The collateral damage from Monash IVF's colossal embryo bungles
The next part of the script unusually involves activists calling for enhanced regulation or better laws.
Advocates are also lobbying for all those who use assisted reproductive technology to have their babies DNA tested, which, if implemented, could uncover if other mistakes have gone undetected.
And no scandal is complete without a politician or two making some hay by grabbing a microphone and castigating the culprits.
Victorian Health Minister Mary-Anne Thomas was the first to step up this week, calling the embryo mix-up 'completely unacceptable'.
'It's very clear to me that the board of Monash IVF needs to have a very good look at what's going on,' Thomas said.
Loading
'Clearly their clinical governance standards are not what they should be.'
But amid the outrage there is another group that will also sustain collateral damage – the shareholders – although sympathy for this group will be way more muted.
They have seen the share price of Monash IVF plunge after the first incident was revealed in April and after the company cut its 2025 full-year profit guidance by 11 per cent.
It took another dive this week when the second implant bungle was revealed, taking this calendar year's stock performance down by 50 per cent.
The shares kicked up by 5.7 per cent on Thursday on the news of the departing chief, but this represents a small recovery.
Enter the investment bank analysts who use their sophisticated models to provide commentary on the impacts of these types of events on a company's market share and future earnings.
In the case of Monash, their opinions run the gamut of possibilities.
RBC Capital markets suggests that the fallout from the original bungle in Monash's Queensland clinic would confine the loss of market share to that state, and not impact too heavily on other state operations. But given there have now been two separate embryo transfer incidents in different states, it believes there is risk of a greater impact of a spread of reputational damage and market share losses. It has a negative stance on the stock.
Macquarie Equities has a somewhat different view. It acknowledges the reputational damage, but says the stock is oversold and represents a good buying opportunity.
You could characterise its advice as 'don't throw the baby out with the bathwater'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Herald Sun
25 minutes ago
- Herald Sun
Victorian university courses with the biggest drop out rates
Victorian university students are accumulating debt for degrees they never complete, with new figures revealing one in three fail to graduate. A Sunday Herald Sun analysis of the latest national Department of Education university completion rate data for domestic students has revealed the courses students are dropping at substantial rates, leaving a portion burdened with HECS-HELP loans and no qualification. Social work and tourism and hospitality students were among the worst offenders, with more than half the cohort dropping out of their degree between 2018 and 2023. Despite incentives, education degrees had the third-lowest completion rate, with two in five students dropping out. Other courses which saw more than 40 per cent of students withdraw included computing and information technology, psychology, and humanities. Conversely, medicine degrees had the highest completion rate with only one in 10 students dropping out, followed by dentistry, rehabilitation and pharmacy. Monash University higher education expert Professor Andrew Norton said the two biggest risk factors which could lead to drop outs were weaker academic preparation and part-time study. 'In the period when the 2018 commencers were studying, we have seen increasing rates of part-time study for continuing students, more students working, and the students who are working spending more time at work,' he said. 'I think this is likely to be a key reason why we've seen some worsening attrition rates in recent years (and) is reasonably consistent with the subjective reasons given such as stress, financial difficulties, study workload or employment.' While it's not known how much money today's students lose when dropping out due to a lack of specific data, Professor Norton said the latest Grattan Institute research on the issue found most students who didn't complete their course would pay or borrow less than $10,000. 'We found most people who dropped out had modest debts but there were some with more significant debts,' he said. He added a significant portion of dropouts occurred in the first year, resulting in lower debt burdens for those students. As for the overall completion rate for each Victorian tertiary institution, the University of Melbourne had the highest completion rate with 89.4 per cent of students who started a course in 2018 graduating within six years. Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Academic) Professor Gregor Kennedy said the institution provides 'extensive academic, enrichment and wellbeing support to students'. 'The University of Melbourne has a strong focus on student connection, belonging and wellbeing, and all students have access to a wide range of activities to supplement their studies,' he said. Meanwhile, Swinburne University of Technology had the highest drop out rate with 53.8 per cent of students not completing their course. A Swinburne University of Technology spokeswoman said the institution 'absolutely recognised the need to find new and innovative ways' to support its students' individual needs. 'For some, that is the 'traditional' university experience of a three-year degree. For others, it is studying part time, over an extended period, while they continue working full-time and balancing the demands of life,' she said. Swinburne University has launched its Education Innovation Exchange which is supporting its first-year refresh project, that works in partnership with schools to address retention and attrition challenges. Overall, Professor Norton said universities have improved their focus on struggling students and sometimes factors driving attrition rates – such as competing demands on students' time – were out of an institution's control. 'We should also accept that attrition is not always bad if students change their interests or get a job that suits them,' he said. Victorian Unis fork out big cash for WorkCover claims in 2024
Herald Sun
2 hours ago
- Herald Sun
Why this renovated Rowville home fetched $1.2m
The Rowville family home that sold for $1.2005m, more than $100k above the top of its price guide. A Rowville family who spent nearly a decade shaping their dream home have sold it for $1.2005m, more than $100,000 above the top of its price guide. Vendors Mary and Nick Nikos's renovated three-bedroom home had $1m-$1.1m price hopes, but strong interest throughout the campaign translated into fierce competition on auction day. Buxton Oakleigh auctioneer and director Peter Gigis said four bidders fought it out after the home was declared on the market at $1.1m, with offers climbing in $10,000 and $4000 increments before narrowing to final $500 bids. RELATED: Shock twist in Australia's property market 'Be realistic': Melb buyers warned Melb suburbs where units save you $1m CoreLogic records show the couple purchased 2 Moama Place for $630,000 in 2015, and overhauled it with a focus on family functionality and warm, timeless design. Their favourite addition? The open-plan kitchen, which Mary described as the 'heart of the home' , a space that once held more than 40 people during family events. The original kitchen before renovation, now transformed into a warm, open-plan entertainer's hub described as the 'heart of the home.' The renovated open-plan kitchen that once hosted 40 guests and helped seal the $1.2m sale, featuring Bosch appliances and oak floors. 'We've had babies take their first steps here, we've hosted huge gatherings, it's full of memories,' she said. 'It's bittersweet, but with baby number four on the way, it's time to start the next chapter.' The home backs directly on to Waterford Valley Golf Course and features solid American Oak floors, Bosch appliances, underfloor bathroom heating, solar panels, and a 48sq m shed with a kitchenette and toilet, ideal for the perfect mancave, trades or home business use. The backyard before landscaping and upgrades, now replaced with a manicured family-friendly space backing onto Waterford Valley Golf Course. The upgraded exterior with shed, solar panels and direct golf course access a lifestyle combo that drew fierce auction interest for the Melbourne southeast home. PropTrack data shows Rowville's median house price has climbed 5.2 per cent in the past year to $970,000, with family homes in quiet courts continuing to attract strong buyer demand. Mr Gigis said Rowville's balance of green space, schools and family-friendly infrastructure was continuing to fuel confidence among upsizers and long-term owner-occupiers. The stylish bathroom includes underfloor heating, just one of many high-end touches that appealed to owner-occupiers. The 48sq m shed with kitchenette and toilet, ideal for a man cave, trades, or home business use, adding serious buyer appeal. 'This wasn't an investor property,' Mr Gigis said. 'It was a genuine family home in a cul-de-sac with golf course views. Those sorts of homes are getting harder to find and buyers know it.' The lounge area pre-renovation, now a modern, light-filled family space with a fireplace and oak flooring. The revamped living room with fireplace, perfect for family gatherings part of a renovation focused on warmth and functionality. Sign up to the Herald Sun Weekly Real Estate Update. Click here to get the latest Victorian property market news delivered direct to your inbox. MORE: Bachelor couple eyeing $6m+ payday Aussie NBA legend set for huge $4m move $32m Mill deal reveals major players' interest
Sydney Morning Herald
3 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Shingles vaccine may increase mild shingles risk for a few weeks, new data shows
The company said many of the cases might be rashes that were misdiagnosed by GPs as shingles; rashes are a noted side effect of the vaccine. But the researchers – which includes the head of signal reporting at Victoria's Vaccine Safety Service – are confident about their data. Australia's drug regulator, the Therapeutic Drugs Administration, confirmed it too had 'found evidence of a possible temporal association' between the vaccine and shingles and was investigating. The new data shows a 16-times increased risk of developing shingles in the three weeks following the first dose of Shingrix, compared to the period before vaccination. Loading The risk only effects people aged over 65. After three weeks, the vaccine's protection kicks in and the risk of developing shingles drops dramatically. The researchers do not yet have absolute risk figures. But other studies suggest that for every 1000 unvaccinated people aged between 60 and 69, there will be about 150 new cases a year. Shingrix cuts cases of shingles by 97.4 per cent in that age group, according to a large clinical trial. 'It does not change the overall benefit this vaccine has been proven to have. It's more about letting people know it is possible,' said Professor Jim Buttery, head of epidemiology and signal detection at the Victorian government's Immunisation Safety Service. 'There is a very short-term increased risk, followed by a much longer period of increased protection.' The data is not yet conclusive and has not shown up in vaccine surveillance programs in other countries rolling out Shingrix. 'I find that data very strange, and biologically difficult to understand,' said Professor Tony Cunningham, director of the Centre for Virus Research at The Westmead Institute for Medical Research. 'It does not quite fit with the trials or the effectiveness studies.' Cunningham led the global clinical trials that showed Shingrix was safe and effective; they did not find any evidence of shingles reactivation following vaccination. The Victorian researchers used two datasets for their study, a database of GP visits from Outcome Health and a second dataset drawn from hospital presentations and lab-confirmed cases of shingles. The increased risk showed up strongly in the GP dataset, but only slightly in the hospital dataset. The researchers believe this means nearly all the vaccine-related cases are mild, as the patients are going to GPs rather than to hospital. They did not see any increased risk for postherpetic neuralgia, a nasty chronic pain that often is a complication of severe shingles. 'We still believe the true effect possibly lies between the two datasets, but we believe the primary care dataset is the most important to explore this,' said Shetty. The mildness of the cases may also explain why other countries have not recorded similar increases in shingles. Because people are not turning up to hospital, they might have been missed by data-collectors. Most countries don't monitor GP visits – Australia's database is brand new. That's a strength of the study, but it could also be a flaw. Cunningham said many doctors misdiagnosed a rash or other symptoms as shingles. Following the vaccine's 2018 rollout in Germany, some patients reported shingles-like rashes following the jab. But a later investigation revealed half those cases were misdiagnosed. However, Buttery pointed to a 2007 study showing GPs had a 90 per cent accuracy rate diagnosing shingles. The signal in his data is so strong it would still stand even if many cases were misdiagnosed, he said. It remains unclear what might be causing the increased risk of shingles following the vaccine. 'The answer is, we essentially don't know. The immunologists we've worked with have theories, but no one knows,' said Buttery. GSK, the manufacturer of Shingrix, said there was 'currently no established biological mechanism through which Shingrix, a non-live vaccine, would cause shingles'. The team's hypothesis focuses on age and the design of the vaccine. Shingles is caused by a reactivation of the Varicella-Zoster virus. We first encounter VZV as children, when the virus causes chickenpox. The nasty red rash fades, but the virus hangs around – slinking off into our nerve cells, where it is out of the reaches of our immune system. Loading As we age, our immune systems naturally lose their punch – a phenomenon known as immunosenescence. Eventually, our immune system might weaken so much VZV is able to reactivate, causing shingles. Why would the vaccine cause reactivation? One possibility: the vaccine's adjuvant may weaken cellular immunity for a small time period. In people who already have weakened immunity, that short period could allow the virus, in rare cases, to reactivate. In a time when vaccine misinformation is rampant, the researchers said the close tracking and disclosure of possible side effects was evidence of the safeguards built into Australia's vaccine system. 'Work like ours is very important to maintain vaccine confidence and vaccine trust, and help patients make informed decisions,' said Shetty.
