Most municipalities flouting Eskom debt relief terms, warns utility
Image: Timothy Barnard /Independent Newspapers
Embattled power utility Eskom has revealed that 87% of municipalities approved for National Treasury's municipal debt relief program are failing to meet the conditions required for debt write-offs, with only 10 out of 71 municipalities remaining compliant.
The municipal debt relief program was introduced by National Treasury in 2023 to help municipalities reduce the large debts they owe Eskom. It offers debt write-offs if municipalities pay their current bills consistently and meet certain conditions.
Despite measures like reducing interest and payment plans, Eskom says municipal debt has kept growing and now stands at about R94.6 billion and warned that ongoing non-compliance poses a significant risk to its liquidity and overall operations.
The state-owned power utility made these disclosures while briefing Parliament's Standing Committee on Appropriations on its finances on Tuesday.
"So this covers the national debt relief program. So just in summary, 71 municipalities, were approved. And right now, we are only sitting with 10 compliant, municipalities,". Rajen Naidoo, Eskom's General Manager for Finance said.
"The sad situation that we find ourselves in is that even municipalities that were approved did not even honour their current bill, some of them from month one of the program. So it's it it's only these 10, municipalities if they are compliant, in terms of how the program works,".
Eskom CFO Calib Cassim emphasised that the purpose of the Eskom Debt Relief Amendment Bill was to place power utility on a sustainable financial footing, reducing the need for future bailouts from the National Treasury.
Committee Chairperson Mmusi Maimane stressed that Eskom plays an important role and that its money problems and the growing municipal debt are key issues for the committee when deciding on funding.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
a few seconds ago
- Daily Maverick
Take the liquor industry's claims on pricing with a fistful of salt
The legal liquor industry is a major contributor to injury, disease and death in South Africa. Studies point to alcohol as a factor in 60% of femicides, half of all homicides, two-fifths of rapes and a quarter of traffic fatalities due to driver error. Late last year, National Treasury proposed the introduction of minimum unit pricing to reduce heavy drinking. There has since been a steady infusion of articles by the liquor industry claiming a sharp increase in the production and sale of illicit alcohol over the past decade, and suggesting an even more chilling effect on tax revenues if minimum unit pricing were to be implemented. Clearly, this narrative is meant to push the buttons of a government struggling to balance its books. Things came to a head on 8 August 2025 when Business Day led with claims by South African Breweries (SAB) CEO Richard Rivett-Carnac that minimum unit pricing will 'punish the poor and turbocharge the illicit market, harming both the industry and public safety'. These claims need to be dissected, both for their truthfulness and their logic. But before we do that, it is important to explain how minimum unit pricing works and what it is intended to do. Floor price Minimum unit pricing is not a tax, but a floor price for a unit of pure alcohol, below which the beverage containing it may not be sold. So, for instance, if the minimum unit pricing is R12 per unit, then a 330ml bottle of beer, which contains one unit (15ml) of pure alcohol (ethanol), could not be sold below that price. Thus, the introduction of minimum unit pricing would have no effect on the price of a 330ml bottle of Castle Lager, which at 5% alcohol by volume contains 1.1 units of ethanol and currently sells in a major retail store for R16. On the other hand, a minimum unit pricing of R12 would have a significant effect on the price of a one-litre bottle, which contains 3.3 units of ethanol and sells for just R22, or R6.67 per unit of pure alcohol. If the minimum unit price were R12, its selling price would have to go up by 80%. No wonder the CEO of its manufacturing company is worried. Of course, the question must be asked why alcohol in one-litre containers is sold so cheaply in the first place. It can't be that the cost of production of each unit of alcohol in the smaller container is more than twice that of the larger one. This price differential suggests deliberate tactics that encourage heavy drinking. In fact, a study from Tshwane published in 2018 found that drinkers who consumed alcohol from containers designed to hold more than one unit of ethanol – a standard drink – were nearly eight times more likely to drink heavily. No doubt the causality works both ways: those who need to drink heavily will buy cheaper liquor, and cheaper liquor feeds their craving to drink more. Injury, disease and death The fact is that the legal liquor industry is a major contributor to injury, disease and death in South Africa. Blood alcohol levels are not routinely taken from the perpetrators and victims of violence, but the many studies conducted over the past decade point to alcohol as a factor in 60% of femicides, half of all homicides, two-fifths of rapes and a quarter of traffic fatalities due to driver error. If the assertions of a study commissioned by the Drinks Federation of South Africa into illicit alcohol are true – that illegal trade constitutes about a fifth of the total market – that still implies that legally produced alcohol contributes up to four-fifths of the total alcohol harm in South Africa. And unlike the industry's suggestion, the major damage is not the occasional death from ill-derived concoctions, but widespread harm from heavy drinking of all liquor products, irrespective of whether it is legally produced or not. Heavy consumption When we say South Africa has a big drinking problem, we are not talking about the number of people who drink, but the volume of alcohol that is consumed by those who do. Only one-third of adults say they drink, but the average drinker consumes five standard drinks a day – that's 2½ times more than what could be regarded as the upper limit of 'responsible drinking'. The liquor industry benefits from heavy drinking – the very same companies that appeal to public health and safety as reasons not to introduce minimum unit pricing. Their claims must be taken with a fistful of salt. Much of the excessive supply of liquor finds its way into poorer communities, where the death rate from alcohol is 4½ times higher than in wealthier ones. Here, the call to 'drink responsibly' rings hollow as many drink heavily to escape the hardships of a daily life devoid of recreational alternatives. The industry compounds their misery by flooding their communities with large quantities of liquor at low prices. It is this behaviour that punishes the poor, not the proposed introduction of minimum unit pricing. Where minimum unit pricing has been introduced in other countries such as Scotland and Wales, Australia and Russia, it has reduced the prevalence of heavy drinking, with positive health benefits for all, including poorer consumers. A systematic review published in 2023 found that immediate reductions in acute alcohol-related hospital admissions ranged between 2% and 9%. Unsurprisingly, admissions for chronic alcohol-related conditions such as liver cirrhosis lagged by two to three years, but then reduced by 4%-9% annually. Illicit sales There may well be some growth of the illicit market, which could affect tax revenues. However, it is clear from the abovementioned review that the illegal market in countries implementing minimum unit pricing did not grow as much as industry had predicted, certainly not enough to undermine its substantial health benefits and consequent savings in healthcare costs. In South Africa, the claim by the liquor industry that illicit sales have increased by 53% since 2017 must be fully interrogated, given that legal beer and wine sales have both increased markedly over the past decade. That report must be made publicly available if it's to be taken seriously. As it stands, there is no objective evidence of substantial erosion of the legal market that would have been expected if illicit sales had expanded sharply – especially as South African consumers have been under pressure for a long time. Nonetheless, the growth of the illicit trade is a real risk that must be dealt with in the same way that illegal cigarettes should be – with effective enforcement of a track-and-trace system from the point of production to the point of sale. There is nothing to stop industry taking the lead in this regard, unless, of course, it is hesitant to divulge where its own products end up. Tax revenue Any excise tax losses will also be offset by the increase in VAT revenues. Modelling by UCT academics Corné van Walbeek and Naomi Gibbs shows that, taking all factors into account, government revenues will increase if minimum unit pricing is set at about R12 per unit (at 2025 prices). Consumption among moderate drinkers – who tend to buy higher-priced products – will be largely unchanged, while consumption among heavy drinkers will decrease. That is exactly what minimum unit pricing is intended to achieve – a reduced burden on society and net savings to the fiscus. Government must not be deterred by claims that minimum unit pricing will reduce tax revenue. The role of extra taxation of the liquor and tobacco industries is to make them pay for the damages they cause to society. If the liquor industry caused less harm to our society in the first place, Treasury would need less money to pay for its damages. SAB's Rivett-Carnac would have us believe that the status quo represents an optimal balance between the liquor industry's societal harm and economic benefit – in a country with twice the average global consumption per drinker, 10 times the worldwide prevalence of foetal alcohol spectrum disorder, eight times the global homicide rate, 1.3 times the traffic fatality rate and 1.1 times the incidence of intimate partner violence compared with the global average. The experience of other countries that have implemented minimum unit pricing and other strategies to reduce heavy drinking proves that we should not swallow that fallacy. DM
TimesLIVE
2 hours ago
- TimesLIVE
Merafong in dire straits as half its water is lost to leaks and illegal mining
He added that a further R50m was paid last month in terms of an agreement with the National Treasury. 'The major contributions are non-recovery of revenue due to non-technical and technical water losses,' he said. Mabuza said the persistently low revenue collection rate undermined the municipality's ability to service creditors, fund infrastructure maintenance, and meet operational obligations. There were many broken meters that had not been replaced over the years, which had put a dent on the collection rate of the institution as these old meters result in inaccurate billing, and will require huge capital to replace in a short space of time, Mabuza said. He told the committee that from October until last month, Rand Water reduced the bulk supply of water to the municipality by 20%. This meant that some areas would end up with dry taps. Mabuza said there were times when the utility did not issue public notices to the community about the lack of water, which led to a public outcry. 'The municipality urgently outsourced water tankers, which further severely hampered the cash flow of the municipality, with a cost of over R5m. The municipality is unable to keep up with monthly invoices due to revenue collection being inadequate to cover the R45m a month billed by Rand Water [for] debt. [The] Eskom bill also ranges between R40m and R83m per month, depending on summer or winter tariffs.' Nelisiwe Ntlhola, director of municipal finance support in Merafong, told the committee that some of the root causes affecting revenue collection were unemployment, poverty and the influx of undocumented foreigners into the municipality. 'There is high unemployment in Merafong and high poverty, which is socioeconomically affecting the revenue of the municipality,' she said. Ntlhola said the province should step in and help the municipality by identifying people who can afford to pay and those who cannot. She said that after this profiling, the enforcement of collection should follow. Ntlhola said there was a lack of support from law enforcement officials when it came to the crime associated with water losses from illegal mining. DA MPL Solly Msimanga said the municipality has not had a proper maintenance plan, and this meant 'you are going to continue having losses'.
IOL News
3 hours ago
- IOL News
Eskom pivots towards renewable energy with new solar power procurement initiative
Eskom on Tuesday announced the launch of its first Renewable Energy Offtake Programme, inviting large power users to submit bids for the procurement of 291MW of solar photovoltaic (PV) capacity. Image: Matt McClain | The Washington Post skom has shifted its focus from merely addressing the crippling issue of loadshedding to positioning itself as a sustainable and competitive player in the energy market. In a bold move, Eskom on Tuesday announced the launch of its first Renewable Energy Offtake Programme, inviting large power users to submit bids for the procurement of 291MW of solar photovoltaic (PV) capacity. This initiative forms part of a broader strategy aimed at transitioning Eskom's generation mix away from its coal-dominated past towards a more diverse blend that includes a growing share of renewable energy sources by 2040. The acceptance of bids comes on the heels of the South African government's approval of six large-scale solar plants, totalling nearly 1.3GW, under the seventh bid window of its national renewable energy procurement programme. This momentum signals a significant commitment from both the public and private sectors towards a greener future. "Just over a year into our turnaround strategy, we are not only focused on ending load shedding but are also pivoting Eskom into a sustainable and competitive company while ensuring security of supply through a customer-centric approach," said Eskom CEO, Dan Marokane. This shift exemplifies Eskom's comprehensive strategy to incorporate additional renewable energy into its power generation portfolio. Under the newly announced Request for Proposal (RFP), individual projects must have a minimum capacity of 10MW to qualify, with bidders invited to propose Power Purchase Agreements (PPAs) ranging from five to 25 years. This flexible procurement approach allows businesses not only to meet their energy needs but also to comply with global sustainability standards, thereby enhancing their competitiveness in a rapidly changing energy landscape. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad loading Eskom's initiative was shaped by an Expression of Interest (EOI) process, which highlighted the strong demand for direct energy contracting among commercial and industrial customers. "This is the next step in the focused execution of our strategy to integrate additional renewable energy into the grid, in line with global electricity industry trends for environmentally sustainable solutions that support broader decarbonisation objectives. "We have seen strong interest in Eskom's capabilities in green energy supply, which this programme demonstrates." Successful bidders are expected to enter into phased PPAs for renewable energy sourced from multiple Eskom projects. The first projects are projected to commence commercial operations by December 2027. Furthermore, Eskom stateed that it intended to accelerate the development of a balanced energy mix, including coal, nuclear, gas, renewables, and innovative energy storage solutions like Battery Energy Storage Systems and pumped hydro options. Eskom Distribution acting group executive, Agnes Mlambo, said this programme demonstrated the utility's commitment to innovation and building a cleaner, more resilient energy future. "By offering customised renewable energy offtake solutions, we are enabling our customers to transition to low-carbon operations while ensuring a secure and competitive supply, through customer-centred solutions," Mlambo said. "Engaging with the private sector in this structured manner gives impetus to Eskom's efforts to create a sustainable pathway for clean power integration into the grid." In pursuit of its ambitious goals, Eskom is establishing a dedicated renewable energy business aimed at delivering 2GW of construction-ready projects by 2026, ultimately scaling up to a remarkable 32GW, inclusive of green hydrogen, by 2040. This marks a transformative step for both Eskom and South Africa's energy landscape as the nation embraces a sustainable future. BUSINESS REPORT
