Watchdog warns that Government's fiscal plans 'lack credibility' as spending to overrun again
The council's chairperson Seamus Coffey yesterday briefed reporters on today's Fiscal Assessment Report. The report, with the tagline 'Ireland's outlook: strong today, uncertain tomorrow', warned of the current volatility of Ireland's longtime reliance on corporation tax as uncertainty arises from mooted tariffs from the US and further trade tensions.
Coffey highlighted that despite the strength of Ireland's economy and financial surpluses, without these factors, there is a structural deficit of 2.4% of gross national income (previously known as gross national product) – equivalent to €2,500 per worker.
The council has been unable to construct a medium-term forecast due to the department's failure to turn over spending profiles, as well as the government's refusal to commit to a fiscal rule. Fiscal rules are permanent constraints on a government's fiscal policy.
It is suggested that the failure to turn over spending profiles to the council and the fact that departmental spending ceilings for 2026 and 2027 have not been published is due to potential transfer of functions within the department that is ongoing.
Ministers Paschal Donohoe and Jack Chambers pictured in the Department of Finance after the publication of the Annual Progress Report 2025 and April's Fiscal Monitor.
Leah Farrell / © RollingNews.ie
Leah Farrell / © RollingNews.ie / © RollingNews.ie
Coffey said that this highlights that there is no medium-term plan or strategy apparent. The council's report found that the government is overspending in certain areas but emphasised the importance of investing in infrastructure and competitiveness.
Employment is at a record high. The growth has been driven by the state and multinationals. Financial services, computer programming and basic pharma products account for roughly 300,000 people in employment in Ireland, the council said.
'Choices must be made. You can't do everything at once,' Coffey said of the government's list of stated priorities. 'In some areas, we can look at maybe where spending could happen that mightn't generate domestic pressures.
Advertisement
'When it comes to infrastructure, a lot of it probably has to be supplied domestically. So you look at housing, transport, an issue there is if you spend additional money, where are the resources going to come from to generate the additional output?
'If the unemployment rate is just over 4%, you don't have this big stock of construction staff just sitting there and say, 'Oh, we're spending three billion on extra infrastructure that's going to give us his extra output'. It might just end up having more money chasing fixed resources and just driving up the prices.'
Concerns were raised regarding the credibility of budget forecasts, as the department has not accounted for spending overruns in 2024 and 2025. It has also not accounted for the once-off double week Christmas bonus social welfare payment.
The predicted overspend is mostly the result of poor budgeting, the council said.
Corporation tax is likely to be higher than forecast, the report found. This has been put down to BEPS (anti-base erosion profit shifting) reforms that mean
groups with a turnover of over €750m will pay a 15% minimum rate of tax
in every jurisdiction in which they operate.
Some 30 to 40% of corporation tax paid by US multinational companies in Ireland comes from three companies, the council said its analysis suggests. It did not identify the three firms.
Ireland's
record export of pharma products earlier this year
mean that exports are likely to be above its forecast, even if the level weakens considerably across the remainder of 2025.
The Irish Fiscal Advisory Council has issued four key recommendations to the government on the back of its report, the first being for the government to commit to a fiscal rule.
It also recommended that the government use budgetary policy to 'reduce the ups and downs of the economic cycle', meaning that it shows restraint when the economy is string, like at present, and being more generous when it is struggling.
The council advised that the government set realistic spending forecasts and move towards medium-term budgeting, calling on it to include previous overruns to paint a more accurate and clearer picture of Ireland's current fiscal situation.
'No matter how the economy evolves, Ireland needs to address shortages of key infrastructure,' the council stated.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
a day ago
- The Journal
Fine Gael's Mairead McGuinness pulls out of presidential race following medical advice
LAST UPDATE | 35 mins ago MAIREAD MCGUINNESS HAS withdrawn from the race for the Irish presidency. Citing medical advice, the former Fine Gael MEP made the bombshell announcement this afternoon that she would no longer be contesting the election for the Áras. McGuinness, who was previously a vice-president of the European Parliament, had been hotly tipped for the role to succeed Michael D Higgins in the vote later this year. McGuinness said it was an 'extremely difficult' call but was adamant that it's the 'right decision' for her and her family. 'I have made the very difficult decision to withdraw my name as the Fine Gael nominee for the Presidential election,' McGuinness said in the surprise statement this afternoon. 'This decision is not lightly taken and follows a stay in hospital last week,' McGuinness revealed. Tánaiste and Fine Gael leader Simon Harris paid paid tribute to McGuinness for her 'incredible contribution' to public life and said her pulling out of the race was an 'awful shock' to party members. Mairead McGuinness has made an incredible contribution to public life in Ireland and in Europe. It was our clear view in @FineGael and the view of many people across Ireland that Mairead would make an excellent President of Ireland. Mairead's health will not now allow this. — Simon Harris TD (@SimonHarrisTD) August 14, 2025 McGuinness said she had discussed the decision with Tánaiste and Fine Gael leader Simon Harris, and thanked him for his 'support and understanding' on the withdrawal. It likely brings an end to a career that has spanned media, farming and politics, with McGuinness spending 20 years in Brussels as part of the EU political scene. In her statement, she outlined that she does 'not believe that I have the strength to give the campaign my all' if she were to stand. 'My priority now is my health,' McGuinness said. Given that the election is in a short couple of months, I do not believe that I have the strength to give the campaign my all. McGuinness, who is 66, added: 'I appreciate that this will come as a shock and disappointment to party members and colleagues in Fine Gael, but our political family is strong. 'I also want to thank all of those people who have done so much to support me, now and in the past.' Advertisement Mairead McGuinness speaking at the Fine Gael Ard Fheis in 2009. In a statement released by Harris, he said that it was 'our clear view in Fine Gael and the view of many people across Ireland that Mairead would make an excellent President of Ireland', were she to be in a position to contest the election. 'Mairead's health will not now allow this,' the party leader said. 'This has come as an awful shock to us all. Mairead is a valued member of our Fine Gael family. It is absolutely essential that she now prioritises her health and I know I speak for everyone when I wish her all the very best on that journey.' Harris added that Fine Gael's executive council will convene in the coming days to 'consider further the Presidential election' for the party. Fine Gael Director of Elections Martin Heydon said this meeting of the executive council would discuss the 'next steps' around whether it would stand a candidate in place of McGuinness. 'The Fine Gael Executive Council will meet in the coming days to discuss the next steps, but for now, I, along with Mairead's many friends and colleagues within the party send their very best wishes to her and her family,' Heydon said. Independent TD Catherine Connolly, who launched her bid for the Áras last month, said McGuinness's decision 'has come as a shock to all of us'. 'Without a doubt this decision could not have been an easy one for her to make,' Connolly said in a statement. 'I would like to extend my best wishes to to Mairead and her family at this time, and all the best for the future.' From RTÉ to Brussels Before entering politics, McGuinness was best known for her role presenting RTÉ's Ear to the Ground TV programme. The Drogheda native also did stints with the Irish Farmers Journal and as editor of the Irish Independent's Farming Independent supplement. She saw her first major success in politics at the 2004 European Parliament elections. With her background in television and farming media, she was able to scoop 25% of votes cast in the old East constituency, which covered Leinster outside of Dublin. In 2009, she was re-elected and later served as an MEP for the Midlands–North-West constituency. From 2014, McGuinness began moving into senior European roles, first serving as a vice-president of the European Parliament before getting promoted to the European Commission in 2020. McGuinness saw her first major success in politics at the 2004 European Parliament elections - she's pictured here on the right alongside then-party leader Enda Kenny and fellow candidate Avril Doyle. Eamonn Farrell / Eamonn Farrell / / McGuinness spent four years as Commissioner for Financial Stability, Financial Services and Capital Markets Union, departing the job after last year's elections. McGuinness did not stand in last year's ballot, with a wide expectation that she was eyeing the opportunity to replace Michael D Higgins in Áras an Uachtaráin. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Irish Times
a day ago
- Irish Times
Cash not the issue for Government but how to spend it wisely, Ifac boss briefed ahead of committee
The Apple tax windfall, the budgetary impact of migration and value for money in the health service were likely questions flagged to Irish Fiscal Advisory Council (Ifac) chairman Seamus Coffey in briefings by his officials in advance of an Oireachtas appearance. Two Q&A documents were prepared for Mr Coffey in advance of the meeting of the committee on budgetary oversight in early July – one highlighting issues likely to be 'pertinent now' while the other looked at questions that arose 'consistently. 'On what to do with the €13.8 billion Apple tax windfall, a suggested answer for Mr Coffey said to remember the Government 'is not stuck for cash.' It said: '[The State] is stuck for its capacity to spend it on things we all want. There are three broad options – spend it, save it, [or] cut debt.' READ MORE The Q&A said spending it on housing was easier said than done as the biggest issues were 'construction sector capacity and planning bottlenecks' not the availability of cash. If asked about the budgetary implications of migration, the briefing noted there had been 'large increases' in numbers coming to Ireland in recent years. 'This has meant the labour force and employment has been able to grow as rapidly as it has in recent years,' it said, before noting that around €2.1 billion 'has been set aside for humanitarian assistance to refugees this year (€800 million of this is for Ukrainian refugees). 'In terms of future costs, these are uncertain,' the briefing note added. The Q&A said that getting migrants integrated into employment and their own homes would reduce costs for the Government. 'An increased supply of housing would mean some of the more expensive means of accommodation [hotels] may be replaced,' it said. On cost-of-living supports, which have been a big feature of recent budgets, the Ifac briefings said these were now 'likely permanent'. 'There is probably less of a case for once-off measures this winter,' the briefing document said. 'Permanent increases in social welfare could be targeted at specific groups. However, the measures have seldom been targeted.' Mr Coffey was also briefed on employment in construction and whether we needed more people working in that sector. 'Just over 6 per cent of all employment is in the construction sector,' his Q&A document noted, adding that between 2005 and 2007, this had reached over 10 per cent. 'This may have been unsustainable, however,' the briefing added, advising Mr Coffey to 'mention productivity, can we get more output from the same workforce?'. A Q&A on broader questions highlighted the challenges in creating a wealth tax that would be fair, not become an administrative burden, and collect enough money to make it worthwhile. On how to fix repeated overruns in health spending, the briefing said that 'poor budgeting' was a problem but that there was also evidence of 'reduced productivity'. It also explained how Ireland's failure to meet its climate targets carried a very real 'fiscal risk'. The Q&A said the State had already forgone €500 million from carbon credits it was entitled to sell and that costs of noncompliance were in the range of €8 billion and €26 billion. 'While several [EU] member states are projected to fall short, the potential costs are significantly higher for Ireland relative to the size of its economy,' the briefing noted. Asked about the records, Ifac said they had no further comment to make.
Irish Examiner
a day ago
- Irish Examiner
IFAC on Apple tax: 'Spend it, save it or cut debt'
Briefings for the Fiscal Advisory Council (IFAC) chair ahead of an Oireachtas appearance flagged likely questions on the Apple tax windfall, the budget impact of migration, and poor value from money in health spending. Two Q&As were prepared for Séamus Coffey as he got ready to appear before a committee on budgetary oversight in early July. One section highlighted issues that were likely to be 'pertinent now' while another looked at questions that arose 'consistently.' On what to do with the €13.8bn Apple tax windfall, a suggested answer for Mr Coffey said to remember the government 'is not stuck for cash.' It said: '[The state] is stuck for its capacity to spend it on things we all want. There are three broad options – spend it, save it, [or] cut debt.' The Q&A said spending it on housing was easier said than done as the biggest issues were 'construction sector capacity and planning bottlenecks' not the availability of cash. If asked about the budgetary implications of migration, the briefing for Mr Coffey said there had been 'large increases' in numbers coming to Ireland in recent years. It said: 'This has meant the labour force and employment has been able to grow as rapidly as it has in recent years. '[Around] €2.1bn has been set aside for humanitarian assistance to refugees this year (€0.8bn of this is for Ukrainian refugees). In terms of future costs, these are uncertain.' The Q&A said that getting migrants integrated into employment and their own homes would reduce costs for the government. 'An increased supply of housing would mean some of the more expensive means of accommodation (hotels] may be replaced,' it said. On cost-of-living supports, which have been a major feature of recent budgets, the IFAC briefings said these cost increases were now 'likely permanent.' The Q&A said: 'There is probably less of a case for once-off measures this winter. Permanent increases in social welfare could be targeted at specific groups. However, the measures have seldom been targeted.' Mr Coffey was also briefed on employment in construction and whether we needed more people working in that sector. 'Just over six per cent of all employment is in the construction sector. Over the period 2005 to 2007, this reached over ten per cent. This may have been unsustainable, however.' The briefing added: 'Mention productivity, can we get more output from the same workforce?' A Q&A on broader questions highlighted the challenges in creating a wealth tax that would be fair, not become an administrative burden, and collect enough money to make it worthwhile. On how to fix repeated overruns in health spending, the briefing said that 'poor budgeting' was a problem but that there was also evidence of 'reduced productivity.' It also explained how Ireland's failure to meet its climate targets carried a very real 'fiscal risk.' The Q&A said the country had already foregone €500m from carbon credits it was entitled to sell and that costs of non-compliance were in the range of €8bn and €26bn. The document said: 'While several [EU] member states are projected to fall short, the potential costs are significantly higher for Ireland relative to the size of its economy.' Asked about the records, IFAC said they had no further comment to make.
