SEC's crypto confusion deepens as next-gen ETFs test limits
A new line of yield-chasing
crypto
funds is forcing the Securities and Exchange Commission to confront unresolved gaps in its regulatory framework, just as the Trump administration eases oversight of digital assets.
The immediate dispute centres on two proposed funds from ETF firms REX Financial and Osprey Funds that would allow investors to earn rewards by deploying Ether and Solana tokens to help validate blockchain transactions, a process known as staking. The firms said they had cleared an initial SEC registration hurdle last week, but agency staff took the unusual step of objecting that very same evening. Staff warned the products may not meet standards to qualify as investment companies under federal law, raising broader questions about the regulation of a hot corner of the crypto-investment world.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Cristiana Oliveira mostra a sua figura perfeita em novas fotos
33 Bridges
Undo
SEC staff noted that to meet the definition of an investment company, a firm must primarily invest in securities. That's a problem when it comes to digital assets: there are no clear lines around what crypto activities trip securities laws and what don't.
Crypto Tracker
TOP COIN SETS
Web3 Tracker
1.21%
Buy
DeFi Tracker
0.98%
Buy
NFT & Metaverse Tracker
-0.27%
Buy
BTC 50 :: ETH 50
-0.94%
Buy
Smart Contract Tracker
-1.53%
Buy
TOP COINS
(₹)
Solana
12,955 (
2.42%
)
Buy
XRP
187 (
2.37%
)
Buy
Bitcoin
9,000,570 (
1.77%
)
Buy
BNB
55,543 (
1.14%
)
Buy
Ethereum
213,477 (
1.11%
)
Buy
'When ETFs generate income from staking, they may start to resemble traditional investment companies under the Investment Company Act — especially if investors are relying on the managerial efforts of others to earn those returns,' said Adam Gana, an attorney at law firm Gana Weinstein LLP. 'However, these types of ETFs are testing the boundaries of what counts as an investment company, and the SEC is sending mixed signals.'
Did you Know?
The world of cryptocurrencies is very dynamic. Prices can go up or down in a matter of seconds. Thus, having reliable answers to such questions is crucial for investors.
View
Details
»
Gana added that 'just because you throw some stocks into the mix doesn't mean the SEC will look the other way.'
Live Events
The SEC, REX and Osprey declined to comment. The general counsel at REX said earlier that the firm expected to satisfy the SEC's questions.
The crypto industry has long argued that many tokens aren't securities and shouldn't fall under the SEC rules. Under Trump, the agency has appeared open to these arguments, and its new chair, Paul Atkins, is a proponent of digital currencies. SEC staff guidance has signalled that memecoins and stablecoins may fall outside securities definitions.
As recently as May 29, the staff said federal securities laws generally don't apply to staking activities — further complicating the regulatory picture as firms try to launch novel products.
These piecemeal statements create inconsistent policy, according to Corey Frayer, director of investor protection at the Consumer Federation of America.
'The SEC and the industry don't get to treat crypto assets as securities when it's convenient, and not as securities when they want weaker regulation,' said Frayer, who served as a senior adviser to former SEC Chair Gary Gensler, a frequent target of crypto industry scorn.
At the crux of the matter is the so-called
Howey test
, which comes from a 1946 Supreme Court decision that still governs securities classification. Under the test, an asset can be considered a security — and thus will fall under SEC purview — if investors contribute capital with the expectation derived from the managerial efforts of others. Bitcoin is generally considered a commodity but the status of other tokens like Ether and Solana are less clear.
SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce, head of the agency's crypto task force, took the unusual step of highlighting the SEC staff's queries about whether the proposed funds met the definition.
'I have those same questions,' Peirce wrote in a post on X.
Donald Trump embraced the digital-asset industry during his reelection campaign, pledging to make the US the 'crypto capital of the planet.' Since re-entering the White House, he has established a national stockpile of Bitcoin, anointed a 'crypto czar' and welcomed memecoin enthusiasts to a private dinner in Washington.
Firms have recently been successful in resolving SEC staff concerns about novel offerings. Earlier this year, agency staffers rebuked an ETF by State Street Corp. and Apollo Global Management — the world's first to invest in private credit — hours after the fund listed over concerns about the fund's liquidity and its ability to comply with valuation rules. The firms took action to rectify the issues.
Also read:
Thanks, Mr Sanjay Malhotra for giving wings to investors' dreams
Crypto executives are optimistic that US regulators will eventually greenlight the staking ETFs.
'They've followed a crawl-walk-run approach — first futures ETFs, then spot ETFs, and hopefully staking ETFs,' said Matt Hougan, chief investment officer at Bitwise Asset Management Inc., which acquired an Ethereum staking platform last year. 'I'm hopeful we'll get to the finish line soon.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
32 minutes ago
- Time of India
How to fix matchmaking error #1 on Fortnite
Image via Epic Games Fortnite players across the globe have reported a recurring issue halting their online gameplay, Matchmaking Error #1. While the message 'Weird. We couldn't connect to the match' may sound vague, the problem usually stems from a handful of causes, and the good news is that most are fixable at home. Here's a breakdown of what causes the error and how you can resolve it. What causes matchmaking error #1? Matchmaking Error #1 typically occurs when Fortnite's servers are undergoing maintenance or if there's a network issue on the player's end. Corrupt game files, server-specific downtime, or device-level issues - especially on consoles and mobiles, can also lead to this error. The message itself offers little clarity, often leaving players confused. But there are several effective methods to fix it. Step-by-step fixes to try 1. Check Fortnite's server status The first step is to check if Fortnite's servers are operational. Head to or visit the official Fortnite Status account on X (formerly Twitter). If the servers are down, it's best to wait until Epic resolves the issue. 2. Change your matchmaking region Sometimes, regional servers may be overloaded or temporarily offline. To switch: Go to Settings > Game Tab Select a different Matchmaking Region Apply changes and try joining a match Note: Switching regions may increase your ping, so choose one that's geographically close. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Treatment That Might Help You Against Knee Pain Knee pain | search ads Find Now Undo 3. Restart devices and network Turn off your Wi-Fi router, restart your PC or console, and relaunch Fortnite. A fresh boot often clears minor network or system conflicts. 4. Verify game files PC players can verify their game files using the Epic Games Launcher: Click the three dots next to Fortnite Go to Manage > Verify This checks for corrupted or missing files and replaces them automatically. 5. Try public DNS settings Changing your DNS to Google's Public DNS (8.8.8.8 and 8.8.4.4) can also help with connectivity issues. The process varies by platform but generally improves network stability. 6. Reinstall the game (If needed) If all else fails, uninstalling and reinstalling Fortnite might resolve the issue, especially if a recent update corrupted the local files. Matchmaking Error #1 can be frustrating, but most issues can be fixed quickly by checking server status, switching regions, or restarting your network and game. If the problem persists, submitting a detailed bug report to Epic Games is the best way forward. Keeping an eye on Fortnite's official updates during major patches can also help, as these errors often pop up during server maintenance. With a few simple steps and a bit of patience, you'll likely be back in the game in no time.
Time of India
35 minutes ago
- Time of India
Golden Visa in Dubai: Can new investors qualify instantly with Dh2 million property investment?
Image generated by AI for illustrative and creative purpsoses only Foreign investors looking to relocate to Dubai can secure the UAE's 10-year Golden Visa by investing in property worth at least Dh2 million, according to legal expert Ashish Mehta, founder and Managing Partner of Ashish Mehta & Associates. Mehta, who is licensed to practise law in Dubai, the UK, and India, shared the legal pathway for new businessmen seeking long-term residency in the UAE in a piece published by Khaleej Times. The Golden Visa is a long-term residence permit granted to eligible foreigners and their families, allowing them to live, work, and invest in the UAE without a local sponsor. It is regulated under Article 8 of the annex attached to Cabinet Resolution No. 65 of 2022, which implements Federal Law by Decree No. 29 of 2021 regarding the entry and residency of foreigners. Investment criteria and legal requirements To qualify for a Golden Visa through real estate, an investor must: Own property or properties worth Dh2 million or more, either solely or jointly. Ownership can include mortgaged properties, provided the loan is from a local bank approved by the competent local authority. Purchase off-plan property valued at a minimum of Dh2 million from local developers authorised by the competent local authority. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Giao dịch CFD với công nghệ và tốc độ tốt hơn IC Markets Tìm hiểu thêm Undo Maintain comprehensive health insurance for themselves and their family members throughout the visa's validity or as per requirements set by authorities. According to the law: 'The investor shall own one or more real estate property with a total value of not less than Dh2,000,000... It may be a loan, on condition that the loan is from one of the local banks determined by the competent local authority.' And for off-plan investments: 'The purchase is made from local companies approved by the competent local authority.' Steps to Secure the 10-Year Residency Once these conditions are met, the following steps lead to the issuance of the Golden Visa: Purchase and registration of eligible property with the Dubai Land Department (DLD) Issuance of a title deed Visa application through the DLD, GDRFA (General Directorate of Residency and Foreigners Affairs), or approved digital platforms like Dubai REST Completion of medical fitness test and Emirates ID registration Final approval and issuance of a 10-year renewable residence permit The process must be approved by the relevant local authorities. As stated under Article 1 of the annex to Cabinet Resolution No. 65 of 2022: 'The ICA may – after the approval of the competent authorities – issue a long-term residence permit for a period of ten years… allowing them to self-reside without the need for the Guarantor/the Host Party inside the State.' New businessmen can apply immediately after investment In response to a query published in Khaleej Times, Ashish Mehta clarified that a businessman planning to move to Dubai may apply for the Golden Visa immediately upon purchasing qualifying real estate worth at least Dh2 million, provided all requirements are met. He advised contacting either the GDRFA or authorised platforms like the Dubai Land Department to begin the application process. 'Based on the aforementioned provisions of the law, as a businessman intending to move to Dubai, you may be eligible for the UAE Golden Visa upon investing in real estate property with a minimum investment of Dh2 million, subject to the conditions set by the competent local authority,' Mehta stated. The UAE continues to position itself as a global hub for investors and entrepreneurs. The Golden Visa offers not just long-term stability but also the freedom to live and operate in the country independently, making it a compelling incentive for foreign businessmen planning to establish roots in Dubai.
Time of India
38 minutes ago
- Time of India
China says willing to improve communication with countries on rare earth controls
China's commerce ministry said on Saturday that it has approved a certain number of compliant rare earth export applications and will continue to refine its examination and approval process. The ministry also expressed willingness to enhance communication with other countries over export controls, according to a statement on its website, Reuters reported. The announcement comes at a time when Indian automakers are facing worsening shortages of rare earth magnets , critical components for electric vehicles (EVs) and other high-tech industries. According to Bloomberg, Beijing has turned down at least two recent applications for India-bound shipments of rare earth magnets, raising fears of an imminent disruption in Indian automobile production . Industry and government officials told Bloomberg that while shipments to the German and U.S. units of a global firm were cleared, the same request to its Indian arm was rejected. Since April 4—when China began enforcing tighter curbs on exports of seven rare earth elements—supplies to Indian auto parts manufacturers have been stuck at Chinese ports. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Villa For Sale in Dubai Might Surprise You Villas in Dubai | Search ads Learn More Undo These new controls require importers to certify that the magnets will not be used for defense purposes or re-exported to the U.S. The new end-user certification process can take at least 45 days and is now facing a global backlog. As per the Bloomberg report, at least 30 Indian applications endorsed by the Indian government are still awaiting Chinese approval, while over 10 applications from other countries have reportedly been cleared. According to a May 28 presentation by the Society of Indian Automobile Manufacturers (SIAM), no Indian applications have received final approval from China's commerce ministry despite many having secured embassy endorsements. Live Events 'Even if one magnetised part is missing, the vehicle cannot be built,' SIAM warned in the presentation, adding that some Indian firms may consider shifting operations to China if the supply crunch continues. The squeeze has heightened concern among Indian automakers. 'The rare earth situation is a very difficult one,' Bajaj Auto 's Executive Director Rakesh Sharma told analysts. 'Supplies and stocks are getting depleted as we speak, and if there's no relief in shipments, production will be seriously impaired in July.' To address the growing crisis, a delegation of Indian businesses is planning to visit Chinese counterparts this month with help from the Indian Embassy in Beijing. The embassy has reached out to China's commerce ministry, seeking expedited clearance of pending applications. A meeting was recently held at the Indian Prime Minister's Office to discuss options for resolving the impasse. Indian officials have advised manufacturers to explore alternative supply chains and consider local refining capacities—though such solutions are long-term in nature. Meanwhile, the Indian government is also encouraging firms to explore ferrite magnets or magnet-free designs, though these come with compromises in cost and performance. As a result, some companies are considering stop-gap measures such as importing motors or shifting production to fossil-fuel-powered vehicles. With inputs from agencies
