Savers should be warned about potential pitfalls of Lifetime Isas, MPs say
The complexity of Lifetime Isas could increase the risk of savers making poor financial decisions and the products may need to carry warnings for some people, according to a committee of MPs.
The savings accounts enable people to save for their first home or their retirement in one pot.
But the Treasury Committee said the dual-purpose design of the Lifetime Isa, or Lisa, may be diverting people away from more suitable products.
MPs found that the objectives to help people save for both the short and long term make it more likely that people will choose unsuitable investment strategies.
Lisas held in cash may suit those saving for a first home, but may not achieve the best outcome for those using accounts as a retirement savings product, as they are unable to invest in higher-risk but potentially higher-return products such as bonds and equities, the committee said.
It also described current rules penalising benefit claimants as 'nonsensical'.
Under the current system, any savings held in a Lisa can affect eligibility for universal credit or housing benefit, despite this not being the case for other personal or workplace pension schemes, the committee said.
The report said: 'The Government provides higher levels of contribution through tax relief to many other pension products that are not included in the universal credit eligibility assessment, such as workplace pensions and Sipps (self-invested personal pensions). Treating one retirement product differently from others in that regard is nonsensical.'
The report added: 'If the Government is unwilling to equalise the treatment of the Lifetime Isa with other Government-subsidised retirement savings products in universal credit assessments, Lifetime Isa products must include warnings that the Lifetime Isa is an inferior product for anyone who might one day be in receipt of universal credit.
'Such warnings would guard against savers being sold products that are not in their best financial interests, which might well constitute mis-selling.'
Savers can put in up to £4,000 into a Lisa each year, until they reach 50. They must make their first payment into their Lisa before the age of 40.
The Government will add a 25 per cent bonus to Lisa savings, up to a maximum of £1,000 per year.
People can withdraw money from their Lisa if they are buying their first home, aged 60 or over or terminally ill with less than 12 months to live.
People withdrawing money from a Lisa for any other reason face a 25 per cent withdrawal charge, and can end up with less money than they put in.
The report said: 'The withdrawal charge of 25 per cent is applied to unauthorised withdrawals, causing Lisa holders to lose the Government bonuses that they have received, plus 6.25% of their own contributions.
'Several witnesses described that loss of 6.25% as a 'withdrawal penalty'.'
There are also restrictions on when Lisas can be used to buy a first home, including that the property must cost £450,000 or less.
The report said: 'Many people have lost a portion of their savings due to a lack of understanding of the withdrawal charge or because of unforeseen changes in their circumstances, such as buying a first home at a price greater than the cap.
'However, the case for reducing the charge must be balanced against the impact on Government spending. The Lifetime Isa must include a deterrent to discourage savers from withdrawing funds from long-term saving.'
It also added: 'Before considering any increase in the house price cap, the Government must analyse whether the Lifetime Isa is the most effective way in which to spend taxpayers' money to support first-time buyers.'
The committee noted that in the 2023-24 financial year, nearly double the number of people made an unauthorised withdrawal (99,650) compared to the number of people who used their Lisa to buy a home (56,900).
This should be considered a possible indication that the product is not working as intended, the committee said.
At the end of the tax year 2023–24, around 1.3 million Lisa accounts were open, the report said.
The Office for Budget Responsibility predicts spending on bonuses paid to account holders will cost the Treasury around £3 billion over the five years to 2029-30 – and the committee questioned whether this product is the best use of public money given the current financial strain.
MPs also raised concerns that the product may not be well enough targeted towards those in need of financial support and could be subsidising the cost of a first home for wealthier people.
It said the data on this issue remains unclear.
The report also highlighted the benefits of certain elements of the Lisa, including being an option for the self-employed to save for retirement.
Treasury Committee chairwoman Dame Meg Hillier said: 'The committee is firmly behind the objectives of the Lifetime Isa, which are to help those who need it onto the property ladder and to help people save for retirement from an early age. The question is whether the Lifetime Isa is the best way to spend billions of pounds over several years to achieve those goals.
'We know that the Government is looking at Isa reform imminently, which means this is the perfect time to assess if this is the best way to help the people who need it.
'We are still awaiting further data that may shed some light on who exactly the product is helping. What we already know, though, is that the Lifetime Isa needs to be reformed before it can genuinely be described as a market-leading savings product for both prospective home buyers and those who want to start saving for their retirement at a young age.'
Brian Byrnes, head of personal finance at Lifetime Isa provider Moneybox said: 'The report marks a further opportunity to engage with policymakers and continue the conversations needed to ensure the Lisa continues to offer the best level of support to those that need it most.'
He added: 'While it is right that the Government ensures the Lisa provides value for money as part of its review of the product, it is our view that it absolutely does…
'The Lisa has proven particularly valuable for first-time buyers on lower to middle incomes, with 80 per cent of Moneybox Lisa savers earning £40,000 or less.'
He continued: 'We firmly believe that by future-proofing the house price cap and amending the withdrawal penalty, the Lisa would continue to serve as a highly effective product, helping young people build and embed positive saving behaviours early in life, get more people onto the property ladder, and prepare for a more secure retirement.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
North Wales Chronicle
22 minutes ago
- North Wales Chronicle
Government demands investigation after Lindsey oil refinery owner collapses
State Oil – the parent company of Prax Group, which owns the Lindsey refinery in North Lincolnshire – appointed administrators on Monday. A separate winding-up order has also been made against the Lindsey oil refinery and related businesses and a liquidator has been appointed. More than 180 staff are employed by State Oil, while it is thought that around another 420 work at the Lindsey refinery. Energy minister Michael Shanks called on the company's owner to 'put his hands in his pockets and deliver proper compensation for the workers'. He said the Government is demanding an investigation into the conduct of the company's directors and the circumstances surrounding its failure. The Lindsey site is one of only five large oil refineries remaining in the UK after the recent closure of the Grangemouth plant in Scotland. Prax Group is led by majority owner and chairman and chief executive Sanjeev Kumar Soosaipillai, who bought the Lindsey oil refinery from French firm Total in 2021. Mr Shanks vowed to 'ensure supplies are maintained, protect our energy security' and said Energy Secretary Ed Miliband 'is today writing to the Insolvency Service to demand an immediate investigation into the conduct of the directors and the circumstances surrounding this insolvency'. He later told the Commons: 'The Government believes the business's leadership have a responsibility to the workers and the local community, and we are calling on them to do the right thing and provide support to the workers through this difficult period. 'The wealthy owner cannot wash his hands of his obligations to the workers and their families, and that's why we are calling on him to put his hands in his pockets and deliver proper compensation for the workers.' Mr Shanks added the Government was told about commercial difficulties 'at the end of April', with the refinery having 'recorded a total of around £75 million worth of losses between its acquisition in 2021 and the financial year ending in February 2024'. He said: 'The Secretary of State was reassured by the company that there was no immediate closure risk to the refinery. A week ago, the business changed their position and said they feared it could no longer be a going concern. 'We repeatedly asked them at official and ministerial level what the financial gap was, to work out whether the Government could help bridge that gap, but the company were unable to share that basic information.' Trade union Unite said the Government needed to urgently intervene to help protect UK fuel supplies and jobs. Unite general secretary Sharon Graham said: 'The Lindsey oil refinery is strategically important and the Government must intervene immediately to protect workers and fuel supplies. 'Unite has constantly warned the Government that its policies have placed the oil and gas industry on a cliff edge.' Built in 1968, the Lindsey refinery can process around 113,000 barrels of oil a day. Clare Boardman, joint administrator of State Oil and Prax, said: 'We appreciate that this is a very difficult and uncertain time for the employees and everyone involved and we will be on site to support them during this challenging period. 'We will be considering all options for the group, including the prospect of a sale for the group's upstream business and retail operations in the UK and Europe, all of which remain outside of insolvency. 'We thank the group's team members and other stakeholders for their continued support.' Prax Group was not immediately available for comment.
The Sun
29 minutes ago
- The Sun
How you can get more money off your Aldi and Iceland weekly food shop this summer
TWO major supermarkets are stepping up to help struggling parents feed their kids over the long summer break. Almost a quarter of British parents have said they plan to skip meals themselves over summer just so their children can eat, while more than half feared they will struggle to cope with rising costs. 1 But two of Britain's biggest budget supermarkets are stepping up to help struggling families. Iceland and Aldi have both announced money-saving initiatives designed to ease the squeeze on household budgets and help parents keep cupboards stocked. Iceland, along with its sister chain The Food Warehouse, has launched a new scheme to give a much-needed boost to families who rely on free school meal vouchers. From the start of the school holidays, eligible families will get a £5 top-up to spend at Iceland, the biggest ever offered by the chain, and more than double the £2 bonus that was given last year. Richard Walker, Executive Chairman of Iceland Foods, described the findings as heartbreaking. He said no parent should have to sacrifice their own meals to feed their kids and stressed that the top-up aims to give a bit of relief to families during the summer. The supermarket has also launched a range of extra deals to help shoppers, including 8 items for £10 offers, half price off popular brands, buy two get one free deals, and big discounts on laundry products. To qualify for the extra fiver, families must first be eligible fro free school meals. Then they need to have an Iceland or The Food Warehouse Bonus Card, which is free to sign up for online or via the Bonus Card app. The £5 bonus will then be credited onto the card within seven working days after scanning it at the checkout. Three key benefits you could be missing out on Meanwhile, Aldi is rolling out its Summer Support Scheme, giving families across Britain the chance to bag a £50 voucher every day during the summer holidays. The scheme will last from July through to the end of August, Each day, one family will be picked at random to win a £50 voucher to spend on anything in store, from fresh groceries and cupboard fillers to toys and games from the Specialbuy aisle. In total, 62 vouchers are up for grabs, helping to ease the pressure on parents as they juggle the cost of feeding, entertaining and keeping children active. The Sun has contacted Iceland to confirm whether the voucher is a one-off or if parents with multiple kids can repeatedly claim this. Unlike, Iceland's offer you don't have to be eligible for free school meals to sign up for Aldi's scheme, parents can enter by sending their name and email address to SummerSupportScheme@ Julie Ashfield, Chief Commercial Officer at Aldi UK, said the scheme would help support families through what can be a financially challenging time. This summer scheme follows Aldi's ongoing efforts to support families, including freezing the price of its Mamia First Infant Formula until the end of 2025. In another major help for families, Aldi has brought back its hugely popular Back to School range and frozen prices once again. Parents can pick up essential school uniform items from just £1.50, and the full £5 uniform bundle, available in sizes ranging from four to 12 years. For those looking to top up on school kit, shoppers will find three-packs of shirts for £3.69, jersey trousers at £2.49 and leather school shoes with memory foam insoles for just £8.99. The range also includes sportswear and PE essentials, with joggers from £6.99 and football boots from £9.99. Who can get free school meals? Whether you are eligible for free school meals after that depends on whether you get certain benefits and your income. In the UK, you qualify if you get certain benefits regardless of income. These benefits include; income support, income-based Jobseeker's Allowance, income-related Employment and Support Allowance (ESA) and support under the Immigration and Asylum Act. In England and Wales, this also includes if you receive the guaranteed element of Pension Credit and working tax credit. For millions on Universal Credit there are income requirements though. If you live in England or Wales, you must have an income of £7,400 a year or less, not including benefits, to qualify for free school meals. Those on child tax credits must earn under £16,190 a year. In Scotland, those on Universal Credit must have a monthly income of £660 or less - £7,920 a year. Meanwhile, Scottish families must have an income of less than £17,005 if they claim child tax credits, which goes down to £7,920 if they claim this as well as working tax credits. In some cases, children aged between 16 and 18 receiving Universal Credit themselves can be eligible for free school meals too. How many eligible children claim free school meals in England? Just under 1.9 million pupils are eligible for free school meals in England. However, analysis from the Liberal Democrats in December 2022 revealed over 230,000 children were not receiving the benefit because their parents were not claiming. Based on that, it means around 1.7 million students are currently claiming free school meals in England. What other support is available? These aren't the only retailers offering help to families this summer. Asda also offers a Kids Eat for £1 deal in its in-store cafes, which runs year-round. Children can get a hot meal for just £1 when an adult spends £1 or more. Some meals also include a free drink and a piece of fruit, making it one of the most affordable lunch options when you're out. Meanwhile, Tesco has teamed up with Community Cookery School to offer free cooking classes to parents and children over the summer, helping families learn budget-friendly recipes and how to reduce food waste. You can also check if your local council is running a Holiday Activities and Food Programme. These government-backed schemes offer free meals and activities to children who qualify for free school meals during term time but places often fill up fast, so it's worth registering early. How to save money on your food shop Consumer reporter Sam Walker reveals how you can save hundreds of pounds a year: Odd boxes - plenty of retailers offer slightly misshapen fruit and veg or surplus food at a discounted price. Lidl sells five kilos of fruit and veg for just £1.50 through its Waste Not scheme while Aldi shoppers can get Too Good to Go bags which contain £10 worth of all kinds of products for £3.30. Sainsbury's also sells £2 "Taste Me, Don't Waste Me" fruit and veg boxes to help shoppers reduced food waste and save cash. Food waste apps - food waste apps work by helping shops, cafes, restaurants and other businesses shift stock that is due to go out of date and passing it on to members of the public. Some of the most notable ones include Too Good to Go and Olio. Too Good to Go's app is free to sign up to and is used by millions of people across the UK, letting users buy food at a discount. Olio works similarly, except users can collect both food and other household items for free from neighbours and businesses. Yellow sticker bargains - yellow sticker bargains, sometimes orange and red in certain supermarkets, are a great way of getting food on the cheap. But what time to head out to get the best deals varies depending on the retailer. You can see the best times for each supermarket here. Super cheap bargains - sign up to bargain hunter Facebook groups like Extreme Couponing and Bargains UK where shoppers regularly post hauls they've found on the cheap, including food finds. "Downshift" - you will almost always save money going for a supermarket's own-brand economy lines rather than premium brands. The move to lower-tier ranges, also known as "downshifting" and hailed by consumer expert Martin Lewis, could save you hundreds of pounds a year on your food shop.
The Sun
29 minutes ago
- The Sun
Major supermarket teams up with Uber Eats to give shoppers exclusive loyalty scheme prices and big discounts
WAITROSE shoppers can now bag even more perks when ordering through Uber Eats. The collaboration will make it quicker and easier to earn offers while putting dinner on the table. 1 The posh supermarket has extended its MyWaitrose loyalty scheme to customers using Uber Eats, meaning you can now buy products at big member-only discounts when using the app. Loyalty members can now link their MyWaitrose card to their Uber Eats app and unlock exclusive offers on thousands of groceries delivered straight to their door in as little as 30 minutes. While Waitrose was unable to provide examples of the discounts, The Sun has found offers of up to 25% off on essentials like milk. The supermarket giant says that after linking the account, its discounts will appear on your Uber Eats app. The offers will vary and change regularly. The move is part of a wider shake-up of the chain's loyalty programme, which recently saw shoppers offered reusable coffee cups as part of a free hot drink perk. Waitrose launched on Uber Eats in July 2023. What started in just five London stores has now expanded to over 250 branches across the UK, stocking 18,000 products. To do this, shoppers can sign up for MyWaitrose online and enter their loyalty number directly into the Uber Eats app when shopping at the Waitrose store. Laura Burbedge, director of Waitrose Online, said: 'Our on-demand partnerships have enabled us to bring our quality products to new food-loving customers. The best loyalty schemes revealed & how to get freebies "We now want to provide greater value to customers ordering via Uber Eats.' 'To start making savings, customers just need to link their MyWaitrose account to their Uber Eats account.' Alex Troughton, Uber Eats' Regional GM of Grocery and Retail, added: 'Our partnership with Waitrose is all about combining quality with convenience and now, with offers for MyWaitrose members, we're adding even more value.' It's the latest sign that big supermarkets are betting big on home delivery and making it easier for customers to cash in on loyalty perks. How do to link MyWaitrose account to Uber Eats Here's how customers can link their MyWaitrose loyalty and Uber Eats accounts If a customer isn't already a My Waitrose member, they can sign up here. Their card number will be instantly available They will need to download the Uber Eats app on the App Store or Google Play Link their My Waitrose card to the Uber Eats app by entering their loyalty number on the Waitrose store on the Uber Eats app And shop. The offers will be visible to them. Loyalty scheme changes at other retailers Meanwhile, Morrisons shoppers can now earn More Points even when they're not shopping at the supermarket– thanks to a perk that launched last month. The change means that Morrisons More Card holders can collect points with over 300 popular brands including eBay, Just Eat, Expedia, Asos, Very, and loads more. It followed last year's decision to bring back the More Points scheme, after scrapping the old My Morrisons setup which didn't offer points on purchases. Earlier this year, Tesco also made a major change to its Clubcard scheme, to the delight of pizza lovers. Customers were able to exchange their points for money off drinks and food at PizzaExpress until the end of April. Any Clubcard points exchanged for money off at Pizza Express were worth double, so a £1.50 voucher would have saved you £3. Sainsbury's also made a huge change to its Nectar loyalty scheme for 18 million customers. The UK's second biggest grocery store introduced a new security feature on its loyalty card app to prevent points from being stolen. The free scheme allows customers to earn one Nectar point for every £1 spent at Sainsbury's, both in-store and online. Supermarket loyalty schemes - which has one? MOST UK supermarkets have loyalty schemes so customers can build up points and save money while they shop. Here we round up what saving programmes you'll find at the big brands. Iceland: Unlike other stores, you don't collect points with the Iceland Bonus Card. Instead, you load it up with money and Iceland will give you £1 for every £20 you save. Lidl Plus: Lidl customers don't collect points when they shop, and are instead rewarded with personalised vouchers that gives them money off at the till. Morrisons: The My Morrisons: Make Good Things Happen replaces the More Card and rewards customers with personalised money off vouchers via the app. Sainsbury's: While Sainsbury's doesn't have a personal scheme, it does own the Nectar card which can also be used in Argos, eBay and other shops. You need 200 Nectar points to save up £1 to spend on your card. You need to spend at least £1 to get one Nectar point. Tesco: Tesco Clubcard has over 17million members in the UK alone. You use it each time you shop and build up points that can be turned into vouchers - 150 points gets you a £1.50 voucher. Here you need to spend £1 in Tesco to get one point. Waitrose: myWaitrose also doesn't allow you to collect points but instead you'll get access to free hot drinks, and discounts off certain brands in store.
