Kathryn Garcia Was Nearly Elected Mayor in 2021. Who Gets Her Votes Now?
She drew voters with her no-nonsense style, proven management skills in city government and moderate political views. She almost won that primary, in 2021, finishing second to Eric Adams by roughly 7,200 votes. He went on to become mayor.
This year's Democratic mayoral primary seems just as unwieldy, with nine major candidates, including a former governor, two recent city comptrollers, the City Council speaker and three state lawmakers — but not Ms. Garcia.
Her supporters, while not a traditional voting bloc, still coalesced in the late stages to nearly elevate Ms. Garcia to City Hall. Where will those voters go this time?
Interviews with more than a dozen voters who said they backed Ms. Garcia four years ago revealed a split: Some support former Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo's candidacy, some had mixed feelings about him and many were looking for a better alternative.
Kate McDonough, a writer who lives on the Upper West Side of Manhattan — a neighborhood that Ms. Garcia easily won — voted for her. She likes Brad Lander, the current city comptroller, though she could not recall his name.
As she left the grocery store Zabar's on a recent afternoon, Ms. McDonough expressed concern about Mr. Cuomo, who resigned as governor in 2021 after a series of sexual harassment allegations that he has denied. She said he seemed 'meanspirited' and questioned whether he had lived in the city 'for more than two minutes.'
'Why can't we just have a good manager who loves New York?' she said.
Ms. Garcia was viewed as just that. She was a successful leader of the city's Sanitation Department who was tapped to create an emergency food network during the coronavirus pandemic, and had leadership positions at the city's environmental and public housing agencies.
Many of the candidates this year hold or have held public office, but few boast the hands-on experience that Ms. Garcia had. Mr. Cuomo seems to come the closest, having led the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development under the Clinton administration, and served as attorney general and governor of New York.
Mr. Cuomo is fond of reciting a list of accomplishments, including raising the minimum wage and opening the Second Avenue subway. But his record also includes sexual harassment complaints by 11 women; investigations into his handling of nursing homes during the pandemic and allegations of concealing the number of nursing home residents who died from Covid; and a vindictive management style.
Some of Ms. Garcia's supporters on the Upper West Side were ready to give Mr. Cuomo a second chance. Ellen Friedman, a retired architect, said she watched his daily coronavirus pandemic briefings and thought he had the 'best grasp' of the issues.
'He's a doer,' she said. 'He gets things done. We all screw up.'
Ms. Garcia now serves as director of operations under Gov. Kathy Hochul, and declined to comment on the race.
Many candidates are courting her voters. Mr. Cuomo has highlighted his infrastructure projects, including rebuilding LaGuardia Airport. Mr. Lander, the left-leaning comptroller, has moved to the center to broaden his appeal; he once called for reducing the police budget and now wants to hire hundreds of officers.
Matt Wing, a former top adviser to Ms. Garcia, recently joined the campaign of Adrienne Adams, the City Council speaker. Mr. Wing, who is a former aide to Mr. Cuomo and is divorced from a top Cuomo adviser, Melissa DeRosa, said that Ms. Adams was in a strong position to win over Ms. Garcia's supporters.
'Garcia voters wanted competence without the political drama — someone focused on running the city well, not on themselves,' he said.
If Mr. Cuomo, who has a sizable lead in polls, gets enough of the roughly 400,000 votes Ms. Garcia won in the 2021 primary, his victory seems assured. He is expected to benefit from Mr. Adams's decision to exit the Democratic primary and run as an independent, especially by drawing from the mayor's base of Black and Latino voters.
Rich Azzopardi, a spokesman for the Cuomo campaign, said that Mr. Cuomo would fight for every vote.
'This city is in crisis and Governor Cuomo is the only person in this race with the experience and proven record of results necessary for the job, and that's why he has built a broad coalition of support that reflects our great city and is leading in every borough, and with every race and gender,' he said.
Liz Krueger, a state senator who represents the Upper East Side of Manhattan and endorsed Ms. Garcia in 2021, said that Ms. Garcia's campaign message was even more important after the tumultuous first term of Mr. Adams, who was indicted on federal corruption charges that were dropped under pressure from the Trump administration.
'I still think people want competence,' she said. 'I'm concerned that they may think that Andrew Cuomo offers that.'
Ms. Kreuger argued that Mr. Cuomo brought chaos to state government and had a poor record on the mental health crisis and public housing. She said she supports Mr. Lander, who 'loves to get into the weeds on issues' and 'surrounds himself with smart people.'
Others view Mr. Cuomo's record more warmly. Betsy Gotbaum, a former city public advocate who until recently led Citizens Union, a good government group that backed Ms. Garcia in 2021, said that Mr. Cuomo had the most experience and appears to have learned from his brief period in exile.
'Andrew has proven that he can manage and get things done and boy, is that important,' she said.
Some of Ms. Garcia's supporters lamented that The New York Times, which gave her its editorial-page endorsement in 2021, does not plan to formally back a candidate this year. They worry that it could be harder for a competent candidate with low name recognition to stand out in a large field without an endorsement.
Many of the civic groups who endorsed Ms. Garcia, including the New York League of Conservation Voters, are weighing whom to back.
Eric McClure, executive director of the street safety group StreetsPAC, which endorsed Ms. Garcia, said that Mr. Cuomo did not have a strong record on public transit, but many other candidates did.
Mr. Lander 'checks a lot of the technocrat boxes,' Mr. McClure said, and Zohran Mamdani, a democratic socialist state lawmaker who is second in polls, was running the 'most joyful and exciting' campaign.
The city's ranked-choice voting system, which allows voters to list five candidates on their ballots in order of preference, played an important role in Ms. Garcia's performance in 2021. She forged an alliance with another candidate, Andrew Yang, and wound up getting many of his votes after he was eliminated in an earlier vote-counting round.
Several candidates this year are considering forming similar alliances to defeat Mr. Cuomo. The left-leaning Working Families Party has endorsed four candidates — Mr. Lander, Ms. Adams, Mr. Mamdani and State Senator Zellnor Myrie — and for a progressive candidate to defeat Mr. Cuomo, they would likely need a large number of Garcia voters to rank them. Another candidate, Scott Stringer, a former city comptroller, is also vying for Garcia supporters.
Many business leaders have lined up behind Mr. Cuomo and donated to his campaign. Kathryn Wylde, the president of the Partnership for New York City, a major business group, said that her members had met with several candidates and that none had yet emerged as the natural successor to Ms. Garcia.
Ms. Wylde said that having a 'technocrat city manager mayor' like Ms. Garcia was 'attractive to the business community in a political environment that they feel is chaotic and unfriendly.'
Some Garcia voters on the Upper West Side said they were reluctant to vote for Mr. Cuomo. Joe Giordano, a retired artist, said that competence was important to him, but Mr. Cuomo was not the answer.
'I think he has too much baggage,' he said. 'I don't think I want to see him every day.'
Molly Pollak, a retired teacher, said she used to like Mr. Cuomo, but now she was 'not so sure.' So far, none of the other candidates have 'said anything that makes me think they can do the job effectively.'
For Ms. Pollak, the most important issue is standing up to President Trump. She said she admired elected officials who were challenging him.
'I want a person with that kind of guts,' she said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Los Angeles Times
16 minutes ago
- Los Angeles Times
Mississippi becomes fourth state to send National Guard troops to D.C.
WASHINGTON — Joining forces from three other Republican-led states, the Mississippi National Guard will deploy 200 troops to Washington as part of the Trump administration's ongoing federal policing and immigration overhaul in the nation's capital. Mississippi Gov. Tate Reeves said in a statement Monday that he has approved the deployment of approximately 200 Mississippi National Guard Soldiers to Washington, D.C. 'Crime is out of control there, and it's clear something must be done to combat it,' Reeves said. Mississippi joins three other states that have pledged to deploy hundreds of National Guard members to the nation's capital to bolster the Republican administration's operation to overhaul policing in the Democratic-led city through a federal crackdown on crime and homelessness. West Virginia said it was deploying 300 to 400 troops, South Carolina pledged 200 and Ohio said it will send 150 in the coming days, deployments that built on top of President Trump's initial order that 800 National Guard troops deploy as part of the federal intervention. Trump's executive order that launched the federal operation declared a 'crime emergency' in the District of Columbia and initiated a takeover Washington's police department. The administration has ordered local police to cooperate with federal agents on immigration enforcement, orders that would contradict local laws prohibiting such collaboration. 'D.C. has been under siege from thugs and killers, but now, D.C. is back under Federal Control where it belongs,' Trump wrote on his social media website a day after issuing his order. 'The White House is in charge. The Military and our Great Police will liberate this City, scrape away the filth, and make it safe, clean, habitable and beautiful once more!' National Guard members in the District of Columbia have been assisting law enforcement with tasks including crowd control and patrolling landmarks such as the National Mall and Union Station. Their role has been limited thus far, and it remains unclear why additional troops would be needed. Over the weekend in Washington, protesters pushed back on federal law enforcement and National Guard troops fanning out in the city. Scores of protesters gathered in the city's Dupont Circle on Saturday and marched to the White House. Brown and Pesoli write for the Associated Press.
Boston Globe
16 minutes ago
- Boston Globe
Jules Witcover, political columnist who relished the horse race, dies at 98
Advertisement Mr. Witcover went to the nation's capital in 1954 for the Newhouse publishing chain, which owned the Star-Ledger. Rising to become its indefatigable chief political writer, he witnessed some of the defining moments of the era. He covered the 1960 presidential nomination of Senator John F. Kennedy. The next year, he stood at the Berlin Wall soon after it went up to divide the German capital for almost 30 years. He interviewed civil rights leaders Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X as well as the segregationist governor of Alabama, George C. Wallace. Get Starting Point A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday. Enter Email Sign Up He was feet away from Robert F. Kennedy when the New York senator was mortally wounded at a Los Angeles hotel while campaigning for the Democratic presidential nomination. Mr. Witcover said that the sound of the shots rang in his ears long afterward, and that the sight of the senator bleeding on the floor just after winning the California primary would haunt him for decades. Advertisement Mr. Witcover helped power a highly competitive Los Angeles Times bureau in Washington from 1969 to 1973, serving as political reporter and assistant news editor during the first Nixon administration. He spent the next three years at The Washington Post as a specialist in executive branch politics before being recruited to the rival Washington Star to start a five-day-a-week column with Germond called 'Politics Today.' The Baltimore Sun picked up the column after the Star folded in 1981. (Mr. Witcover was unceremoniously dropped in 2005, five years after Germond retired.) The reporting and analysis of 'Politics Today' ran in 140 newspapers and made the Witcover-Germond partnership a major brand in political journalism. Their specialty was chronicling the backroom decision-making of the political elite, from the candidates to the party functionaries, and how the rest of the media chased the story. Embracing sports metaphors, they likened politics to a game with stars who could triumph or fall in ignominious defeat. They also wrote for publications including National Journal and generated a series of well-received books about presidential campaigns, among them 'Blue Smoke and Mirrors: How Reagan Won and Why Carter Lost the Election of 1980.' Writing in the Christian Science Monitor, reporter Curtis J. Sitomer called the 1981 volume 'a delightful repast of amusing and often telling anecdotes, as it prances us down the Republican and Democratic primary paths and finally on to the broader general election trail.' Advertisement Other Witcover-Germond titles included 'Wake Us When It's Over: Presidential Politics of 1984,' 'Whose Broad Stripes and Bright Stars? The Trivial Pursuit of the Presidency 1988' and 'Mad as Hell: Revolt at the Ballot Box, 1992.' Mr. Witcover's reputation was that of a 'shoe leather' reporter who preferred to gather facts on the hustings instead of on the phone. He and Germond also hosted informal dinners with leading politicians, deep-background events where no one could be quoted by name but that gave the two journalists invaluable access to figures such as future president Ronald Reagan. Mr. Witcover never attained the celebrity of the pugnacious Germond, who relished the spotlight and became an omnipresent TV pundit on 'Today,' 'Meet the Press,' and 'The McLaughlin Group.' Instead, he spent his extracurricular time writing books of history, on subjects as varied as the selection of vice presidents from John Adams to Dan Quayle and German sabotage missions in the United States during World War I. His 1997 book 'The Year the Dream Died: Revisiting 1968 in America' explored a momentous year in Mr. Witcover's career, with the assassinations of Robert Kennedy and King, protests and rioting over the Vietnam War, and the election of Nixon as president. Mr. Witcover 'is old-fashioned in the sense of being possessed of an empirical eye,' former journalist and Clinton White House aide Sidney Blumenthal wrote in a New York Times review. 'He clearly enjoys politics, tries to understand the particular motivations of politicians and observes events to see how it all plays out. His approach is the opposite of using people and circumstances as grist for the turn of phrase, whose object is not really to describe the man in the arena but to polish the image of the spectator.' Advertisement Jules Joseph Witcover was born in Union City, N.J., on July 16, 1927. His father ran a one-man auto-body shop. His mother was a homemaker who raised Jules and his older sister in her Catholic faith. His father was Jewish but was nonpracticing. In high school, Mr. Witcover helped out in his father's shop. He had not initially planned to go to college, but a teammate on his high school basketball team - the class valedictorian - suggested he take a look at Columbia University. Mr. Witcover, who reportedly did not know that Columbia was a highly competitive Ivy League school, applied and was accepted after scoring well on an admissions test. After a year in the Navy, Mr. Witcover returned to Columbia on the G.I. Bill and graduated in 1949. Mr. Witcover began his journalism career at the Providence Journal in Rhode Island. His nearly 40-year marriage to Marian Laverty ended in divorce in 1991. In 1997, he married Marion Elizabeth Rodgers, an author and biographer of the iconoclastic journalist H.L. Mencken. Mr. Witcover had three children from his first marriage, Paul, Amy and Julie; and a son, Peter Young, from a relationship with Amy Young. Complete information on survivors was not immediately available. After Germond retired, Mr. Witcover used their column to express increasingly caustic and opinionated views of political leaders. He slammed George W. Bush as the 'worst and most dangerous president in my lifetime' and the Iraq War as 'unnecessary and calamitous.' The Sun - then part of the Tribune Co. - published the column with less frequency and slashed Mr. Witcover's salary at a time of drastic staff cutbacks and declining circulation. Mr. Witcover was subsequently syndicated by the Tribune Content Agency. Advertisement Mr. Witcover was still working at age 92, publishing an update of his 2010 biography 'Joe Biden: A Life of Trial and Redemption' with material on the 2020 presidential campaign. In reviewing Mr. Witcover's 2005 memoirs, 'The Making of an Ink-Stained Wretch,' an admiring Sun colleague characterized Mr. Witcover as 'a species that seems more and more endangered' in the digital age of news reporting. The Atlantic's Ron Brownstein, another admirer, later called him 'the last of the mastodons.' Mr. Witcover seemed aware of his reputation as a throwback and began his book with a self-deprecating observation: 'Unless you're an old political junkie who knows the difference between H.L. Mencken and Walter Lippmann, you've probably never heard of me.'
The Hill
16 minutes ago
- The Hill
Bill Barr deposition kicks off House GOP's Epstein probe
Former Attorney General Bill Barr answered questions about Jeffrey Epstein in a Monday deposition with the House Oversight Committee that kicked off the panel's probe into matters relating to the late sex offender — an interview that fueled Republican defenses of President Trump while leaving the panel's Democrats hoping to call additional witnesses. Rep. James Comer (R-Ky.), the panel's chair who was present for the first hours of the deposition, told reporters that Barr testified that he did not know of any information that would implicate President Trump. 'What Attorney General Barr testified in there was that he never had conversations with President Trump pertaining to a client list,' Comer said. 'He didn't know anything about a client list. He said that he had never seen anything that would implicate President Trump in any of this, and that he believed if there had been anything pertaining to President Trump with respect to the Epstein list, that he felt like the Biden administration would have probably leaked it out.' Asked about reporting from the Wall Street Journal that Attorney General Pam Bondi had told Trump that he was mentioned in the Epstein files, Comer said Barr talked about how 'you go over everyone that you've ever been in communication with, or whatever, that doesn't implicate you, as far as being guilty.' Democrats on the panel who sat in on the deposition, meanwhile, asserted that they were taking the investigation more seriously than the Republicans. 'I think the Democratic side is doing most of the heavy lifting. I don't think we're learning much from the questioning from the House Republicans. It doesn't seem like this is something where they are truly caring about the victims and about trying to get to the bottom of what's happening,' Rep. Suhas Subramanyam (D-Va.) said. 'It seems like they are going through the motions, and they want people to believe that they are digging in,' Rep. Jasmine Crockett (D-Texas) added about her Republican counterparts. 'But at the end of the day, I don't think that we've learned anything through the Republican questioning that you couldn't find in one of the articles that most likely your outlets have printed.' Comer in response said: 'It's unfortunate the Democrats are trying to, seems to me, politicize this, when you look at the basis of this, horrific crimes against young girls. And of course, the Democrats' goal is to try to dig up some type of dirt on President Trump.' The panel's Epstein investigation was spurred by the furor that followed the Department of Justice and FBI releasing a memo in July saying that it would not release any more information from the so-called 'Epstein files.' The announcement further fueled conspiracy theories that the government is shielding powerful individuals who may have been involved with Epstein's abuse of young women and underage girls. Barr is one of 10 high-profile former federal officials who the Oversight panel subpoenaed as it looks into the Epstein matter, pursuant to a Republican-led motion that came as Democrats on the panel also successfully moved to subpoena the Justice Department for the 'full, unredacted Epstein files.' Deposition dates are also set for former President Bill Clinton and former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton — who, like president Trump, had socialized with Epstein — and other former attorneys general and FBI directors going back to the first prosecution of Epstein in 2008. Barr was attorney general in President Trump's first term when Epstein was arrested on federal charges of sex trafficking minors in 2019, and when died in his prison cell later that year in what federal authorities have repeatedly said was a suicide. He was also attorney general when Ghislaine Maxwell, Epstein's former girlfriend and associate, was arrested on federal sex trafficking charges in 2020. Maxwell was later convicted and is currently in prison. Crockett said that the questioning led her to want to seek more information from investigators in the Southern District of New York and from former Labor Secretary Alex Acosta, who was the prosecutor who handled Epstein's much-criticized plea deal in 2008 and was not one of the former officials subpoenaed pursuant to the Republican-led motion in July. Comer indicated he was open to calling more witnesses when asked about the possibility of bringing in Acosta. 'We'll bring in everyone what we think can add information to the investigation. This is a serious investigation, this is a sincere investigation. I hope this will be a bipartisan investigation,' Comer said. The next deadline in the panel's investigation is Tuesday, the date by which it directed the Department of Justice to deliver all documents and communications relating to its Epstein investigation. Comer indicated that the Tuesday deadline could be pushed back. 'We're having really good conversations. You have to understand how many, you can imagine, how many documents there are,' Comer said. 'I think we'll receive the documents very soon,' Comer added, saying 'we're working together in a good faith effort.' Crockett said that if the DOJ does not comply with the deadline, Democratic leadership will talk about how to respond. 'I fully anticipate that they should at least try to substantially convey the vast majority of the request,' Crockett said. 'Because that is one of the things that the court will look at, if we have to go so far as to try to seek enforcement on this, is whether or not there was substantial compliance.' The Oversight panel has also subpoenaed Maxwell, but Comer has agreed to delay deposing her until after the Supreme Court considers her petition to overturn her conviction for sex trafficking. The Justice Department, meanwhile, has made new efforts to reveal previously unseen information — despite the president himself dismissing the Epstein saga as a 'hoax.' Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche sat down with Maxwell to try to get new information. The DOJ also made motions to unseal grand jury testimony transcripts from the Epstein case and from Maxwell's case, but both were denied.
