logo
Ex-Archbishop of Wales says retiring painful amid Bangor cathedral crisis

Ex-Archbishop of Wales says retiring painful amid Bangor cathedral crisis

BBC News05-07-2025
The former Archbishop of Wales has told the BBC that his decision to retire was the right one for himself and the Church.Speaking to BBC Radio Cymru's Bwrw Golwg, Andrew John said the decision had affected him."It has been very painful and my mental health has suffered in a way I've never experienced before, but that's a consequence of having to make big decisions," he said.He announced he was retiring with immediate effect just over a week ago after the publication of the summaries of two critical reports mentioned "a culture in which sexual boundaries seemed blurred", excessive alcohol consumption, as well as governance and safeguarding weaknesses at Bangor Cathedral.
While there is no suggestion the archbishop behaved inappropriately, the church's representative body had said there must be a "change in leadership, procedures and governance in the Diocese of Bangor".After the publication of the summaries, he had faced criticism and calls to stand down, with calls for an independent inquiry into the diocese.The archbishop, who will also step down as Bishop of Bangor next month, said he had little choice but to go."Being present at the meeting and [to] have people more or less calling for your resignation was like being in a nightmare," he said."I know the people who were in that meeting."I don't think I had a chance to explain the changes we've made and how complicated things are, but having heard from them I don't want to be a problem for them either."I think it's a good decision for the future."
He said he did not feel he had the opportunity to emphasise the improvements which had already been made and regretted not being more open with the press to explain what was happening.The former archbishop said it was difficult, given the church needed to show whistleblowers it was treating what they said in confidence.He said he did not know about the "drinking culture" around the choir in Bangor Cathedral."The idea that they went out after important services, that they went out until late saddens me," he said."It gives a bad impression of the diocese. It was a shock to hear about heavy drinking in the diocese."He said allegations of people making inappropriate jokes around children were "unacceptable" and that changes in culture were necessary.He acknowledged financial mismanagement had been a problem and that a "lot of mistakes had been made".But said he was not unhappy that about £20,000 had been spent on two trips to Rome and one to Dublin."I'm not unhappy, because the diocese decided to have those three trips," he said."It's not extravagant with 20 people travelling."
'These things happened under my watch'
He admitted he had not paid enough attention to the cathedral, but said that was down to his role as archbishop, which meant taking on wider interests.When asked what his biggest regret was, he said not ensuring there was a structure in place in the cathedral to deal with some of the issues and that he had been part of the problem."It pains me that these things happened under my watch and I'll have to live with that," he said."Bangor is a fantastic diocese."The damage done to the diocese, because I didn't pay enough attention to problems, is a burden I'll carry."He said he thought change would take years, but that the church would have to work together to ensure that change happened.He said he did not feel he had been mistreated, but added he had been shocked by some of the comments directed towards him on social media."It's been very difficult to see what people are saying on social media."I'm a bishop and a leader in the church, these things have happened during my tenure, so it's only right to give someone else the opportunity to take responsibility for the future."
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Tory leader Kemi Badenoch says Josef Fritzl case made her ‘reject God'
Tory leader Kemi Badenoch says Josef Fritzl case made her ‘reject God'

The Independent

time24 minutes ago

  • The Independent

Tory leader Kemi Badenoch says Josef Fritzl case made her ‘reject God'

Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch has revealed the case of Austrian sex offender Josef Fritzl caused her to lose faith in God. Mrs Badenoch said she was 'never that religious' while growing up but 'believed there was a God' and 'would have defined myself as a Christian apologist'. But this changed in 2008 when she read reports that Fritzl had imprisoned and repeatedly raped his daughter, Elisabeth, in his basement over 24 years. Mrs Badenoch, whose maternal grandfather was a Methodist minister, told the BBC: 'I couldn't stop reading this story. And I read her account, how she prayed every day to be rescued. 'And I thought, I was praying for all sorts of stupid things and I was getting my prayers answered. I was praying to have good grades, my hair should grow longer, and I would pray for the bus to come on time so I wouldn't miss something. 'It's like, why were those prayers answered and not this woman's prayers? And it just, it was like someone blew out a candle.' But she insisted that while she had 'rejected God', she had not rejected Christianity and remained a 'cultural Christian', saying she wanted to 'protect certain things because I think the world that we have in the UK is very much built on many Christian values'. During her interview, which is due to be broadcast on Thursday evening, Mrs Badenoch also said her tenure as Conservative leader was going 'well', adding her job was to 'make sure that people can see that we are the only party on the centre-right'. In an apparent dig at Nigel Farage's Reform UK, she said: 'There are pretenders. We're the only party on the centre-right, and we're the only ones who still believe in values like living within our means, personal responsibility, making sure that the government is not getting involved in everything so it can focus on the things it needs to look at, like securing our borders.' She went on to defend previous comments saying the fact she had worked at McDonald's made her working class, saying: 'I had to work to live. 'That, for me, is what being working class is. It's the lifestyle that you have. You have to work, to survive.' And she argued that parents who were 'worried about their children getting stolen or snatched' had created a younger generation that lacked the 'resilience' to deal with problems in life. Responding to figures suggesting a quarter of people aged 16-24 said they had a mental disorder, Mrs Badenoch said: 'I think they think they have a mental disorder, I don't think they all have a mental disorder.' She added: 'I'm not a medical expert so it is not my expertise on exactly what we need to do to get them into work, but we should be trying to get them into work.'

‘One in four councils could lose money' under Government's funding proposals
‘One in four councils could lose money' under Government's funding proposals

The Independent

time24 minutes ago

  • The Independent

‘One in four councils could lose money' under Government's funding proposals

Around a quarter of councils in England could lose money under the Government's proposed reforms to how local authorities are funded, analysis has found. A report from the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) said the changes would create big 'winners and losers' as ministers attempt to address perceived unfairness in levels of core funding across the country. Sir Keir Starmer's own council, Camden in north London, will be hit by the reforms when taking inflation into account, the IFS added. The think tank said Camden, along with other inner London boroughs including Westminster, will have less money to spend on services even if they increase council tax by the maximum amount allowed. Whitehall will provide a minimum level of funding, a so-called funding floor, for council leaders during the changes, but the IFS said overall cash for inner London town halls would be 11-12% lower in 2028-29 in real terms. The paper said: 'Around one in four councils would see real-terms falls in overall funding under the Government's proposals, with around 30 on the lowest funding floors seeing real-terms cuts of 11–12%. Conversely, another one in four councils would see real-terms increases of 12% or more.' The changes, which will come into effect from next year, are being consulted on by ministers. The Government plans to create a new methodology to assess local authority needs relatively and factor in population and deprivation. It will also assess need for adult and children's services. Overall spending will fall for 186 councils and rise by the same total sum for 161. One in 10 will see a fall in overall funding, while one in 10 will see an increase of 10% or more. The overall Government spend on local authorities will not change. The changes will be phased in across three years, from 2026/27 to 2028/29. Kate Ogden, co-author of the IFS report and a senior research economist with the think tank, said: 'England has lacked a rational system of local government funding for at least 12 years – and arguably more like 20. It is therefore welcome that the nettle of funding reform is being grasped, and some councils will benefit substantially under the new system. 'But the changes will sting for those councils that are assessed to currently receive too high a share of the overall funding pot, and so which lose out from moves to align funding with assessed spending needs.' The proposals are criticised in the report as 'not particularly redistributive to poor, urban areas of England'. It cites South Tyneside and Sunderland councils being among those to lose out from the reforms as slow population growth is accounted for. The report added: 'It is somewhat surprising that, on average, councils in the most deprived 30% of areas would see very similar changes in overall funding over the next three years to those for councils in the middle 40% of areas.' It noted that rural areas, which feared being badly hit by changes, will benefit from a 'remoteness adjustment' which will compensate areas with higher needs due to being far from large towns. London will gain the least, with a cash-terms increase in funding of 8% in the next three years. Analysis by the London Councils collective has highlighted the risk of the funding 'dramatically underestimating' needs for local services in parts of the capital. It noted the city has the highest rate of poverty in the country when housing costs are factored in. Outside the capital, the East Midlands (22%) and Yorkshire & the Humber (19%) are set to see the biggest increases in funding, with the South East set to see the smallest at 13%. However, the proposals have been criticised by youth charity the National Children's Bureau, which said it was 'significantly concerned' about the way the Government plans to work out needs for children's services. Ms Ogden added: 'The Government should consider giving highly affected councils which currently have low council tax rates greater flexibility to bring their council tax bills up to more typical levels to offset funding losses. 'More generally, reform of council funding allocations is just one part of the financial sustainability puzzle. Efforts to reduce demands on, and the cost of providing, local services through reform and the use of new technology will also be vital.' A spokesperson for the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government said: 'The current, outdated way in which local authorities are funded means the link between funding and need for services has broken down, leaving communities left behind. 'That's why we are taking decisive action to reform the funding system so we can get councils back on their feet and improve public services, with the IFS recognising that our changes will better align funding with councils' needs.'

Kemi Badenoch says case of vile Austrian sex offender 'killed' her belief in God
Kemi Badenoch says case of vile Austrian sex offender 'killed' her belief in God

Daily Mirror

time24 minutes ago

  • Daily Mirror

Kemi Badenoch says case of vile Austrian sex offender 'killed' her belief in God

Kemi Badenoch said her belief in God changed in 2008 when she read the vile story of Josef Fritzl, who locked and repeatedly raped his daughter Elisabeth in a cellar for 24 years Tory leader Kemi Badenoch has said the case of Austrian sex offender Josef Fritzl 'killed' her belief in God. ‌ In an interview with the BBC, she said she was "never that religious" growing up but "believed there was a God" and defined herself 'as a Christian apologist". ‌ But this changed in 2008 when she read the vile story of Fritzl, who locked his daughter Elisabeth in a cellar for 24 years, repeatedly raping her and fathering seven children with her. ‌ Ms Badenoch, whose maternal grandfather was a Methodist minister, said: "I thought to myself, no human being should have had to experience what this woman did. 'And maybe because I was very close to my father. So the idea of a father doing that to his own daughter for me was a level of disgust and abhorrence that I'd never experienced. ‌ 'I couldn't stop reading this story. And I read her account, how she prayed every day to be rescued. And I thought, I was praying for all sorts of stupid things and I was getting my prayers answered. I was praying to have good grades, my hair should grow longer, and I would pray for the bus to come on time so I wouldn't miss something. "It's like, why were those prayers answered and not this woman's prayers? And it just, it was like someone blew out a candle." ‌ She said that while she had "rejected God", she had not rejected Christianity and remained a "cultural Christian", saying she wanted to "protect certain things because I think the world that we have in the UK is very much built on many Christian values". During her interview, which was due to be broadcast last night, Ms Badenoch also said her tenure as Conservative leader was going "well", but admitted: 'This was never going to be an easy job. ‌ 'I knew when I was taking on this role that it was going to be the most difficult thing I ever had to do. Opposition is difficult, but opposition after a historic defeat, immensely difficult." In an apparent dig at Nigel Farage's Reform UK, she said her job was to "make sure that people can see that we are the only party on the centre-right". Ms Badenoch said: "There are pretenders. We're the only party on the centre-right, and we're the only ones who still believe in values like living within our means, personal responsibility, making sure that the government is not getting involved in everything so it can focus on the things it needs to look at, like securing our borders." She went on to defend previous comments saying the fact she had worked at McDonald's made her working class, saying: "I had to work to live. That, for me, is what being working class is. It's the lifestyle that you have. You have to work, to survive."

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store