logo
‘Traitors': Hate-filled songs target Indian Muslims after Kashmir attack

‘Traitors': Hate-filled songs target Indian Muslims after Kashmir attack

Al Jazeera29-04-2025

Mumbai, India – Less than 24 hours after news broke of the April 22 attack, in which gunmen killed 25 tourists and a local pony rider in the Indian-administered Kashmir region, a new song surfaced on Indian YouTube.
Its message was unmistakable:
We made a mistake by allowing you to stay on,
You got your own country, why didn't you leave then?
They call us Hindus 'kaffirs',
Their hearts are full of conspiracies against us.
The song, titled 'Pehle Dharam Pocha' (They Asked About Religion First) targeted Indian Muslims, insisted they were conspiring against Hindus and asked them to leave India. In less than a week, the song has garnered more than 140,000 views on YouTube.
And it is not the only song. The killings in the picturesque resort town of Pahalgam marked the worst attack against tourists in Kashmir in a quarter of a century. But even as New Delhi hits back against Pakistan, which it accuses of links to the attack – a charge Islamabad denies – a wave of incendiary music tracks, crafted and circulated within hours, has set off an anti-Muslim backlash in India.
Set to pulsing beats and catchy rhymes, these songs, part of a genre that has come to be known as Hindutva Pop, are calling for violent retribution for the attack. From songs that label Indian Muslims as 'traitors' to songs that advocate their boycott, the country's smartphones are buzzing. Hindutva is the Hindu majoritarian political ideology of Prime Minister Narendra Modi's governing Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and its allies.
Al Jazeera found at least 20 songs that carried and amplified such Islamophobic themes at a time when Indians were anxiously scrolling through their digital feeds for more information on the aftermath of the attack.
These songs have a chillingly consistent narrative: Since the attackers are believed to have singled out Hindu tourists, Indian Muslims can no longer be trusted – never mind that a Muslim Kashmiri pony rider who tried to stop the gunmen was also killed.
Apart from these, a glut of other hyper-nationalist songs has also emerged in the past week, pushing warmongering rhetoric deeper into Indian digital veins. There are songs that call for Pakistan to be nuked or for the Indian government to 'wipe Pakistan off the map', and others that advocate for 'Pakistani blood' in exchange for the deaths,
These songs have become a part of a broader digital push by Hindutva groups, who are using social media and encrypted platforms like WhatsApp to stoke fear, hatred, and division among Indians – all at a time when tensions with neighbouring Pakistan are ratcheting up.
This campaign is mirroring real-world violence, across multiple Indian states. In Uttar Pradesh, Haryana, Maharashtra and Uttarakhand, Muslims have faced brutal attacks and threats. Kashmiri Muslims have been evicted from their homes, street vendors assaulted, and in chilling acts of retribution, Muslim patients have been denied medical care by Hindu doctors.
On Friday, a Muslim man was shot dead, with a Hindu supremacist in Agra, Uttar Pradesh, claiming responsibility for the shooting and saying it was retribution for the Pahalgam attack.
All the 20 songs that Al Jazeera analysed saw a common theme being pushed: a reiteration of the assertion that tourists were killed for their Hindu identities, and therefore, Hindus across the country must now feel threatened in living around Muslims. Multiple witness and survivor accounts of the Pahalgam attack suggest that the gunmen asked the tourists to recite the Kalimas (sacred Islamic verses) and the men who could not do so were shot.
The song Pehle Dharm Poocha (They Asked About Religion First) was released on April 23, the day after the attack. Singer Kavi Singh insists that letting Muslims stay on in India after the country's partition in 1947 was 'a mistake', and asks them to go to Pakistan.
Another song, Ab Ek Nahi Huye Toh Kat Jaaoge (If You Don't Unite Now You Will be Slaughtered), by singer Chandan Deewana, is addressed entirely to Hindus, asking them to rise up and 'save our religion'. The song insists that Hindus, not Indians, are under threat and warns that they will be 'slaughtered' if they do not unite. It has garnered more than 60,000 views on YouTube in just two days.
Jaago Hindu Jaago (Wake Up, Hindus) is a song that asks Hindus to identify 'traitors within the country', a coded reference to Muslims. The song's video on YouTube contains an AI-re-enactment of the Pahalgam attack and has more than 128,000 views so far.
Another song, Modi Ji Ab Maha Yudh Ho Jaane Do (Modi ji, Let The Great War Begin), refers to Muslims as 'snakes' living in India. Another song calls the events in the country a 'religious war', and yet another asks for Hindus in India to be allowed to carry arms.
These songs provide a background score for social media posts that bear similar themes.
From AI-generated videos and memes recreating the attack to Ghibli images, social media timelines have seen a flood of content emerging from the attack. Much of it carries similar undertones: to paint the attack as an assault on Hindus and the Hindu religion, while exhorting Hindus to 'unite' against the threat of Muslims.
Some posts liken the Pahalgam killings to the October 7, 2023, attacks on Israel by Hamas and other Palestinian armed groups, and exhort the Indian government to 'take revenge the Israel way'. Israel launched a war on the Gaza Strip that has, since October 2023, killed more than 52,000 Palestinians and wounded more than 117,000 others.
Raqib Hameed Naik, the executive director of the Washington, DC-based Center for the Study of Organized Hate (CSOH), which tracks hate speech in India, said the centre has observed 'a sharp spike' in anti-Muslim rhetoric on social media since the Kashmir attack.
'The [Muslim] community is frequently portrayed as an existential threat through memes, AI-generated images, videos and misinformation, systematically designed to inflame passions and justify exclusionary rhetoric,' Naik said.
In addition to the 20 songs that Al Jazeera identified, there is a plethora of songs on YouTube abusing Pakistan (one song's title is 'Pakistan, You M***********', and it has garnered more than 75,000 views). The videos accompanying some of these songs feature military simulation videos of air strikes, soldiers in combat and tanks firing munitions.
Some of them even feature the singers dressed in military fatigues and camouflage face paint, with one singer holding a rifle throughout the video.
Since the Kashmir attack, there have been multiple incidents of violence on the streets, targeting Kashmiri and other Muslims across the country.
The Association For Protection Of Civil Rights (APCR), a civil rights advocacy group consisting of lawyers and human rights activists, has recorded 21 incidents of anti-Muslim violence, intimidation and hate speech across the country in the days after April 22.
These include assaulting Kashmiri women and students, delivering hate speeches against Muslims in public rallies and asking the Indian government to replicate Israel's actions in Palestine against Kashmiris – as well as evicting Kashmiri students from their rented homes and hostels.
'Indians are being bombarded by this hateful campaign, which uses the attack as a base,' said Nadeem Khan, the general secretary of APCR. 'This campaign has taken the country's temperature to its boiling point.'
APCR, he said, was now in the process of arranging legal aid for victims of the post-attack violence.
Members of Modi's BJP have been linked to some of the hate speech and violence.
One BJP minister in the western state of Maharashtra, Nitesh Rane, called for an economic boycott of Muslims, while addressing a public event attended by hundreds last week. 'If they are behaving this way about religion, then why should we buy things from them and make them rich? You people will have to take a pledge that whenever you make any purchase, you should buy it only from a Hindu,' Rane told the gathering.
Another BJP legislator entered Jaipur city's Jama Masjid and pasted offensive posters inside the premises of a mosque, during a protest against Pakistan for its involvement in the Kashmir attack. A group of BJP leaders in Mumbai were booked by the police for abusing and assaulting Muslim hawkers in central Mumbai.
In addition, leaders of the BJP as well as its ideological affiliates, the Bajrang Dal and the Vishwa Hindu Parishad, have also been organising protests against Pakistan, often indulging in anti-Muslim hate speeches in the process.
The Washington DC-based CSOH has recorded at least 10 hate speech events since April 22, where participants have threatened Muslims with violence, advocated for a boycott of Muslims, asked Hindus to arm themselves and even warned Kashmiri Muslims to leave, failing which they would 'face consequences'.
Naik, from CSOH, said that the online hate campaign against Muslims had sought to 'justify' this violence.
'This follows a longstanding pattern where certain domestic or international incidents are weaponised to demonise Muslims and promote hate and violence against them in India,' he said.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

UK aims to ‘deepen' India ties
UK aims to ‘deepen' India ties

Qatar Tribune

time6 hours ago

  • Qatar Tribune

UK aims to ‘deepen' India ties

London: British Foreign Secretary David Lammy will seek to deepen UK-India economic ties as he visits New Delhi this weekend, saying Britain's recently agreed trade deal with the country is 'just the start of our ambitions.' Trade and migration will be at the top of the agenda for the Foreign Secretary's trip, during which he will meet Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and external affairs minister S Jaishankar. The Foreign Office said Lammy, who was expected in New Delhi on Saturday, would also raise 'the recent escalation in tensions following the Pahalgam terrorist attack, and how the welcomed sustained period of peace can be best supported in the interests of stability in the region.' Pakistan and India agreed to a US-brokered ceasefire last month after rising hostilities between the two nuclear-armed rivals followed a deadly attack on tourists in Pahalgam, Kashmir. Ahead of the visit, Lammy said: 'Signing a free trade agreement is just the start of our ambitions - we're building a modern partnership with India for a new global era.' (PA Media/dpa)

AI chatbots: New frontier of misinformation, not fact-checking
AI chatbots: New frontier of misinformation, not fact-checking

Qatar Tribune

time3 days ago

  • Qatar Tribune

AI chatbots: New frontier of misinformation, not fact-checking

Agencies As misinformation exploded during India's four-day conflict with Pakistan, social media users turned to an AI chatbot for verification -- only to encounter more falsehoods, underscoring its unreliability as a fact-checking tool. With tech platforms reducing human fact-checkers, users are increasingly relying on AI-powered chatbots -- including xAI's Grok, OpenAI's ChatGPT, and Google's Gemini -- in search of reliable information. 'Hey @Grok, is this true?' has become a common query on Elon Musk's platform X, where the AI assistant is built in, reflecting the growing trend of seeking instant debunks on social media. But the responses are often themselves riddled with misinformation. Grok -- now under renewed scrutiny for inserting 'white genocide,' a far-right conspiracy theory, into unrelated queries -- wrongly identified old video footage from Sudan's Khartoum airport as a missile strike on Pakistan's Nur Khan airbase during the country's recent conflict with India. Unrelated footage of a building on fire in Nepal was misidentified as 'likely' showing Pakistan's military response to Indian strikes. 'The growing reliance on Grok as a fact-checker comes as X and other major tech companies have scaled back investments in human fact-checkers,' McKenzie Sadeghi, a researcher with the disinformation watchdog NewsGuard, told AFP. 'Our research has repeatedly found that AI chatbots are not reliable sources for news and information, particularly when it comes to breaking news,' she warned. NewsGuard's research found that 10 leading chatbots were prone to repeating falsehoods, including Russian disinformation narratives and false or misleading claims related to the recent Australian election. In a recent study of eight AI search tools, the Tow Center for Digital Journalism at Columbia University found that chatbots were 'generally bad at declining to answer questions they couldn't answer accurately, offering incorrect or speculative answers instead.' When AFP fact-checkers in Uruguay asked Gemini about an AI-generated image of a woman, it not only confirmed its authenticity but fabricated details about her identity and where the image was likely taken. Grok recently labeled a purported video of a giant anaconda swimming in the Amazon River as 'genuine,' even citing credible-sounding scientific expeditions to support itsfalse claim. In reality, the video was AI-generated, AFP fact-checkers in Latin America reported, noting that many users cited Grok's assessment as evidence theclip was real. Such findings have raised concerns as surveys show that online users are increasingly shifting from traditional search engines to AI chatbots for information gathering and verification. The shift also comes as Meta announced earlier this year it was ending its third-party fact-checking program in the United States, turning over the task of debunking falsehoods to ordinary users under a model known as 'Community Notes,' popularized by X. Researchers have repeatedly questioned the effectiveness of 'Community Notes' in combating falsehoods. Human fact-checking has long been a flashpoint in a hyperpolarized political climate, particularly in the United States, where conservative advocates maintain it suppresses free speech and censors right-wing content -- something professional fact-checkers vehemently reject. AFP currently works in 26 languages with Facebook's fact-checking program, including in Asia, Latin America, and the European Union. The quality and accuracy of AI chatbots can vary, depending on how they are trained and programmed, prompting concerns that their output may be subject to political influence or control. Musk's xAI recently blamed an 'unauthorized modification' for causing Grok to generate unsolicited posts referencing 'white genocide' in SouthAfrica. When AI expert David Caswell asked Grok who might have modified its system prompt, the chatbot named Musk as the 'most likely' the South African-born billionaire backer of President Donald Trump, has previously peddled the unfounded claim that South Africa's leaders were 'openly pushing for genocide' of white people. 'We have seen the way AI assistants can either fabricate results or give biased answers after human coders specifically change their instructions,' Angie Holan, director of the International Fact-Checking Network, told AFP. 'I am especially concerned about the way Grok has mishandled requests concerning very sensitive matters after receiving instructions to provide pre-authorized answers.'

China's critical mineral export curbs trigger global alarm
China's critical mineral export curbs trigger global alarm

Qatar Tribune

time3 days ago

  • Qatar Tribune

China's critical mineral export curbs trigger global alarm

Agencies Concerns over China's grip on critical minerals are escalating, as global automakers joined U.S. companies in warning that Beijing's export restrictions on rare earth alloys, mixtures and magnets could lead to production delays and disruptions unless swiftly addressed. German automakers became the latest to warn that China's export restrictions threaten to shut down production and rattle their local economies, following a similar complaint from an Indian EV maker last week. Meanwhile, several European auto supplier plants and production lines have been shut down due to a shortage of rare earths caused by China's restrictions, Europe's auto supplier association CLEPA said on Wednesday, warning of further outages to come. China's decision in April to suspend exports of a wide range of rare earths and related magnets has upended the supply chains central to automakers, aerospace manufacturers, semiconductor companies and military contractors around the world. The move underscores China's dominance of the critical mineral industry and is seen as leverage by China in its ongoing trade war with U.S. President Donald Trump. Trump has sought to redefine the trading relationship with the US' top economic rival, China, by imposing steep tariffs on billions of dollars of imported goods in hopes of narrowing a wide trade deficit and bringing back lost manufacturing. Trump imposed tariffs as high as 145% against China only to scale them back after stock, bond and currency markets revolted over the sweeping nature of the levies. China has responded with its own tariffs and is leveraging its dominance in key supply chains to persuade Trump to back down. Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping are expected to talk this week, White House spokesperson Karoline Leavitt told reporters on Tuesday, and the export curbs are expected to be high on the agenda. 'I can assure you that the administration is actively monitoring China's compliance with the Geneva trade agreement,' she said. 'Our administration officials continue to be engaged in correspondence with their Chinese counterparts.' Trump has previously signaled that China's slow pace of easing the critical mineral export controls represents a violation of the agreement reached last month in Geneva. Shipments of the magnets, essential for assembling everything from cars and drones to robots and missiles, have been halted at many Chinese ports while license applications make their way through the Chinese regulatory system. The restrictions have triggered anxiety in corporate boardrooms and nations' capitals – from Tokyo to Washington – as officials scrambled to identify limited alternative options amid fears that production of new automobiles and other items could grind to a halt by summer's end. 'If the situation is not changed quickly, production delays and even production outages can no longer be ruled out,' Hildegard Mueller, head of Germany's auto lobby, told Reuters on Tuesday. Chinese state media reported last week that China was considering relaxing the curbs for European semiconductor firms, while the Ministry of Foreign Affairs has said it would strengthen cooperation with other countries over its controls. However, rare-earth magnet exports from China halved in April as exporters grappled with the opaque licensing Fannon, a minerals industry consultant and former U.S. assistant secretary of state for energy resources during Trump's first term, said the global disruptions are not shocking to those paying attention. 'I don't think anyone should be surprised how this is playing out. We have a production challenge (in the U.S.), and we need to leverage our whole government approach to secure resources and ramp up domestic capability as soon as possible. The time horizon to do this was yesterday,' Fannon said. Diplomats, automakers and other executives from India, Japan and Europe were urgently seeking meetings with Beijing officials to push for faster approval of rare earth magnet exports, sources told Reuters, as shortages threatened to halt global supply chains. A business delegation from Japan will visit Beijing in early June to meet the Ministry of Commerce over the curbs, and European diplomats from countries with big auto industries have also sought 'emergency' meetings with Chinese officials in recent weeks, Reuters reported. The CLEPA association on Wednesday said that of the hundreds of requests for export licenses made by auto suppliers since early April, only a quarter have been granted so far, with some requests rejected on what the association described as 'highly procedural grounds.' 'Procedures seem to vary from province to province and in several instances IP-sensitive information has been requested,' it said, adding that if the process was not streamlined soon, more plants would likely be affected in the next three to four weeks as inventories depleted. India, where Bajaj Auto warned that any further delays in securing the supply of rare earth magnets from China could 'seriously impact' electric vehicle production, is organizing a trip for auto executives in the next two to three weeks. In May, the head of the trade group representing General Motors, Toyota, Volkswagen, Hyundai and other major automakers raised similar concerns in a letter to the Trump administration. 'Without reliable access to these elements and magnets, automotive suppliers will be unable to produce critical automotive components, including automatic transmissions, throttle bodies, alternators, various motors, sensors, seat belts, speakers, lights, motors, power steering, and cameras,' the Alliance for Automotive Innovation wrote in the letter.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store