Banksy's ‘Broken Heart' painting defaced on a Brooklyn wall is up for sale
The apparent graffiti battle didn't end there. Another tagger also attempted to leave his mark but was stymied by security guards. Today the phrase 'SHAN' is still visible in light purple paint.
Get Love Letters: The Newsletter
A weekly dispatch with all the best relationship content and commentary – plus exclusive content for fans of Love Letters, Dinner With Cupid, weddings, therapy talk, and more.
Enter Email
Sign Up
Maria Georgiadis, whose family owned the now-demolished warehouse and ultimately removed the section of wall to preserve the artwork, says the graffiti pastiche is quintessentially New York.
Advertisement
'It looks like a war going on,' she said recently. 'They're literally going at it on the wall.'
Artwork up for auction
The preserved wall, dubbed 'Battle to Survive a Broken Heart,' will be going up for sale May 21 at Guernsey's, the New York auction house.
Georgiadis, a Brooklyn schoolteacher, says the sale is bittersweet. Her father, Vassilios Georgiadis, ran his roofing and asbestos abatement company from the warehouse adorned with the balloon.
He died four years ago at age 67 from a heart attack, which is why some of the proceeds from the sale will be donated to the American Heart Association.
Advertisement
'It's just very significant to us because he loved it and he was just so full of love,' Maria Georgiadis said on a recent visit to the art warehouse where the piece was stored for more than a decade. 'It's like the bandage heart. We all have love, but we've all went through things and we just put a little Band-Aid over and just keep on moving, right? That's how I take it.'
The nearly 4-ton, 6-foot-tall (3.6-metric ton, 1.8-meter-tall) wall section is one of a number of guerrilla works the famously secretive British artist made during a New York residency in 2013.
At the time, Banksy heralded the work by posting on his website photos and an audio track recorded partly in a squeaky, helium-induced voice.
Banksy may not have painted response to tagger
Guernsey auction house President Arlan Ettinger said it is impossible to know for certain because Banksy works clandestinely. But he said the neat stenciling and wording 'strongly suggest that this was a gentle way for Banksy to put the other artist in his place.'
Ulrich Blanché, an art history lecturer at Heidelberg University in Germany, called the piece a 'very well executed' stencil notable partly because of Banksy's decision to place it in Brooklyn's port area of Red Hook.
'This part of NYC was not easy to reach at that time,' he said by email. 'Banksy wanted people to go to places in NYC they never have seen and love them as well.'
But Blanche questioned whether the additional stenciled text was truly the work of Banksy, saying the word choice and design don't appear to comport with the artist's style at the time.
Advertisement
'To call a graffiti guy a 'girl' is not something Banksy would do in 2013. This is misogynic and immature in a sexist way,' he wrote. 'Three different fonts that do not match and three colors — why should he do that? Too unnecessarily elaborated without reasons. So I think this was added by someone else.'
Blanché also said he is ambivalent about the pending sale, noting Banksy usually doesn't authorize his street pieces for sale. At the same time, he understands the burden placed on property owners to protect and maintain them.
'Banksy's works should be preserved, but for the community they were made for,' he said. 'They should not be turned into goods. They are made and thought for a specific location. Not portable. Not sellable.'
Spokespersons for Banksy didn't respond to an email seeking comment.
Difficult to determine price
Maria Georgiadis' brother, Anastasios, said his father had also hoped to keep the piece in Red Hook after having cut it out of the wall and framed in thick steel for safekeeping.
The elder Georgiadis, he said, envisioned the work as the centerpiece of a retail and housing development on the property, a dream he didn't realize. The property has since been sold off by the family.
Ettinger said it is difficult to say what the piece might fetch. There is little precedent for a sale of a Banksy piece of this size, he said.
In 2018, a canvas that was part of Banksy's 'Girl With Balloon' series sold in London for 1.04 million pounds ($1.4 million), only to famously self-destruct in front of a stunned auction crowd.
Maria Georgiadis said she hopes whoever buys the 'Broken Heart' finds the same beauty and meaning her father drew from the piece.
Advertisement
When Banksy painted it, the family business had been recovering from destructive floods caused by Hurricane Sandy the prior year. Georgiadis recalls her father had no idea who Banksy was but was moved by the simple image.
'My dad had it in his head that Banksy knew what we went through,' she said. 'He goes, 'Can you believe it Maria? It's a heart.''
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Boston Globe
15 hours ago
- Boston Globe
Retiree feels obligated to always go see friends' new band
I love these people and feel like I have to start going to their gigs. I can tell them how great they sounded. And I know the whole time I will be wishing I was home. Get Love Letters: The Newsletter A weekly dispatch with all the best relationship content and commentary – plus exclusive content for fans of Love Letters, Dinner With Cupid, weddings, therapy talk, and more. Enter Email Sign Up Any advice on how to proceed? Advertisement FRIEND OF THE BAND A. Good on you for trying to show up and support your friends, and good on you, in advance, for advocating for what you need and staying home when it suits you. When giving a performance, or running a marathon, or really anything that would be enriched by an audience, it's important to right-size the expectation around support. Some friends and members are very willing to show up whenever and wherever to cheer us on. And that's great. Others, like you, might find that they're just not the right audience. And it's fine to give what you can — attendance at a few gigs — without overextending yourself. Advertisement Your friends presumably formed the band for the joy of playing. And part of that joy comes from being seen. It's healthy for them to remember that not everyone they love or care about will be their target audience. And that people can cheer them on from home. In the past, when I've written to people who've felt an obligation to support a loved one's creative endeavors (or written to a loved one who is feeling unsupported), some readers have responded that it's always our duty to show up and support. After decades of public performances in other areas of my life, I see support as more multifaceted. I want to perform for people who want to be there, and I understand if it's not the right gig, venue, or even day for someone else. Try to address the pressure you're feeling head on, in a non-charged way. 'I'm excited you found this, and I think your music is really great. Coming to live shows is hard for me, but I hope you know that it doesn't diminish how proud I am!' And even if you don't show, the best advertisement is word-of-mouth, so tell someone else who would really enjoy a night out. Q. I would add something to your good response to Beleaguered Mom. Her daughter went through substance abuse and self-destructive behaviors as a teen. In her early 20s she was close with her adoptive Mom. Things went 'sideways' shortly after Mom and Dad left to sail around the world. I worked in treatment foster care for 12 years as a social worker and program director. Sadly, it is not uncommon for adoptees to struggle to come to grips with why their biological parents couldn't or wouldn't care for them, or ask 'Who am I really?' or 'Will I end up like them?' Advertisement Mom's reference to the daughter's biological parents' 'history of mental illness and substance abuse' is a red herring. Despite extensive research, geneticists cannot point to any genes — singly or in combination — that significantly correlate with 'mental illness.' Mary's behavior is better explained by her struggles with adoption than by genetics. A clear thread appears to run through Mom's account: Mary struggles as a teen with adoption issues; she recovers with Mom's support; Mom, having become very close with Mary, literally goes 'to the other side of the world' and Mary lashes out at her for removing a crucial part of her support system, just when she finally felt secure. No wonder Mary exploded at Mom for her bland suggestion that she see a therapist. What Mary really wants is closeness with an essential part of her support system that helped her emerge from the other side of her drug and self-destruction crisis. Mom could, as you suggested, use therapy. Grasping how important she truly is to her daughter could help her to deal with Mary's outbursts, and to find ways to reassure her daughter that she will always be there for her. FAMILY CARE A. Thank you for this insight. The inner workings of a family system can be so complicated. We impact each other in ways of which we're often quite unaware. R. Eric Thomas can be reached at .
Hypebeast
a day ago
- Hypebeast
Adam Pendleton's 'Love, Queen' Reframes Protest and Abstraction
Summary TheHirshhorn Museumin Washington, DC is hostingAdam Pendleton: Love, Queen, the artist's first solo exhibition in the city. On view through January 3, 2027, the show features new and recent paintings, along with a large-scale video installation, in the museum's second-floor galleries. Pendletonis known for blending painting, drawing, and photography. He starts his pieces with ink, shapes, and text on paper, then photographs and layers them using screen-printing. The result is a bold visual language that mixes abstraction, minimalism and conceptual art. The exhibition includes Pendleton's signature 'Black Dada,' 'Days,' 'WE ARE NOT,' and 'Composition and Movement' paintings. These works often use only two colors over black backgrounds, drawing attention to gesture and language. Also debuting is 'Resurrection City Revisited (Who Owns Geometry Anyway?),' a video projected floor to ceiling. The piece uses archival images of Resurrection City, the 1968 protest camp tied to Martin Luther King Jr.'s Poor People's Campaign. Combined with found footage and flashes of geometric shapes, the film blurs the line between history and abstraction. The score, by Hahn Rowe, includes a recording of poet Amiri Baraka. Curated by Evelyn C. Hankins with support from Alice Phan,Love, Queenruns alongside the museum's permanent collection. Hirshhorn MuseumIndependence Ave SW &, 7th St SWWashington, DC 20560
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Hailey Bieber's Net Worth Revealed Amid Reports ‘Broke' Justin Is Close to ‘Financial Collapse'
With two famous last names, it's understandable why fans want to know about Hailey Bieber's net worth and how much she makes compared to her husband, Justin Bieber. Hailey was born as Hailey Rhode Baldwin in Tuscon, Arizona, on November 22, 1996. Her father, Stephen Baldwin, is an actor and the youngest of the Baldwin brothers, which also include her uncles Alec, Daniel and Billy Baldwin. Herm other, Kennya Deodato, is a graphic designer. Hailey's modeling career started as a teenager after she was signed to her first modeling agency, Ford Models, and appeared in magazines like Tatler, LOVE, V and i-D. Her first commercial campaign was for French Connection in 2014. That same year, she also made her runway debut, walking for the brand Top Shop. Since then, Hailey has modeled for brands like Guess, Ralph Lauren and Tommy Hilfiger. More from StyleCaster Justin Bieber Just Shared a Cryptic Post About 'Loyalty' After Rumors He & 'Not Happy' Hailey Are 'Getting Divorced' Hailey Bieber's Latest Move Speaks Volumes About Her Marriage With Justin Bieber After He Felt 'So Disrespected' by His Wife Hailey and her husband, singer Justin Bieber, married on September 13, 2018, after three years of on-again, off-again dating. 'I'm not going to sit here and lie and say it's all a magical fantasy,' Hailey told Vogue in 2019 about her marriage to Justin. 'It's always going to be hard. It's a choice. You don't feel it every single day. You don't wake up every day saying, 'I'm absolutely so in love and you are perfect.' That's not what being married is. But there's something beautiful about it anyway—about wanting to fight for something, commit to building with someone.' In an interview with the 'Call Her Daddy' podcast in 2022, Hailey responded to rumors she dated Justin at the same time he dated her ex-girlfriend, Selena Gomez. 'When him and I ever started, like, hooking up or anything of that sort, he was not ever in a relationship ever — at any point,' she explained. 'I'm not interested in doing that and I never was. … I can say — period, point blank — I was never with him when he was in a relationship with anybody,' Hailey said. She continued, 'It's not my character to mess with someone's relationship.' Hailey added that she could 'understand' how her and Justin's relationship could look different 'from the outside.' She continued, 'That was a situation where I know for a fact that it was the right thing for them to close that door. They were not in a relationship at that time, but of course, there's a very long history there. … It has nothing to do with me. I know that it closed a chapter and I think it was the best thing that could have happened for him to move on and be engaged and get married and move on with his life in that way.' But back to Hailey Bieber's net worth. So…how much is Hailey Bieber's net worth and how much does she make from Rhode Skin and other business opportunities? Read on for what we know about Hailey Bieber's net worth and how much she makes now. Hailey Bieber launched her skin care brand, Rhode Skin (which is named after her middle name, Rhode), in 2022 as a clean, affordable skin care line with its first products all under $30. 'My journey towards healthier skin inspired me to develop products that really work, in a way that's accessible to everyone. Rhode is dedicated to making products based in science and great formulation, simplifying many of the mysteries and complex narratives behind efficacious skincare. I hope these will become your go-to essentials that can live in your bathroom, be your favorite travel companion, improve your skin over time, and keep your skin happy and hydrated,' Hailey wrote in Rhode Skin's about page. So how much is Rhode Skin worth? Hailey told Forbes in 2022 that Rhode Skin was 'on track' to hit eight figures, though she declined to give specific numbers. Forbes also reported that Rhode Skin had a waitlist of more than 700,000 people for each of its three first products—Peptide Glazing Fluid; Peptide Lip Treatment; and Barrier Restore Cream—and that the brand's most recent restock at the time saw products sell at a rate of 36 units per second. 'When I run out of my Peptide Glazing Fluid, my skin, like, misses it,' Hailey told Forbes. 'That was how I realized that it was a solid product, because when I run out of my samples, my skin doesn't feel the same without it.' In May 2025, Hailey sold Rhode to e.l.f Beauty for $1 billion. 'When I launched @rhode in 2022, I always had big dreams for the company, and the most important thing for me is to keep brinring rhode to more spaces, places, and faces globally,' Hailey wrote in an Instagram post at the time. 'So today I am so incredibly excited and proud to announce that we are partnering with e.l.f. Beauty … a like-minded disruptor with a vision to be a different kind of company that believes in big ideas and innovation in the same way that I do.' She continued, 'I feel invigorated, excited and more ready than ever to step into an even bigger role as Chief Creative Officer, and Head of Innovation of rhode as well as strategic advisor to e.l.f Beauty. Thank you to the amazing rhode team who have helped me build over the years. I couldn't have done it without all of you. And to our rhode community, thank you for being the most supportive and for being on this journey, this next chapter is going to be even more incredible together.' According to Forbes, Hailey's billion-dollar deal with e.l.f. Beauty broke down to $600 million in cash, $200 million of e.l.f. Beauty stock, and a potential $200 million in future payouts based on the company's growth over the next three years.' Justin reacted to the news by resharing Hailey's post on his own Instagram Story. The news also came after a source told The Hollywood Reporter in April 2025 that Justin was suffering financially. TMZ also made similar claims at the time, reporting that Justin is 'broke' and sold his music catalogue for $200 million in 2022 because he was on the verge of 'financial collapse. A representative for Bieber denied the allegations in a statement to The Hollywood Reporter. 'Any source that is trying to sell you a story about alleged financial distress … either doesn't understand the entertainment industry or, more likely, is trying to paint an unflattering portrait of Justin, which bears no resemblance to reality,' the statement read. Following Rhode's deal, fans told Hailey to divorce Justin to protect her money. 'Just a casual Hailey Bieber observer but she needs to take that $1B money and run from that man,' a user wrote. Another added, 'HAILEY GET THAT DIVORCE NOW BEFORE JUSTIN STEALS THAT MONEY.' In her 2022 interview with Forbes, Hailey also explained her 'fear' that she wouldn't be taken 'seriously' because of who her husband and family are. 'The thing that was on my mind was the fear of not being taken very seriously,' she said. 'Does anybody even take me seriously, as a founder, as an entrepreneur?' Michael D. Ratner, a founding partner of Rhode Skin, added, 'It's a really big gamble. When you're Hailey, you could be the face of a brand. You could continue with no risk and get that cash in your pocket. She went into skincare because that's her first real love.' Ratner also confirmed that Hailey invested a lot of her own money into Rhode Skin. (She declined to tell Forbes the exact amount she invested.) 'She wants to do it the right way and really build up the team,' Ratner said. 'I think she wanted real ownership,' he said. 'She put in a real portion of money to back this thing, and to show people that she was serious and all-in on it.' (Rhode declined to comment on exactly how much money Bieber has invested.) She continued, 'I think it would be very easy for me to just approve something that's 95% perfect and just be okay with the 95 instead of waiting for it to be 100 percent. What I'm learning is that the quality of this brand is really, really important to me.' Hailey also explained to Forbes that she chose to name her brand Rhode, which was passed down to her from her mother's side of the family, because she her middle name was lesser-known versus her married name, Bieber, or maiden name, Baldwin. 'It just sounded so strong, and beautiful on its own,' she said. She told Forbes that her goal was to create a brand that was around for 20 to 40 years and was known for its products, not who its found was. 'I think it would be really awesome,' she said. 'If people just love the brand because they love the product.' At the Forbes Under 30 Summit in 2022, Hailey also explained why she wanted to create a brand of her own. 'I've lent money, my name and my face to other people's creative process,' she said. 'I think that actually has helped me develop mine in a lot of ways. It feels very empowering to be the one that's in charge.' Hailey Bieber's net worth is $300 million, according to Celebrity Net Worth. In comparison, Hailey's husband Justin Bieber's net worth is $200 million, while his ex-girlfriend Selena Gomez's net worth is $1 billion. Hailey's father Stephen Baldwin's net worth is $1 million, according to Celebrity Net Worth. Along with what she's made from Rhode Skin, Hailey Bieber's net worth also includes what she's made from her modeling career, including campaigns with brands like French Connection, Guess, Ralph Lauren, Tommy Hilfiger and Moschino. Hailey Bieber's net worth also includes her hosting careers for shows like TBS' Drop the Mic, which she hosted from 2017 to 2019, and the iHeartRadio Music Awards, which she hosted in 2018. Hailey Bieber's net worth also includes her acting career in music videos for artists like Cody Simpson, Baptiste Giabiconi, Dan + Shay, Ariana Grande, DJ Khaled, Drake and her husband, Justin Bieber. In an interview with Vogue Australia in 2019, Hailey opened up about her modeling career, and why it hadn't been as successful as her friends like Gigi Hadid, Bella Hadid and Kendall Jenner. 'My burn in the modeling industry has been slow, and I've had to learn to be OK with that,' she said. 'I'm shorter than most of the girls. Even though I'm five foot eight [inches], I'm not a runway girl and I totally used to feel inferior to some of my friends. Look at Kendall and Bells and Gig…they're all tall and doing every runway.' She continued, 'For a while, there was a part of me that didn't know if I could have the career I wanted if I couldn't do runway. I don't think that anymore. I had so many people, like casting directors, say, 'We don't think she's a real model.'' Hailey explained to Vogue Australia about how she eventually 'found' her 'own lane' with catalogue versus runway. 'It was disappointing until I found my own lane. I don't look short in photos. You can make it work and not have to do runway, and I've done a good job with that,' she said. 'I'm proud of myself for building a more commercial career that worked for me and being confident about it. I've hosted a show, I did major American campaigns, and a bunch of other things that I've really enjoyed. Sometimes I feel like I'm still finding my lane, but now I know I'm going in the right direction.' Along with Rhode Skin, Hailey also told Vogue Australia at the time that she plans to launch her own fashion line with her husband, Justin Bieber. 'I couldn't register it myself, because Justin owns all trademarking for his last name,' she said. 'Honestly, that was more about being proactive. I'm not sure how I want to dip into that space, and it's been a conversation between me and my husband.' Best of StyleCaster The 26 Best Romantic Comedies to Watch if You Want to Know What Love Feels Like These 'Bachelor' Secrets & Rules Prove What Happens Behind the Scenes Is So Much Juicier BTS's 7 Members Were Discovered in the Most Unconventional Ways
