case, it has come to light that a cocaine-addled Scottish postman beheaded his girlfriend after lamenting that her waitress shifts left him feeling "lonely." Ewan Methven brutally murdered 21-year-old Phoenix Spencer-Horn in her East Kilbride home, using three knives to stab her 20 times. The High Court in Glasgow was informed that Methven viciously attacked his partner, severing her head and attempting to dismember her limbs and torso. During a call to emergency services, he confessed to the operator that he had been "trying to muster up the courage to phone" following the incident, claiming he "totally blacked out through the thing." The 27 year old awaits sentencing this month.

Avant loan book remains at €4bn as deposits offering awaited
Avant loan book remains at €4bn as deposits offering awaited

Irish Times

time4 minutes ago

  • Irish Times

Avant loan book remains at €4bn as deposits offering awaited

Avant Money's loan book remained stable at €4 billion at the end of June compared to the close of the previous quarter, but up by a fifth on the year, according to its Spanish parent, Bankinter . The company officially become a branch of Bankinter in April. Irish consumers are now awaiting a launch of a deposits offering from Avant, which is led by chief executive Niall Corbett. Avant's mortgage book expanded by 22 per cent to €3 billion in the 12 months to the end of June, Bankinter said in an investor presentation as it reported quarterly figures. The portfolio was flat on the quarter. Its consumer portfolio grew by 13 per cent to €1 billion, year-on-year. Net interest income rose by 15 per cent to €55 million in the first half of the year, while pretax profit nudged 2 per cent higher to €21 million, according to the presentation. READ MORE [ Bankinter boss bullish on Irish business Opens in new window ] Bankinter chief executive Gloria Oritz previously said that she expects Avant Money to gather €100 million-€200 million of deposits in 2025, before growing gradually to a stage where the Irish loan book is almost funded by local deposits within eight years. Its digital, rather than branch network, strategy means that Avant's running costs equated to 47 per cent of total income in the first half, below the typical target of about 50 per cent for a retail banks. However, Bankinter's ratio was 36 per cent. The wider Bankinter group saw its pretax profit rise 7 per cent in the first half to €766 million. Bankinter, the fifth-largest Spanish bank, entered the Republic in 2019 through the acquisition of AvantCard, a credit card and consumer finance business, from US investment group Apollo. AvantCard was subsequently renamed Avant Money, which moved into Irish mortgages in late 2020 with headline rates that undercut the cheapest home loans available at the time in the market.

PayPal to create 100 jobs with AI fraud centre
PayPal to create 100 jobs with AI fraud centre

Irish Times

time4 minutes ago

  • Irish Times

PayPal to create 100 jobs with AI fraud centre

PayPal is to create 100 high-tech jobs in Ireland as the payments company establishes a new artificial intelligence (AI) fraud and data science centre here. The payments company is hiring across AI engineering, data science, software development, risk modelling and cybersecurity. PayPal, which already employs about 1,500 people here, said the new jobs would be located at the company's headquarters in Dublin and would support key areas such as loss prevention and enhancing customer experiences. Ciara O'Brien has the details. The EU and US are closing in on a trade deal that would impose 15 per cent tariffs on European imports, similar to the agreement Donald Trump struck with Japan this week. Brussels could agree to the so-called reciprocal levies to avoid the US president's threat to raise them to 30 per cent from August 1st, three people familiar said. 'The Jap agreement made clear the terms of the shakedown,' said one EU diplomat. 'Most member states are holding their noses and could take this deal.' Rye River Brewing , the Kildare-based craft brewer, has reported a more than €521,000 after-tax loss for 2024 as commercial and one-off project costs ate into rising gross profits at the Celbridge-headquartered company. The brewer moved into contract brewing this year with a deal to produce the popular Galway Hooker brand of beers. Ian Curran reports. READ MORE After months of back and forth and lots of shadow boxing, the European Union and the United States are said to be closing in on a trade deal that would impose a 15 per cent tariff on European imports , notes Cantillon and, while not what was wished for, it should give Irish and European businesses some certainty on the issue, albeit at a cost to them, and an end to the swirl or rumour and uncertainty that has existed since Trump returned to power. How will the updated National Development Plan shape Ireland in years to come? Listen | 35:59 It is the end of an era, writes Ciara O'Brien in her column. Everyone has a horror story about Microsoft's error screen appearing at the worst possibly moment, taking hours of work with it. I don't remember the first time I saw Microsoft's blue screen of death on my computer. But I do remember the worst time. Cantillon, in digesting the quashing by the UK Supreme Court of the conviction of former UBS and Citigroup dealer Tom Hayes for his role in the so-called Libor scandal, wonders at what point does a bad business decision become a law-breaking one? EU leaders are increasingly waking up to the bloc's dependence on US tech companies for the infrastructure that powers everything from healthcare systems to national defence. Those operations are both deep and wide. Amazon , Microsoft and Google control more than two-thirds of the European cloud computing market. Google and Apple prevail in the mobile phone operating systems in the EU, while Google dominates the global search market. Can the EU break that dependency? Barbara Moens reports. 'Every year, thousands of children enter school with undetected literacy needs. Under today's system, it can take up to five years for a child to receive a diagnosis of dyslexia. By then, they have already struggled, disengaged, and fallen behind,' says Joe Fernandez, founder of Early Intervention Tools , which has created a screening method that picks up signs of early literacy problems in four- to six-year-olds. Olive Keogh met him. What matters most to you in a phone? Is it camera? Battery life? Or is it pure thinness that gets your attention? Samsung has long satisfied demand for high-powered premium smartphones with the Galaxy series, building in better cameras, more power, improving battery life. Now it is trying to tempt the holdouts with the new Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge , a thinner, lighter phone. The only problem is that is has made some sacrifices to get there, says Ciara O'Brien as she runs the rule over it. If you'd like to read more about the issues that affect your finances try signing up to On the Money , the weekly newsletter from our personal finance team, which will be issued every Friday to Irish Times subscribers.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store